Gnosticism

Some folks act as if they think physical reality is bad and having a body is icky. The notion’s ‘Biblical,’ sort of.

Galatians 5:19 through 21 call bad ideas like licentiousness, hatreds and idolatry “works of the flesh.” With a little paraphrasing, I could claim that 1 Corinthians 3:3 says jealousy and rivalry are “of the flesh.” Romans 8:3 mentions “sinful flesh.”

Taking those verses, ignoring Genesis 1:31, Psalms 84:3, Ecclesiastes 2:24–25 and two millennia of Catholic teaching, and I might see loathing physical reality as an option. But not, I think, a reasonable one. (October 8, 2017)

“Spiritual” isn’t necessarily good or bad. Neither is having a body. What matters is what I decide, how I use my reason and will. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1704-1707, 1730, 1852-1869)
I see sin as acting against reason, truth, and right conscience. (Catechism, 1849-1850)

Any creature with free will can do that. (February 4, 2018; November 6, 2016)

Satan was and is pure spirit, with no body at all; which didn’t keep the spiritual creature from sinning on an epic scale. (Catechism, 328-330, 385-395)

Philosophers and Fame


(From Dustin Dewynne, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Seeing reality as two things, dualism. Or one thing, monism.)

Materialism/physicalism and idealism are, in a way, two sides of the same coin. Both beliefs see reality as basically one thing. Like quite a few other views, materialism and idealism go back at least to what Jaspers called the Axial Age. (April 15, 2018)

Idealism assumes that consciousness, or something else immaterial, is the most basic part of reality. Plato may be the best-known idealist philosopher. He wasn’t alone. Anaxagoras said that nous, intellect, came first. Aristotle had pretty much the same view.1

Time passed, Anaxagoras didn’t get noticed nearly as much as the other two, and some European scholars got overly-excited about Aristotle in the 1200s. (November 5, 2017)

Meanwhile, folks kept refurbishing and repackaging Plato’s and Aristotle’s ideas about ideals and forms.

Versions with a Christian spin started popping up during the first century AD. They’ve been endemic ever since.

One of the earliest headliners was Valentinus. He taught in Alexandria and set up a school in Rome. That was in the second century AD.

Saint Valentine is a different person and got killed for being a Christian. He wasn’t the first, or last, to decide truth is more important than this life.

Valentinus, the fellow with a school, enjoyed considerable success. So did Valnetinianism, an intriguing alternative to Christianity.

Valentinianism was a big deal in the 2nd century, not so much later.

St. Irenaeus called the Valentinian school “he legomene gnostike haeresis:” “the heresy called Learned (Gnostic),” “the sect called Learned,” or something like that.

Henry More coined the word “Gnosticism” in the 17th century. He was talking about a particular variation of Valentinus-style ideas. The name caught on as a handy label for that sort of anti-materialism.

“Gnosticism” comes from Ancient Greek γνωστικός/gnostikos, “having knowledge.” I think Gnostic beliefs were at least partly inspired by Plato’s theory of forms; but they’re not quite idealism, Platonic or otherwise.

Unlike idealism — and materialism — Gnosticism doesn’t necessarily say that everything’s basically one thing. I gather that a Gnostic might see physical reality as real: but not nice.

Each variation of Gnosticism was and is unique, but they agree in seeing physical reality as something to shun. That’s an enormous over-simplification.

Exclusivity Appeals

‘Secret knowledge’ seems to be another popular feature in Gnostic beliefs.2

I see the same exclusivity appeals in ‘learn ancient secrets’ advertisements. Saw, actually. It’s been a long time since I’ve run into that sort of thing in a magazine.

Selling the sizzle, not the steak, is effective advertising. I’ve heard that Elmer Wheeler said it in the 1920s. Advertising goes back at least to the Song Dynasty. And that’s another topic.

I suspect sizzle helps sell my culture’s chronic End Times prognostications. They arguably give believers opportunities to see themselves as part of the cognoscente.

I don’t take assorted ‘ancient knowledge’ and Rapture claims seriously.

Their effect on folks who believe them is another matter. So are impressions made on folks who see others getting duped. I think deliberately distorting truth is a serious violation of trust. (Catechism, Catechism, 2468, 2486)

Deliberately presenting fiction as fact is a problem. Presenting fiction as fiction — I’ll get back to that.

Gnostic notions and fizzling End Times predictions have been around for centuries. Millennia. Details vary, which isn’t surprising.

First century Rome, 11th century Paris and 21st century Los Angeles were and are centers of culture and influence. But they’re not identical.

Human nature doesn’t change. Not that I can see. Cultures are constantly changing. No competent publicist would ignore a target audience’s current perceptions.

I haven’t seen ‘ancient secrets’ ads in magazines recently. Maybe too many folks started thinking. Or maybe ‘truth in advertising’ regulations caught up with them. Or, more likely, I’m not browsing through the same sort of periodicals now.

‘Secret knowledge’ isn’t Gnosticism’s only attractive feature. I get the impression that denouncing physical reality is a cornerstone of faith for many folks, Gnostic and otherwise.

Being Human

I’ve encountered incandescent Christians of the fire and brimstone ilk raging against “works of the flesh.”

I don’t doubt that they’re sincere. The same goes for Carrie Nation and the “Reefer Madness” set. But I’m sure they’re wrong. (July 10, 2016)

Having a body isn’t a problem. How I decide to see my body, and how I act, can be. But being human, being a body and soul, is how God makes us. (Catechism, 362-379, 992, 2288-2291, 2331-2336)

I’m okay with that. Even if I wasn’t, I wouldn’t see complaining about God’s design aesthetic as a good idea. I hope I’d have that much sense.

The notion that being physical isn’t nice may play well to folks of fastidious spiritual tastes.

Maybe believing “the Word became flesh,” as John 1:14 says, doesn’t feel sufficiently ‘spiritual.’ But believing that the Son of God is human and divine comes with being a Catholic. (Catechism, 285, 456-478, 517)

So does acknowledging that I’m human. I like understanding things, but see wisdom in recognizing limits. How the Incarnation works is beyond me. God is infinite, transcending time and space. Fully understanding God won’t happen. Learning what I can? That’s a good idea. (February 25, 2018; August 20, 2017; June 16, 2017)

Christian-themed Gnosticism probably has roots in Judeo-Christian traditions, Platonism and Neoplatonism. Or Neopythagoreanism, Persian and Hindi traditions, Zurvanite and Zoroastrian beliefs, and Buddhism. Or maybe all of those. Or something else.

There’s not, putting it mildly, a consensus.3

Knowledge and Choice

“To follow knowledge like a sinking star…” is my Google Plus tagline. I might look like someone who’d become a Gnostic. Maybe I would. But it’s not likely.

I like knowledge, a lot. I also enjoy flights of fancy. But confusing what’s real and what’s a product of human imagination doesn’t make sense.

Neither does ignoring realities because I don’t like them, or believing that a figment of imagination is real.

I can continue being a Catholic. Or I can believe that Jesus isn’t or couldn’t be human. Not both. I have to pick one or the other. (Catechism, 285, 465)

I’ve got free will, so in principle I could change my mind about what I think is true. But deciding to stop being a Catholic is about as improbable as it gets. I like being a Catholic, know why I joined, and keep finding more reasons to stay with the Church.

Cool Names

Being a Catholic doesn’t keep me from seeing what’s appealing in Gnosticism. Appealing to someone with my tastes and interests, anyway.

Like that diagram. It’s from a book published in 1826, Jacques Matter’s “Histoire critique du Gnosticisme.”

It’s the Plérome de Valentin, showing how Valentinianism viewed reality.

Valentinian’s version of reality has entities with cool names like le Père, la Pensée and des éons.

If I was reading about it in English, they’d be the Father, the Thought and the Aeons.

If that sounds like some alternative liturgies you’ve run into, I’m not surprised. Like I said, Gnostic notions have been popping up for about two millennia: repackaged but recognizably Gnostic. The New Age4 brand was popular recently. Still is, in some circles.

I like cool names and imaginative alternate realities. But I don’t see a point in believing something because it’s cool, or because it’s kinda now and kinda wow.

Or impressively ancient.

And I know enough of what’s happened and what we’ve thought over the last few millennia to realize that many New Age ideas, for example, aren’t all that new. Some only go back a few centuries, at most. And that’s yet another topic.

Sub-Creation

I’ve known folks who don’t like fiction because “it’s not true.” Or dismiss myth for the same reason.

I wouldn’t try forcing them to read “Through the Looking Glass.”

Or avoid a tale of Líf and Lífþrasir riding out Ragnarök by hiding in Yggdrasil because it’s not science or history.

Avoiding stories because another person won’t or can’t enjoy products of our imaginations is possible. But doesn’t seem reasonable. (July 16, 2017)

Sharing a figment of imagination may not always be a bad idea. I see differences, significant ones, between a storyteller weaving a tale and a con artist selling a version of Victor Lustig’s “money-printing machine”

I also think Tolkien is right about at least one aspect of mythology:

“…This aspect of ‘mythology’ — sub-creation, rather than either representation or symbolic interpretation of the beauties and terrors of the world — is, I think, too little considered….”
(“J.R.R. Tolkien, On Fairy Stories,” via The Heritage Podcast)

And that’s yet again another topic, for another day.

Other posts that may or may not be related to this one:


1 Philosophers, “isms” and all that:

2 A Saint, A Gnostic, and two “isms:”

3 Gnosticism’s origins, maybe:

4 Mysticism isn’t the problem. Nescience can be:

Posted in Being Catholic, Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

Minnesota Spring Weather Continues

That’s what my webcam saw, a few minutes before 8:00 this morning.

It’s now about 10:15 am here in central Minnesota. The view is still much the same: a bit more light, off-and-on snow and wind.

Lighthearted poems about April showers bringing May flowers weren’t, I think, written by folks who lived in my part of the world. Taking a positive view of current reality, we’ve still got power and Internet connections — so I’m sitting back and enjoying the show God’s creation provides:

Posted in Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Materialism, Robots and Attitudes

Robots are starting to look and act a lot like humans.

Wondering if robots can be people, or if humans are merely biological robots, involves assumptions about reality. I’ll look at one of those assumptions in this post and why I believe there’s more to me than chemicals.

Whether a robot could be a person is more of a philosophical question than a legal issue. So far. The question would be particularly interesting if a robot asked to be recognized as a person. Or disturbing, depending on how you look at it.

With today’s robotic tech and AI, my guess would be that a human had programmed the robot to sue for recognition.

Or provided data and analytic processes which pretty much guaranteed that it would ask to be seen as a person.

The question would still be interesting if humans demanded legal recognition of robotic “persons.” I haven’t heard of that happening yet, but think it’ll likely pop up in a few years.

We’ve had folks making similar demands for non-human animals. I think many ‘animals are people too’ folks mean well. I don’t think they’re right about chimps being people, but agree that humans should treat other creatures humanely.

That’s because I think Genesis 1:27 and Psalms 8:6 are right. We’re made “in the image of God” and “little less than a god” — with power and responsibilities to match.

Western civilization’s upper crust abused that power in recent centuries. “Little less than a god” isn’t “God.” Not even close. (January 21, 2018)

Folks misunderstanding or misusing Christian beliefs don’t make Christianity wrong. Genesis, Exodus, Deuteronomy and EU Directive 2010/63/EU tacitly agree that we’re in charge here. (August 11, 2017; November 18, 2016; July 15, 2016)

Christians acting badly were a problem long before the Thirty Years War. It still is. We’re human. Nothing wrong with that, but we’re carrying some very old baggage.

Humans didn’t start out being evil to the core, or ‘loathsome insects.’ We’re not like that now. We’re still good, basically: just wounded. (January 8, 2018; November 6, 2016)

And that’s not what I was talking about. Not quite. Let me think.

Robots. Humans. Assumptions. Animal rights. EU directives. Christians acting like humans. Right.

Programmable Tech: Ismail al-Jazari’s Automata, Pepper, and Looking Ahead


(From Wikipedia and Boston Dynamics, used w/o permission.)

About robots acting like humans, I’ve enjoyed Isaac Asimov’s ‘robot’ stories, and had some fun with the idea myself. Not that I’m in the Asimov league.

Today’s chatbots and tomorrow’s robotic receptionists don’t and won’t fracture my faith. But it’s probably just a matter of time before someone denounces them as works of Satan.

Or claims tax-exempt status for a robot-oriented church. “Church of the Holy Robot” has a nice ring to it. Weird, though.

Making tech that acts like humans is an old idea. “Automaton” comes to my language through Latin. Romans got it from a Greek word that means acting of one’s own will.

Automata in stories, like Talos, were more ‘robotic’ than tech built by Hero of Alexandria and Ktesibios. Ismail al-Jazari described and built programmable automata, and that’s another topic. The point is that programmable tech acting like a critter isn’t new.

What’s different about today’s robots is more a matter of degree than of kind. Their programming is much more complex than post-Renaissance clockwork automata.

We’re also learning more about how humans act and respond. That helps us design AI and robots.

Today’s humanoid robots, robots shaped more or less like us, can do much more than walk, sit, and kneel. They’re still not quite as light on their feet.

They can, however, dance and play soccer. Nao’s famous for doing both.

The folks who developed Nao, a humanoid robot, worked for Aldebaran Robotics. SoftBank Group acquired Aldebaran in 2015, but I think “Aldebaran Robotics” sounds cooler, so that’s what I’ll call them.

The Nao synchronized dance performance at the Shanghai Expo in 2010 made international headlines.

With different programming, Nao robots played in the RoboCup.

Although accomplished dancers and athletes, Nao robots weren’t much for conversation.

They could be programmed to understand spoken words and speak. They could even detect emotional cues and emote with gestures and body language. But I gather that they weren’t very bright.

Which brings me to the robot in that photo, Pepper. Aldebaran Robotics says Pepper is “kindly, endearing and surprising.”

Among other things, Pepper is programmed to notice major human emotions, respond appropriately, learn how individuals act and change its behavior accordingly.

The robot may be better at noticing and responding appropriately to human emotions than I am.

Or maybe not. I’ve been developing the skill for decades. I’m pretty good at noticing and identifying emotions in others.

But I’ve been told that my affect display, verbal and non-verbal displays of emotion, is well off the norm. That’s not surprising.

Undiagnosed depression made dealing with also-undiagnosed PTSD, autism spectrum disorder and other quirks difficult.

My psychiatric oddities got identified a little over 11 years back.

I knew something was going wrong. So did my wife, who suggested I see a psychiatrist.

Being ‘cured’ won’t happen. But knowing what I deal with makes the job easier. Less difficult, at any rate. (January 7, 2018; December 17, 2017; March 19, 2017)

Being offended that Pepper and other robots may be better at acting like humans than I am is an option. But not a reasonable one, I think.

Fear and Frustrated Technicians

Neither is fearing rogue robots or homicidal homunculi. Although that sort of thing can make a rousing good tale.

Concerns that a robot will take my job might make sense if I worked on an assembly line. (March 16, 2018)

I think truck drivers and cabbies may be better off if they start exploring other lines of work now. Driverless vehicles are here, with more in development.

Recent high-profile accidents involving automated vehicles give developers a public relations problem.

Three fatal accidents, each involving Tesla systems, aren’t making automated vehicles seem safer. How much of a threat autonomous cars are, that I don’t know.

I haven’t compared accident and fatality rates with automated and human-operated vehicles in equivalent circumstances. I strongly suspect that human owners aren’t quite ready for today’s technology. Or don’t understand it.

My memory tells me that one crash happened because the operator/driver wasn’t paying attention. I’d have to research that to be sure. My guess is that the automated vehicle was smart, but not smart and wise enough to be unsupervised.

We may develop fully-automated, ‘set and forget’ automated vehicles. Adjusting to the new tech will take time. I think we’ll deal with change as well as we have since stone tools were new. Or as poorly.

My guess is that someone saw cooking fires as a deadly technology. Which they can be. I think tech is as safe or unsafe as whoever’s using it.

Robots have worked on assembly lines for years, and are very close to filling other jobs. I’d be surprised if robots didn’t start working at reception desks and in stock rooms.

But do I fear a robot apocalypse? No.

Skynet is still more fiction than science.

Economic, political or imperial ambitions strike me as more of a “human” thing.

Frustrated technicians dealing with a glitchy robot may lack the dramatic appeal of rampaging robot revolutionaries. But with today’s technology, it’s by far the more likely scenario. We’re still a long way from dealing with something like the HAL 9000 in “2001: A Space Odyssey” (March 16, 2018)

Mechanical Minions, Digital Despots and Being Human

Nothing I’ve seen go from the ‘explore, hypothesize and clarify’ to the ‘design, develop and test’ stage looks promising as a robot overlord.

I think “The Phantom Creeps,” where a human mastermind used a robot makes sense as a plausible threat. Plausible enough for a movie, that is.

Another entertaining scenario could be the usual evil computer seeking world domination.

With the fate of humanity hanging in the balance, when all seems lost, as Our Hero hangs helpless in the grip of its mechanical minions, the digital despot declares: “Fool! Nothing can withstand my FILE NOT FOUND!” (January 28, 2018)

I think robots will be increasingly good mimics of human behavior.

I think they’ll replace human workers in many jobs.

Replacing humans? That seems very unlikely at best.

My attitude comes partly from my experience as a human. I’ve been a delivery guy, computer operator and sales clerk. But that wasn’t “what I was,” except in a grammatical or economic sense. Certainly not “who I was” and am.

I see my jobs as what I’ve done, and “me” as the person who did the jobs. I see myself as a “who,” not a “what.”

That probably seems irrational to some folks. I am, after all, a Christian: and a Catholic to boot. We’re seen as unreasonable at best in some communities.

I’ll grant that some Christians, Catholics included, live up — or down — to the ‘ignorant and superstitious’ stereotype. It’s not, sadly, just the uneducated ones. (March 4, 2018; November 5, 2017)

If their ilk was all I’d seen of Christianity. I might feel that faith and reason, science and religion, get along about as well as cobra and mongoose.1 Folks taking spirit photographs and the like seriously don’t help. (April 11, 2018)

About robots, humans and being a “what” or a “who,” I’m quite certain that a robot couldn’t have a human soul. Robots aren’t, by most definitions, humans.

Whether a robot or other AI could have a soul of some other sort is another question. And a reasonable one:

In my considered opinion — my thoughts regarding theological implications of Artificial Intelligence will wait for another day.

It’s not merely a can of worms. It’s a 12-pack, at least.

“Kinda Now … Kinda Wow”

Materialism isn’t a new idea.

Folks have been inventing, and re-inventing, variations on that theme for about two dozen centuries.

We’ve traced it back to China, India, Persia, Judea and Greece during the 8th to the 3rd century BC.

Many ideas started then, apparently. Folks started noticing the coincidence in the 18th century. Karl Jaspers called it Achsenzeit, the Axial Age.2

I suspect the trail is much older. But we don’t have evidence backing up my hunch. Not yet.

I’m dubious about the new ideas being developed independently.

I grant that there’s little evidence of major cultural exchange. Bodhidharma’s an exception.

I strongly suspect that individuals might have information which most others in their area didn’t, and weren’t fussy about naming their sources. Or open, transparent, forthright: you get the idea.

About Bodhidharma, he’s credited with bringing Chan Buddhism to China. Folks in Japan call him Daruma, and that’s yet another topic. (April 2, 2017)

I think academics are starting to realize that folks travel. A lot. When we do, more often than not we also trade tech and ideas with folks we meet.

Some newcomers settle down, which leads to kids with different ancestry having kids of their own: making people like me possible. (March 2, 2018; May 19, 2017)

The current version of Western materialism popped up during the Enlightenment.

Someone puts a new paint job on it every few decades. Shiny new packaging gives folks something “kinda now … kinda wow” to fuss or gush over. Until the next metaphysical novelty item comes along.

A few ‘unprecedented paradigm shifts’ later, and it’s generally as well-remembered as the Charlie perfume 1973 jingle:

“There’s a fragrance that’s here today, and they call it — Charlie!
A different fragrance that thinks your way, and they call it — Charlie!
Kinda young, kinda now, Charlie!
Kinda free, kinda wow! Charlie!
The kind of fragrance that’s gonna stay, and it’s here now — Charlie!”
(Charlie by Revlon (1973),” Yesterday’s Perfume (July 19, 2010)

I could ‘act my age’ at this point, playing the cantankerous old coot.

Kvetching that history repeats itself and nobody ever learns may have a certain appeal. I’d much rather make sense.

Four Millennia After Sargon

We do learn. Eventually. Not all new ideas or observations have the profundity and lasting value of advertising jingles.

Sometimes we even learn how to make a new idea work. That takes effort and time. Lots of both.

I see cycles in history, like Western civilization’s empire-collapse-rebuild pattern. Sargon of Akkad started the first cycle, about 43 centuries back. (May 28, 2017)

The first that we know of, at any rate.

I don’t “believe in” Atlantis, Mu or Caprona. Which doesn’t keep me from enjoying some ‘lost civilization’ yarns.

I think Plato’s tale may be inspired by stories of the Late Bronze Age Collapse and Thera eruption. Even if that’s true, both events happened a millennium and more after Sargon’s day. (November 3, 2017; March 30, 2017; March 12, 2017)

Philosophically-inclined Europeans noticed the empire-collapse-rebuild cycle a few centuries back. “Decadence” got its current meaning then. (October 22, 2017)

Each failed effort was unique, but I think the events were cyclic. We started the most recent “empire” phase about five centuries back. That’s when European explorers started finding new places, and new routes to places they already knew.

Europe’s imperial bosses never managed to do more than form uneasy and temporary alliances with each other. That sparked a global conflict about a hundred years ago.

Trying Something New

Many of us survived. While clearing occasionally-radioactive rubble, some decided that enough was enough. (November 10, 2017)

A remarkable number of surviving bosses decided to write off what was left of their empires and try something else. That was a few years before I was born.

The United Nations is far from perfect. I don’t trust it any more than I trust America’s Congress. But as a possibly-viable alternative to another global war?

I’ll take what we’ve got and suggest that we can do better. Much better. (February 4, 2018; November 5, 2017; August 20, 2017)

I can understand feeling that it’s ‘the end of civilization as we know it.’

Folks near the start of each ‘rebuilding’ phase probably felt the same way. For me, it’s more like ‘it’s the end of civilization as we know it — and about time!’

We’ve tried getting stability or security of a sort with empires.

Empires don’t work. Not for more than a few centuries.

We’ve survived and rebuilt each time. But that’s no reason to keep hoping the next cycle won’t take us back to another ‘rebuild’ phase. (May 28, 2017)

Suggesting that trying something new makes more sense to me than trying the same failed strategy again. Or assuming that humanity is doomed. Although I think “the centre cannot hold” attitudes gave us some memorable poetry:

“…Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned….”
(“The Second Coming,” William Butler Yeats (1920))

Beliefs

Western materialism — I’m back to that, finally — arguably makes more sense than feeling that God blundered by creating us with physical bodies. (January 14, 2018)

Christians who feel that way may be sincere. So, I hope, were those who tried merging materialism and religion. And who keep sharing End Times predictions. (September 29, 2017; March 24, 2017; August 13, 2017)

Small wonder some folks see faith and reason as polar opposites.

Materialism and idealism start with the idea that all reality is basically one thing. Philosophers call it monism. Materialism says that everything’s basically physical.

I’ll agree that physical reality exists. I think my body is ‘real’ in that sense.

Physically, I’m mostly oxygen, carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, calcium and phosphorus with traces of other elements.3 Assuming that I’m nothing but the elements in my body and their chemical interactions is possible.

I could believe that my self-awareness is an illusion: probably caused by something in my brain. Or maybe it’s a conditioned response. Or some other physical phenomenon: something I could, in principle, detect and measure.

I think I have free will. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1730-1742)

I can decide to believe something is true when it’s not. But I won’t. I vastly prefer believing what I think is true.

That doesn’t stop me from acknowledging that other viewpoints are possible.

I think many folks have my preference for truth. Maybe most. We don’t all arrive at the same conclusions, and that’s yet again another topic. (October 22, 2017)

Believing that free will isn’t real could let me act on whatever daft impulse I liked without feeling guilty. In principle, anyway.

I might also have to believe that feeling guilty is an illusion caused by instinct, social conditioning or something similar.

Believing that I can’t help it might feel liberating.

Dodging consequences of my behavior might not. But I could decide that cleaning up the mess is tomorrow’s problem and ‘live in the moment.’

I’m sure not all materialists feel that way.

And I know that all Christians don’t fear ‘thinking too much.’ But some act as if they believe ‘blessed are the absurd, for they shall spread absurdity’ is a Beatitude.

That sort of thing makes ‘faith and reason are incompatible’ seem — reasonable.

My attitude may need some explaining.

I’m a Christian, a Catholic. I can’t be a Catholic and believe that reality starts and ends with the material world. Not if I take my faith seriously. (Catechism, 285, 2124-2125; “To participants in the General Assembly of the members of the Pontifical Academy for Life,” 1 (2017); “Evangelium Vitae,” 23 (1995); “Populorum Progressio,” 18 (1967); “Gaudium et spes,” 10 (1965))

Using my brain isn’t an option. It’s an obligation. Faith, the Catholic sort, and reason work together. Faith is willing acceptance of God and all truth. Reason helps me live as if I accept God and truth. (Catechism, 35-37, 150, 154-159, 812; 1730, 1778)

I can’t be a materialist. Not if I’m going to be a Catholic and even remotely rational.

More; mostly what I think about robots, the universe and nifty photos:


1 Catholics don’t have to be scientists, but it’s an option:

2 Ideas and eras:

3 Views and ingredients:

Posted in Being Catholic, Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Minnesota in the Springtime

“…I love Paris in the springtime.
I love Paris in the fall….”

It’s been years since I heard “I Love Paris.” Nice song, but a bit schmaltzy for today’s tastes.

And nobody’s written a follow-up, expressing affection for Minnesota in the springtime.

Maybe it’s our weather. There’s a winter storm in progress: rain and freezing rain a little earlier, then snow, with heavy snow and thunderstorms on the way.

That picture is what the webcam saw around 7:00 this evening. I won’t mind staying inside tomorrow. Maybe I’ll get some writing done:

Posted in Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Spirit Photographs

My wife asked me if I knew some of my ancestors were spiritualists. She’d seen an odd picture of my Campbell forebears while putting together a family photo album. This was in September, 2011.

I had, and even knew a little about the photo. It’s a studio portrait, with something extra.

A child’s ghostly image is near my great-to-some-power grandmother. The couple’s daughter had died when she was three years old.

My father told me about the trick, probably more common in the ‘good old days’ than now. Another family member had been given a similarly-doctored photo. In that case, she insisted that the studio fix it. Without the extra image. Which they did.

Maybe the bereaved couple thought they had a ‘spirit photograph’ of their daughter. Or maybe they had no other picture of their child, knew the photo was fake, and didn’t mind.

Spirit Photographs

The photo my wife showed me looks a bit like this one, taken in 1868 or thereabouts. It shows someone called “Mrs. French.” I don’t know who the ghost is supposed to be.

The “Mrs. French” photo is by William H. Mumler, who’s given credit for starting spirit photography in the early 1860s.1

I’ve read that Mumler, an amateur photographer, accidentally took a double exposure. The resulting photo included a ghostly image of what looked like Mumler’s dead cousin.

Mumler quite his job, set up shop as a spirit photographer and married a “healing medium.” The two weren’t business partners, though.

Mumler’s troubles started in 1869, when he was accused of fraud. He won the trial, but lost his credibility. Spirit photography’s reputation didn’t seem affected, though.

Quite a few folks had lost relatives in America’s Civil War. Their grief and spiritualism’s popularity arguably helped Mumler attract customers.

So did assorted diseases like cholera, yellow fever, smallpox, and tuberculosis. Many parents saw their children survive measles and scarlet fever. Many didn’t.2

Christian parents might see “crossing the Jordan” or “taking the last train to glory” as a potentially good thing. But grief happens anyway. (October 9, 2016)

So does death, for everyone. Sooner or later.

Make that almost everyone. I figure Elijah’s spectacular departure in 2 Kings 2:8–14 was a one-time event. Mostly for Elisha’s benefit. And that’s another topic.

I don’t look forward to death, not like I look forward to reading a good book. But I’ve thought about it. So have a great many other folks. That’s led to advice like memento mori and carpe diem, remember your death and seize the day, more or less.

I think both make sense, within reason. (January 21, 2018; November 11, 2016)

Death Happens

Death seems to have been as popular in Victorian literature as unlikely roommates were in sitcoms.

Tennyson’s “Lady of Shallot” may be one of the better-known examples.

In Tennyson’s tale, the Lady of Shallot weaves night and day to keep some kind of curse from happening.

Then she sees Lancelot going by. He’s on his way to Camelot.

She stops weaving, writes her name on a boat and gets in. By the time the boat drifts downstream to Camelot, she’s dead.

Lancelot, seeing a woman’s corpse in the boat, says “she has a lovely face.”

That might seem weird today. Let’s remember that English Victorian society wasn’t like postmodern America. Folks apparently thought, talked, and read about death a lot more than we do. Differently, at any rate.

Americans don’t think about death much. Or don’t seem to. Certainly not the way Victorians did. But death happens. And I’m pretty sure not all Americans shun thoughts of death, any more than all Victorians were repressed Babbitts.

America’s apparent attitude may come from how we live. And die.

Many Americans die in hospitals these days, often after enjoying retirement someplace other than where they grew up and lived.

Some folks pick a ‘retirement state’ based on climate. Others look for favorable investment opportunities, insurance, whatever.

I’m not overly fond of winter’s cold and the spring thaw. But Minnesota’s weather is not boring. I like that. A lot. Isolation from friends and family ‘back home’ would make moving a poor choice for me. Even if it was an option. And that’s yet another topic.

Hand-wringing over society’s decline and all that is something I’ll skip. The point is that having most of the family around when we die isn’t typical today. Not in America.

Options for housing and medical treatment were different in the ‘good old days.’

Victorian Sentimentality and Nietzsche

I don’t see Victorian families as ideal role models. But dying at home happened a lot. Being around a dying family member was nearly unavoidable.

That up-close-and-personal encounter with death and dying may help explain the Victorian era’s over-the-top sentimentality.

So, I think, did seeing results from the Age of Enlightenment’s love affair with reason. Quite a few folks felt reason hadn’t worked, so they tried relying on emotion.

Romanticism isn’t that simple, of course. I’m pretty folks throughout history weren’t all on the same page, even in the most conformist eras.

I think reason and emotion are both part of being human. They’re basically good, when used properly. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1730, 1762-1770, 1778)

Romanticism peaked in the early 19th century, followed by Realism, Gothic novels and Edgar Allan Poe. But not in that order. I see the 1960s as Romanticism’s reboot, sort of.3

But not exactly. The Swinging Sixties didn’t last nearly as long, for starters. I see the Romantic era’s fascination with exotic lands replayed in early 1960s psychedelic art.4 Not that Caspar David Friedrich and Thomas Cole were painting hallucinatory terrain.

I think some of us overdid valuing emotion and bucking authority. But I also remember the preceding era’s lockstep conformity and attitudes. America, at least, was due for a change. Overdue, in some ways.

Attitudes

Back in the Sixties, “conservative” politics ranged from intense nationalism to unthinking jingoism. That’s how it looked to me at the time, as a teen.

“Liberal” politics weren’t always reasonable either. But I thought the goals made more sense: freedom, peace and cooperation.

Conservatives defended freedom, too. For those who agreed with them. I see McCarthyism and political correctness as the same attitude, held by folks with different views.

I’ve learned a lot since the sixties, including an appreciation for nuance. But my basic attitudes haven’t changed. And living as if I believe them still isn’t easy.

Folks with what we still call “conservative” attitudes were The Establishment in my ‘good old days.’

I’m pretty sure conservatives thought they were right. And that liberals did, too.

Thinking I’m right shouldn’t mean feeling that anyone who disagrees must be a fool, hypocrite, or worse.

I was more or less at odds with ‘The Establishment’ and many conventionally-unconventional ‘outsiders’ in my teens. It helped me keep re-thinking my opinions and attitudes.

Having like-minded folks on top in media, politics, and academia probably feels good. So would being part of a ‘movement.’ I’ve never quite experienced the feeling, which isn’t a bad thing. I suspect noticing wacky behavior is harder when the nut case is ‘one of us.’

I was going somewhere with this. Let’s see. Family photos, spiritualists, cholera, Victorian attitudes. Right.

Today’s conservative positions aren’t quite what they were in my youth, and quite different from the Concert of Europe’s peacekeeping efforts. The further we get from ‘now,’ the less useful today’s labels are.

That’s partly because we don’t know much about folks like Ajita Kesakambali and Diagoras of Melos. Stories and lore retold generations later suggest that they didn’t think gods existed. We call that sort of thing atheism today.

Thomas Huxley was more of an agnostic than an atheist, but shared Friedrich Nietzsche’s lack of conventional Christian beliefs. Considering what was conventional then, I can see how their views might make sense.

Which doesn’t mean I share them. (February 9, 2018; January 21, 2018; May 12, 2017)

Nifty Photos


(From MrX, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Diagram: Kirlian photography cross-section.)

Kirlian photography was getting attention from the late 1960s to 1970s. It’s a contact print photo technique using high voltage.

Some folks thought it was an interesting natural phenomenon. Others thought they were recording life force auras.

I’ll talk about life force and vitalism in another post. Alchemy too, probably.

The aura folks had evidence on their side, along with replicable experiments.

Folks at UCLA made several Kirlian photos of a pickled leaf, at set intervals. Sure enough, the leaf’s ‘energy field,’ recorded in the Kirlian photograph, faded as the leaf withered. They figured they’d recorded the leaf’s dwindling life force.

In another experiment, they made Kirlian photos of leaves, tore part of each leaf off, and then took another photo. Sometimes a faint ‘memory’ of the missing part was in the second image. It looked as if the leaf ‘remembered’ its natural form.

Scientists thought the experiments and conclusions were worth testing.

Maybe some didn’t ‘believe in’ energy fields. I’ll give them credit for being scientists, and doing their job.

Scientists are as human as anyone else. Belief or lack of it may be personally important. Facts and testable predictions are what make research ‘scientific.’

They paid closer attention to laboratory technique, removing all traces of moisture from the glass plate after taking Kirlian photographs of the whole leaf. ‘Ghost’ images didn’t materialize with clean plates.

What the first researchers had done was document otherwise-imperceptible traces of water left by the whole leaf. The glass plates were ‘remembering’ where the leaf had been, in a metaphoric sense. Not the leaf.

I don’t think that proves that the original researchers were charlatans.

America’s zeitgeist, ambience, or whatever, being what it was — I figure they thought they’d found something real, and weren’t consummate experiment designers.

I’ve got more to say about the UCLA experiments, science and assumptions. But not today.

I see Kirlian photography as laboratory curiosity. Scientists haven’t found practical applications. Not yet, anyway. The photos are nifty, though.5

I’m almost certain that Kirlian photos don’t record auras: not in the ‘life energy’ sense.

That’s partly because Kirlian phtos of non-living things show ‘auras.’

I’m not sure what the non-dime in that photo is. It looks like a Jefferson nickel.

Whatever it is, I don’t think it is or ever was alive. Neither was the dime.

I’m quite sure that we’re looking at electrical effects at the edges and angles of the coins. Possibly enhanced by residual moisture and oils from folks who handed them.

I’ve got a pretty good imagination, so I could say that we’re looking at life force auras left by folks who handled them. Or of the artists who designed them. Or of Jefferson, an oak and an olive tree.

That could be a ‘good enough for a story’ explanation. Maybe something along the lines of Lovecraft and Poe, with a dash of Charles Addams and Gahan Wilson. There’s an idea.

But ‘good enough for a story’ doesn’t mean ‘real.’ Or ‘replicable.’

Telling or reading an imaginary tale can be fun, and harmless. If folks can see differences between make-believe and reality.

That’s my opinion, but it’s one I’m pretty sure of. (“Address of John Paul II to the International Cinema Conference” (December 2, 1999))

Tricking folks into believing something I know isn’t true is another story. And trouble that I don’t need. (Catechism, 150, 2125, 2464, 2475-2487)

How I see life, death, and making sense:


1 Darkroom ghosts:

2 Death and disease:

3 Eras and attitudes:

4 Making sense, and learning:

5 Energy, life and weather:

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic, Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments