Independence Day 2017

Today is American Independence Day. It’s also the anniversary of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland’s inspiration, and Trois-Rivières founding day. Ashikaga Yoshiakira’s birthday, Pactum Sicardi, and whole bunch of other stuff make this day important, too.


(From Downtown Winnipeg BIZ, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(The “largest living maple leaf,” July 1, 2017, in Winnipeg, Canada.)

This whole year is special for folks in Canada. Canadians are celebrating their nation’s 150th anniversary with special events, including Winnipeg’s “largest living maple leaf.”

I’m mostly aware of July Fourth as my country’s Independence Day.

Patriotism Can be Cheesy

America!

Land of the free, home of the Patriotic Inflatable Drink Cooler, and — for a brief shining moment — a one-ton replica of Trumbull’s Declaration of Independence, made entirely of cheese and cooking oil.

I don’t mind the ‘commercialization’ of America’s Independence Day. Although I appreciate fine art, I also like just-for-fun kitsch like ‘patriotic’ bottles and — bow ties?

The 2008 Cheez-It sculpture was on display in New York City and Philadelphia before getting shipped back to Wisconsin. I’d tell you where you could see it now, but it’s long since been broken down and given to food pantries.

The ‘Good Old Days’ Weren’t

I like being an American, but realize that my country isn’t perfect: and never has been. On the whole, I think we’ve been getting better over the last 241 years.

I’ll admit to a bias.

I’m a Catholic, and like being allowed to live here. We’re even allowed to own property and vote. That’s a huge improvement over the ‘good old days’ in some parts.

I certainly don’t miss more recent ‘good old days’ when a disturbing fraction of red-white-and-blue-blooded Americans seemed convinced that Jesus was an American.

In fairness, I’ve never heard anyone actually say that. My guess is that even the most rabid radio preachers of my youth would, if they had calmed down a little, have realized that the Age of the Apostles did not end in 1954. (June 18, 2017)

Some folks still get their notion of patriotism confused with their religious beliefs. I think that attitude helped make “kill a commie for Christ” an anti-war slogan.

Sadly, Weege’s 1967 lithograph echoes America’s traditional anti-Catholic imagery, as well as contemporary political sentiments. I really don’t miss the ‘good old days.’1

Five Years of the Toleration Act

Maryland enjoys the distinction of being called the “birthplace of religious freedom in America.” (Wikipedia)

George Calvert founded the Province of Maryland for English Catholics.

Maryland was Calvert’s second North American colony. The first was Avalon, founded in 1621 and currently part of Newfoundland.

Calvert’s house in Avalon was the only one big enough for large groups, so both Catholics and Protestants held services there. That freaked out Erasmus Stourton, Avalon’s Anglican clergyman, with the usual results.

Maryland had troubles, too. Human nature pretty well guaranteed that. England’s 1642-1651 civil war led to Maryland’s 1644-1646 Plundering Time.

The 1649 Maryland Toleration Act, mandating religious tolerance for Trinitarian Christians, lasted until 1654. It’s the second ‘religious freedom’ law in American history. Rhode Island got the ball rolling in 1636, and that’s another topic.

Salem Witch Trials and — Psychedelic Pumpernickel???

Puritans set their “City upon a Hill” in John Winthrop’s 1628-1691 Massachusetts Bay Colony. That’s where Salem and Boston are now.

Massachusetts-bound Puritans were fleeing England in part because Charles I had married a Catholic.

They feared, not unreasonably, that their version of Henry VIII’s English church might succumb to — creeping Catholicism???

Starting around 1660, assorted English kings got interested in their North American colonies again. Maryland was reorganized as a dominion and a royal province before the American Revolution happened. Now it’s an American state with a colorful history.

Religious beliefs were a factor in the 1692-1693 Salem witch trials. But the last I heard we’re not sure exactly why those folks went nuts. One of the more imaginative ideas is that the lunacy started with a bad batch of rye bread.

The idea isn’t as crazy at it sounds. Claviceps purpurea infects rye and similar grains. It contains ergotamine. Ergotamine is a precursor of lysergic acid, which should ring a bell.

Albert Hofmann synthesized the first lysergic acid diethylamide in 1938, Timothy Leary popularized LSD three decades later, and that’s yet another topic.

The 1780 Constitution of Massachusetts guaranteed religious freedom: for some. Its declaration of rights included equality for “every denomination of Christians, demeaning themselves peaceably and as good subjects of the commonwealth.”

I’d like to think that Catholics were considered a “denomination of Christians” by then.

Patriot Dream

Being Catholic doesn’t keep me from being an American, but I don’t have to be an American to be Catholic.

I’m obliged to be a good citizen, no matter where I live.

Contributing to the good of society and taking part in public life is part of my faith. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1915, 2239)

Different cultures allow different kinds of participation, and that’s okay. (Catechism, 1915)

One of the issues I’m concerned about is religious freedom: which does not mean forcing everyone to agree with me. ‘Free to agree with me’ isn’t freedom.

As a Catholic, I must support religious freedom — for everybody. (Catechism, 2104–2109)

There’s more to being Catholic. But the ‘citizenship’ part boils down to loving God and my neighbor, and seeing everyone as my neighbor. (Matthew 5:43–44, 7:12, 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; 10:25–27, 29–37; Catechism, 1789)

Like I said, America isn’t perfect. No society in humanity’s long story has been ideal. That’s why I can’t accept the status quo.

Yearning for days of yore isn’t an option, either. Even if I could, I wouldn’t try dragging America back to some imaged ‘golden age.’ My memory is too good to imagine that nostalgia is more than an occasionally-pleasant daydream.

That leaves one direction: forward.

“…O beautiful for patriot dream
That sees beyond the years
Thine alabaster cities gleam
Undimmed by human tears!…”
(“America the Beautiful,” Katharine Lee Bates, 1911 version, via Wikipedia)

I don’t imagine that humanity’s many problems will be solved in the next century, millennium, or ten millennia from now. As I’ve said before, we’re working through an enormous backlog.

But I am sure that we make something better than what we have today.

Part of my job is helping bring a greater degree of justice and charity, and respect for “the transcendent dignity of man,” to America; and the world. (Catechism, 1928–1942, 2419–2442)

I’m just one man, living in central Minnesota. There isn’t much I can do to change the world: apart from suggesting that loving our neighbors, all our neighbors, makes sense.

I think we can, if we work with all people of good will, build a better world. I am certain that we must try.

Acting as if love matters:


1 The ‘good old days:’

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Calling Us

13th Sunday in Ordinary Time, 2017:


13th Sunday in Ordinary Time, 2017

By Deacon Lawrence N. Kaas July 2, 2017

What a week this has been, a Deacons Retreat at the Abbey of the Hills, resulting in thoughts, reflections, and stories to share.

The Abbey is a former Benedictine Abbey located about 30 miles west of the border in South Dakota. It’s hard to count exactly, but we had something like 40 deacons in attendance and our retreat master being Father Knoblach. I really don’t know if I’m the one that makes this declaration, but to my estimation he is absolutely brilliant. His theme for the weekend became known as old books. Besides the Bible, obviously an old book, he spoke extensively on G.K. Chesterton, C.S. Lewis, and a bit on Tolkien. I’m sure not trying to tell you that I understood everything he said, for the reality is some of that what was said was over my head. Not saying that that is bad, but a reality to the point where taking notes was difficult to almost impossible for rear you would miss something that was being said.

You can well imagine that Chesterton piqued my imagination, because he wrote the Father Brown mysteries, that I just happened to be watching on Netflix. We know full well that Chesterton didn’t write all of these mysteries, but certainly they are written in the spirit of Chesterton. I’ll share with you only two of his quotes that are quite interesting, from the works he has titled “What’s Wrong With the World,” reflecting on Christianity, he said, “the Christian ideal has not been tried or found wanting; it has been found difficult and left untried.” Another time in response to a story from the London Times posing the question, “what’s wrong with the world today?” He answered, “dear Sirs: I am” Yours, G.K. Chesterton.

A quote from C.S. Lewis, from his work entitled “Mere Christianity.” “Humility is not thinking less of yourself, but thinking of yourself less.”

And one quote from Tolkien, titled, “Fellowship of the Ring, “Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then do not be eager to deal out death and judgment. For even the very wise cannot see all ends.” Along with many typewritten pages of articles and quotes from old books.

The only sad part of the retreat was that I was not able to get back for the hundred year celebration at St. Alexius. Proof of which is that I do not bi-locate very well yet.

Then early in the week father Greg asked me to preach this weekend and now what?

As it turns out, I’m going to tell you a story: Tuesday of this week we had an optional Memorial for St. Cyril of Alexandria, by the way we did not celebrate. Why, I do not know; because not only was he an Archbishop and Doctor of the Church, he also was the presider at the Council of Ephesus. I’ve told this story before and if you’ve heard it before please remember what Father Statz would tell us, that good music, a good play, or a good homily, or a good story is worth retelling, so here’s what happened.

There was a Bishop Nestorius of Constantinople who taught his people that Mary could not be called the mother of God because she was simply the mother of a man. This so upset some of the people that finally they petition Rome to look into this question and give them an answer. It so happened that Cyril of Alexandria presided at the council at Ephesus in 431. The single topic to be looked at was this debate on whether Mary could be called a mother of God. Three times they asked Nestorius to come and plead his case, which he refused to do. So finally the Council declared emphatically that, “Mary was to be called the mother of God because she had given to Jesus everything and anything that any mother had given to any son.” Is the way they put it! The people, then overjoyed, raised in the streets a din, with drums and pots and pans and the women rattling their tongues, proclaiming Mary is the mother of God.

The story does not end there, because they ordered Nestorius to recant his teaching and he refused to do so. As time goes on, we find him sick abed, dying as worms were eating his tongue, that tongue that dared blaspheme the Blessed Virgin Mary. Now I want to take the liberty of putting words in Jesus’ mouth, He says, “you betrayed me, you scourged me, you crowned me with thorns, and you crucified me, but you do not mean mouth my mother!” This story not only gives proof of how much Jesus loves his mother and I declare to you, without hesitation, it is also proof how much he loves every mother! Remember too, that as a little boy Jesus grew up in a society that took very seriously any boy that should abuse or slap his mother, the penalty could be stoning.

Then Thursday of this week we celebrated the feast of Saints Peter and Paul. Simon to be called Peter was a married man and a fisherman, who Jesus called, rock, on whom he would build his church. Peter was called the chief of the Apostles and from the middle of the third century onwards documents show that the Bishop of Rome was recognized as the successor of Peter.

Paul an apostle to the Gentiles was born a Roam living in Tarsus and was educated as a Pharisee. From the time of his vision of Christ on the way to arrest Christians and bring them in for punishment, he heard Jesus say to him, “why are you persecuting me”, and was struck blind. The rest of the story is found in this old book, called the Bible.

Then we come to this weekend where we are encouraged to answer the call: today’s Gospel occurs after Jesus calls each of his disciples by name, and remember now, these are ordinary people who lead commonplace lives marked by birth, growing up, married, having children, working, and finally dying – much like our own lives. Jesus called these people out of their everyday existence to a spectacular purpose: working with him to bring about the kingdom of justice, peace, and love in this world and to prepare for the next.

And calling them and Him calling us, through the baptism that Paul refers to, Jesus affords each of us a dignity, a purpose, and a value unique to our gifts and our capacities.

Some of us may be called to welcome strangers or to listen with patience and openness to the prophets in our midst, no matter how unwelcome their Message might be. Or maybe we are simply called to respond to someone’s need for a cold cup of water to offset the heat of the blazing July 2nd sun.

So, you all be Good, be Holy, preach the Gospel always and if necessary use words!


(‘Thank you’ to Deacon Kaas, for letting me post his reflection here — Brian H. Gill.)


Related posts:


More:

Posted in Guest Posts, Reflections, Series | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Still Rejoicing

My father reminded me of this good advice when I was in my teens: “…whatever is true, … whatever is lovely, … think about these things.” My response was something like ‘…because they won’t last.’

I wasn’t happy about saying that at the time. I still regret it.

I can’t, of course, undo what was done. And the time for telling my father “I’m sorry” has long since passed. In any case, I said “I’m sorry” too often, and that’s almost another topic.

The quote is from Philippians 4:6–9. I’ll get back to that.

Following the advice from Philippians isn’t easy for me.

But it’s been getting easier as I work though a massive backlog of bad habits. Nothing unusual there, since we’re all dealing with consequences of a bad choice described in Genesis 3:1–13.1

My inner housecleaning got a boost about 11 years ago.

That’s when my wife told me I should talk to a psychiatrist. As usual, she was right.

We knew I had problems. Now we know more about what they are.

That didn’t make them go away, but it helps me deal with them.

The most obvious problem was depression. It still is, but now I don’t have to fight the controls just to make my brain work. Antidepressants keep my body from running through neurotransmitters faster than they’re produced.

I even have moments when I feel good about who I am and what I do.

It’s a nice change of pace.

Like I said, antidepressants didn’t make my problems go away. But they make dealing with Asperger’s/ASD/whatever, plus PTSD and assorted other glitches, a whole lot easier. Let’s face it, I’m a mess.

Melancholia was being redefined as depressive reaction while I was growing up, then to depressive neurosis. Maybe it’s just as well that my condition wasn’t spotted then.

We’ve been learning a great deal about mental illness. There’s a great deal left to learn.

It’s been some time since I ran into the notion that medication and faith don’t get along. But I’ll repeat what I’ve said before: being and staying healthy is a good idea, within reason. (March 31, 2017)

If I’d spent more than four decades of my life in a different way — I wouldn’t be where I am today.

Joy, Zest, and Mud

As it is, I had an opportunity to reason my way out of suicide; and developed a knack for seeing beauty in just about anything.

Seeing a crescent moon, or noticing symmetries and order in drying mud, didn’t give me an emotional rush of wonder and delight very often. It still doesn’t.

But I learned to appreciate the beauty that’s built into this universe. It’s always available for inspection, no matter what sort of emotions I’m experiencing.

Decades later, I learned that paying attention to such things can help us find God. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 341, 1147)

A dictionary says that joy can mean intense happiness: particularly ecstatic or exultant happiness. Ecstasy can mean intense joy or delight, getting so emotionally whipped up that rational thought and self-control are impossible.

I’ve run into folks who seem to approach faith with a zest and enthusiasm worthy of a homecoming game pep rally.

That’s okay, I suppose. But I very much prefer a faith that still works when all the light and color has drained from the world.

Emotions Happen

Experiencing emotions is part of being human. They’re not good or bad, by themselves. It’s what I decide to do with them that matters. (Catechism, 1767-1770)

Using my brain is part of being human, too: or should be. Doing what is right is easier when my emotions are in sync with my reason. But how I feel shouldn’t determine what I do. I’m expected to think. Catechism, 1777-1782)

My faith depends on what I decide to think is true: not how I’m feeling. (Catechism, 30, 142-150, 156-159, 274, 1706)

But it’s not all about cold logic. Now and then we get a glimpse of the beatific vision. The beatific vision is contemplation of God in heavenly glory. (Catechism, 163, 1028)

That’s what I’m told, at any rate. I don’t know from personal experience. My metaphorical mirror isn’t all that shiny.

“At present we see indistinctly, as in a mirror, but then face to face. At present I know partially; then I shall know fully, as I am fully known.”
(1 Corinthians 13:12)

That’s okay: since, like 2 Corinthians 5:7 says, “we walk by faith, not by sight.”

As a Catholic, I must believe that by using reason, we’re “…capable of understanding the order of things established by the Creator…;” and that “conscience is a judgment of reason … a law of the mind….” (Catechism, 1704, 1778)

It’s not blind faith, or the sort that avoids facts and reason.

Swooning Saints and Ham Sandwiches

Maybe it’s just as well that I haven’t gotten the ecstatic ‘beatific vision’ experience described in some tales of Saints like Teresa of Ávila.

Swooning Saints were a staple of some Medieval and Victorian pop literature.

The Saints are real. Some of the tales, apparently not so much.

Garrigou-Lagrange’s advice for folks getting “visions” like that makes sense to me.

Basically, they should calm down, go to the kitchen, and eat something. They’re hungry, or tired; possible both:

“…These swoons should be eliminated as much as possible; they should be resisted and the organism strengthened by more substantial food….”
(“The Three Ages of the Interior Life: Prelude of Eternal Life,” Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange (1938-1939) via Google Books)

My cure for that sort of ‘mystical experience’ would be a ham sandwich.

Again, there’s nothing wrong with emotions. Affective piety, intensely emotional devotion to some part of our Lord’s life, is important for some folks.

What gets us in trouble is letting emotions replace thinking.

Expecting the sort of mystical ecstasy Teresa of Ávila reported isn’t reasonable. Folks like her don’t come along very often. She was remarkable, even for a Saint.

Wanting happiness, within reason, makes sense. I put definitions of happiness and the beatific vision at the end of this post.2

On a related point, I’ve been learning that Christian mysticism makes sense. The real thing, that is.

I think David Torkington does a good job of discussing differences between today’s Pelagianism retread and serious mysticism.

I also recommend studying “Jesus Christ The Bearer Of The Water Of Life….” At upwards of 26,000 words, it’s not light reading. But it’s worth the effort, I think:

Trouble Happens, Anxiety is Optional

It’s been nearly a half-century since my father reminded me of this bit from Philippians:

“Rejoice in the Lord always. I shall say it again: rejoice!
“Have no anxiety at all, but in everything, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, make your requests known to God.
“Then the peace of God that surpasses all understanding will guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus.
“Finally, brothers, whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is just, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is gracious, if there is any excellence and if there is anything worthy of praise, think about these things.”
(Philippians 4:4, 6–8)

I don’t “feel” joyful very often, and that’s okay.

I may never have the “mountaintop experience” folks describe as being overwhelmed, ‘knocked down,’ by God’s presence. That’s also okay.

Folks have taken verses like Philippians 4:6, “have no anxiety at all…,” and run straight off the edge of reality.

Assuming that God will make my life rosy if I pray, ask for something, and say ‘thank you,’ makes no sense. Not to me. Neither does assuming that folks who have trouble must be sinners. I don’t know which, if either, of those wacky ideas is popular these days.

Christians are wounded people, living in a damaged world; just like anyone else. We’re going to have trouble. (Job 5:7; Catechism, 386-390)

The trick is not being anxious about the troubles we face.

I think looking at the big picture helps.

The Big Picture

About two thousand years back, Jesus, the Son of God, was born, lived, was tortured and finally killed on Golgotha.

For anyone else, that would have been the end.

Jesus isn’t just anyone. A few days later, our Lord stopped being dead.

If that seems unbelievable, you’ve got company. It took quite a few meetings and at least one working lunch to convince the Apostles that Jesus was — in fact — really — no kidding — not a ghost — sit-down-and-eat-a-baked-fish, alive.

“While they were still incredulous for joy and were amazed, he asked them, ‘Have you anything here to eat?’
“They gave him a piece of baked fish;
“he took it and ate it in front of them.”
(Luke 24:41–43)

“Now a week later his disciples were again inside and Thomas was with them. Jesus came, although the doors were locked, and stood in their midst and said, ‘Peace be with you.’
“Then he said to Thomas, ‘Put your finger here and see my hands, and bring your hand and put it into my side, and do not be unbelieving, but believe.'”
(John 20:26–27)

A little later our Lord gave them standing orders, told them that he’d be back, and left.

Matthew 28:18–20 is one of my favorite parts of the Bible. I also enjoy reading what happened next:

“While they were looking intently at the sky as he was going, suddenly two men dressed in white garments stood beside them.
“They said, ‘Men of Galilee, why are you standing there looking at the sky? This Jesus who has been taken up from you into heaven will return in the same way as you have seen him going into heaven.'”
(Acts 1:10–11)

Our Lord’s return has been “imminent” for about two millennia now. Jesus said we should “be prepared,” since we wouldn’t know when that will be. (Matthew 24:44; Catechism, 673, 840, 1040, 2772)

I’m okay with that.

We’ve got our hands full, helping set up the civilization of love, and passing along the best news humanity’s ever had — God loves us and wants to adopt us. All of us. (John 1:12–14, 3:17; Romans 8:14–17; 2 Peter 1:3–4; Catechism, 27-30, 52, 1825, 1996)

Posts that aren’t entirely unrelated:


1 Part of my take on being human and getting a grip:

2 Definitions:

“BEATIFIC VISION: The contemplation of God in heavenly glory, a gift of God which is a constitutive element of the happiness (or beatitude) of heaven (1028, 1720).”

“HAPPINESS: Joy and beatitude over receiving the fulfillment of our vocation as creatures: a sharing in the divine nature and the vision of God. God put us into the world to know, love, and serve him, and so come to the happiness of paradise (1720).”
(Glossary, Catechism of the Catholic Church)

Posted in Being Catholic, Creativity, Poems, Series | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Exoplanet Frontier

We wouldn’t expect to find life on 51 Eridani b, even if were the size of Earth and at the right distance from its star.

The planet is only a bit over 20,000,000 years old.

At that point in our home’s long story, the earliest critters wouldn’t appear for at least another several million years.

We’ve discovered thousands of new worlds so far, some a bit like Earth, most not; and many not like anything in our Solar System.

Scientists are starting to make sense of what’s being found, and discovering that we have a very great deal left to learn.


Worlds Circling Other Stars

Until around 1990, all known planets were in the Solar System.

We’d had several false alarms earlier, starting in the 19th century.

In 1855, for example, William Stephen Jacob published observations and analysis that he said showed a massive planet in the 70 Ophiuchi system.

Swarthmore College’s Peter van de Kamp did the same with Barnard’s Star in the mid-20th century.

We’ve learned quite a bit since then. It’s pretty much certain that Jacob’s and van de Kamp’s planets aren’t actually there.

That doesn’t mean there can’t be planets orbiting the stars. But they’d have to be a whole lot smaller than the ones folks like Jacob and van de Camp thought they’d found.

Then, in 1992, scientists confirmed that three exoplanets circled the pulsar PSR B1257+12. In 1995 we confirmed that a planet orbits 51 Pegasi, a main-sequence star. We’ve discovered thousands since then.

We’re not even close to thoroughly mapping planetary systems around nearby stars, let alone the rest of this galaxy.1

We are, however, starting to piece together enough to realize how much is left to learn.


1. 51 Eridani b Forecast: Partly Cloudy and Cooler


(From Rajan et al. 2017, via Sky and Telescope, used w/o permission.)
(“Images of 51 Eri b from GPI (top) and Keck (bottom).”
(Sky and Telescope))

“A Partly Cloudy Exoplanet”
AAS Nova, Sky and Telescope (June 22, 2017)

“Direct imaging of exoplanets was once only possible for the brightest of planets orbiting the dimmest of stars — but improving technology is turning this into an increasingly powerful technique. In a new study, direct-imaging observations of the Jupiter-like exoplanet 51 Eridani b provide tantalizing clues about its atmosphere.

“Direct Imaging of 51 Eri b

“While transit detections remain the best way to discover large quantities of new exoplanets, direct imaging provides a unique advantage: you can measure the light from the exoplanet itself. With proper constraints on the host star, it therefore becomes possible to measure the spectrum of the planet’s atmosphere.

“One target for this technique is 51 Eri b, a Jupiter-like exoplanet located roughly 100 light-years away. This object was the first exoplanet directly imaged by the Gemini Planet Imager Exoplanet Survey, a project that used the Gemini Planet Imager (GPI) instrument in Chile to search for exoplanets around 600 young nearby stars….”

The planet is a lot like Jupiter, but not a twin. It’s about the same diameter, with twice the mass. Like Jupiter, there’s methane and water in its atmosphere.

It’s as far away from its sun as the Solar System’s outer planets are from ours: 13 Astronomical Units, give or take. Something orbiting our star at that distance would be between Jupiter’s and Saturn’s orbits.

51 Eridani b is hotter than the Solar System’s big planet: around 700 Kelvin, 427 Celsius, 800 Fahrenheit. Jupiter’s temperature is about 165 Kelvin where atmospheric pressure is the same as Earth’s. That’s 108 Celsius, 163 Fahrenheit.

The high temperature isn’t surprising. 51 Eridani is a young star, in the Beta Pictoris moving group.

Young Stars and Rogue Planets

The Beta Pictoris moving group is a set of young stars, more than a dozen; plus at least one ‘rogue planet,’ PSO J318.5-22.

Scientists figure the group’s stars formed between 20,000,000 and 26,000,000 years ago. For stars, that’s not a long time.

An early age estimate of around 10 or 12 million years was doubled as researchers made more exact observations of the group’s stars.

It’s the closest young group we’ve found, which makes it important for scientists studying stellar and planetary system formation.

I wondered about the Sky and Telescope article’s discussion of 51 Eridani b’s “spectral type.” That’s a term I’d associated with a stellar classification system astronomers started developing in the mid-19th century.

Since a star’s spectral type is based on what sort of radiation it emits, applying the term to planets makes sense: particularly warmish ones glowing with noticeable infrared ‘light.’

While checking out 51 Eridani b’s “spectral type,” I learned that the star has a binary companion: GJ 3305 A and B, a slightly-mismatched pair of red dwarf stars.

GJ 3305 A and B orbit each other every 29.03 years, give or take six months. They’re small stars, spectral type M1.1; 0.67 and 0.44 times our sun’s mass plus or minus 0.05.

Big Planets, Small Stars

Maybe GJ 3305 A and B just happen to be in 51 Eridani’s vicinity.

There’s probably still debate on that point. Consensus seems to be that they’re gravitationally bound to 51 Eridani.

Their connection to 51 Eridani, if it exists, isn’t particularly firm.

Passing close, by cosmic standards, to another large star could send them off on their own.2

51 Eridani b’s spectra looks a lot like what comes from Spectral class T brown dwarfs.

That’s the current name for objects considerably more massive than Jupiter but not quite massive enough to be stars.

It’s probably not a brown dwarf, though. It’d be a very lightweight one, and its spectra is too “red.” Scientists who published the latest study say we’re probably looking at clouds in 51 Eridani b’s atmosphere.

Clouds in Earth’s atmosphere are usually made of water. 51 Eridani b’s atmosphere has water, but these clouds are probably dust: salt and sulfide, or maybe iron and silicate. What’s observed so far could be either.

That sort of cloud is what scientists expect to observe in atmospheres of ‘cold start’ or ‘warm start’ big planets as they cool off. This is a wonderful opportunity to see if those models match what’s in the real world.

Fine-Tuning the Nebular Hypothesis

Scientists figure planets start at least one of two or three ways.

The Sky and Telescope article says the cold-start scenario is where planets form slowly by accretion onto a solid core.

The hot-start scenario is faster, with hot stuff in the protoplanetary disk collapsing to form a gas giant.

Warm-start is, naturally enough, about halfway between hot and cold.3

They’re all variations of the nebular hypothesis.

The nebular hypotheses started looking good in my youth. Scientists still figure it’s the best explanation we’ve found for how planetary systems form.

What’s been changing is basically fine-tuning of the nebular hypothesis.

It’s sort of like what’s been happening with the Copernican model of the Solar System.

We still figure our sun is in the center of the Solar System. What’s been changing in the last 475 years is how much we know about the details. (April 14, 2017; March 24, 2017; December 9, 2016)


2. Unexpected New Worlds


(From NASA/Ames Research Center/Natalie Batalha/Wendy Stenzel, via Space.com, used w/o permission.)
(“The planets characterized by NASA’s Kepler mission (yellow dots) and other surveys split into several different broad planet types. Future exoplanet surveys will reveal small planets orbiting further from their stars in the corner marked ‘frontier’.”
(Space.com))

“NASA’s Kepler Space Telescope Finds Hundreds of New Exoplanets, Boosts Total to 4,034”
Sarah Lewin, Space.com (June 19, 2017)

“NASA has unveiled the complete set of data from the first four years of the agency’s Kepler Space Telescope mission, which stared at a single patch of the sky in the search for alien planets. The result: Kepler has discovered 219 new candidates since NASA’s last data unveiling, including 10 near-Earth-size planet candidates in the so-called habitable zone around their stars where the conditions are just right for liquid water to exist on a planet’s surface — a key feature in the search for habitable worlds.

“The new discoveries boost Kepler’s total to 4,034 candidate planets during its mission, 2,335 of which were later confirmed by follow-up observations, NASA officials said in a statement. The 10 newfound potentially Earth-size worlds bring Kepler’s total up to 50 of that type of exoplanet, with more than 30 of those being confirmed, NASA officials said during a briefing today (June 19).

“The researchers also revealed a surprising divide between small, Earth-like planets and mini-Neptunes gleaned from the data….”

The Kepler telescope isn’t the only one being used to look for exoplanets. But I feel like I’m mentioning Kepler-this and Kepler-that quite often.

There’s at least two reasons for that.

First, I’m an American — which gives me a particular interest in America’s people, issues, and government activities. That includes NASA.

I’m also interested in other space agencies like KARI, JAXA, AEB, UNOOSA. But I don’t think exploration and other activities in space should be a government-only thing.

That’s why I’m glad to see more private-sector outfits like Excalibur Almaz, Planetary Resources, Blue Origin, and SpaceX.

I don’t mind folks finding practical reasons for space exploration. Maybe that’s because I’m an American. Knowing a bit about history helps. And that’s another topic.

Another reason for focusing on Kepler is that it’s been collecting a lot of data.4

My guess is that we haven’t run out of surprises among ‘Kepler’ planets: and will learn even more as we extend the search for new worlds past today’s “frontier.”

About Kepler

By June 22, 2017, we’d found and confirmed 3,497 exoplanets. Don’t bother memorizing that number. It may have changed by the time you read this.

Quite a few of those planets were first spotted by Kepler.

Kepler’s observed 4,496 stars that might host exoplanets before May 11, 2013, a little over four years after launch.

Then the second of the telescope’s four reaction wheels failed. The telescope could hold steady with only three working, but not with two. Most of its equipment should keep working for years, but without stability the telescope wasn’t usable.

Ideally, technicians would repair the worn parts, or replace them. We could do that with the Hubble telescope, since it was in low Earth orbit — and the Shuttles were flying.

Kepler is orbiting the sun a little outside Earth’s orbit, for pretty much the same reasons observatories are built on mountaintops.

By 2013, it was 137,000,000 kilometers, 85,000,000 miles from Earth. Nobody’s developed spacecraft that carry folks that far, which I think is another reason for developing long-range vehicles.

For the time being, however, Kepler is well outside NASA’s service area. Scientists and engineers developed workarounds that let Kepler start its Second Light mission with slightly different goals.

Kepler’s found 391 more candidate exoplanets exoplanets so far.

Not quite 58% of Kepler’s ‘maybe’ planets have been shown to be the real thing.

That’s a little over 28% of the three-thousand-plus confirmed expolanets we’ve found to date. By any reasonable standard, I think that’s a significant contribution.

Being Human

My guess is that folks were wondering how things began long before we started developing information storage tech like pictograms and cuneiform.

That doesn’t bother me, since I accept being curious as part of being human. I’m also quite sure that using our brains doesn’t offend God. I’ll get back to that.

Nobody had wondered how the Solar System formed before 1500.

That’s mainly because up to that point we didn’t realize that Anaximander and Pythagoras were on the right track.

Aristotle had been much more persuasive, and had many overly-enthusiastic fans in Europe. (December 2, 2016 )

We didn’t have data to back up Copernican heliocentrism until well after the idea started giving some folks fits. (June 2, 2017; December 2, 2016)

René Descartes thought the sun and planets might have formed in a vortex. The same sort of folks Copernicus had called babblers didn’t like vortexes either. (April 28, 2017)

You can call more than one vortex vortices. Or you can sidestep the ‘how do I say it’ issue by calling them whirlpools, and that’s another topic.

Rightly or otherwise, Emanuel Swedenborg often gets credit for the first version of the nebular hypothesis. That was in 1734. About 15 years later, Georges-Louis Leclerc said maybe planets formed after a comet hit the sun.

Still Learning

Various folks pointed out that angular momentum and orbital mechanics made nebular and collision scenarious unlikely.

We’ve been learning that nebular and collision hypotheses were both not entirely wrong. They weren’t entirely right, either.

We’re pretty sure that planets and stars start as a sort of nebula, and that planets run into each other fairly often before settling into more-or-less stable orbits. (December 9, 2016)

James Jeans should, I think, get more credit for his work. He was wrong about quite a bit, but his 1917 tidal or near-miss idea made sense at the time.

My high school science textbooks included variations of his near-miss and tidal ideas.

The nebular hypothesis started looking a lot more likely after 1970. We had more data by then, plus work by folks like Otto Schmidt and Andrew Prentice. Getting Victor Safronov’s ideas about accretion disks translated helped.5

I would be astounded, and disappointed, if we now know everything there is to learn about this universe. But I suspect that the nebular hypothesis is a pretty good match to reality. It’ll do until we uncover something better.

Super-Earths, Mini-Neptunes, and More

NASA/Ames Research Center/JPL-Caltech/R. Hurt's 'Assembly Line of Planets' illustration. (June 19, 2017) via NASA, used w/o permission
(From NASA/Ames Research Center/JPL-Caltech/R. Hurt, used w/o permission.)
(“Researchers combining data from the Keck telescope in Hawaii and the Kepler space telescope found that there’s a sharp divide between super-Earths and mini-Neptunes.”
(Space.com))

Scientists figured that planetary systems around other stars, if they existed, would be pretty much like the Solar System. It was a reasonable assumption.

I think it’s likely that we’ll find systems like ours, with rocky planets closer to the star than the big gassy ones. Eventually.

What we’re been finding so far is, I think, much more interesting than ‘more of the same.’

Upsilon Andromedae A’s planetary system is the closest thing to a Solar System analog we’ve spotted so far. One of its planets is close to Jupiter’s mass and about as far away from its star as Jupiter is.

The system isn’t a really close match to ours, though. Two of the three known inner planets, Samh and Majriti, have 10.25 and 13.98 times Jupiter’s mass.

Majriti’s orbit is eccentric, but inside Upsilon Andromedae A’s habitable zone.

If planets that size can have rocky moons — there’s debate about that — one of Majriti’s moons could be habitable.

My guess is that the climate would be somewhat extreme.

But habitable doesn’t mean idyllic. I’m among the humans who ended up living in central Minnesota, and that’s another topic.

There’s another Jupiter-analog planet orbiting HIP 11915. Maybe there are rocky planets closer to that star, maybe not.

An interesting — to me, your experience may vary — detail is that there’s a distinct break between terrestrial planets and the smaller gassy planets.

It looks like if a growing planet gets beyond a specific mass, it’ll keep enough gasses to become a mini-Neptune. Below that mass, it’ll lose the ‘extra’ gas as it heats up.

Still Seeking Another Earth

We’re starting to find planets with about Earth’s mass in other systems.

We’re also finding planets that aren’t like anything in the Solar System. Based on their mass, orbits, and other data, scientists have been sorting them into categories.

Some hot Jupiters may be losing their atmosphere rapidly enough to become chthonian planets before the star runs out of fuel. Then again, maybe not.

COROT-7b, Kepler-78b, and Kepler-10b, may be lava planets: terrestrial planets so close to their sun that they’re covered by molten rock.

Terrestrial doesn’t mean ‘just like Earth.’ In this context it means the planets are mostly rock and metal, like Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars.

Gliese 1214 b, Kepler-22b, and many of the worlds circling Kepler-11, may be ocean planets: worlds with a rocky core and far more water than Earth. That doesn’t necessarily make them habitable, but Kepler-22b might be.

Kepler-438b, is the closest to an Earth-analog that we’ve found so far.

That world orbits a red dwarf a bit more than 470 light-years out in the general direction of Sheliak. It’s more massive than Earth, and gets more sunlight. Or would that be starlight? Kepler-438b isn’t quite quite an ‘Earth twin.’ Cousin, maybe.


Faith Embraces All Truth, or Should

I don’t know why so many folks assume that religion is against science, and that science threatens faith.

Folks who don’t think God exists sometimes say that since the universe follows rational physical laws, a rational Creator can’t exist. I’m over-simplifying the point, a lot.

The ‘knowable physical laws exist, so God doesn’t’ attitude makes sense, almost. As much as many political campaigns, anyway.

What makes considerably less sense to me is why loudly-Christian folks agree.

Much of the sound and fury focuses on evolution, so leftovers from 19th century English politics are probably a factor. (October 28, 2016)

There was almost certainly more going on in the days of Konstantin Pobedonostsev and the Belle Époque. From what folks like Nietzsche said, I get the impression that what passed for Christianity back then didn’t much resemble my faith. (March 31, 2017)

Some still doesn’t, sadly. (March 31, 2017)

Even if I felt like ignoring reality and reason, I couldn’t. Not if I’m going to act like being a Catholic matters.

Faith, we’re told, means embracing “the whole truth that God has revealed,” including what we find in this universe; and using our brains. (“Fides et Ratio;” “Gaudium et Spes,” 36; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 31–32, 142–150, 159, 319)

I’m not sure why so many Christians, some of them Catholics, insist that evolution mustn’t be real. Some of them seem equally devoted to the notion that this universe is no more than a few thousand years old.

That does not, I think, help correct the notion that Christianity’s worldview is more a little myopic.

“A millennium before Europeans were willing to divest themselves of the Biblical idea that the world was a few thousand years old, the Mayans were thinking of millions and the Hindus billions.”
(“Cosmos,” p. 213-214, Carl Sagan, via Wikiquote)

God Thinks Big

Narrow-gauge versions of Christianity may have encouraged some folks around my age to start taking Hindi beliefs seriously, back in the 1960s.

I sympathize, a bit, with those who decided that Christianity couldn’t be right.

I don’t agree with them, but can see their point.

Most of us had grown up in a world where scientists were taken seriously.

Those of us who were paying attention realized that we lived in a universe that’s vast on a literally cosmic scale.

Meanwhile, vehemently-Christian types were attacking what they called Satanic threats. Like evolution, commies, the Catholic Church, and rock music.

Many of them insisted that Christianity depended on unyielding allegiance to the King James Bible and declaring October 23, 4004 BC, as the day of creation.

Hindu beliefs didn’t seem nearly as goofy.

Interestingly some folks say that a day of Brahma, the Hindi creator, endures for about 4,320,000 years.6

That’s a few powers of ten short of Earth’s age, as measured by radioactive decay rates: 4,540,000,000 years, give or take 50,000,000. But it’s a dang sight closer match to reality than the few thousand held to be ‘Biblical’ by loyal disciples of Ussher.

What impresses me, some days, is how many folks didn’t see Christianity as a quaint residue from the 17th or 19th century.

‘Biblical’ Ideas: Including Wisdom 11:22

As a Catholic, and a Christian, I have no problem with thinking that God’s creation is vast. We’ve known that for millennia.

“3 Terrible and awesome are you, stronger than the ancient mountains.”
(Psalms 76:5)

“He sits enthroned above the vault of the earth, and its inhabitants are like grasshoppers; He stretches out the heavens like a veil, spreads them out like a tent to dwell in.”
(Isaiah 40:22)

“3 Raise your eyes to the heavens, and look at the earth below; Though the heavens grow thin like smoke, the earth wears out like a garment and its inhabitants die like flies, My salvation shall remain forever and my justice shall never be dismayed.”
(Isaiah 51:6)

“4 Indeed, before you the whole universe is as a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth.”
(Wisdom 11:22)

As I’ve said before, all that’s been changing is how much we know about how vast it is.

I don’t mind:


1 Exoplanets:

2 Youthful stars and a rogue planet:

3 Learning how planets form:

4 The Kepler observatory:

5 Science, planetary systems, and accepting reality:

6 Senses of scale:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , | 8 Comments

London Fires, Mostly

Many folks who lived in Grenfell Tower got out. Many others died.

We don’t know how many. A current estimate is 79. Determining the exact number will be difficult, since high temperatures may have effectively obliterated some human remains.

Some survived because they didn’t listen to official instructions to stay in their homes. That advice makes sense in a building with sprinklers and adequate interior firewalls.

In Grenfell Tower, not so much.

Emergency responders realized that sheltering in place was a bad idea at some point, and told those still in Grenfell Tower to get out.

Some could, others were trapped.

I’m covering a bit more ground than usual today. The manufacturer of a refrigerator-freezer involved in the fire has product information you may want to check on. That’s under Grenfell Tower Fire’s Point of Origin, below.

Bad as the Grenfell fire was, it could have been much worse: in terms of death, property damage, and how folks are reacting. I think the Great Fire of London in 1666 and the Grenfell Tower disaster are similar in some ways. And very dissimilar in others.

I’ll be talking about how folks are reacting to the Grenfell Tower fire, and a ‘van attack’ in Finsbury Park, another part of London.

This year’s responses to stress are far from ideal, but we are learning.

Links to news and background are at the end of this post.1


Grenfell Tower Fire’s Point of Origin


(From Metropolitan Police, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

It’s small comfort that the Grenfell Tower fire was an accident. Apparently a refrigerator-freezer malfunctioned.

Glitches happen, which is why my household repairs or at least unplugs gadgets that might cause trouble. We also have smoke alarms and a fire extinguisher.

Folks living in apartments don’t necessarily have a choice over how the property and appliances are maintained.

The link in this excerpt works here in central Minnesota, so it’s probably not ‘regional.’ I don’t know if the telephone number is valid outside the UK:

“…What do I do if I have a Hotpoint fridge freezer?”
Kevin Peachey, BBC News (June 23, 2017)

“Anyone who has a white Hotpoint fridge freezer model number FF175BP or graphite fridge freezer model number FF175BG should register their appliance with the manufacturer to receive any updates.

“Generally, the model number is found on a bar code on a sticker behind the salad container in the fridge.

“These models were discontinued in 2009, but 64,000 were sold between March 2006 and July 2009. It is not known how many are still in use.

“Owners should ring 0800 316 3826 or visit the Hotpoint website….”

Why Care?


(City lights in Asia and Australia.)

With all the misery in the world, why am I paying attention to what’s been happening in London? It’s not like I live there.

I’m aware that folks in Syria, the ones who couldn’t escape but are still alive, aren’t having a good time.

Coptic Christians living in Egypt — again, the survivors — have been getting many opportunities for martyrdom this year. Sadly, that’s hardly a new development.

Assorted suicide bombings and other attacks have been killing folks this month. Again, that’s not anything new.

Quite a few of the victims, and perpetrators, were Muslims. Some weren’t.

I could say it’s the Muslims’ fault for not being Christians living in the upper Midwest. That makes about as much sense to me as blaming Christians in Egypt for their troubles.

I could imitate folks who blame Christianity for atrocities like the Verden massacre, Islam for the 9/11 attack, or religion in general for making folks hate each other. That doesn’t make sense either. Not to me. (June 4, 2017; November 15, 2016; November 6, 2016)

I’ll get back to that.


1. Inspections, Evacuation


(From PA, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Council staff have been advising residents”
(BBC News))

“Camden flats: Hundreds of homes evacuated over fire risk fears”
BBC News (June 23, 2017)

“More than 800 homes in tower blocks on a council estate in Camden, north London, have been evacuated because of fire safety concerns.

“Camden Council says people in five towers on the Chalcots estate were moved for ‘urgent fire safety works’.

“The council said it was booking hotels but 100 residents are spending the night on air beds in a leisure centre….”

It’s an inconvenience, at least, for folks who were evacuated. Some apparently didn’t know about the order until they heard about it on the news, and aren’t happy about that.

The timing of this evacuation could probably have been handled better, however.

One of the folks said that the dubious cladding had been in place for about 10 years. The council had met with residents the previous night and reassured them that things were okay. The next day they were evacuated because the building is a fire hazard.

Another resident said that he, his parents, and two sisters were told they had five minutes to get out. It was 8:15 p.m. A neighbor had given them the information.

In their position, I’d be far less than pleased with the situation. On the ‘up’ side, they’re not getting burned alive in their homes.

I don’t know why at least some of the folks got such short notice.

Maybe someone in charge got information that made immediate evacuation necessary: even if it meant rousting folks out in the evening.

Maybe the folks had ignored, not noticed, or forgotten, earlier notices. Maybe the Camden Council isn’t well-organized, or someone didn’t finish the job of spreading the world.

It sounds like getting those folks out and fixing the structure is a good idea.

Besides easy-light kindling on the building’s exterior, officials noticed that insulation around gas pipes going into the apartments was worrisome: and so were the fire doors.

Again, there’s good news. At least architects had specified fire doors for the place.

Maybe this time around the powers that be will take a hard look at materials that actually get installed: and make sure they’re the same sort that was paid for.

It’s starting to look like the Grenfell Tower fire might not have spread as fast, if a contractor had used materials specified in the plans.

If true, there could be criminal charges down the road.

Grenfell Tower and towers on the Chalcots estate weren’t the only ones with questionable materials. As of Saturday this week, 34 tower blocks in 17 council areas have failed fire safety tests. That number has been going up daily.


2. Dead, Missing, and Missed


(From Various, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Some of the victims of the Grenfell Tower fire”
(BBC News))

“London fire: Who are the victims?”
BBC News (June 23, 2017)

“At least 79 people are believed to have died, police say, five days on from the huge fire that engulfed Grenfell Tower in west London….”

Nine victims were formally identified on Monday. Families of four asked that their names be withheld.

Quite a few other folks are missing. Maybe they got out, but were injured and haven’t been able to tell others who they are yet. Maybe they didn’t make it.

What the dead and missing have in common is that they lived in Grenfell Tower. They were retirees, schoolkids, mothers, fathers, friends.

Some had “English” names, like Anthony Disson. I’m guessing it’s an alternative spelling of Dison, a form of the ‘Yorkshire’ name Dyson.

In America it can be what happened to “Theisen” when Danish, German, or Norwegian immigrants wanted to ‘fit in.’ Theissen is the same name, with an extra “s,” in German.

Anthony Disson was a retired truck drive, and had lived at Grenfell Tower for eight years. He called his son at 3:30 that morning.

He’d been told to stay in his 22nd floor apartment. Like I said earlier, that advice makes sense in buildings with the right sort of walls and doors.

His wife, sons and grandchildren, miss him now. That’s what the family said in a statement, and I believe them. He hadn’t met one of the grandkids yet.

Isaac Paulos, 5, had been leaving the burning building with his brother, Luca, 3, and his parents, Genet Shawo and Paulos Petakle.

He and his family got separated on their way out. They survived. He won’t be going back to Saint Francis of Assisi Catholic Primary School. I don’t know where his ancestors lived.

In my country, most folks with the Paulos surname either arrived from Portugal themselves, or are descended from Portuguese immigrants.

Khadija Saye, 24, was an artist and photographer. I don’t know if Ya-Haddy Sisi Saye was her professional name, nickname, or something else. She and her mother, Mary Mendy, were living on the 20th floor. She’s dead, her mother is missing.

Mohammed Alhajali, 23, was a Syrian refugee. He’d arrived in the UK in 2014, and was studying civil engineering. He and his brother Omar had been sharing an apartment. He won’t be studying for any more exams.

Omar Belkadi and Farah Hamdan, and their six-month-old baby, are dead. Their kids, 8 and 10, are alive, but hospitalized.

Abufars Ibrahim, 39, was apparently visiting his mother, Fathia Alsanousi, 72, and sister Esra Ibrahim, 32. He’s dead. They’re missing.

Khadija Khalloufi, 52, is alive. He’s been relocated to an old folks’ home: not his idea, he was forced there. He’s the only person from Grenfell Tower living at the place. But at least he’s alive. His wife, Sabah Abdullah, is dead.

A lot more folks are missing: like Marco Gottardi, architect, and his girlfriend Gloria Trevisan. They were staying with friends at Grenfell.

Sawsan Choucair doesn’t know what happened to the rest of her family: her mother Sirria, sister Nadia, and brother-in-law Bassam are missing; so are Zainab, Fatima, and Mierna, 3, 10, and 13.

Marketing manager Mariem Elgwahry, 27, talked to someone at 2:30 Wednesday morning. She hasn’t been seen since.

Five folks in the Miah family are missing: Husna Begum, 22, her mother Rabiya Begum, father Komru Miah, nearly 90; two brothers, Abdul Hamid and Abdul Hanif, 28 and 25.

The Ancestry.com website says Miah means “Muslim;” and can be a variant of Mian, a Hindi/Punjabi/Urdu name.

The Kidir family is missing, too, all of them: Hashim Kidir, his wife Nura Jamal, and their three children.

So are five folks in the El-Wahabi family: Abdul Aziz, 52, his wife Fouzia, 42, son Yasin, 21, daughter Nur Huda, 15, and youngest son Mehdi, 8.

I think the family of Jessica Urbano Ramirez, 12, described how many are feeling. Her family is “desperate for news about her whereabouts.”

Simple, Not Easy

Most folks where I grew up had Scandinavian, German, or British surnames, the same one their fathers had.

That’s the pattern my name follows.

Some names on the list of dead and missing are British, or at least European.

Many aren’t. Folks in some of the families don’t even have the same surname. They all lived in an another country. Why should I care?

I’m a Catholic, which could explain my sympathy for the Paulos family.

Maybe giving a rip about what happened to folks whose names suggest that they’re Muslims takes the most explanation.

Being Catholic doesn’t guarantee having sensible attitudes. I’ve run into a Catholic who said Protestants aren’t Christian. He may be sincere. I’m sure he’s wrong.

I get the impression that some Catholics are diffident about praying for folks who don’t share our faith. I could be wrong about that, and hope I am. Praying for others is a good idea. All others.

I take what Jesus said seriously, including this:

“But I say to you, love your enemies, and pray for those who persecute you,
“that you may be children of your heavenly Father, for he makes his sun rise on the bad and the good, and causes rain to fall on the just and the unjust.”
(Matthew 5:44–45)

We live in a wounded world, so many folks don’t get along. At all. But praying for others is a must-do, even if we’re not on the same page. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 396–401, 2259, 2303)

So is recognizing the “goodness and truth” in all religions that seek God. That’s particularly true for those whose people worship the God of Abraham. (June 18, 2017)

I talked about family names last month. Some parts of the world follow my culture’s custom of giving children the same surname as their father. Some don’t. (April 2, 2017)

My culture’s habit works, but isn’t among the unchanging principles we call natural law. (February 5, 2017)

The way I see it, I should love God, love my neighbor, and see everyone as my neighbor. Those rules are “the whole law and the prophets.” (Matthew 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Matthew 5:43–44; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 10:25–30; Catechism, 1825)

It’s simple, and anything but easy.

‘Everyone’ means just that. Humanity is one huge family. A sadly-dysfunctional one. (Genesis 10:1–32; Catechism, 360, 396–409)

I’ve been paying particular attention to London because folks there speak a version of my native language, English. That gives me easy access to news from that part of the world.

British culture isn’t quite like American culture. But we’re not all that different, either.

It’s not that I think folks in England are more — or less — important than those living elsewhere. It’s a bit easier for me to understand what’s going on in London than events in, say, Singapore or Guangzhou.

Besides, I think news from London shows how much can change in three and a half centuries — and how little humans have changed.

Great Fire of London, 1666

The mid-1660s weren’t a good time to live in London. About one out of four Londoners died in the 1665 plague.

Survivors either couldn’t afford to live anywhere else, or were wealthy enough to afford residences west of Charing Cross. The city was picturesque, an organically-grown jumble of flammable buildings.

A bit after midnight on Sunday, September 2, 1666, a fire started in a bakery on London’s Pudding Lane.

It’s not an exact parallel to the Grenfill Tower disaster, but it’s close: one fire, in one building, starting around midnight.

Fire suppression tech being what it was at the time, surrounding structures should have been torn down; creating a firebreak.

Folks who owned and lived in those buildings objected to having their homes torn down. That’s understandable.

London’s Lord Mayor was the only person with authority to order the demolition. He didn’t give the order until Sunday night.

Maybe he kept hoping the fire would burn itself out. Maybe he didn’t want the negative publicity demolition might cause. Or maybe nobody called him. Whatever the reason or reasons, by the time he did give the order — it was too late.

Winds drove the fire westward. The firestorm eventually spread north. Several days later, the Tower of London garrison blasted firebreaks ahead of the flames.

Death Toll: Unknown

Buildings around the bakery in Pudding Lane were long since gone by then.

So were about 13,200 more houses, 87 parish churches, St Paul’s Cathedral, and most of the city government buildings.

But many of the newly-cleared firebreaks held. Fires eventually ran out of fuel, and went out. The wind had finally calmed, which helped.

Only six folks died, officially. The actual death toll is unknown. Quite a few folks who would have been caught by the fire weren’t among the gentry, and so may not have been missed. Officially.

There’s evidence that temperatures reached well upwards of 1250 °C. Bodies would have been cremated, making an accurate death toll a matter of speculation. A recent estimate ran from several hundred to several thousand.

In fairness, survivors who were wealthy didn’t keep much more than their lower-class counterparts.

Efforts that Monday to keep the upscale parts of London from being incinerated were as ineffective as those elsewhere.

I gather that the firestorm had Londoners rather badly rattled. The Second Anglo-Dutch War was in progress, with all-too-predictable rumors of imminent invasion and/or foreign saboteurs.

This was before live video news, cell phones, and online media. Folks in England relied on newspapers to keep them up to date.

The London Gazette got their Monday edition out just before their printers went up. For many folks, all they knew was that London was burning.

These days, it’d be a bit like Americans tuning in to the news, hearing that New York City was in flames — followed by a burst of static and then nothing.

That doesn’t excuse the occasional lynching.

A local militia, the Trained Bands, and the Coldstream Guards, might have helped more with firefighting. But they were mostly rounding up Catholics, foreigners, and other odd-looking folks; or rescuing them from mobs. Sometimes both.

Popish Plot and a Playing Card

The Second Anglo-Dutch War was one of many post-Renaissance wars in Europe. It ran from March 1665 to July 1667, one of four in that series.

It’s nowhere near as famous as the Thirty Years’ War. That one ran out of cannon fodder in 1648.

The Anglo-Dutch wars happened because England’s leaders wanted a piece of the action in world trade.

Dutch leaders objected. They won the second A-D War, after only a bit more than 12,000 folks got killed.

It wasn’t a particularly “holy” war, but that didn’t stop propaganda from playing up the religious angle.

English folks who didn’t approve of pro-Catholic Charles II’s court said Catholics started the Great Fire.

Meanwhile in the Netherlands, other folks said the Great Fire was divine retribution for a Dutch town getting torched by the English.

Aside from the vocabulary, it’s pretty much the same thing I see in my Twitter feed. From both/all sides of American politics. Like I said, humans haven’t changed all that much.

London’s Court of Aldermen had an inscription added to the Monument to the Great Fire of London in 1681.

A loose translation reads: “Here by permission of heaven, hell broke loose upon this Protestant city…..the most dreadful Burning of this City; begun and carried on by the treachery and malice of the Popish faction…Popish frenzy which wrought such horrors, is not yet quenched….”

Kickoff for the Nine Years’ War was a few years away at that point. The inscription’s patriotic sentiment may have been meant to keep Aldermen from getting accused of involvement in the Popish Plot.

If that was their motive, I think it was understandable. Before the Popish Plot ran its course, 22 men had been executed for their alleged complicity.

Then someone started looking at the data.

The “Popish Plot” turned out to be fictional. Academics still aren’t sure whether or not folks accused by Titus Oates were chosen randomly.

When the dust settled, Oates was fined £100,000 and imprisoned: a life sentence. By the time he died he’d been an Anglican and a Catholic, spent a few years behind bars, been whipped, pardoned, released: and eventually forgotten by all but a few history buffs.

He did, however, have his very own playing card during his heyday.

The Monument’s ‘Popish Plot’ text was removed in 1830.2

Yellow Peril

I’d like to say that folks, Europeans at least, had finally achieved full enlightenment by the mid-19th century: putting aside all hatred and prejudice.

Instead, we got the yellow peril, World Wars I and II, and — in America — McCarthyism. As I keep saying, I don’t miss the ‘good old days.’3

“Yellow peril” as a distinct cultural issue didn’t get traction until the 19th century. I suspect the roots are much deeper.

I’m a bit more familiar with American “yellow peril” blunders, like Executive Order 9066. We didn’t start token efforts at correcting that injustice for far too long, and that’s another topic.

Folks from China who moved to Australia, Canada, the U.S., and New Zealand, worked harder for less pay than their more-settled neighbors. Human nature being what it is, some Australians, Canadians, and so forth, saw them as a threat.

Again, I see the same song playing in today’s social media: with a new ‘foreign threat’ and the same unreasoned fears.

No legislation will eradicate fears, prejudices, and selfishness. That doesn’t make them good ideas. (Catechism, 1931)


3. Meanwhile, in Finsbury Park —


(From Getty Images, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“A vigil was held outside Finsbury Park Mosque”
(BBC News))

“Finsbury Park suspect Darren Osborne’s family ‘in shock’”
BBC News (June 19, 2017)

“The family of a man arrested after a terror attack near a north London mosque say they are ‘shocked’ and ‘devastated’.

“Father-of-four Darren Osborne was held after a van hit Muslims after evening prayers in Finsbury Park.

“They had been helping a man who had collapsed. He later died but it is not clear if it was because of the attack.

“Mr Osborne, 47, was held on suspicion of attempted murder and later further arrested over alleged terror offences….”

I don’t know what was going on in Darren Osborne’s head. He apparently was upset about an incident on London Bridge earlier this month. That’s understandable.

His sister said he’d tried to kill himself a few weeks earlier, and tried to get himself committed in a psychiatric hospital. They hadn’t accepted him. She also said he was taking antidepressants.

That may help explain why he decided to rent a van and run down those folks. But it’s not an excuse.

I’m pretty sure that there’s more to his actions than depression. I’ll admit a bias, since I’ve been taking antidepressants and other prescriptions to keep my glitchy neurochemistry working. (March 19, 2017; October 14, 2016)

Mr. Osborne is in serious legal trouble now, as he should be.

Deliberately killing innocent people is a bad idea. So is holding on to anger and hatred. (Matthew 5:22; Catechism, 2262, 2269)


4. Freedom and Racial Hatred


(From BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“Finsbury Park attack: Theresa May condemns ‘sickening’ terror attack”
BBC News (June 19, 2017)

“A terror attack near a London mosque is ‘every bit as sickening’ as others in recent weeks, Theresa May says.

“A man drove a van into worshippers close to Muslim Welfare House in Finsbury Park as they were gathered to help an elderly man who had collapsed.

“He later died, but it is not clear if this was a result of the attack. Nine other people were taken to hospital….”

I’ve seen complaints that British authorities were a bit slower to identify this incident as a ‘terror attack.’ I don’t know enough to have an informed opinion about that.

We’ve got more than enough uninformed opinions flying around, so I’ll leave it at that.

As I said before, deliberately holding on to anger and hatred is a bad idea.

That’s probably what got Richard Evans in trouble over a social media post. His father’s an owner of the company that owned the van Mr. Osborne used.

South Wales police say the younger Mr. Evans posted “It’s my dad’s company I don’t get involved it’s a shame they don’t hire out steam rollers or tanks could have done a tidy job then.”

BBC News says that his father has condemned what his son allegedly wrote, and that he doesn’t agree with the sentiment.

Now Richard Evans is “being held on suspicion of displaying threatening, abusive, insulting written material with intent that is likely to stir up racial hatred:”

I share my country’s traditional high regard for freedom of expression. On the other hand, I think that was a profoundly daft thing to write.


5. Solidarity in Finsbury


(From Reuters, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Faith leaders from the area met near the scene of the attack”
(BBC News))

“Finsbury Park attack: Horror and sympathy among locals”
Cherry Wilson, BBC News (June 19, 2017)

“Two large police vans are parked just metres away from a large poster emblazoned with some of Arsenal’s most famous stars which stands by the club’s shop.

“Locals say this is a proudly multicultural area where the biggest rivalry is whether you support Arsenal or their north London rivals Tottenham.

“…Mum of four Nicola Senior, 43, is walking back from taking her children to school when she stops to take in the scene.

“She said: ‘I’m frightened. Is there going to be retaliation?

“‘I am fearful for my kids. Can we go to the park? Can we go to the church?

“‘It feels like this is happening all the time.

“‘For me, people want to live here quietly whatever their religion.

“‘This is such a mixed area. There are so many nationalities. People get on. They accept and respect each other.

“‘People are in shock. It affects everybody. I’m worried for the safety of all of us.’…

“…Nasser Alyarimi, 18, knows people who worship at the mosque close to where the tragedy took place.

“He said: “There’s been lots of incidents taking place. Someone I know was thrown down the stairs and had beer poured over her headscarf just because she is Muslim….'”

“…They talk about reaction to the incident and question why it was not widely reported as a terror attack much earlier.

“One friend, who asked not to be named, said: ‘I’m really upset. I feel let down by the government that we are being portrayed as savages that we are not.

“‘They’ve portrayed us as if we walk around killing infidels. Just because one or two people believe that it doesn’t mean the whole Muslim community does.’

“Many locals point to the streets and the various ethnicities of people walking around as an indication of the diverse make-up of this area….

“…Mendy Korer, Rabbi of Islington, says: ‘This is a great community to live in. There’s so many different types of nationalities and faith groups. We all understand each other….'”

I don’t know why Mr. Osborne drove all the way to Finsbury for his attack on a mosque. The Bristol Jamia Mosque was closer, and the largest in England’s southwest.

I don’t think it’s because the Arsenal Football Club’s home field is called Emirates Stadium. It used to be the Ashburton Grove, but got renamed when Emirates airline sponsored renovation work. And that’s yet another topic.

Three and a half centuries after the Great London Fire and Popish Plot, some folks still fear new neighbors. Some politicos still make outrageous accusations against their counterparts in the other party.

But I think for every Mr. Osborne and Richard Evans, there are many Nicola Seniors, Nasser Alyarimis, and Mendy Korers.

We seem to be learning that humans act like humans, no matter where our ancestors lived or how we worship. Or don’t worship, for that matter. I think that’s a step toward wisdom.


Scary Questions at the Family Get-Together


(From Reuters, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Faith leaders from the area met near the scene of the attack”
(BBC News))

“Eid: How to handle the tough questions at family gatherings”
BBC News (June 23, 2017)

“The holy Islamic fasting month of Ramadan is coming to an end this weekend. For many Muslims around the world, it’s the one time of the year that they return to their hometowns and gather with their extended family for a catch-up and feast.

“But as Christine Franciska of the BBC’s Indonesian Service explains, for many young people, Eid al-Fitr’s family gatherings are not as pleasant as they seem.

“It’s the time when aunties, uncles, and older relatives who you rarely see ask you ‘scary questions’.

“‘Who’s your boyfriend (or girlfriend) now?’ ‘When are you getting married?’ ‘Why are you looking a bit…fat?’

“‘It is not comfortable at all,’ said Indonesian Mochamad Fadly Anwar on Facebook. ‘And I think it crosses the line. I am like, hey mind your own business.’

“‘Those questions are legendary…’ said another user….”

“Legendary,” indeed. And, I strongly suspect, part of the common human experience: apart from differences in language.

In American culture, Thanksgiving is often a ‘family’ holiday. One branch of my wife’s extended family has big get-together in the summer. There’s a lot of them, so they rent a park in a nearby town.

I generally don’t ask the “legendary” questions. It’s not that I’m above that sort of thing. I’ll get the information in good time, from another family member.

I have, however, occasionally asked my kids “so, when are you going to make me an ancestor?” And that’s yet again another topic.

Had enough of my opinions? If not, here are more:


1 London, 2017:

2 London, 1666-1830:

3 Yellow Peril and getting a grip:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 6 Comments