Jesus, the Ultimate Alpha: a Personal View

I was a Christian long before I became a Catholic Christian, and that’s another topic. Topics. The point is, I’ve been trying to follow Jesus ever since I was a child.

Somewhere along the line, I started noticing a disconnect between what I occasionally, not always, saw in religious art and the Jesus I was reading about in the Bible.

'Christ Walking on the Sea,' Nathaniel Currier (19th century); from Springfield Museums, used w/o permission.Looks like I wasn’t the only one.

“…The distance between these alarming and operative realities and the memory, say, of fat Mrs. Dimble saying her prayers, was too wide. … On the one hand, terror of dreams, … the tingling light and sound from under the Director’s door, and the great struggle against an imminent danger; on the other … horrible lithographs of the Saviour (apparently seven feet high, with the face of a consumptive girl) ….”
(“That Hideous Strength,” Chapter Eleven | Battle Begun, C. S. Lewis (1945) via fadedpage.com [emphasis mine])

The aesthetic quality of Jesus junk — I’ll save that for another day.

I don’t know when, where or why Western artists started equating ‘spiritual’ with a limply languid posture.

Snapshots

'Jesus Cleanses the Temple,' Otto Elliger. (1700) from Pitts Theological Library, Candler School of Theology, Emory University, Atlanta (Georgia); used w/o permission.

I’m less uncertain about why I’ve seen an incident recorded in all four Gospels (Matthew 21, Mark 11, Luke 19 and John 2) called the “temple tantrum.”

A ‘Christianity Lite’ version of Jesus is all about peace, love and passivity. Which, I’ll grant, feels better than the old-school ‘fire and brimstone’ judge of commies and hippies.

But I think both miss important aspects of our Lord’s character.

At any rate, I’ve got snapshots like these bits of Luke’s Gospel to deal with.

“When the people in the synagogue heard this, they were all filled with fury. They rose up, drove him out of the town, and led him to the brow of the hill on which their town had been built, to hurl him down headlong. But he passed through the midst of them and went away.”
(Luke 4:28–30)

“Then Jesus entered the temple area and proceeded to drive out those who were selling things, saying to them, ‘It is written, “My house shall be a house of prayer, but you have made it a den of thieves.”‘”
(Luke 19:45–46)

Since Nazareth was our Lord’s home town, I could imagine the close shave in Luke 4 as either showing a helpless nebbish being saved from his psychotic neighbors by a miraculous intervention — or something else. I’ll get back to “something else.”

The cleansing of the Temple account isn’t quite as ambiguous. Although I think a reader’s prior assumptions matter.

Questions and Definitions

'Jesus Brought Before Pilate,' William Brassey Hole. (ca. 1890)Starting with a ‘Jesus Christ, flower child’ model, that “den of thieves” outburst sounds like a dedicated passivist’s — that’s not a typo — collision with equally-dedicated disciples of avarice.

Passivist? Pacifist? Not quite the same thing.

  • Oxford Dictionary on Lexico.com
    • pacifist
      “A person who believes that war and violence are unjustifiable.”
    • passivist
      (2) “Characterized by the habit or practice of being passive, accepting, or non-resistant.”

I figure that Jesus is no fool, knows what to expect from us, and isn’t shocked when people act like humans. Which reminds me of another close shave.

“Jesus said to them, ‘Amen, amen, I say to you, before Abraham came to be, I AM.’
So they picked up stones to throw at him; but Jesus hid and went out of the temple area.”
(John 8:58–59)

Clarifying that “I AM” remark, Jesus was quoting Scripture and saying “I am God.”1 No wonder folks in the Temple area freaked. They knew Scripture, too; and likely knew what happened after attempted deity-level identity theft.

So — how come folks in Nazareth didn’t hurl Jesus down that hill? And what kept him alive after that “I AM” incident?

Maybe Jesus was a lucky nebbish.

Or, my opinion, Jesus of Nazareth really was and is “I AM.”

That still leaves unanswered questions.

Miracles?

'Transfiguration of Jesus,' Carl Bloch. (1872)Both close shaves could be blatant miracles. Maybe Jesus “passed through the midst of them” by becoming incorporeal, and “went out of the temple area” the same way.

Or maybe Jesus has what my culture calls “charisma” — personal charm, in this case cranked up to “God” level.

If I focus on the “God” level aspect of our Lord’s charisma, then that’s a miracle.

Or I could decide that since we’ve all got charisma, Jesus is simply an extreme example. I figure it depends at least partly on which definitions are in play.

“MIRACLE: A sign or wonder, such as a healing or the control of nature, which can only be attributed to divine power. The miracles of Jesus were messianic signs of the presence of God’s kingdom (547).”
(Glossary, Catechism)

Or maybe all the times when folks didn’t notice that they were talking with the Son of God were miracles. And that’s yet another topic.

Fig Failure?

Foliage and fruit, C. J. Trew. (1771)Then there’s the time Jesus cursed a fig tree for lacking figs.

“When he was going back to the city in the morning, he was hungry.
Seeing a fig tree by the road, he went over to it, but found nothing on it except leaves. And he said to it, ‘May no fruit ever come from you again.’ And immediately the fig tree withered.
When the disciples saw this, they were amazed and said, ‘How was it that the fig tree withered immediately?’
Jesus said to them in reply, ‘Amen, I say to you, if you have faith and do not waver, not only will you do what has been done to the fig tree, but even if you say to this mountain, “Be lifted up and thrown into the sea,” it will be done.
Whatever you ask for in prayer with faith, you will receive.'”
(Matthew 21:18–22)

As a child, the fig tree’s fate didn’t bother me nearly as much as the bit about unwavering faith and throwing a mountain.

Decades later, taking a line through various oddball notions, I can imagine someone saying that Christianity’s a fraud because faith-based mountain pitching is stupid.

Or, coming from another direction, I can picture some crackpot’s followers insisting that they’ve moved mountains from Elk Ridge to Pikes Peak. And nobody noticed because Monsanto put tracking cookies in our burgers and fries.

Options

Gutenberg Bible, Lenox Copy, New York Public Library. (2009)I could even try founding my own ‘First Church of the Holy Mountain Flingers.’ But I won’t.

That sort of trouble I don’t need.

Making up my own version of what the Bible ‘really’ means is an option.

But not if I’m going to be a Catholic.

Reading and understanding the Bible matters. So does accepting the authority Jesus gave Peter, and paying attention to what some of the world’s best minds have been saying for the last few millennia.

If I felt that I was smarter and wiser than Saints Catherine of Siena, Thomas Aquinas, and Augustine of Hippo, that’d be a problem. But I don’t.

I’m also okay with God being God and me being me. And that’s yet again another topic. Almost.

I’m forgetting something. Let me think. Ghastly lithographs. Perceptions and a den of thieves. A fig tree. Right.

Cursing a fig tree because it’s fig-free seems petty. Or scary. Or both.

Either way, the disciples asked Jesus about the tree’s demise. Since our Lord answered by talking about faith, prayer, trees and mountains — I’ll assume he was making a point about faith and prayer. And using trees and mountains as figures of speech.2

Human on His Mother’s Side

'Crucifixion,' detail, Jacopo Tintoretto. (1565)Remembering that Jesus is humble makes sense. As long as “humble” isn’t taken to mean “delusional” or “self-degrading.”

I have no problem with thinking that it took great humility for Jesus to become “true God and true man.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 464-478)

“Who, though he was in the form of God,
did not regard equality with God something to be grasped.
Rather, he emptied himself,
taking the form of a slave,
coming in human likeness;
and found human in appearance,
he humbled himself,
becoming obedient to death, even death on a cross.”
(Philippians 2:6–8)

“…We believe in one Lord, Jesus Christ,
the only Son of God,
eternally begotten of the Father,
God from God, Light from Light,
true God from true God,
begotten, not made,
one in Being with the Father.
Through him all things were made….
…by the power of the Holy Spirit
he was born of the Virgin Mary,
and became man….”
(Catechism, Credo Chart (The Nicene Creed))

I also think Jesus really, physically, suffered and died on Golgotha.

If I thought Jesus was just some guy who’d been given a “son of God” badge, maybe I’d see him as among history’s outstanding teachers. Who was also delusional, since he said he was God; which would make him a lunatic, not an ‘outstanding teacher.’

And that’s still another topic. Topics.

But I think Jesus is human on his mother’s side.

And that Jesus was humiliated, tortured, executed and buried.

But that’s not why I’m following him. Not the whole reason, at any rate.

Many folks have been humiliated, tortured and killed. Some, like Jesus, knew what they’d be suffering; and willingly accepted their messy deaths. Admiring them may make sense. Worshiping them? Not so much.

Following the Man Who Didn’t Stay Dead

'The Resurrection of Jesus Christ,' Piero della Francesca. (1463)

Lots of folks admire someone who’s above average, who’s done something remarkable.

Some of us even try to be like our hero, maybe even join the team. Or company. Or society. Psychologists occasionally call these dominant folks “alphas.”

A few of us owe our lives to someone who died while saving us.

I follow Jesus the Nazorean, the man who said ‘I am God,’ was nailed to a cross, and left there until he died.

Then, a few days later, Jesus stopped being dead. That’s, putting it mildly, remarkable.

The Best News Ever

'Supper at Emmaus,' Matthias Stom. (17th century)The surviving Apostles were, eventually, convinced that Jesus wasn’t a ghost.

Then they started telling anyone who’d listen what had happened.

Some of us thought it was the best news humanity’s ever had.

Others — well, John is the only one who died of natural causes.

I’d prefer skipping opportunities to choose between renouncing Jesus and a painful death.

But I follow the man who is God, who was killed on a mission that made God’s kingdom — and family — open to each of us, and who didn’t stay dead.

Heroes just don’t get more “alpha” than that.

I’ve talked about this before, and probably will again:


1 A profoundly non-comprehensive look at Jesus, God and the Trinity:

2 A non-comprehensive look at prayer and why Sacred Scripture matters:

  • Catechism of the Catholic Church (online flipbook via USCCB.org/United States Conference of Catholic Bishops)
    • The Transmission of Divine Revelation 74–94
    • Sacred Scripture 101-133
    • What Is Prayer? 2559-2565
    • The Way of Prayer 2663-2679
    • The Battle of Prayer 2725-2745
    • And see Index; P, Prayer; S, Sacred Scripture
Posted in Being Catholic, Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Holy Week: Top of the Charts to Lethal Fiasco

It’s the start of Holy Week, almost the end of Lent.

And it’s the 219th anniversary of Heinrich Wilhelm Matthäus Olbers spotting 2 Pallas, an asteroid. But that’s not what I’m talking about today.

Today’s Palm Sunday. That’s when we remember our Lord’s entering Jerusalem in the first century equivalent of a ticker tape parade.

Ecce homo.Jesus was top of the charts, wildly popular.

Grass roots opinion, apparently, was that they finally had their messianic king.

Jesus looked like someone who’d finally end the Roman occupation.

The powers that be had the same idea, which scared them.

If this Jesus person, they figured, says ‘I’m the king,’ then we’ll be out of a job. After that, the Roman governor will send in troops and we’ll lose everything else.

So they arrested Jesus, tried and convicted him in a kangaroo court and pressured the Roman governor to enforce the death penalty.

Jesus: tortured, then killed.Then after a really bad night, our Lord was nailed to a cross and died.

One Apostle committed suicide.

The rest were keeping a low profile.

Assuming that our Lord was the national hero folks had been expecting, that first Holy Week and Good Friday ended in a fiasco.

Two millennia later, we’re still celebrating. That sounds crazy, at best.

But it’s not.

A few days after his messy death, Jesus stopped being dead. And that’s another topic.

Posted in Being Catholic, Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Minnesota in the Springtime: And Loving It

That’s what my webcam saw on the afternoon of April 13, 2018.

That’s not a typo. It was April, and we had snow on the ground.

That was then, this is now. We’ve got a little snow in sheltered and shady places, and still-brown grass elsewhere.

Along with the usual concrete and and asphalt. We do have paved roads up here, and that’s almost another topic.

I spent a few minutes this afternoon sitting on the front stoop, with a John Dickson Carr mystery. Today’s the official start of spring, it wasn’t quite too cool and windy, and I enjoy my time there.

Fire Weather and Snow in the Forecast

But this is Minnesota. Within a hundred miles of my town, neighbors are and will be experiencing “fire weather conditions,” followed by snow.

“Hazardous Weather Outlook
National Weather Service Twin Cities/Chanhassen MN
439 AM CDT Sat Mar 20 2021

“…This Hazardous Weather Outlook is for portions of central and
southern Minnesota, and west central Wisconsin.

“.DAY ONE…Today and Tonight….

“…Elevated fire weather conditions are expected today across parts of central and east central Minnesota and western Wisconsin as in addition to the winds, afternoon relative humidities will fall to between 20 and 35 percent.

“.DAYS TWO THROUGH SEVEN…Sunday through Friday.

Accumulating snow is possible across a portion of the area from Tuesday into Wednesday. There is significant uncertainty at this time, but there is some potential for plowable snow from west central into central Minnesota from Tuesday into Wednesday as a storm system tracks across the region….

“…SKYWARN spotter activation will not be needed.”
(Watches, Warnings & Advisories, Sauk Centre Municipal Airport (KD39), National Weather Service (March 20, 2021))

As the Weather Service said, our spotters needn’t be ready for deployment. This is Minnesota. It’s the first weekend in spring, so keeping an eye out for fire, rain and snow is par for the course.

Minnesota’s weather is many things, but boring it’s not. I love it here:

Posted in Journal | Tagged , | 2 Comments

Atlanta Spa Shootings: Remembering Dignity

EPA's photo: 'Two of the spas were across the road from each other in Atlanta.' From BBC News article, 'Atlanta shootings: Suspect charged with murder as victims identified' (March 18, 2021) used w/o permission.

Eight people didn’t go home Tuesday.

Someone attacked at least five folks at Young’s Asian Massage in Acworth, Georgia, an Atlanta suburb. Two were dead when police arrived. Another two died in a hospital. A fifth victim is still alive, but wounded.

Police found three more bodies at the Gold Spa in northeast Atlanta. They found another at the Aromatherapy Spa, across the street.

Six of the eight victims are Asian women. A couple guys died, too.

Atlanta-area law enforcement identified and caught a suspect.

That was Tuesday.

News and op-eds seem to have reached a consensus:

First Assumption: Hate Crime

I think my echo chamber is broken.

Instead of seeing nothing but affirmation of my darkest beliefs, I’m seeing several different versions of what ‘really’ happened in Atlanta.

I also saw a social media service’s announcement: warning undesirables that they were not welcome.

Posted by staff on Tumblr
(March 17, 2021)
“The events that unfolded over the past 24 hours in Atlanta were not isolated incidents. Hate crimes against Asian Americans have increased nearly 150% in the US in the last year.
“Last June, in the wake up of yet another uprising in hate crimes committed by white supremacists, we released the following statement:
“White supremacists, Nazis, and other purveyors of hate can [redacted]. They are not welcome here….
“…To help the survivors and families of yesterday’s hate crimes, please consider donating to a nonprofit like [redacted]….”

I redacted Tumblr’s directive to their undesirables because I don’t like abusive language.

The nonprofit recommended by Tumblr staff may or may not be legitimate. I don’t know, I haven’t researched it.

Helping folks who are hurting seems like a good idea. So does doing due diligence before giving to a nonprofit, and that’s another topic.

As for saying who they didn’t want sullying their establishment, I see their point. “Purveyors of hate” don’t make pleasant company. Deciding where ‘freedom of expression’ ends and ‘hate speech’ begins is an ongoing discussion.

Second Assumption: False Flag

Coming from another direction in my social media feed was speculation that the Atlanta killings were a “false flag” operation.

It’s a nifty idea.

As presented, malevolent masterminds had arranged the killings: as part of their plot to persecute American gun owners.

As I said, it’s a nifty idea. And plays into ‘we gotta have more gun control laws’ headlines.

But, nifty or not, I don’t think it’s true. I’m also quite sure that I’ll be seeing more ‘anti-Asian hate crime’ and ‘gun control false flag’ assertions.

And, unless this mass murder’s allure fizzles, assorted other unlikely claims.

For example — and I emphatically do not think this is true, or even plausible — maybe the killings are a Baptist plot, intended to stamp out dens of iniquity.

Seriously: I do not believe this. Although there’s a tiny bit of truth in the nutty notion. I’ll get back to that.

Close Encounters of the Conspiracy Kind

'At the Sign of the UNHOLY THREE' cartoon, warning against fluoridated water, polio serum and mental hygiene. And 'communistic world government.' (1955)I’m not immune to conspiracy theories.

Certainly not from the viewpoint of folks who say religious beliefs are a conspiracy theory. And that’s yet another topic.

But I’m human, so in principle I could start believing that shape-shifting space-alien lizard-men are controlling my brain with radio waves from invisible helicopters.

Or that the Illuminati are putting identity chips in COVID-19 vaccines.

Or that gun control advocates and/or Baptists ordered the Atlanta killings.

But I’ve learned to have a rather high threshold for taking such things seriously. Apart from the effect they have on believers and folks who encounter believers.

That attitude comes in part from living through a half-century-plus of conspiracy buff encounters. And having read a statistical analysis of (real) conspiracies, yielding estimates on how long a given conspiracy might remain secret.1

Motive?

H. Strickland Constable's illustration of 'low types,' left and right; and his preferred 'Anglo-Teutonic' sort. (1899)I figure the ‘Baptist plot’ notion wouldn’t get traction in more than maybe a few overcaffeinated subcultures. Even though the suspect seems to have been very, maybe excessively, ‘religious.’

On the other hand, I’ve braced myself for screed in my social media feeds, coming from zealots on America’s two major screwball political extremes.

In my considered opinion, I don’t know nearly enough to have a reasoned opinion regarding why eight people were killed in Atlanta.

Or why a Cherokee County sheriff’s spokesman spoke two regrettable words. And whether that blunder will end his career.

The suspect has said that his motive isn’t racial. Maybe that’s true. But his assertion that sexual addiction was involved doesn’t seem to play well in mainstream news and views. Oddly enough, he seems to really have had rehabilitation for that problem.

“What we know about Robert Aaron Long, the suspect in Atlanta spa shootings“
Eliott C. McLaughlin, Casey Tolan and Amanda Watts, CNN (March 18, 2021)

“…Tyler Bayless said he shared a housing unit with Long at Maverick Recovery, a rehab facility in Roswell, Georgia, between August 2019 and January or February 2020. He said that most residents were suffering from drug or alcohol addiction, but Long was being treated for sex addiction….”

My view is that the killer’s motive doesn’t matter; apart from psychiatric and judicial concerns.

The main point is that killing those folks was a bad idea. And nobody should have done it.

Next Stop: Florida?

'The Yellow Terror in all His Glory.' Artist and publication not known. (ca. 1899)On the ‘up’ side, this could have been worse.

For starters, America’s news media isn’t playing up the ‘yellow peril’ angle.2

And the suspect was apparently on his way to Florida, intending to stamp out porn.

I’m very glad he was stopped.

Now that I think of it, the ‘massage parlor/spa’ angle, the suspect’s religious enthusiasm, and what looks like his plan to attack “a hub for the pron industry” could support a ‘Baptist plot’ conspiracy theory.

But I still that a ‘Baptist plot’ scenario is as unlikely as the ‘gun control false flag’ notion.

Which reminds me. A fair number of folks assume that “massage parlor” means “brothel.” I won’t argue that prostitution is a sideline for some massage parlors. But these three places apparently offer massages. Period.

‘What might have happened’ speculation aside, part of the ‘up’ side is that the suspect’s parents helped stop their son from making an appalling situation worse.

“…Baker said [suspect] Long viewed Florida as a hub for the porn industry and ‘an outlet for something he shouldn’t be doing,’ Baker said. The Atlanta area spas were ‘temptations to him he wanted to eliminate,’…
“…Long’s parents contacted the Cherokee sheriff’s office to identify their son. They also informed deputies that a tracking device could lead authorities to his vehicle, a Hyundai Tucson. Cherokee sheriff’s spokesman Jay Baker said he didn’t know why Long was being tracked, or if he was aware of it.
“They do know that, without the GPS tracker, and his parents’ cooperation, Long, accused of fatally shooting eight people Tuesday at three metro Atlanta massage parlors, would not have been apprehended so quickly….”
(“Spa shooting suspect’s parents helped authorities catch him,” Christian Boone, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution (March 17, 2021))

Maybe a few clarifications are in order. Maybe not. Either way, here they are.

Love, Respect: and Really Bad Ideas

Rembrandt's 'Christ and the woman taken in adultery' drawing. (ca. 1639-41)I think eight people should not have been killed last Tuesday.

I would think that whether they had been Asian, European, prostitutes or news anchors.

But I think prostitution and pornography, monetizing sex, are bad ideas.

All of us, each of us, has and deserves dignity. Treating someone as a marketable object isn’t dignified. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 356, 1700, 1929, 2354–2355)

I think human life is precious, sacred. Killing an innocent person is a bad idea. Killing a not-so-innocent person isn’t a particularly good idea, either. (Catechism, 2258–2279)

We’re not all alike. We’re not supposed to be. Respecting each other is a good idea. Maintaining sinful inequalities isn’t. (Catechism, 1934–1942)

Finally, all that ‘respect and life’ belief should be obvious — considering the two rules behind “the whole law and the prophets.” I should love God. I should love my neighbor. And see everyone as my neighbor. No exceptions. Everyone. (Matthew 5:43–44, 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Luke 10:25–37; Catechism, 1706, 1776, 1825, 1849–1851, 1955)

I said that a couple days back.

And I’ve talked about life, death, love and acting like people matter fairly often:


1 Conspiracies happen, and get discovered:

2 This isn’t, happily, the ‘good old days:

Posted in Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Happy Saint Patrick’s Day!

The day being what it is, I thought sharing a bit of a prayer called St. Patrick’s Breastplate might be in order.

“…Christ with me, Christ before me,
Christ behind me, Christ within me,
Christ beneath me, Christ above me,
Christ at my right, Christ at my left…..”
(St. Patrick’s Breastplate, a Todd & Stokes edit and translation (1964-1888), via Wikipedia)

Seems that the prayer, it’s a long one, comes from a complete copy written in the 11th century. And maybe dating from the ninth century. Or maybe the eighth. So maybe it’s not from St. Patrick. But ‘Saint Patrick’s Breastplate’ is what we’ve been calling it.

Today, of course, being Saint Patrick’s Day. A feast day no longer on the official liturgical calendar, but remembered nonetheless.

And, as up to now this has been a somewhat serious day for me — which did not restrain me from wearing green, I will have you know ‐ I’ll close with a ‘Happy Saint Patrick’s Day’ to you.

And, as seems inevitable, a link:

Posted in Journal | Tagged , , | 4 Comments