Robots and Being Catholic

I’ll talk about artificial intelligence, robots, self-awareness, Turing tests, and all that. Someday. Probably. Not today.

Robots in factories are getting smarter.

We’ve already got ‘robots’ driving cars and trucks. And doing it well enough for folks to be looking at commercial applications.

That hasn’t made a big impact yet. But I’m about as sure as I can be that it will. Soon. It’ll make a huge difference.

I don’t see it as all good or all bad. But anyone who’s a truck driver, cabbie, or delivery driver should probably start learning new skills. Or finding off-the-road ways of earning a living with what they already know.

Learning new skills for a new-to-me job is what I’ve done most of my life. It’s easier for me than job-hunting.

More fun, too.

Besides being fun, I’ve learned a lot besides new skills. I’ve been a delivery guy, computer operator, radio DJ, beet chopper, ‘office girl’ — light clerical & answering phones — and graphic designer. Among other things.

That’s helped me as I try understanding how others see this world.

And appreciate that some see retraining as a threat, not a change of pace.

The ‘robot drivers’ thing will wait.

This post is what happened when I picked the ‘robots’ topic and started writing. It’s ‘organized’ in the sense that I added headings.

I had fun writing it. Your experience may vary:


Family time and Robots

I’m still enjoying having #1 daughter around. The good news is that we like to talk. The bad news — it’s not bad, actually, just different.

We really like to talk, so I’ve been and will be spending more time doing that. Also less time researching and writing these posts. (January 26, 2018)

The ‘up’ side is that Friday’s was shorter than usual. Post, that is.

And maybe more of how I see things, less of what I found while rummaging around humanity’s virtual archives. That could be a ‘down’ side, too. Depends on viewpoint.

Now, about robots that look and act like humans. More or less. We’re getting closer to making bots that talk, act, and occasionally look like humans.

What I’ve seen to date is occasionally useful. Chatbots, for example, sometimes. And about as convincing as someone doing a robot dance: a human imitating a robot.

Beware the Robot Menace

I think robots do a better job of imitating humans imitating robots. That could start an — interesting??? — discussion.

Or maybe not.

Either way, I think we’ll be seeing scary headlines and earnest editorials about the growing robot menace. Maybe later this year.

They’ll be based on actual events. Some may have moments of clarity. Maybe even useful insights or proposals.

The reality behind those scary headlines and sedulous editorials — Oddly enough “sedulous” and “seditious” don’t have much in common. On the other hand, they’re both from Latin words with slightly-related meanings.

Etymology, which isn’t studying insects. That’s entomology, an “ology,” but not — this isn’t what I was talking about, is it?

Let’s see: robots, humans, Latin, insects. right.

I’m pretty sure that folks living in America, at least, will see a big change in how we earn a living. That’s nothing new. Some of us will change gears without much trouble. Others, maybe not so much.

But I don’t think robots will take over, or that we’re doomed.

We’re NOT Doomed?

I’ve got my own views about robots and what’s ahead for humanity.

Basically, I think today’s world isn’t what it was in 1818 or 1918.

I’m about as sure as I can be that it’ll be different in 2118. America included.

Even how many of us see change changes.

From at least 1818 to the early 1900s, quite a few folks in America, and elsewhere, figured that the future looked spiffy.

They had a point. We were learning how to not die quite so often from disease. Or famine, or disease caused by famine.

I keep saying this: the “good old days” weren’t. The late 19th century wasn’t perfect. We’ll be cleaning up some of the mess it left for centuries.

But folks had pretty good reason to think that we could keep making life better. I think they were right. Partly. Overly-optimistic, but basically on the right track.

Some also assumed that stamping out ignorance and superstition would be a vital step in building a better world. I think pretty much the same thing.

The ‘stamp out’ assumption’s down side was that many thought religion and superstition were the same thing. Some still do. I don’t. (October 30, 2016)

I’ll grant that some self-described religious folks, including some Catholics, include a hearty helping of superstition in their beliefs.

That’s a bad idea and we shouldn’t do it. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2110–2111)

The 19th century’s optimistic outlook and dedication to Progress lasted until around the mid-20th century. I miss the optimism, but not the unreasoning belief.

Quite a few folks breathed a sigh of relief when 1918 saw the end of the “war to end war.” America got the Roaring Twenties next, followed by a global depression and the next global war.

That time around we weren’t calling it the “war to end war.” (November 10, 2017; February 17, 2017; December 16, 2016)

Quite a few folks survived. Both times. Many, digging out of the rubble, thought enough was enough. I think they were right.

We’re currently trying a new approach to conflict resolution. It’s lasted well over a half-century, and isn’t perfect. But I think it’s better than many alternatives.

And we can do better. But it’ll do for now. (November 10, 2017; May 28, 2017)

The End of Civilization as We Know It

I quoted Yeats “the centre cannot hold” poem Friday. Like many folks at the time, he had some cause for feeling apprehensive.

That chap with the facial tentacles is Cthulhu. I’ll get back to the author who imagined him. Or it. I’m not really sure.

Lovecraft lived and wrote around the same time as Yeats. Both had reasons for feeling apprehensive, like I said.

The same goes for folks living today. Or in any other era.

Particularly those times when folks are dealing with a solution that’s become a problem. I think that’s happening now.

I also think it’s the end of civilization as we know it. And think it’s a good thing.

New ways replacing old isn’t new. What’s remarkable are those eras when not much changes. For a few centuries, anyway. Then — you guessed it — things change.

If I thought post-1967 America was a golden age, I’d probably be angsty about current events. I’d be more apprehensive if I thought it really was the best humanity can do.

I think today’s ‘business as usual’ must change. And will. But I don’t hanker for Happy Days America. I remember what came before the 1960s, and why we made changes.

I really wouldn’t want those “good old days” back. The trick will be working for changes that make sense. (December 3, 2017; February 5, 2017)

God, Truth, and Lovecraft’s “Placid Island of Ignorance”

I don’t know how seriously Lovecraft took his “placid island of ignorance” attitude.

It certainly works well in his tales of cosmic horror. But seeing our only hope as either fleeing into “the peace and safety of a new dark age” — or madness?

That seems unreasonable. But the attitude helped put Lovecraft on the map.

“…The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents. … The sciences, each straining in its own direction, have hitherto harmed us little; but some day the piecing together of dissociated knowledge will open up such terrifying vistas of reality, and of our frightful position therein, that we shall either go mad from the revelation or flee from the light into the peace and safety of a new dark age….”
(“The Call of Cthulhu,” H. P. Lovecraft (1929); via WikiQuote)

I’ve met folks who don’t seem comfortable with what we’ve learned in the last few decades.

Some are Christians who feel that science and religion get along like cobra and mongoose. Others seem convinced that we can have either technology or clean air. “Technology” defined as whatever’s been developed since some arbitrary date. I don’t agree with either.

Treating science as a religion or faith as science doesn’t make sense. Neither does blaming our tools for what we do. (January 12, 2018; October 29, 2017; February 10, 2017)

My lively interest in our expanding knowledge of God’s creation isn’t, I think, vital to being Catholic.

But it sure doesn’t hurt.

Studying natural processes is a good idea. It’s one way we can learn more about God. (Catechism, 31–35)

I can learn about God by paying attention as I read the Bible, too.

I’d better. It’s an important part of being Catholic. (Catechism, 101–133)

I think faith is willingly and consciously embracing “the whole truth that God has revealed.” (Catechism, 142–150)

That’s the whole truth. All of it. Not just the parts I like, or what we’d uncovered by 1543. Or 1859. Or knew when Hammurabi wrote his law code.

I think God creates everything we can see or will ever be able to observe.

Being scared of studying God’s work doesn’t make sense. Pursuing truth does. It’s part of being human. Or should be. (November 5, 2017; March 26, 2017; October 28, 2016)

Using the brains God gave us doesn’t offend God. We’re supposed to be curious. Truth cannot contradict truth. Scientific discoveries? They’re opportunities for greater admiration of God’s creation. (Catechism, 159, 214–217, 283, 294, 341)

We’re surrounded by beauty and wonders. Paying attention makes sense:

“Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth—in a word, to know himself—so that, by knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves (cf. Exodus 33:18; Palms 27:8–9; 63:2–3; John 14:8; 1 John 3:2)….”
(“Fides et Ratio,” Pope Saint John Paul II (September 14, 1998) [emphasis mine])

“…if methodical investigation within every branch of learning is carried out in a genuinely scientific manner and in accord with moral norms, it never truly conflicts with faith, for earthly matters and the concerns of faith derive from the same God. … we cannot but deplore certain habits of mind, which are sometimes found too among Christians, which do not sufficiently attend to the rightful independence of science and which, from the arguments and controversies they spark, lead many minds to conclude that faith and science are mutually opposed….”
(“Gaudium et Spes,” Pope Bl. Paul VI (December 7, 1965) [emphasis mine])

“…God, the Creator and Ruler of all things, is also the Author of the Scriptures – and that therefore nothing can be proved either by physical science or archaeology which can really contradict the Scriptures. … Even if the difficulty is after all not cleared up and the discrepancy seems to remain, the contest must not be abandoned; truth cannot contradict truth….”
(“Providentissimus Deus,” Pope Leo XIII (November 18, 1893) [emphasis mine])

“Question the beauty of the earth, question the beauty of the sea, question the beauty of the air…. They all answer you, ‘Here we are, look; we’re beautiful.’…
“…So in this way they arrived at a knowledge of the god who made things, through the things which he made.”
(Sermon 241, St. Augustine of Hippo (ca. 411))

Letting our appreciation of this universe get out of hand is a bad idea. But the reality we’re in isn’t bad. Like God said, it’s “very good:”

“Now if out of joy in their beauty they thought them gods, let them know how far more excellent is the Lord than these; for the original source of beauty fashioned them.”
(Wisdom 13:3)

“You adorn the year with your bounty; your paths drip with fruitful rain.
“The meadows of the wilderness also drip; the hills are robed with joy.”
(Psalms 65:12–13)

“God looked at everything he had made, and found it very good. Evening came, and morning followed—the sixth day.”
(Genesis 1:31)

Using our Brains

I think “The Phantom Creeps” showed a slightly more plausible scenario than many tales of cybernetic menaces.

Rampaging robots weren’t the only tool Dr. Zorka developed.

The point is that they were tools. Assorted humans used them. Or tried.

I’m quite sure that blaming tools for the movie’s disasters doesn’t make sense. It’s the same way in real life.

Tools make it easier for us to help, or hurt, others. And ourselves.

We’re the ones in control. Not the tools. Our track record suggests that many of us don’t think about likely outcomes. Not well enough, anyway. Then there’s the issue of choices based on feelings, not reason.

Emotions are part of being human. So is thinking. Or should be. (February 10, 2017; October 5, 2016; August 21, 2016)

Artificial intelligence, AI, in the movies occasionally runs amok on its own. I think that’s more a testimony to human imagination and fears than a likely threat. Some of the stories are well-crafted, though. And fun, if the reader remembers that they’re tall tales.

Or, occasionally, satire. Or a semi-serious look at what might happen. Maybe.

Daniel Wilson had fun with fear in his 2005 “How to Survive a Robot Uprising.”

So did XKCD’s Randall Munroe:

“…Here are a few snapshots of what an actual robot apocalypse might look like:
“In labs everywhere, experimental robots would leap up from lab benches in a murderous rage, locate the door, and—with a tremendous crash—plow into it and fall over.
“Those robots lucky enough to have limbs that can operate a doorknob, or to have the door left open for them, would have to contend with deceptively tricky rubber thresholds before they could get into the hallway.
“Hours later, most of them would be found in nearby bathrooms, trying desperately to exterminate what they have identified as a human overlord but is actually a paper towel dispenser….”
(“Robot Apocalypse,” What If? XKCD.com)

AI, robotic and otherwise, has gotten smarter. Better at some tasks than humans. Seeing the tech as a threat to humanity doesn’t make sense. As a threat to some of our jobs, that’s another story. John Henry comes to mind. (July 7, 2017)

Machines can do some jobs better than humans. And sometimes using machines is a good idea for other reasons.

Before today’s crash test dummies came along, researchers used animals, human cadavers, and the occasional volunteer for vehicle testing.

Getting a Grip About Crash Test Dummies

Tests on human subjects gave researchers useful information. But I don’t think crashing a car with an infant, two kids and an adult couple into a wall is prudent.

Mad scientists can be entertaining in stories. Their real-life counterparts are anything but fun. (January 12, 2018; November 11, 2016)

Medical or scientific experiments with human test subjects “can contribute to healing the sick and the advancement of public health.” (Catechism, 2292)

Learning how we and this universe work is part of being human. That’s a good thing. Taking “disproportionate or avoidable risks” with someone’s health or sanity isn’t, or shouldn’t be. Doing it without informed consent is worse. (Catechism, 2292–2295)

Like I said, sometimes using machines for a human’s job makes sense. Medical simulators help folks learn medical procedures and resuscitation techniques without putting patients or volunteers at risk.

Crash test dummies and the like can be a bit creepy. But I see them as tools. Not threats. And I’m pretty sure that God doesn’t mind if we use tools to help other folks.

Being Human

Some Christians may still think vaccines and lightning rods offend an irascible Almighty. Vaccines, anyway. (July 21, 2017; October 16, 2016)

I think vaccines, lightning rods, robots, stone knives, or any other tech can help us help each other. Or not.

That doesn’t mean they’re fool-proof “safe.”

Folks still get burned by inadequately controlled fires. I’m quite sure that happens because humans got careless: not that God smites those who dare cook or grill.

Georg Wilhelm Richmann’s spectacular demise encouraged development of today’s safety procedures.

And we still get hurt. Knowing how something’s done doesn’t help when we don’t use our knowledge. (July 28, 2017; October 16, 2016)

Our tools aren’t the problem. It’s us. We have freedom, “the power, rooted in reason and will, to act or not to act….” (Catechism, 1731)

Deciding that we’d rather act against reason, truth, and right conscience is an option: and a very bad idea. (Catechism, 311, 396, 1704, 1730, 1739, 1849)

Studying this universe and developing new technology with what we learn, is part of being human. Or should be. (Catechism, 2293–2296)

More, mostly about paying attention and using our brains:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , | 6 Comments

Books and Flying Cars

That’s a photo of the Malatestiana Library. It’s a public library in Cesena.

The Malatestiana Library was built around the mid 1400s. It’s named after a local aristocrat, but is the first civic library in Europe: not a private collection. Depending on how you look at it, that was the tail end of the Middle Ages or early Renaissance.

I call the 15th through 17th centuries cultural, economic, and ideological changes in Europe the Renaissance.

That’s because I speak English. That’s what my language calls it. Sometimes clear communication is more immediately important than accuracy. This, I think, is one of those times.

I’ll admit to a bias. I see “Gothic” architecture as a high point of Western Civilization’s engineering. Other eras were high points too. I think we’re in one now.

The word “Renaissance” dates from the 1830s.1 I don’t see it as a “rebirth.” More like an era when quite a few Europeans started thinking ‘outside the box.’

That’s one way of looking at it.

I see the it more as a climax following several centuries of groundbreaking research and development.

It’s impressive, and good news/bad news.

Good news: some long-overdue reforms and restructurings got started.

Not-so-good news: the reforms didn’t turn out as well as they might have.

Nothing unusual about that. Or new.

“Human beings beget mischief as sparks fly upward.”
(Job 5:22)

But we keep trying to fix problems, occasionally succeed, and don’t achieve perfection. But we keep trying. That is, I think, good news. Very good news.

More not-so-good news. My opinion. The Renaissance is when European and Euro-based cultures started slavishly aping Roman and Greek architecture and art.

Nothing wrong with those forms. But the Greeks and Romans pretty well rang all the changes. Doing the same thing, again? I suppose I can look at it as watching reruns of a well-crafted television series.

Most of us didn’t jump off that treadmill until the 20th century. And that’s another topic.

Not the Usual ‘Science News’

If you’re still reading this post, you may be wondering why it doesn’t look like the regularly-scheduled ‘science news’ post.

That’s because it’s not.

I had a topic and some material lined up for more of the usual thing.

Then #1 daughter showed up.

She and I started talking, so quite a bit of research and writing didn’t happen.

That’s a good thing, since talking is something we enjoy. She’s still here, so I didn’t have enough time to work on the ‘Friday’ post.

Trawling my mind’s backwaters, I came up with something that’ll take less time and effort. It’s a possible explanation for why Malatestiana Library has chains on its books. Also scriptoriums, Bibles, and flying cars.

The last is my opinion, but I think I’m right. Naturally enough. How many folks think something is true and also think they’re wrong? Think about that. Or not. Suit yourself.

Here’s what I’ve got today:

Remembering Card Catalogs

On the whole, I like living in the early 21st century. Partly because I was born with defective hips. And that’s yet another topic.

Another reason, a big one, is that today’s information technology isn’t what it was in the springtime of my life.

Card catalogs were pretty much the ultimate information retrieval technology.

Library of Congress Classification, LCC, had been around since 1897. But just about everyone else in the country used Dewey Decimal Classification. They’re both still in use.

Card catalogs, too — rank upon rank of little drawers with three by five inch cards in them.

I’ve learned to use all of the above. But I don’t miss the ‘good old days’ all that much.

I could, and did, do academic research with the old technology. I have fond memories of searching card catalogs and walking through stacks and archives. Tracking down one fact could take days. Then, often, there was the thrill of discovery.

It’s been a year or so since I ran into someone writing about “information overload” or the looming threat of a “hive mind.” Maybe because I haven’t looked.

I sympathize, a bit, with folks who miss limited information channels and managed access. For part of my ‘good old days’ there was the local daily newspaper, plus a magazine subscription.

Television news was a new thing — boon or threat, depending on who you listened to. Then came fax machines, the Internet, and the 24 hour news cycle. All the while echoed the poet’s words:

“…Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned….”
(“The Second Coming,” William Butler Yeats (1920))

I’ve talked about doom, gloom, Yeats and Lovecraft before. (August 11, 2017)

Like I said, I sympathize for folks who yearn for ‘the good old days.’ A little.

But I like living in an era where a search for information often takes seconds or minutes. Not days. Or longer. And I have access to information that some editor didn’t decide was suitable for the common citizen.

The Internet and virtual search software give me data interfaces that are almost fast enough to suit me. It’ll do for now, and that’s almost another topic.

Using Technology

I don’t know why the Malatestiana Library’s books are chained.

Maybe librarians were obsessive about keeping the books organized.

Or didn’t want visitors walking out with part of the collection. That might make sense, since at least some of the books might have been made by hand.

Gutenberg’s printing press was revolutionizing information sharing, but movable type was an emerging technology. Sort of like AI-assisted online search today, maybe. Or maybe not. That’s not exactly new any more.

I still use some skills learned during my youth. Reading and keyboarding, mostly. We called it “typing” then. Because we used something called typewriters.

Although I’ve been interested in new tech since the late 1950s, my knowledge isn’t current. I like it, though. Today’s world isn’t boring.

Back to libraries and books in chains.

Wow. There’s a — strange — title lurking in that phrase.

Quite a few libraries today have books and other materials that don’t leave the building, or shouldn’t. Some archives take extreme care to make sure that nothing can leave.

Including, I’m told, having visitors sit in a huge sack while reading a one-of-a-kind document. The bag is loose and and thin, so handling manuscripts is no problem.

But slipping part of one into a pocket would be impossible. Should be. Stuff occasionally disappears anyway, sometimes. And that’s yet again another topic.

Libraries I visited weren’t like that. Some were good-sized, with wide-ranging volumes of knowledge, wisdom, and — sometimes — cartoons.

Usually I’d have the choice of bringing the item away with me. Or reading it: in areas designed for serious study or light browsing. Good memories. Seeing a photo of a big library and the Columbus state university reminded me. I’ve never been there, though.

Sharing Knowledge

The Thompson Library holds 1,250,000 books, roughly. It’s the largest library on the Ohio State University Columbus campus.

It’s not the biggest library in this country, not by a long shot. America’s largest public library is the Library of Congress, with about 34,528,818 volumes.

Those aren’t necessarily all books. Defining and measuring a library’s holdings is complicated, and one of the reasons it takes a couple years to become a librarian.

Slicing and dicing the data another way, the Library of Congress has upwards of 164,000,000,000 units. Something like 1,800,000 folks visit it each year. Using the same recipe, the British Library has 150,000,000 units and 1,750,000 visitors yearly.

I’m not sure why the Library of Congress staff is 3,149 and the British Library employs 1,977.

Maybe Brits are brighter and need less help. Or America’s filing system is more complicated, or — likely enough — there are other reasons.

Good ones. Or not so good, and that’s still another topic.

I was mildly surprised that today’s two largest libraries are both in English-speaking countries.

Maybe English and American decision-makers have preferred centralized collections recently. Or, again, something completely different.

We’re not the only ones with central libraries. Countries from Abkhazia to Zimbabwe have national libraries.

Japan’s 国立国会図書館/Kokuritsu Kokkai Toshokan is among the world’s top 20 biggest libraries. So is Національна бібліотека України імені В.І. Вернадського/Vernadsky National Library of Ukraine.

Folks are still using libraries. But not as many as in my younger days. I haven’t been inside a library in years. And I’m one of those folks who are looking something up just about every day.

I could take the library-visitors statistic and start kvetching about the decline and fall civilization, rampant ignorance, deaf falcons, drowning ceremonies, and all that.

Then launch into a lament over today’s youth: so unlike my heroically scholarly self. Walking to a library every day. Four or five times daily. Uphill. Both ways. Through snow.

I won’t. My memory’s too good, for one thing. For another: like I said, I like living in the Information Age.

Books, Then and Now

The book over there dates from around 1300. It’s a collection of treatises about natural science, philosophy, and math.

A university graduate gave it to an Oxford school. Holy Trinity collegiate church, Tattershall, Lincolnshire, owned it later.

If the diagrams look familiar, they should. That page discusses geometry and basic trigonometry. You probably saw something like it in high school or college.

I see two big differences, other than the language, between this book and today’s textbooks. The ones I used were much more focused on one branch of learning.

Science and math might be combined, but philosophy is a whole different thing these days. I think focusing on one thing at a time can make sense. That includes seeing science, religion, and philosophy as different ways of understanding reality.

Imagining that these different ways are mutually exclusive?

Some folks act as if science and religion were at war with each other. That’s a pretty common assumption today. I don’t agree, and finally learned that philosophy doesn’t belong in a semi-detached continuum.

Where was I? Medieval universities, books, academic specialties. Right.

Gutenberg, I mentioned him before, didn’t invent movable type. The technology had been around for about five centuries by his day.

What Gutenberg did was combine existing tech more efficiently, making mass-produced books practical. Not just books. Pamphlets, fliers, handbills, the plethora of written material we have today. I see that as a good thing.

But we’re talking about humans here, so it wasn’t all good news. I don’t think blaming the Thirty Years’ War on Gutenberg makes sense. (March 17, 2017; November 6, 2016)

On the ‘up’ side, my view, is that mass production lowered the cost of books. Including Bibles. I could buy an NAB St. Joseph Deluxe Gift Edition, bonded leather, brown-large print for $40.99. Plus shipping and handling, probably.

That’s not even close to what I’d pay for high-end luxury Bibles.

Or someone else would pay. I have no need or use for the bells and whistles. It’s not that I disapprove of ‘display’ Bibles. Just that the household budget is what it is, and I’m more interested in Sacred Scripture I can read without being concerned about appearance.

I read a paperback edition of the ‘Catholic Bible’ before online resources gave me faster access to the same content. My Bible had gotten somewhat tattered around the edges by then. I’ve still got it. I could replace it for about $20.23, plus shipping and handling.

That’s very roughly how much money I’d make in two hours, before I retired. There’s a story about that. For another day. Basically, a Catholic Bible, complete with indexing and footnotes, costs about two hours’ work. Quite a bargain, I think.

So: how much would my counterpart have paid in feudal Europe? Easy to ask, hard to answer. The feudal economy didn’t use money the way we do now. But working out how much making a Bible the good old-fashioned way in today’s America? That, I can do.

Words and Pictures

Today’s custom-designed handcrafted books are like the Duc de Berry’s Book of Hours. Beautiful, valuable, and not available in the corner bookstore’s paperback section.

Then, as now, the price of a luxury book was — whatever you would and could pay. Someone with the Duc de Berry’s resources could commission something like Hours.

I’ll be assuming that my hypothetical Bible is today’s NAB, New American Bible, with just text. No pictures, nothing fancy.

That Bible has a lot of words in it. Readinglength.com says the word count is 776,475. That’s pretty close to other counts I’ve seen. But I’ll assume that my hypothetical bible is only 700,000 words long.

I’ve seen quite a few DIY instructions for making a book by hand, but I’m assuming that I pay someone else to do the work.

A Job for Superscribe!

Jonathan Day Book Art offers handmade blank books on Amazon.com.

Leather-and-wood covers hold 224 pages in one of them. Some of the binding tech is contemporary, but it’s the closest equivalent I found to what could have been a serviceable Bible a millennium back.

More accurately, it was the example I found that included page count and size.

Each page is seven by eight and a half inches. It’s a bit small for a medieval book, but still large enough to accommodate handwritten text. That particular item is no longer available, but a similar one costs $55.

Estimating how many words an exceptional scribe could fit onto one of those pages is a good question.

I’ve seen estimates for larger typewritten pages from 250 to 500 words per page. Handwritten script? I could say about 200 words per page.

But that’s wildly optimistic. I’ll go with 100 words per page. These are smaller than the American standard 8½ by 11 inches.

This increasingly-hypothetical Bible would be around 7,000 pages long. All text. No pictures. Really small handwriting. I’d need an unrealistically good scribe.

Throwing plausibility to the winds, I’ll assume that my superscribe could legibly write 40 words per minutes. For eight hours a day. Six days a week. That’s 19,200 words a day, 115,200 words a week.

Real Scribes

After six weeks and part of Monday morning on the seventh, Superscribe would have finished transcribing the Bible.

Realistically, the next step would be proofreading the work. I’ll assume that takes about as long.

So 12 weeks and a day after starting the transcription process, I’d have a handmade Bible. Superscribe and a proofreader would expect pay.

I’ll assume that they agreed to work for about $5.00 an hour. That’s ridiculously low for this sort of specialized work.

They’ve been working for about 291 hours and 40 minutes. I’ll be generous and round that up to 292 hours. 292 times $5.00 is $1,460. It would be in the equivalent of nearly 32 of those handmade books. I’ll say 33, at $55 for a total of $1,815.

Add the two together, and my very hypothetical handmade Bible cost only $3,275. I think that’s an unreasonably low estimate.

I’ve made wildly optimistic assumptions about how fast Superscribe could write legibly. And I’m pretty sure I overestimated how many words per page would be practical.

Not all books were high-end luxury items like Duc de Berry’s.

The Oxford university text was more like today’s textbooks, for example. Quite a few monasteries and abbeys produced and copied their own books.2 Transcription could be done in a specialized area called a scriptorium. Maybe I’ll talk about that, but not today.

A monastery might not spend money, currency, on books they made. But the work wasn’t “free.” The job took specialists preparing material for the pages, crafting the covers, transcribing the contents, and binding the pieces.

Illustrations or diagrams would take other specialists. None of them could be working in the fields or doing other immediately-needed tasks at the same time. And the materials themselves represented some effort.

Comparing costs between economies that do and don’t use money would be more work than I’ll try this week. Making my hypothetical handcrafted Bible for an equivalent of a few thousand dollars is: optimistic.

Multiplying that by 10 wouldn’t, I suspect, be unreasonable.

Not if the book included any ‘extras.’ Like an index, commentary, illustrations, more-durable materials. You get the idea.

A few books could be worth $20,000 these days. To collectors, anyway. Someone on AbeBooks.com pointed out that a lot depends on the book’s history and condition.

A first edition of Steinbeck’s “The Grapes of Wrath,” signed by the author, could sell for upwards of $20,000. But an unsigned first edition with a missing dust jacket, torn pages and ragged cover might be unloaded at under $20.

A book fancier might decide to buy a helicopter instead.

Ford’s Flivver, Convair Model 118 and the Samson Switchblade

Consolidated Vultee Aircraft’s 1947 Convair Model 118 wasn’t the first flying car.

Henry Ford built a prototype Ford Flivver in the 1920s.

It was a compact version of today’s private aircraft, not quite what I think of as a “flying car.”

The Flivver flew several times. Then it crashed, killing the pilot. Ford still thought flying cars were coming, but focused more on ground cars after the Flivver.

I think Ford was right. We’ll have “automobiles” that fly. Eventually. Folks have been designing and occasionally building prototypes for nearly a century. Some flew, successfully. None have gone into mass production, though. Not yet.

I ran into an explanation a few decades back. It seems to make sense.

‘Ground cars’ rotate on one axis.

The vehicle will keep turning at a fixed rate or going straight as long as you hold the wheel steady. In principle. In practice, I constantly adjust the wheel a bit to deal with bumps, wind, that sort of thing.

An aircraft rotates on three axes. Freely. Flying, I understand, is a bit like driving on glare ice. Start turning, and the vehicle keeps turning. On its vertical, fore-aft and port-starboard axes.

We’ve got control systems that assist pilots, but it’s the same three-axis control issue. Small wonder pilots need training.

The Samson Switchblade prototype hasn’t been built yet.

The last I heard, it passed wind tunnel tests and carbon fiber parts for a protype are being made. This isn’t the only in-development effort, and may fly.

It might, maybe, make it into full production. We’ve learned a lot since the 1920s. My guess is that when we do get ‘real’ flying cars, they’ll use control technology that’s a bit like today’s autonomous vehicles. And that’s — what else? — another topic, for another day.

Serious predictions of ‘a helicopter in every garage’ were fading when I started high school. Some folks have personal helicopters, but not many.

You can build a helicopter from a kit that costs about $20,000. It’s little more than a rotor, motor, frame and seat.

‘Where’s My Flying Car?’

Interestingly, Albert Robida’s 1882 illustration may not be far from the mark.

Not the open-air seating or, probably, 1880s design aesthetic.

I’m thinking about how Robida’s imagined future handles the control issue.

He apparently assumed that, with few if any exceptions, the flying taxis and buses were operated by pilots: not one of the passengers, like today’s personal ground cars. A few decades later, pulp magazine artists imagined humanoid robots in similar roles.

The ‘driver’ of today’s robotic cars and trucks is tucked inside the vehicle, but it’s the same idea. Only real. That’s going to be huge. I’m pretty sure it’ll be another good news/bad news scenario. Like I said: that’s for another day.

Getting back to dilemmas 0f the rich, famous or not, and helicopters.

I don’t have $20 to burn, let alone $20,000. But if I did, was decades younger, and not married, I might buy a build-your-own-helicopter kit. It’d be little more than an open frame, seat, motor and rotor. But it’d fly. Assuming that I didn’t crash on takeoff.

Or I could buy a used 2014 Millennium MH-1 New Helicopter for $45,995. A bargain, probably. A used 2-seat 2010 Safari Helicopter goes for $107,995. Or I could get a 2007 Mosquito 2-seater for $40,000.

A ‘family van’ equivalent might be a 1992 Eurocopter BO 105 $539,900.3

Even if we had a half-million-plus to blow on discretionary spending, my wife would have words about the purchase. Good grief, I’d have words. We profoundly don’t need something like that. Wouldn’t fit in the back yard, for one thing.

Over-the-house helipad, that could work. But seriously: I don’t get out in the family ground van much. A flying van we don’t need.

New Horizons

The 21st century isn’t what it used to be.

Some seriously expected us to have cities on the moon by now, or at least permanent settlements. Flying cars are still in the research and development stages.

Robots are: different. Not what most expected. And certainly not the homicidal maniacs with a dash of megalomania so beloved by some authors.

We didn’t have the environmental collapse, ice age, thermonuclear End Times, or assorted other catastrophes. Can’t say I’m disappointed by that.

On the whole, I like living in ‘the future.’ The real one. It’s nowhere near as wonderful or dreadful as some dreamed.

But also on the whole, I think it’s better than what we had. Not perfect. But like I said: we keep trying. And occasionally succeeding.

I think we’ve got a lot to look forward to. More millennia of hard work, and new horizons we’re just beginning to see:


1 Culture and libraries:

2 Books:

3 Personal aircraft:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

More Mass Murder

Death happens. I’ll die, sooner or later. That’s the way it is. I’ve lasted more that six decades so far. Some folks I’ve known haven’t lasted this long. Some will almost certainly outlive me. But like I said, death happens.

But its inevitability doesn’t make murder okay. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2261)

You’ve probably seen the news. Some high school kids in Kentucky didn’t go home this week. They were killed at their school:

I’ve seen quite a few mass murders in the news this year. That’s not good. Neither, I think, are reactions I’ve seen. I don’t like seeing the usual ‘it’s the other party’s fault’ from politicos, or assorted other blame games.

That’s one reason I won’t blame public education, or say that we must ban high schools now, or demand the immediate deportation of teachers. Another reason is that I think those ideas make no more sense than other — sadly real — responses.

Murder, mass or not, is a bad thing to do and nobody should do it.

But it’s not something new. Hammurabi’s law code included penalties for murder. And theft. (September 25, 2016)

I don’t think either can be blamed on technology, and certainly don’t think we should return to Hammurabi’s ‘steal and die’ policy. (November 15, 2017)

We probably wouldn’t hear about so many nasty crimes if it weren’t for Gutenberg’s printing press and online news.

But I don’t think we were better off when folks heard little if any news of far-off lands. And “far-off lands” meant anything more than a day’s walk from the village.

I think that America isn’t perfect, and that thinking about reasonable changes is a good idea. A key idea there is “thinking.” Feeling bad about what happened is natural. But we’ve got brains. Using them seems prudent.

I’ve talked about this before. A lot:

Posted in Being a Citizen | Tagged , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Remembering Wisdom

I’m a Christian. So why, one might ask, am I not denouncing something most folks enjoy: like demon rum or Bingo? Or playing the Grinch for Halloween? (October 30, 2017; October 31, 2016; July 10, 2016)

Or enjoying a friendly pint with the boys, but adding my voice to the ensemble ‘prophesying’ the purported perils of fantasy and imagination? (July 16, 2017)

Or at least stalwartly refusing to learn anything we didn’t know before the 18th century.

Choices

The answer’s pretty simple. I’m not that sort of Christian. I’m a Catholic. By choice.

I signed up as an adult, a few decades back now. The decision meant changing a few opinions and assumptions, but not many.

I still enjoy science fiction and fantasy stories, and think jack o’lanterns are fun.

Thinking that they ward off evil spirits would be a bad idea. The jack o’lanterns, that is. I’ve yet to meet someone who sees them as anything other than holiday decorations, so I figure it’s a non-issue where I’ve lived.

My alcohol intake is nearly zero, but I don’t think Carrie Nation made sense. Drinking in moderation isn’t a problem. I wasn’t doing the “in moderation” part, and found that cutting out was easier than cutting down.

I’ve never had ‘Bingo fever.’ If that had been a problem, I hope I’d have had the sense to see that the problem was in me.

A reasonable solution would have been to stop spending so much time and money on Bingo, or whatever was out of balance in my life.

Ignoring family, work — and God — in a tireless crusade to stamp out Bingo? That’s a daft idea on several levels. And another topic. Topics.

Besides, I’ve said it before. Sin and Satan are real. But Holy Willie is a terrible role model, and “sin” isn’t what some folks seem to imagine. (December 4, 2016; November 21, 2016; November 13, 2016)

“God’s God” and Other Opinions

“God’s God, I’m not.” Neither is Aristotle. In the image of God is another matter. I’ll get to that later.

“God’s God, I’m not” is hardly an original idea. Many folks have said the same thing.

But it’s not the only possible opinion.

Shirley McClain said “I am God” back in 1987. That was in her “Out on a Limb” miniseries. I’ve got options galore for responding to that.

I could denounce mainstream entertainment. Or do a Dylan Thomas and rage against old ideas refurbished and reissued as New Age beliefs. Both seem like a waste of time and effort.

The way I see it, we’ve got a surplus of folks raging and ranting. Not so much supporting what they believe, as attacking what they don’t. I keep an eye out for nuggets of reason in the slurry, but that’s about it.

About Shirley McCain’s “I am God” thing, I don’t see myself that way. I hadn’t seen the mini-series, or read her earlier book. And don’t plan to. I did, however, see what someone who wasn’t ranting said about it.

My understanding is that she made her daft-sounding remark after realizing that folks should “assume responsibility for their own karmic destiny.”

Instead of going ballistic over “karmic,” I’ll remember that someone was talking about personal responsibility.

I can’t reasonably argue against that, so I won’t. Moving along.

Memento More, Carpe Diem, and Flying Saucers

I don’t see movies, television, opera, or one-act comedies as inherently evil. They can be fun, which I also don’t see as basically bad.

Pleasures, in moderation, are fine. What’s tricky is learning moderation. Tricky for me, anyway.

I see a measure of wisdom in memento mori and carpe diem. (October 8, 2017; November 11, 2016)

New Age isn’t all that new these days. As a major cultural influence, I think it’s going the way of enthusiasms for Velikovsky, ancient astronauts and flying saucers.

I have, however, briefly touched on New Age beliefs, along with swooning Saints and ham sandwiches. (July 2, 2017)

Wisdom

An eager Christian I knew in college told me that science fiction isn’t Christian.

Fair enough. “Pilgrim’s Progress” and “Brave New World” don’t have much in common, apart from having obvious messages. But that’s not what he meant.

He told me that Christians shouldn’t read science fiction.

Nobody should. According to him. I suppose he was trying to save my soul, since he knew about my eclectic interests.

I saw his point.

He quite correctly noted that many if not all science fiction tales depend on thinking that humans can decide what we do, and have considerable control over this world.

That, according to him, wasn’t “Christian.”

This was in the Swinging Sixties, when a great deal of published science fiction took the old ‘lords of creation’ attitude.

The ‘60s cultural thing doesn’t quite match the calendar decade. Kennedy’s assassination in 1963 is a plausible start, with 1974’s Watergate scandal as a grand finale. And that’s yet another topic.

The current ‘fear and tremble before Mother Nature’s might’ attitude isn’t much of an improvement. But quite a few folks saw that as more of a hippie tree-hugger thing in those days of yore.

Defenders of American values rebuked excessive love of nature and other newfangled ideas.

They had a point, and hid it well.

I think more folks would have taken them seriously, if they weren’t also preaching the perils of “Bewitched” and men growing beards.

I don’t recall anyone condemning the prevalence of polypropylene furniture. Odd, that.

The eager Christian was a ‘Bible believer.’ So am I, the Catholic variety.

My Bible includes books edited out of most American versions. I see that as a ‘plus’ for being Catholic. I also like having access to millennia of accumulated wisdom.

That doesn’t make me better than others. But I think it helps me see more than my culture’s outlook enhanced by my own opinions. (November 5, 2017; October 29, 2017; August 20, 2017)

One of the counter-cultural values we have, or should, is seeing knowledge and this universe as good things. (March 26, 2017)

Giving God credit for what we see, and our brains, makes sense. So does remembering that God sees this wonder-filled universe differently, and likes it.

“For he gave me sound knowledge of what exists, that I might know the structure of the universe and the force of its elements,”
(Wisdom 7:17)

“Indeed, before you the whole universe is like a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth.
“But you have mercy on all, because you can do all things; and you overlook sins for the sake of repentance.
“For you love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for you would not fashion what you hate.
“How could a thing remain, unless you willed it; or be preserved, had it not been called forth by you?”
(Wisdom 11:22–25)

“Dominion” and Awesome Responsibilities

The most stalwart guardians of 19th century ideals were still defending the barricade when I finished high school.

But by the ’60s, most folks were at least starting to realize that the Victorian ‘lords of creation’ attitude left a huge mess.

The problem isn’t just environmental and ecological damage.

A fair number of folks assume that pillaging natural resources is a core Christian value.

I don’t agree, but see where they get the idea. It’s right there in Genesis. Sort of.

We’ve got “dominion” over this world. The problem, as I see it, is that too many Victorian Christians apparently read Genesis 1:26. Period.

“Then God said: Let us make human beings in our image, after our likeness. Let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, the birds of the air, the tame animals, all the wild animals, and all the creatures that crawl on the earth.
“God created mankind in his image; in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.
“God blessed them and God said to them: Be fertile and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it. Have dominion over the fish of the sea, the birds of the air, and all the living things that crawl on the earth.”
(Genesis 1:26–28)

What I see in the rest of Sacred Scripture doesn’t encourage smug self-satisfaction.

“God looked at everything he had made, and found it very good. Evening came, and morning followed—the sixth day.”
(Genesis 1:31)

“The LORD God then took the man and settled him in the garden of Eden, to cultivate and care for it.”
(Genesis 2:15)

“Speak to the Israelites and tell them: When you enter the land that I am giving you, let the land, too, keep a sabbath for the LORD.”
(Leviticus 24:2)

“Look, the heavens, even the highest heavens, belong to the LORD, your God, as well as the earth and everything on it.”
(Deuteronomy 10:14)

“What are humans that you are mindful of them, mere mortals that you care for them?
“Yet you have made them little less than a god, crowned them with glory and honor.”
(Psalms 8:5–6)

“A psalm of David. The earth is the LORD’s and all it holds, the world and those who dwell in it.”
(Psalms 24:1)

Taking Genesis 1:26 and Psalms 8:5-6 out of context, I could argue that Western Civilization’s upper crust had the God-given right to plunder this world’s resources.

Or that it doesn’t matter what we do to animals. Folks on any rung of the social ladder can get that wrong.

I can’t. Won’t, more accurately. I could, in principle, abandon facts and reason, along with Catechism of the Catholic Church 373, 1938, 2402 and 2415 through 2418.

I’d also be obliged to ignore the universal destination of goods. That’s the idea that private property is fine: if we remember that we share this world with everyone else. (Catechism, 1937-1938, 2211, 2213, 2237-2238, 2401–2406, 2415, 2456)

That doesn’t strike me as prudent.

I don’t know how many Victorian industrialists actually said that God gave them this world, or believed it. But the attitude was, I think, there. And almost impossible to miss.

Taking the mess left by that lot in light of Matthew 25:14–30, I really don’t feel smug about humanity’s awesome power — and frightening responsibilities. Happily, using our brains is an option:

Posted in Being an Artist, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Chasing Butterflies and Truth

Which came first? The butterfly or the flower? And how did flowers happen at all?

The question hasn’t been answered yet, not quite. But scientists are closer to finding answers. Meanwhile, wondering whether chickens or eggs came first gives philosophers something to do.

Aristotle came up with an answer. So did Anaximander, who figured thunder and lightning were natural events: not evidence of divine anger issues. I’ll talk about those two, beetles, and Orlando Ferguson’s flat Earth map.

Also butterflies, flowers and why I think pursuing truth and seeking God work together.


Professor Ferguson’s Amazing “Bible Map of the World”


(Orlando Ferguson’s 1893 “Map of the Square and Stationary Earth.” The legend at top says, in part, “this … is the Bible Map of the World.”)

It could be worse. Christian bookstores where I grew up didn’t have entire sections devoted to earnest and well-illustrated defenses of a flat Earth.

They did, however sell a great many books condemning evil influences like evolution and the Catholic Church. Evil in their eyes, not mine.

It helps, maybe, that many folks in my civilization have realized Earth is round for millennia. We’ve had ‘flat Earth’ enthusiasts of various sorts, but they’re a colorful sideshow: not the main event. (November 5, 2017; May 19, 2017)

On the other hand, enough Christians have odd notions to keep stereotypes going.

I read a comment something like this several years back: ‘Christians? They think Earth is flat.’ That’s a paraphrase, but a close one. I wasn’t taking notes that time.

Seeing stuff like this isn’t an everyday thing for me.

But it happens, and I don’t like it. That’s almost inevitable, since I’m interested in science, among a great many other things.

I’m also a Christian and take my faith seriously. But I’m not the sort of Christian who dotes on shunning science and opposing Catholic influences. I’m a Catholic.

I was taking notes when someone made this request — “Please cite the Bible as your source, so that everyone can be keenly aware you have made no distinction between mythology and science….” (May 19, 2017)

This is where I could imitate Non Sequitur’s Danae. I won’t.

Partly because I don’t have minions. Mostly because I’d much rather make sense.

Back to that “Bible Map.”

I give Orlando Ferguson’s variation on the flat Earth theme points for originality.

I don’t remember another anachronistic ‘Bible truth’ trying to accommodate reality by curving Earth’s northern hemisphere.

I did a little checking. “Prof. Orlando Ferguson” was from Hot Springs, South Dakota: as it says on his map.

He was a “professor,” too: a real estate developer by trade, professing his apparently-unique mix of Bible verses and science with a 92-page lecture.

He went on tour with his lecture and map, selling the maps for 25 cents a pop. At least one has survived: remarkable, considering the flimsy paper used.

I see its preservation as a good thing. A lot of work went into making it. It’s an attractive curio — and a nice showpiece of late-19th century culture.

Bible Bits and a Blood Moon

Orlando Ferguson’s map says he’s got 400 bits from the Bible “that Condemn the Globe Theory, or the Flying Earth, and None Sustain It.” That’s near the top.

I’m a Catholic, so taking the Bible seriously isn’t an option. It’s a requirement. I talk about that, and what we’ve been passing along for two millennia, fairly often. (August 18, 2017; July 30, 2017)

Basically, Catholicism isn’t a roll-your-own faith. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 74–95, 101–133)

Taking Sacred Scripture, the Bible, seriously is one thing. Deciding that it means what I want it to mean is something else. Also a bad idea. (Catechism, 85, 890, 2033)

Back to Professor Ferguson’s amazing Bible Map. Again. An impressive number of Bible verses fills the lower left corner.

Each verse includes an excerpt: in “thus sayeth” and “hath laid” ye olde style English. I see a lot less of that these days, and that’s another topic.

Ferguson’s map listing leads with Exodus 17:12; Joshua 10:12-13 and Chronicles 16:30. He doesn’t say if that’s Chronicles 1 or 2. My guess is that he used a Hebrew Bible.

More Bible bits from Prof. Ferguson: Psalms 136:6-7; Isaiah 12:10, 11:12 14:7, 30:1, 38:8-9, 40:22, 52:5, 54:24 and 58:13. Plus Isaiah’s entire 29th chapter. Jeremiah 31:35-36 and Acts 2:20 wrap up Professor Ferguson’s Bible verse map listing.

I’ll give him credit for doing his Bible research. I’m not sure how Isaiah 29 supports his flat Earth idea. Prophecies and getting a grip are yet another topic, for another day.

His verse from Acts talks about the sun going dark and the moon turning to blood “before the coming of the great and splendid day of the Lord.” (Acts 2:20)

I talked about a “blood moon prophecy” and another fizzled ‘End Times’ prognostication last year. (August 23, 2017)

Like I said, it could be worse.

Mainstream American Protestant outfits were defending Christianity against the Copernican threat up to the early 20th century. I gather that the Missouri Synod started distancing themselves from those fervent faithful in 1902.1

Defending the Weak?

I like to think that many or most folks mean well. That includes those who say they’re defending impressionable minds from enticing but evil ideas.

Those defending others from religion may honestly believe that outfits like Pillar of Fire represented Christian values.

That lot were wacky even by 1920s conservative standards. Their ilk tend to be among the loudest voices. I think their enthusiasm is admirable. Not their beliefs. (September 22, 2017; August 13, 2017)

I don’t like seeing bad behavior by Christianity’s lunatic fringe getting so much attention. But I see no point in denying that it happens.

I’m more upset about less loony Christians who seem determined to defend others from science. Some may believe that science, particularly evolution, is evil because they think it’s responsible for moral decay, racism, and other social ills.

I’ll assume that they also mean well. But I think they unintentionally support the ‘faith demands ignorance’ stereotype.

Christians who see the Catholic Church as a threat may mean well well, too. Fulton Sheen got it right, I think:

“There are not a hundred people in America who hate the Catholic Church. There are millions of people who hate what they wrongly believe to be the Catholic Church — which is, of course, quite a different thing.”
(“Radio Replies Vol. 1,” Forward, page ix, Fulton J. Sheen (1938) via Wikiquote)

Bias, Being Human, and Aristotle

Ideally, researchers would never have biases. Or at least not let their flawed perceptions affect their work.

Like I keep saying, we don’t live in an ideal world. Scientists and scholars are human.

We’ve had a few outright fraudsters. Some may have honestly believed what they said.

Nott and Gliddon’s 1857 “Indigenous races of the earth” probably played well in the Victorian age. Its ‘white folks are better’ conclusions didn’t stand up to analysis.

F. Kupka’s iconic “caveman” Neanderthal rendering was another matter.

I don’t blame the artist. It’s taking scientists a long time to get used to evidence that Neanderthals may have been much more ‘human’ than the grunting brutes we imagined (March 10, 2017; September 23, 2016)

The problem isn’t just with science. Mistaking strong feelings and cultural quirks for truth and unchanging realities can affect anything we do. And sometimes does, sadly.

I’ve talked about ersatz science, published gibberish and the Thirty Years’ War before. (August 4, 2017; April 28, 2017; August 26, 2016)

Darwin’s “Origin of Species” came out a few years after the Nott and Gliddon book.

Darwin’s research was sound science. I suspect one reason it’s still such a hot-button item is that it doesn’t pander to what some folks want to believe is true.

Besides science, Darwin apparently knew some history. He added a history of evolutionary thought to later “Origin” editions, going back to Aristotle.

I think Aristotle was smart. He gave my civilization quite a few good ideas, and some that we’ve learned aren’t accurate.

Most of us have gotten over the shock of learning that Aristotle was wrong and Aristarchus of Samos was on the right track about Earth and our sun.

Strong evidence of that was accumulating about 475 years back. Copernicus was right, pretty much, and that’s yet again another topic. (April 28, 2017; March 24, 2017)

Maybe by the 2490s most of us will realize that accepting evolution won’t shatter an informed Christian faith. Provided we keep up today’s pace.

If I take Aristarchus-to-Copernicus as my ‘norm,’ reality won’t sink in for many until the early 4100s. (April 28, 2017; March 24, 2017)

Aristarchus, Anaximander, and Aristotle are among my favorite examples of smart folks who had good reasons for what they figured was true. But who turned out to be mistaken. At least in part.

Chickens and Cosmologies

Getting back to the “chicken or egg” causality dilemma, Aristotle saw chickens and eggs as an infinite sequence, with no true start. That was a good fit with Aristotelian cosmology, and his idea that species can’t change.

Many of Anaximander’s ideas were close to what we’ve learned recently.

His cosmology included a free-floating Earth and the possibility of multiple worlds. He thought lightning and thunder were what we call natural events: not evidence of divine anger.

Unlike Aristotle, he figured species can change. He suggested that we happened when critters had to adapt to dry land.2

Anaximander was right, basically. But he didn’t have much data to back up his speculation. Neither did Aristotle, although his Earth-centered cosmology may have seemed much more reasonable. Still does, to some.

Anaximander might have had more influence, sooner, if scholars had kept more of his work. As it is, much of what we know about him is what Aristotle wrote.

I see Aristotle’s logic as a huge factor in his later acceptance. I also see an impressive lack of logic in what some of his fans assumed. (November 5, 2017)

Nearly 24 centuries after Anaximander, some folks — Christians — still saw lightning as God’s thunderbolts.

Some still do, apparently. Seeing the Almighty as a sort of super-Zeus enjoys perennial popularity. I’m not sure why. (November 19, 2017; September 10, 2017; October 16, 2016)

Bombardier Beetles

J. B. S. Haldane’s observation that “God has an inordinate fondness for beetles” reflected his belief that God isn’t there.

I don’t agree with Haldane’s philosophical beliefs. But I like the quote.

I see it more as illustrating that Isaiah 55:8–9 is right. God’s thoughts aren’t ours.

Someone asked me about bombardier beetles and evolution in January of 2014. He’d read an assertion that the beetles couldn’t have survived evolution. The idea was that their explosive exhaust would have obliterated them before their ‘canon’ was complete.

A mental image of exploding beetles and more cerebral interests appealed to me. I started checking sources, and posted an answer. Scientific sources, not Leviticus 11:22 or Psalms 78:45. Today’s ‘flowers and butterflies’ post seems like a good time to bring beetles up again.

The story of how bombardier beetles got their unique defense mechanism is something we’re still learning. It’s a mystery in the sense that we haven’t found fossil or other hard evidence verifying a particular step-by-step sequence.

But scientists have enough pieces of the puzzle to show how it could have been done. That probably wouldn’t be enough to convince a dedicated disciple of Ussher or today’s creation science enthusiasts. I can’t imagine what would be.

Briefly, all animals produce the chemicals in bombardier beetle ‘boom juice.’ All insects have at least some of the bombardier beetle’s mechanisms. This critter isn’t as inexplicable as it seems.3

But it’s still weird. So are platypuses. Platypi? Those duck-billed Australian whatsits.

As usual, there’s more to say about beetles and other strange critters. But that’ll wait.


Floral Success Puzzle Answered: Maybe


(From Getty Images, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Angiosperms are the most diverse group of land plants, with hundreds of thousands of known species”
(BBC News))

“How flowering plants conquered the world”
Helen Briggs, BBC News (January 14, 2018)

“Scientists think they have the answer to a puzzle that baffled even Charles Darwin: How flowers evolved and spread to become the dominant plants on Earth.

“Flowering plants, or angiosperms, make up about 90% of all living plant species, including most food crops.

“In the distant past, they outpaced plants such as conifers and ferns, which predate them, but how they did this has has been a mystery.

“New research suggests it is down to genome size – and small is better….”

I like that last sentence: saying “research suggests” instead of ‘scientists declare!’

I prefer science news written by someone who understands that scientists aren’t prophets or preachers. Some scientists may see themselves that way, and that’s still another topic.

We’ve known about cells for a few centuries now, and understand some of their functions. But there’s a lot we don’t know. Not yet. We’ve learned enough to make this research possible: and intriguing.4

Genomes and Pores


(Simonin, Adam B. Roddy; via PLOS Biology; used w/o permission.)
(Genome size in 393 land plant species.)

“Small is better” for plant cells, maybe, since smaller photosynthesizing cells can process more carbon dioxide per unit volume than bigger ones.

Smaller cells let plants get more cells for each bit of nutrients they absorb. Smaller cells mean smaller — and more — veins and pores on leaves. That’s another productivity boost.

That’s what these scientists say may be so. It makes sense. They’ve got statistical data to back up the suggestion. They could easily be on the right track.

Right now, this is a “research suggests” situation. I figure we’ll know more in a few years. Or decades. Probably both. Genetic analysis is a new field, and just one of many new research tools we’ve been developing.


Dawn of the Lepidoptera


(From Bas van de Schootbrugge, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“One of the scales under the microscope”
(BBC News))

“Meet the butterflies from 200 million years ago”
Helen Briggs, BBC News (January 10, 2018)

“Newly discovered fossils show that moths and butterflies have been on the planet for at least 200 million years.

“Scientists found fossilised butterfly scales the size of a speck of dust inside ancient rock from Germany.

“The find pushes back the date for the origins of the Lepidoptera, one of the most prized and studied insect groups.

“Researchers say they can learn more about the conservation of butterflies and moths by studying their early evolution….”

I’m pretty sure that this article’s first four paragraphs could spark heated discussions. Starting with whether or not butterflies need conservation and when the critters first showed up.

Using some criteria, butterflies didn’t exist until the Palaeocene, about 56,000,000 years back. That’s way before Ussher’s ‘first light’ in 4004 BC.

I’ll get to belief, reality, the universe and me after chasing a few butterflies.

Scientists found the oldest ‘Paleocene’ butterfly fossils in Denmark’s Fur Formation. The oldest known American butterfly is Prodryas persephone. Prodryas lived about 34,000,000 years back, where Colorado is now.

Post-dinosaur butterflies were more like current models than the critters these scientists studied. What’s really odd about the 200 million year old critters is that they had may have had structures like the ones butterflies use to get nectar from flowers.

That’s downright puzzling. Flower didn’t come until long after these early lepidopterans. Scientists had figured that butterfly mouths and flowers had evolved side-by-side. If that was so, nectar-adapted butterflies wouldn’t have shown up before flowers.

Maybe someone will say this proves that evolution is a lie, a vile religion of the Antichrist, or whatever seems like a catchy slogan.

I don’t think so. I think we’ve got a new puzzle to work on. A delightfully complicated one.

A Big Puzzle


(From Timo J. B. van Eldijk et al., via Science Advances, used w/o permission.)
(Fossil scales, up close. The black bars with each scale are 20 micrometers long. A micrometer, or micron, is one thousandth of a millimeter. That’s 0.000039 inch.)

About conserving butterflies and all that, I think Earth is where live. Taking reasonably good care of the place makes sense. Emphasis on reasonably. It’s also part of our job.

I see no point in jumping on the latest ‘we’re doomed’ bandwagon, or imagining that what we do doesn’t matter. (August 11, 2017)

Now, about these scales and the critters that grew them.

Some of these early lepidopterans lived in the Rhaetian, right before the Triassic–Jurassic extinction event. About half of Earth’s species didn’t survive that. But the rest did, including critters that would be ancestors of dinosaurs, butterflies — and us.

Don’t bother trying to remember those names. There won’t be a test. I’ve put a few links near the end of this post.5

Like I said, I expect lively debate about these scales: and how they fit into life’s story.

I’m pretty sure there won’t be much trouble establishing that they are from lepidoptera: critters like moths and butterflies. Scientists have gotten pretty good at classifying critters by looking at very tiny details in scales, hair, and the like.

A big puzzle involves flowers and nectar.

Hard Work Ahead

Some of those scales came from critters very much like, and presumably ancestors of, living insects with specialized nectar-drinking mouths.

It’s likely that the Rhaetian and Hettangian critters had similar mouths.

If that’s so, it’s pretty much a sure thing that they used the ‘nectar-adapted’ mouths for something else. Learning what that was should keep at least a few scientist busy for quite a while.

It’ll be hard work. Particularly since we’ve found very few fossilized lepidoptera.

That’s hardly surprising. Butterflies and moths generally doesn’t live where fossils easily form. On top of that, we’ve learned that one bunch migrated over open water: what’s now the North Sea. That was after dinosaurs and before the mesonyx heyday.

Mesonyx is another odd critter, by today’s standards. Was. Think a wolf. With hooves.

Back to butterflies. Scientists have been doing well to find fossilized bits and pieces: including these microscopic scales. Most of what we know comes from DNA analysis.

There’s more to say about butterflies, fossils, and strange critters.

But I said I’d talk about belief, reality, and why I see no problem with using my brain. I’ll get to that next.

After a tip of the hat to Leeuwenhoek, Mendel and the Human Genome Project.


Animalicules

European scholars were probably using magnifying glasses before Galileo got in trouble for dissing Aristotle. His personality didn’t help. (March 24, 2017; June 2, 2017)

Leeuwenhoek built his microscope a few decades later. He called tiny critters he saw “animalcules.”

Robert Hooke wrote about “cells” he’d seen in cork slices. That was in 1665. He figured what he was seeing wasn’t alive, which was true.

He’d seen and described cell walls: not the living cells. Maybe Hook’s descriptions are a reason Hook often gets credit for discovering cells.

Gregor Mendel studied inherited traits in peas during the late 1850s and early 1860s. Friedrich Miescher discovered nucleic acids in 1869. The Human Genome Project mapped the human genome on April 14, 2003. It’s been an eventful century-and-a-half.

I think we’ve just started getting answers from genetics research. And many new puzzles. (November 3, 2017; March 31, 2017; September 23, 2016)

Drinking May be Hazardous to Your Health

Aristotle didn’t say anything about cells. The Bible doesn’t mention them.

Not unless you count Psalms 139:13. On the other hand, I can imagine someone using Ezekiel 27 as a prophecy against believing that we don’t have any parts smaller than bones and sinews.

That wouldn’t, I think, make sense. But neither do some other fervently-held beliefs I’ve seen. I haven’t run across a tightly-wound Christian who won’t believe in cells because they’re not Biblical. I’m not sure why.

Maybe it’s because we’ve known about cells for a few centuries, and finally learned that drinking animalcules was a bad idea. On the other hand, some folks didn’t ‘believe in’ vaccinations in 1902, and still don’t. (July 21, 2017; August 21, 2016)

Changes

I don’t “believe in” cells or cell theory. Or evolution. Not in the sense that I expect any or all to answer the big questions.

But I’m quite sure cells exist and that some affect our health.

I’m also quite sure that critters have been changing for a very long time.

I talked about science, religion, and the Big Bang model last week. (January 12, 2018)

Recapping what I keep saying, the Bible isn’t a science textbook. Genesis wasn’t written by an American.

I don’t expect ‘just the facts’ from a book of poetry, or metaphorical flights of fancy from a paper on orbital mechanics. That said, I’ll start with “let there be LIGHT.”

Fast-forwarding from Genesis 1:3 to 1:11, the first plants appeared about a half-billion years back.

Later, if you don’t think of eukaryotic algae as plants.

Earlier, if you count cynaobacteria. Lots earlier. That’s looking at life on Earth through a scientist’s eyes.6

Metaphorically speaking.

I don’t think God gives us brains and has a snit when we use them. Or blundered by including curiosity in our motivational toolkit.

The problem Darwin had with flowering plants is that they showed up so abruptly.

His evolutionary theory involved gradual change of one species into another.

Not the sort of abrupt jump he’d found in the fossil record.

We’ve found many more fossils since then, and learned quite a bit about life’s long story. Darwin, it turns out, was wrong.

But not entirely. Evolution happens. Species change. Sometimes they change gradually. Sometimes the change is — apparently — abrupt.

We’ve learned about DNA. Genetic analysis is showing us relationships between critters we hadn’t seen before.

And another reason the ‘tree of life’ has been rearranged a few times. I think we’ll see quite a few more changes in how scientists define species, kingdoms, domains, and all that.

Folks who like everything to stay pretty much the way it was when they grew up won’t like that. I’m having a ball, trying to keep up with what we’re learning.

Living in a Post-Lagash World

I could believe that we live on a flat plate, no more than a few thousand miles across, with nothing but a dome between us and the cosmic ocean.

I might have, if I’d lived in Lagash when Urukagina was cleaning up a mess left by Lugalanda; or Ur when Enheduanna’s poetry was enriching Sumerian literature.

It’s a ‘Biblical’ cosmology, in the sense that Sacred Scripture includes poetic imagery from Mesopotamian culture.

I see that as resulting from folks who the Bible living in the western reaches of that civilization. The imagery would have been familiar to them.

I think the Bible is God’s word. I also think God decided to have human authors write Scripture. (Catechism, 101–106)

Some living today may firmly believe that they live on a plate supported by pillars. Some of that fraction may also say they are Christians. If they are consciously following our Lord, doing God’s will as well as they can, I think they’re Christians.

But I also think they’re mistaken about the size and structure of God’s visible world.

Knowing what I do about post-Lagash developments, I couldn’t embrace ancient Mesopotamian cosmology and follow our Lord. Accepting truth is part of my faith.

In a State of Journeying

Since the notion that seeking knowledge offends God is rather well-entrenched in some circles, I’d better explain that.

And why I do not think acknowledging orderly change means believing that an orderly God cannot exist.

I’m a Catholic. I see faith as a willing and conscious “assent to the whole truth that God has revealed.” (Catechism, 142–150)

Again, I think God’s revealed truth is in the Bible.

I also think God’s truth is in everything we can observe. If I’m paying attention, I’ll find God’s truth in the natural world’s order and beauty. Noticing, understanding, and appreciating this world’s wonders is a good idea. (Catechism, 32, 41, 74, 283, 341, 2500)

Or I can close my eyes, cover my ears, and hum real loud: stalwartly ignoring God’s work. That doesn’t strike me as a good way to show appreciation, so I won’t.

I think God could have made a world, a universe, that was perfect from the start: and couldn’t change. Maybe there are physical realities like that, not part of this space-time.

But the continuum we’re in changes. I’m okay with that. Not that my attitude could change God’s source code for this reality. God’s God, I’m not, and that’s a good thing.

I don’t know why God made this universe “in a state of journeying,” moving toward an ultimate perfection: but not there yet. (Catechism, 302)

My guess is that even if God somehow showed me the reasons, I wouldn’t understand. Not completely. It’s not possible for any creature.

God is the Almighty, infinite, eternal, beyond human understanding. Even so, wanting and trying to understand is a good idea. (Catechism, 27, 155, 202, 206–209, 230)

So is using our brains. Noticing the order and beauty surrounding us is part of what we’re supposed to be doing. If we’re doing it right, we’ll learn something about God in the process. (Catechism, 31–32, 35–36, 301, 303–306, 311, 319, 1704, 2293–2296)

“Wonderful Things”

Pursuing knowledge and seeking God both mean learning something new, at least occasionally. Sometimes that’s not easy, particularly if what’s new doesn’t fit neatly into old assumptions.

But I think it’s a good idea. And sometimes we find “wonderful things.”

“…Occasionally people ask me how I can be Catholic and a science journalist. The answer is simple: Truth does not contradict truth. Both science and religion are pursuit of truth. They’re after different aspects of truth, different layers of reality, but they’re still both fundamentally about truth….”
(Camille M. Carlisle, Sky and Telescope (June 2017))

“…faith must be there first, if one wishes to see God in Creation.”
(Brother Guy Consolmagno, Vatican Observatory, in a Zenit interview (May 2017))

“No matter where and how far we look, nowhere do we find a contradiction between religion and natural science. On the contrary, we find a complete concordance in the very points of decisive importance. Religion and natural science do not exclude each other…. They mutually supplement and condition each other.
“Religion and natural science are fighting a joint battle in an incessant, never relaxing crusade against scepticism and against dogmatism, against disbelief and against superstition, and the rallying cry in this crusade has always been, and always will be: ‘On to God!’”
(“Religion and Natural Science,” Lecture about the relationship between religion and science. Originally entitled Religion und Naturwissenschaft. (1937) Complete translation into English: “Max Planck: Scientific Autobiography and Other Papers” (1968); via Wikiquote [emphasis mine])

“…Even if the difficulty is after all not cleared up and the discrepancy seems to remain, the contest must not be abandoned; truth cannot contradict truth…”
(“Providentissimus Deus,” Pope Leo XIII (November 18, 1893))

Lord Carnarvon: “Can you see anything?”
Howard Carter: “Yes, wonderful things!”
(First look into Tutankhamen’s tomb (1922) via Wikipedia)

I think we’ve barely begun discovering “wonderful things:”


1 Dealing with reality, and other options:

2 Chickens, eggs, and philosophers:

  • “Symposiacs,” Book 2, Question 3
    Plutarch (1st century AD) From “The complete works of Plutarch: essays and miscellanies,” Thomas Y. Crowell (1909) via The University of Adelaide Library

3 Bombardier beetles, briefly:

4 Cells, science and flowers:

5 More than you need to know about lepidoptera:

6 Life and science:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , | 4 Comments