Sickness, Death, God, Love and Questions

Just when you thought it was safe to grow up —

Folks in their 20s may run afoul of a quarter-life crisis: the doubt and disappointment of student loans, dull careers and iffy relationships.

Others learn that they’re terminally ill.

I learned about Michelle Pittman at Mass last Sunday.

An inoperable brain tumor will kill her.

She and her family have unexpected expenses. That’s why a Michelle Pittman Benefit fund was set up at a local bank:

Michelle Pittman Benefit
c/o MN National Bank
PO Box 306
Sauk Centre, MN 56378


Michelle Pittman’s situation and the benefit fund are the important part of this post.

I’d planned on writing about assorted crises, including terminal illness.1 That started me thinking about life, death and not having all the answers:


Life


(From Ramie Liddle, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

I’m not sure which would be harder: being told that I have a terminal disease, or that someone in my family does. Either way, it wouldn’t be welcome news.

Learning that they’re terminally ill, folks occasionally pick something from their bucket list: like the 90-year-old who went on a road trip.

Coping with impending death and other bad news isn’t new. Neither is thinking about it.

Over the last 28 centuries, folks like Adi Shankara, Ajita Kesakambali and Sigmund Freud added their views to humanity’s archives.

They agree that death happens, and little else. I figure that’s at least one step past the “denial” Kübler-Ross stage.

Maybe that’s better than getting stuck in Freud’s ‘three Rs:’ repression, regression and reaction. Western civilization’s current iteration seems to be getting over Freud’s view of religion as a “universal obsessional neurosis,” and that’s almost another topic.2

Questions

‘Why do we get sick?’

It’s not a simple question. There are several sorts of “why,” for starters.

We’ve learned that Hippocrates was right about disease and divine anger issues. Humorism, not so much.

Learning more about Varro’s “animalcules” eventually removed bloodletting from “The Principles and Practice of Medicine,” and that’s another topic.3

Blaming God, or the gods, for disease and disasters remains popular in spiritual niche markets. Like the Atra-Hasis epic, where Enlil deals with noisy humans by ordering our extermination. Several times. We survived, thanks to divine infighting, and that’s yet another topic.4

Where was I? Impending death, Freud, bloodletting and Enlil. Right.

My culture’s versions of divine retribution traditionally had God smiting folks as punishment: for opening a casino, avoiding smallpox, whatever.

“…There was the burgeoning Gulf Coast gambling industry, with a new casino that was to open on Labor Day weekend….”
(“Katrina: God’s Judgment on America,” Anonymous, Restore America (2005) via Beliefnet)

“Smallpox is a visitation from God; but the cowpox is produced by presumptuous man; the former was what Heaven ordained, the latter is, perhaps, a daring violation our of holy religion.”
(A physician’s reaction to Dr. Edward Jenner’s experiments in developing a vaccine for smallpox, (1796) via Psychological Sciences, Vanderbilt University)

Believing that God smites bad people with disease might be comforting. Until the believer gets sick.

Sooner or later, we’ll learn that sickness, pain and death happen to folks. No matter how nice we’ve been.

Some figure that God shouldn’t let that happen, so God isn’t there. Believing that may feel good, too, for different reasons.

Reality

The way I see it — backing up a bit here — I’m as sure as I can be that reality is real, that I’m not a figment of your imagination. Or vice versa.

I’m also sure that God exists: the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1, 232–260)

I think this universe is God’s handiwork. It’s more like a tent than something permanent, but it’s “very good.” (Genesis 1:1–31; Psalms 102:26–28; Wisdom 11:22–26; Isaiah 40:22, 51:6; Catechism, 282–289)

I think God keeps this universe going. And that it follows knowable physical laws. Paying attention to God’s handiwork is a good idea, since there’s a facet of God’s truth in everything we can observe. (Catechism, 268, 279, 299, 300–310)

Natural process like fire and gravity exist. Learning how they work doesn’t bother me, since I think God creates everything. Including the physical laws we notice. And those we haven’t yet, for that matter.

It’s like St. Thomas Aquinas said. God makes things happen and creatures make things happen. It’s “and,” not “or.” (March 2, 2018)

Aquinas called that sort of thing “secondary causes.” He’d gotten the idea from St. Augustine of Hippo, and that’s yet again another topic.

Anyway, secondary causes are creatures acting and changing in knowable ways, following laws written into this creation. (Catechism, 301–308, 339)

Ethics, right and wrong, apply to illness. That doesn’t mean I think preventing disease is “a daring violation” of divine wrath.

Being healthy is okay. So is being sick. How I act: that’s what matters. It’s even okay to help others get or stay healthy. (Catechism, 1509, 2288–2291, 2292–2296)

Interesting as all that may be, it doesn’t tell me why someone in her 20s is terminally ill.

Death and Deuteronomy

People suffer and die. I don’t know why. Not in detail, not in the sense of knowing what purpose someone’s death serves.

As “Gaudium et spes,” “Joy and Hope,” says, it’s part of our life’s riddle.

“…It is in the face of death that the riddle [of] a human existence grows most acute….”
(“Gaudium et spes,” Pope Saint Paul VI (December 7, 1965))

I don’t have an answer to that riddle. Not a complete one. I do have a few clues.

Given what our Lord said, I figure that early or unexpected death isn’t necessarily the victim’s fault.

“‘Stop judging, that you may not be judged. For as you judge, so will you be judged, and the measure with which you measure will be measured out to you. Why do you notice the splinter in your brother’s eye, but do not perceive the wooden beam in your own eye?”
(Matthew 7:1–3)

“‘Or those eighteen people who were killed when the tower at Siloam fell on them—do you think they were more guilty than everyone else who lived in Jerusalem?'”
(Luke 13:4)

Even so, I could assume that the fire and brimstone brigade are right, that God has anger management issues. Or shares their views on gambling and smallpox, and has a taste for indiscriminate retribution.

Or I could believe that since a loving God wouldn’t let folks suffer, God doesn’t exist.

Appealing as those answers apparently are, I don’t think they’re right. I’m also quite sure that I don’t know everything. God’s God, I’m not, and I’ve said that before. Often.

I don’t have all the answers. I do, however, have access to wisdom accumulated over several millennia. Some of which keeps getting forgotten and re-learned.

The importance of passing on vital knowledge to children, for instance:

“However, be on your guard and be very careful not to forget the things your own eyes have seen, nor let them slip from your heart as long as you live, but make them known to your children and to your children’s children,”
(Deuteronomy 4:9)

The next bit, Deuteronomy 4:10, says we should fear God: which may account for some of my culture’s more enthusiastic hellfire sermons.

Deuteronomy’s “fear” isn’t being scared silly. It’s more like respect, reverence and awe. (Catechism, 1806, 1828, 1831; General Audience, Pope Francis (June 11, 2014); “Fear of the Lord,” Angelus, Pope St. John Paul II (June 11, 1989))

‘Our Helicopter Parent Who art in Heaven?!’

I figure God is large and in charge. (Psalms 115:3; Catechism, 268)

The Almighty could keep me from making daft decisions, or clean up whatever mess I make — all without me lifting a finger.

That might be a nifty daydream. But would I really want God to fix everything?

Maybe not. Particularly since if God had cleaned up everyone’s mess, I wouldn’t be here.

Again, I think God creates everything, including this universe. I’ve talked about the Bible, Big Bang and using my brain before. (January 12, 2018)

Basically, I can think Genesis 3:1–19 is true without assuming it was written by a poetically-challenged American.

You know how that story goes. The first of us had it made, with only one simple rule. Then we decided we’d rather do our own thing. The man tried blaming his wife and God, which worked out about as well as you’d expect. (July 23, 2017)

When the first of us put our preferences above God’s, I figure the Almighty could have decided to (metaphorically) hit the ‘delete’ key and make another reality.

That’s not what happened.

Even if God had decided to keep us and this universe, we might have lost at least part of what makes us human.

We didn’t.

We were, and are, created “in the image of God.” We had, and have, dominion over this world: and our job, taking care of the place. That job comes with authority and responsibility. (Genesis 1:26–28; 2:5–8; Catechism, 16, 339, 356–358, 2402, 2415–2418, 2456)

We got off to a bad start. We’re still dealing with its consequences. The mess we’re in isn’t God’s fault. And God never forgot us. (Catechism, 30, 55, 390, 396–401)

None of that helps me feel better about death and suffering. I’d be concerned if I started enjoying pain.

Pain

A few more ideas, and I’m done.

Life and health are “precious gifts” from God. Getting and staying healthy is a good idea. Within reason. Painkillers are okay.5 (Catechism, 1506–1510, 2279, 2288–2289, 2292)

Then, no matter what we do or how we’ve lived, we die. What happens later can be good news or bad news. (Catechism, 991, 997, 1021–1037, 1042–1050)

That, and the few clues we have about what’s next, are among the reasons I’m grateful for God’s patience.

“When mortals finish, they are only beginning,
and when they stop they are still bewildered.
“The number of their days seems great
if it reaches a hundred years.
“Like a drop of water from the sea and a grain of sand,
so are these few years among the days of eternity.
“That is why the Lord is patient with them
and pours out his mercy on them.”
(Sirach 18:7, 9–11)

“But as it is written:
‘What eye has not seen, and ear has not heard,
and what has not entered the human heart,
what God has prepared for those who love him,'”
(1 Corinthians 2:9)

I’ve talked about that, and vaguely-related topics, before:


1 Life and death:

2 Dealing with reality:

3 Medicine, mostly:

4 Deities and disasters:

5 Life, death and viewpoints:

Posted in Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Rules, Principles, and a Defrocked Cardinal

I’m not sure how the ‘defrocked Cardinal’ story will play out in America’s news.

Assorted presidential campaigns will be building up steam, and there’s no shortage of other newsworthy angst.

Maybe the McCarrick case will be a nine day wonder, maybe not. Either way, I did a little checking, and shared what I found.


Saturday’s Headlines

The Pope’s decision in the Theodore McCarrick case may have come at almost exactly the right time for a French author’s “bombshell book.”

Maybe the McCarrick case will fade into the back pages, as America’s presidential campaigns get juicier. Then again, it’s been a while since we had a high-profile Catholic scandal; so maybe there’s sound and fury ahead.

Either way, I’m not happy about what’s happened. Maybe I’ll talk about that some other time. Today, I’ll share what I learned about Theodore McCarrick — and talk about what’s right, what’s not, and how I see rules.


Theodore McCarrick: Sentenced to Life in Kansas


(From Reuters, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Multiple allegations against Theodore McCarrick have emerged”
(BBC News))

“US ex-cardinal Theodore McCormick defrocked over abuse claims”
BBC News (February 16, 2019)

“A former Roman Catholic cardinal has been defrocked after historical sexual abuse allegations.

“Theodore McCarrick is the most senior Catholic figure to be dismissed from the priesthood in modern times.

“US Church officials said allegations he had sexually assaulted a teenager five decades ago were credible.

“Mr McCarrick, 88, had previously resigned but said he had ‘no recollection’ of the alleged abuse.

“The alleged abuses may have taken place too long ago for criminal charges to be filed because of the statute of limitations.

“Mr McCarrick was the archbishop of Washington DC from 2001 to 2006. Since his resignation last year from the College of Cardinals, he has been living in seclusion in a monastery in Kansas….”

Backing up a little, Theodore McCarrick was born in 1930. He and his parents lived in New York City. His father died when he was three. McCarrick became a priest in 1958.

He studied and served as an assistant chaplain at the Catholic University of America in Washington, D.C., where he became dean of students and director of development. From 1965 to 1969, he was president of the Catholic University of Puerto Rico.

Next, McCarrick was recalled to New York. He became an assistant secretary for education and was assistant priest at Blessed Sacrament parish from 1969 to 1971. Later, someone said that he’d been abused by McCarrick around this time.

From 1971 to 1977 McCarrick as Cardinal Terence Cooke’s secretary. After that, he was an auxiliary bishop, bishop and archbishop of New York, Metuchen, Newark and finally Washington, D.C. — and now lives in a monastery somewhere in Kansas.

After a life spent mostly in America’s Northeast megalopolis, being sentenced to serve a life of prayer and penance in Kansas may feel like being exiled to Siberia.

Still, it could be worse. McCarrick could have been sentenced to life in Minnesota. And that’s another topic.1


Accusations and a Question

Quite a few folks seem to think Theodore McCarrick did something wrong.

But did he? The question isn’t all that crazy.

McCarrick has been accused of having sex with other men: many of them above the age of consent.

The accusations apparently weren’t made until years after the affairs. That could suggest that the other men didn’t feel victimized until long after the event.

The Catholic Church has rules about sex: controversial rules. Many folks say they’re out of date, not in tune with today’s world. Maybe it’s the rules that are wrong.

The idea’s been around for a while.

“One has not only a legal, but a moral responsibility to obey just laws. Conversely, one has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws. I would agree with St. Augustine that ‘an unjust law is no law at all.'”
(Letter from a Birmingham Jail, Martin Luther King, Jr.(1963))

“An unjust law is no law at all.”
(“On Free Choice Of The Will,” Book 1, § 5, Augustine of Hippo (387–389))

“For there is but one essential justice which cements society, and one law which establishes this justice. This law is right reason, which is the true rule of all commandments and prohibitions. Whoever neglects this law, whether written or unwritten, is necessarily unjust and wicked.”
(“De Legibus (On the Laws),” Cicero (1st century BC))

Rules

Here’s where it gets interesting.

From what I’ve read, Theodore McCarrick probably did violate Church rules about sexual behavior.

The BBC News article says that the Archdiocese of New York had an independent forensic agency investigate allegations against McCarrick.

Legal experts, psychologists, parents and a priest on a review board said the allegations were “credible and substantiated.” (BBC News)

That doesn’t strike me as a rush to judgment. Maybe he honestly didn’t remember the incidents, or maybe he was still hoping that folks would believe him.

Either way, I’m willing to assume that McCarrick acted as his accusers said he did.

That brings me to whether the Church’s rules about sex are okay. Also what sin is. I’ve talked about this before, fairly often.

Sin and Respect

Sin is a failure to love. It’s what happens when I don’t love God and my neighbor, or don’t see everyone as my neighbor. Everyone. No exceptions. (Matthew 5:43–44, 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Luke 10:25–37; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1706, 1776, 1825, 1849-1851, 1955)

Sin is an offense against reason, truth and God. (Catechism, 1849-1850)

I do that more often than I like.

Feeling an impulse to act badly isn’t a sin, by itself. Acting on the impulse: deciding to follow through with whatever I feel like doing, or that stopping myself is too much trouble? That’s where I start sinning. Catechism, 1730-1742)

Basically, I’ve got a brain. I’m expected to use it.

One more thing, about thinking and feeling. Emotions happen. They’re part of being human. By themselves, they’re not good or bad. What matters is what we do about them. (Catechism, 1762-1770)

Feeling an impulse to perform homosexual acts can happen. Feeling the impulse isn’t what’s evil. Deciding to cooperate with the impulse, or deciding to go with the flow: that’s where trouble starts. (Catechism, 2357-2359)

I’m expected to recognize the action as a sin, and remember that folks deserve “respect, compassion, and sensitivity.” (Catechism, 2358)

Even folks who aren’t exactly like me. And that’s yet another topic.

Minions?

Martin Luther King, Augustine of Hippo and Cicero said, or at least implied, that sometimes breaking a law isn’t a bad thing.

How can I, as a Catholic, possibly think they’re right?

Aren’t we expected to blindly do as we’re told? And doesn’t respecting authority mean obeying even the most obviously-wrong laws?

My guess is that describing Catholics as brainwashed minions of a foreign power is out of fashion in most American circles. Times change, and so do our cliches and slogans.

Old stereotypes die hard, though, so I’ll talk about authority, rules, and doing what’s right.

I should respect authority. Obedience is a good idea. Blind obedience isn’t. (Catechism, 1900, 1951, 2242-2243)

Some rules don’t change. No matter where or when I lived, loving God and neighbor would still be good ideas.

Some rules must change, as our circumstances change. Rules work better when they’re in line with the rules that don’t change.

We call the unchanging rules, principles written into this reality, natural law. (Catechism, 1950-1974)

Positive law is our name for rules we make up. Those rules should change if they aren’t consistent with natural law. (February 5, 2017)

More, mostly how I see love and acting like it matters:


1 Background:

Posted in Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Walking

Reflections and reality,
Walking toward the light.
Footprints lost to time and tide.
Destination still unseen,
Following rippled outlines,
Walking toward the light.


Not-entirely-unrelated posts:

Posted in Poems, Series | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Arrivals and Departures

Light and dark, green and brown.
Crescent moon, textured memories.
Past is done, a quiet present.
What was, will be. Their now
Is yet to come.


This blog now has a new category, poems; a sort of cousin-category to narratives. I’ve got a few more poems to post, and most likely will write more. Meanwhile, here’s the inevitable link list of posts that aren’t completely unrelated to this one:

Posted in Poems, Series | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Jolo: Bombs at the Cathedral

Jolo’s Our Lady of Mount Carmel parish lost 15 of its members Sunday morning. They stopped living when a bomb shredded part of the cathedral.

Maybe they survived the first blast, but not the second. Either way, they’re dead. So are five soldiers.

I’m not nearly as upset as I would be if this had happened in my town. But I’m upset, just the same. I’m also trying to see this as a time to remember that I’m expected to love God and my neighbors — and see everybody as my neighbor. No exceptions. (Matthew 5:43–44, 22:36–40; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31, 10:25–37; Catechism, 1789)


A “Good Community”


(From Google Maps, used w/o permission.)
(Satellite view of Jolo, Sulu, Philippines.)

Jolo is the capital of Sulu province, home to around 125,500 folks, and one of many municipalities not covered by Street View on Google Maps.

The closest ‘street view’ area I found was Zamboanga City, Mindanao, about a hundred miles northeast of Jolo.

Jolo is a little like my home town, if I think of Fargo-Moorhead as a single urban entity. The population is about the same as Fargo-Moorhead’s when I last lived there. Both are regionally-prominent spots in a country’s outlying regions.

On the other hand, Fargo’s current temperature is 4° Fahrenheit/-16 C. At midday. In Jolo it’s 79° Fahrenheit/26 C, and two in the morning. If I unexpectedly woke up in Jolo, it wouldn’t take me long to realize that I wasn’t in the Upper Midwest any more.

Regional cultures and histories are different, too. About six centuries back now, folks from the Middle East arrived in Jolo. I’m not sure how the first meetings went. By 1405 or so, Jolo was part of the Sultanate of Sulu and officially Muslim.

My guess is that the local’s first encounters with foreign traders came much earlier. The city’s name, Jolo, apparently comes from ho lâng and ho ló, “good people” and “good community.” The names speak volumes, I think, of the folks living there and the Chinese traders. Traders noticed that material they left unattended on the shore was still there when they returned.

Time passed, Ferdinand Magellan showed up in 1521 and said the Philippine islands belonged to Spain. Spain’s occupation forces followed, successfully held northern parts of the archipelago, but not the Sultanates.

Jolo kept being a regionally-important port city. That probably helps explain why so many folks there have Chinese ancestors, who learned the local language — mostly in Singapore.

Spanish authorities tried solving their Muslim problem by burning Jolo in 1876. They followed up by building the smallest walled city in the world — a distinction of sorts — possibly as a defense against other European forces who wanted a piece of the action.

The United States acquired Spain’s claim to the Philippines in 1876, following traditional European habits for a while. We’ve learned quite a bit since then. What not to do, partly.

These days, about 90% of the folks in and around Jolo are Muslims. Quite a few of the others are Christians of one sort or another, and that brings me to Sunday’s news.1


Death in the Cathedral


(From Huw Evans picture agency/Philippine army/AFP, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The bomb attack devastated the church in Jolo”
(BBC News))

“Jolo church attack: Many killed in Philippines”
BBC News (January 27, 2019)

“Two bombs at a Roman Catholic cathedral in southern Philippines have killed 20 people and injured dozens more, local officials say.

“The Islamic State (IS) group said it was behind the attack on Jolo island, where jihadist groups are active.

“The first blast happened as Sunday Mass was being celebrated. A second device exploded outside as soldiers responded….

“…The local officials say the first blast happened at 08:45 local time (00:45 GMT) inside the Cathedral of Our Lady of Mount Carmel, which has been hit by bombs in the past.

“The second explosion was shortly afterwards on the doorstep of the church.

“Police initially put the death toll at 27 but later lowered it to 20, saying there was double counting in earlier official reports….”

I’ve got mixed feelings about what happened in Jolo. Mostly, I’m angry and upset over the deaths and destruction. That makes ‘weeping with those who weep’ a bit easier.

“Bless those who persecute [you], bless and do not curse them.
“Rejoice with those who rejoice, weep with those who weep.”
(Romans 12:14–15)

Blessing folks who do this sort of thing — that’s probably easier for me than it is for folks closer to the attack. Even so, it’s not easy. But it’s still a good idea.

From my viewpoint, killing folks at Our Lady of Mount Carmel is “senseless.”

That doesn’t keep me from realizing that others have their own perspectives.

Apparently an IS statement describes Sunday’s target as a “crusader temple.”

I can see how someone living in Jola might see a Christian church or cathedral in that light. Folks who decided to cooperate with the Sultanate of Sulu, back in 1405, might not have insisted that later generations remember their pre-Islamic roots.

In any case, six centuries is a long time. Long enough for family memories to get a tad fuzzy. The area’s more recent history hasn’t helped the situation either. My opinion.

Between conflicts of the Hatfield-McCoy variety, turf and autonomy issues and a succession of occupation forces, there’s a smorgasbord of local and regional tensions.2


“Deep Indignation”


(From EPA, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The first bomb went off in or near the cathedral of Jolo, followed by a second blast outside the compound as government forces were responding to the attack”
(Al Jazeera))

“Philippines church bombing: Twin blasts hit Jolo cathedral”
Al Jazeera (January 27, 2019)

“ISIL claims responsibility for the attacks that killed 20 people and wounded more than 100.

“…Sunday’s incident claimed the lives of at least 15 civilians and five soldiers, police said, adding that 111 others were wounded….

“…President Rodrigo Duterte’s spokesman Salvador Panelo condemned the ‘act of terrorism’ and vowed that government forces will pursue the perpetrators of the attack.

“‘The Armed Forces of the Philippines will rise to the challenge and crush these godless criminals,’ he said.

“Pope Francis, the head of the Roman Catholic Church, said he expressed ‘the firmest reproach’ for this episode of violence. As too did Yousef Al-Othaimeen, the head of the OIC, the world’s largest body of Muslim-majority countries, who said he expressed ‘deep indignation’ over the bombings….”

I figure someone, somewhere, has decided that Francis and Yousef are in cahoots, or Satanic stooges, or space-alien shape-shifting lizard-men. Or something equally colorful and unlikely.

There’s something oddly appealing about conspiracy theories. I find them appealing, sometimes, in stories. What’s odd, maybe, is how many folks take them seriously. And that’s another topic.3

Back to death, destruction and Jolo; sympathizing with folks in the Our Lady of Mount Carmel parish isn’t hard. We share the same faith, and apparently at least one of the same devotional habits.

The photo used by both BBC News and Al Jazeera shows a Divine Mercy picture between two stations of the cross. I’m not involved in Sauk Centre’s Divine Mercy devotional group, but I do spend about an hour a week at the chapel. (October 15, 2017)

One of these days I may talk about how paying attention to Jesus and what our Lord said isn’t idolatry, but not today.


America and the Kilkenny Cats

Frothing radio preachers denouncing the ‘whore of Babylon’ helped me become a Catholic. Decades later, I may understand their viewpoint a little better; and even have a sort of sympathy for them.

They may have seen ‘those Catholics’ as foreign agents, in thrall to a diabolical mastermind: a fifth column threat to their “Christian” America.

Never mind that, as a Catholic, I’m expected to recognize legitimate civil authority and be a good citizen. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1897–1917)

Remembered rants of yesteryear help me understand why some folks in the Philippines might think bombing a “crusader temple” is a good idea.

Understanding motives, or trying to, is one thing. Thinking that spitting venom is a good idea, or applauding mass murder, is another.

In a way, I’m impressed that there isn’t more bloodshed in Jolo. Counting the cathedral, I found a half-dozen provocative landmarks within a mile of the city’s center.

There’s the Tulay and Abu Harris mosques, a Sacred Heart of Jesus Chapel, and — right next to the Kasanyangan Mosque — the Notre Dame of Jolo School for Girls.

If the not-uncommon idea that religion makes folks kill each other was true, I’d expect the city’s population to end up like the Kilkenny cats:

“There once were two cats of Kilkenny
Each thought there was one cat too many
So they fought and they fit
And they scratched and they bit
Till (excepting their nails
And the tips of their tails)
Instead of two cats there weren’t any!”
(Kilkenny cat, Wikipedia)

Life and Dignity

On the other hand, I’m not all that surprised either.

I figure that many, probably most, Christians and Muslims aren’t fanatic assassins or kill-crazy psychopaths.

Others are arguably a bit cracked, but only occasionally violent. (September 22, 2017; June 4, 2017)

There’s the ‘don’t get mad, get even’ attitude; and that’s yet another topic.

Instead, I’ll talk about life, dignity, and how that applies to lethal threats.

I think human life is precious. Sacred, because “…it involves the creative action of God…” (Catechism, 2258)

We each have equal dignity. How we act, who we are or where we live doesn’t affect that. (Catechism, 360, 1700–1706, 1932–1933, 1935)

Thinking that human life is precious doesn’t mean that I must let someone kill me. My attacker’s life is precious, but so is mine. Defending myself is okay. Even if that results in my attacker’s death. It’s a question of intent. (Catechism, 2258, 2263–2269; “Summa Theologica,” Thomas Aquinas, II-II,64,7)

That’s not even close to ‘I thought he was going to hit me, so I killed him.’

And that’s yet again another topic:


1 Jolo, Sulu, the Philippines:

2 Factions and friction:

3 Making sense and other options:

Posted in Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , | 4 Comments