Floyd/Chauvin Trial, Taser Trouble and Irksome Issues

On Tuesday, April 20, 2021, a jury said that Derek Chauvin murdered George Floyd.

Folks have been reacting to that.

But protestors haven’t torched Minneapolis shops and services in the three days since then. Not as far as I know.

Which is a relief, but not a surprise. For one thing, it’s late April: still a bit too chilly for comfort during pyromaniac performance art’s prime time.

I’ll be taking a quick look at headlines. Then I’ll talk about life, law, justice and why I think murder is a bad idea.


Headlines


(From Harper’s Weekly, via Chicago History Museum and Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Harper’s Weekly’s version of death and drama in Haymarket Square. (May 15, 1886))

I still don’t know what, if anything, folks who thought defunding Minneapolis police was a good idea were thinking.

Maybe that’s because I don’t assume that police departments cause crime.

Or maybe if I understood the political subtleties in play, then I’d have added my voice to an anarchist anthem, liberal lyric or conservative chorus.

Then again, maybe not. I’m guessing “not.”

At any rate, there’s been no shortage of opinions — expressed by words or actions— regarding the recent trial.

Before I wade into politics, pigs and all that, another of my assumptions.

Based on experience and ‘book learning,’ I figure that police officers neither paragons of virtue, nor thugs with badges. Not all of them.

Maybe picking a knee-jerk response the last year’s craziness would be easier if I chose one or the other stereotype. But that doesn’t make sense. Not to me.

Porcine Protest and a “Confrontational” Controversy


(George Floyd protests, 2020.)

“Pig’s head thrown at former home of Chauvin defense witness”
Tim Stelloh, NBC News (April 18, 2021)

“Vandals threw a pig’s head at the onetime home of a former California police officer who was a defense witness for Derek Chauvin, the former Minneapolis officer accused of killing George Floyd, police said.

“The incident occurred early Saturday in Santa Rosa, California, at a house where the witness, Barry Brodd, used to live, Santa Rosa police said in a statement….”


“Waters calls for protesters to ‘get more confrontational’ if no guilty verdict is reached in Derek Chauvin trial”
Chandelis Duster, CNN (April 19, 2021)

“…The comments by Waters, a California Democrat and icon among progressives, were immediately seized on by Republicans who claimed that Waters was inciting violence. The congresswoman denied in a subsequent interview that she was encouraging violence, but the remarks come at a time of immense national tension amid several high-profile killings of Black people at the hands of police officers and as American cities brace for a fresh wave of protests as the Chauvin trial nears a close….”

A key phrase in the pig’s head piece is “used to live.”

Barry Brodd doesn’t live in Santa Rosa, or California, any more. But seeing the pig’s head as an anti-Brodd protest seems reasonable.

On the other hand, it’s not the only possible motive.

Maybe whoever lives there incurred a militant vegetarian’s wrath, shortchanged a butcher or was the victim of random pig violence.

Regarding the Waters “more confrontational” statement, I don’t know its context or history. In any case, I’m glad that folks didn’t celebrate the guilty verdict by torching more stores. By my standards, that’d be daft: at least as daft as last year’s use of arson as a call for justice.

Actions, Responses


(From Fibonacci Blue, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(George Floyd memorial in Minneapolis, Minnesota. (May 30, 2020))

“George Floyd: Jury finds Derek Chauvin guilty of murder”
(April 20, 2021)
BBC News

“…Chauvin was found guilty on three charges: second-degree murder, third-degree murder and manslaughter.

“He will remain in custody until he is sentenced and could spend decades in jail….

“…The 12-member jury took less than a day to reach their verdict, which followed a highly-charged, three-week trial that left Minneapolis on edge….

“…They say one of the most likely avenues of appeal is the huge publicity given to the case, with the defence team arguing that this might have influenced the jury.

“Also, Presiding Judge Peter Cahill said on Monday that public comments by Democrat Congresswoman Maxine Waters could be grounds for an appeal.

“Over the weekend, Ms Waters had urged protesters to ‘stay on the street’ and ‘get more confrontational’ if Chauvin were acquitted….

I wasn’t surprised at a guilty verdict in the D. Chauvin trial.

Intransigent conservatives and ardent liberals agree that Chauvin’s actions resulted in Floyd’s death.

Well, mostly agree. One version of the events says that Floyd was sick, and so didn’t survive last year’s encounter.

The way I heard it, Chauvin restrained Floyd in a way that’s legitimate. When dealing with a strong, active suspect.

If Floyd was so unwell that a routine restraint technique killed him, then I’d wonder why police used the technique: when they outnumbered the suspect four to one.1

Perceptions

Walt Kelly's Deacon Mushrat and Simple J. Malarky. (1953)Blaming Chauvin’s defense for raising what I see as goofy questions is an option.

But I grew up in an America where too many of my homeland’s self-described best and brightest could have checked into a loony bin, no questions asked.

Could have, if they’d had a trifle more self-awareness and weren’t promoting currently-trendy crackpot notions.

Watching McCarthyism’s dying gasps and enduring academia while political correctness was in bloom did nothing to encourage adulation of my betters. And that’s another topic.

What does surprise me a bit is that D. Chauvin was found guilty on all three counts. And that the jury reached that conclusion after only 10 hours of deliberation.

Consequences

Fiery protest in Washington DC, 2020.
(From Brett Weinstein, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Protest and fire in Washington, DC. (May 30, 2020))

Claes Jansz Visscher's Gunpowder plot executions etching, detail. (1606)Looks like we’ll learn what D. Chauvin’s sentence will be this coming June.

I’m not looking forward to that.

Quite a few folks, I strongly suspect, feel prison is too good for Chauvin. I also strongly suspect that we’ll see a revival of last year’s ‘defund the police’ demands.

And nights are warmer in June, so maybe we’ll have a replay of last year’s ‘let’s set fire to the neighborhood’ events. I hope not.

Oopsie

Comparison: Glock 17 and Taser X26P.
(From Brett Weinstein, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(When is a Taser not a Taser?)

The traffic stop in Brooklyn Center, a week ago last Tuesday, wasn’t quite routine.2

Duante Wright had an outstanding arrest warrant. He and a Mr. Driver had been accused of attacking and robbing someone. Using a gun as well as their hands.

Maybe that explains why a police officer used a “Taser” during the traffic stop. But the arrest warrant doesn’t explain how the Taser turned out to be a Glock pistol.

I Am Not Making This Up

'Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers' No. 1 cover. (1971) (low-resolution thumbnail)Events during the next few minutes reminded me of yesteryear’s underground comix.3

“How a veteran officer could have mistaken a Glock for a Taser in the fatal shooting of Daunte Wright”
Corky Siemaszko, NBC News (April 13, 2021)

“…The answer to that question may have as much to do with what was going on in Brooklyn Center police Officer Kim Potter’s mind as with which weapon she was holding in her hand, experts told NBC News on Tuesday.

“The Glock pistol that Potter was wielding when she fired the fatal shot at Wright on Sunday as he allegedly attempted to flee is black metal and almost a pound heavier than the neon-colored plastic Taser she may have believed she was brandishing as she was caught on a video yelling, ‘Taser! Taser! Taser!’…”

Glocks, Tasers, and Frames of Reference

Police issue X26 TASER. Not a Glock.
(From Junglecat, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(This Taser is not a Glock.)

I’ve never been a police officer. My frame of reference does not include dealing with someone who violated traffic rules, and may have used force while acquiring $820.

So maybe just over 7 ounces of plastic can look and feel just like 1 pound, 6 ounces of metal during a traffic stop.

Maybe everything with a handle looks like a Taser on Tuesday afternoons.

At any rate, a bullet from the “Taser” punctured Duante Wright.

Maybe he shouldn’t have driven away, but he did. Then he hit another car and a concrete barrier. Police officers caught up with him, used CPR, but he died anyway.

Then the ‘I didn’t know the Taser was a Glock’ police officer and the Brooklyn Center police chief resigned. The last I heard, the police officer has been charged with second-degree manslaughter. I don’t know what’s happened in that $820 robbery case.

I gather that quite a few folks aren’t happy about how Duante Wright died. Can’t say that I blame them.


Troublesome Topics

(Members of Texas Army National Guard's 136th MEB military police supporting local law enforcement in Austin, Texas. (May 30, 2020)
(U.S. Army photo by Charles E. Spirtos, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)

Something that’s gotten lost in the George Floyd shuffle is why four police officers came to Cup Foods last May.

And this brings me to life, law, justice and other awkward topics.

Whether or not George Floyd bought cigarettes with a counterfeit $20 bill is probably a moot point.

He’s dead. And in the Cup Food owner’s place, I’d prefer dropping charges to risking the wrath of Floyd’s followers.

For all I know, someone’s proven that the $20 bill was genuine.

But oddly enough, nobody’s said that money, cigarettes or Big Tobacco caused last summer’s mess. Not that I’ve seen. Maybe news and social media can accommodate only so many crazy ideas at a time, and that’s yet another topic. Topics.

Since proof that a mistake sparked George Floyd’s lethal encounter would enhance his value as a martyr, I suspect that the bill was bogus. Whether he knew it was counterfeit, and hoped a clerk wouldn’t notice, or thought it was legal tender — is another moot point.

The same goes for the $820 robbery charge that ended in death by “Taser.”

How I see law, justice and all that hasn’t changed since the last time talked about it.

So this may be a good time for you to stop reading — and go polish the cat, let out your shoes or do whatever.

Life and Love

'Vanitas Still Life,' Pieter Caesz. (1630)I think my life matters. But I can’t stop there. Since I’m a Catholic, I must see all human life as special: sacred, a gift from God. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2258, 2260)

I must also see everyone as a real person, a neighbor, someone who matters: created in the image of God. Someone I should — must — love. No exceptions. (Genesis 1:27; Matthew 5:43–44, 22:36–40; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31, 10:25–37; Catechism, 1789, 2258, 2260)

As I’ve said before, and almost certainly will again, that can be awkward.

Law and Chickenman

Dick Orkin's Chickenman, opposing crime and/or evil.I think that passing a bogus bill is wrong.

But that’s not because I think America’s assorted federal and state laws are sacred: immutable principles carved into the great world-tree Yggdrasil.

It’s because I think our laws regarding counterfeit currency aren’t all that far from natural law: principles that are woven into reality, and which don’t change.

Recapping what I keep saying: natural law doesn’t change. It’s part of reality. Positive law, rules we make up, changes. And should change as our circumstances change. In an ideal world, positive law would reflect natural law. (Catechism, 1950-1974)

We don’t live in an ideal world; so sometimes what’s legal isn’t right, and sometimes what’s right isn’t legal. That sort of disconnect may have inspired Chickenman’s ongoing quest: opposing crime and/or evil. (June 6, 2020)

Stealing Isn’t Right, Even if It’s Legal

Étienne Picart's 'Faces Expressing Anger.' (1713)Justice matters. Theft is wrong, even when it’s legal. (Catechism, 1807, 2401-2414)

For example, if I paid someone $10 for $20 worth of work, that’d be wrong; even if my era’s laws said it was okay.

Buying something with a piece of paper that’s nearly worthless strikes me as being uncomfortably close to forgery: which the Church says is a form of theft. (Catechism, 2409)

That’d be true, even if I feel that stealing is okay because I’ve been cheated. Intent matters, but the end does not justify the means. (Catechism, 1753)

Finally, justice isn’t fueled by anger. Or shouldn’t be. (Catechism, 2302)

Murder Isn’t Nice And We Shouldn’t Do It

A Saturday night gone wrong: nine killed in Dayton, Ohio. (August 4, 2019)I figure — and hope — that only a few folks see killing an innocent person as okay.

Defining “person” and “innocent” gets tricky.

So does settling on what “killing” means. And that’s yet again another topic.

Since I’m a Catholic, I think killing an innocent person is murder, no matter how it’s done — or how young, old, or sick the person is. That’s because, again, human life is sacred: a gift from God. (Catechism, 2258, 2268-2279)

I also think that sometimes taking a human life can’t be avoided.

There are times when the only way to keep someone from killing innocent people is ending that person’s life. The idea’s called legitimate defense. (Catechism, 2263-2267)

But legitimate defense isn’t even close to saying murder is okay if I feel threatened. And I sure don’t think an alleged $820 robbery warrants ‘shoot to kill.’

Angry and Disgusted

Temporarily closed businesses in Minneapolis, Minnesota. (June 21, 2020)I’m still angry about George Floyd’s murder.

I’m not so much angry as disgusted and puzzled by this month’s ‘I thought the Glock was a Taser’ SNAFU in a Twin Cities suburb.

And I’m profoundly glad that I live in a town where the local police are not earning a reputation for using lethal force when responding to allegedly counterfeit bills, or being befuddled over distinctions between a Glock and a Taser.

But being angry, or disgusted, won’t help me understand what went so horribly wrong in Minneapolis and Brooklyn Center.

So I’ll keep trying to stay calm(ish), remember that my assumptions aren’t facts, and maybe return to this subject when I’ve learned more. Or table the topic. Maybe permanently.

I’ve talked about this sort of thing before:


1 A dubious $20 bill, death and carrying signs:

2 The Curious Case of the Taser That Wasn’t:

3 Remembering days of yore, when relevance was relevant:

Posted in Discursive Detours | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Marlowe’s Faustus: Chorus, Soliloquies and Film Noir

“Doctor Faustus…” starts with a 194-word soliloquy. Sort of. It’s delivered by Chorus, named last in Marlowe’s “Dramatis Personae.”

Ancient Greek tragedies had a chorus, acting like today’s narrators. Again, sort of.

Aristotle said that chorus was a character, so maybe Marlowe saw it that way, too. Make that probably did, since his “Dramtis Personae” lists Chorus.

Anyway, here’s Marlowe’s first whacking great chunk of soliloquy, whittled down considerably, in “Dr. Faustus.” Assuming that what Chorus says is soliloquy.

“CHORUS. Not marching in the fields of Thrasymene,
Where Mars did mate the warlike Carthagens …
…His waxen wings did mount above his reach,
And, melting, heavens conspir’d his overthrow;
For, falling to a devilish exercise,
And glutted now with learning’s golden gifts,
He surfeits upon cursed necromancy;
Nothing so sweet as magic is to him,
Which he prefers before his chiefest bliss:
And this the man that in his study sits.”
(“…Faustus…,” Marlowe (1604, From The Quarto Of 1616) Edited by The Rev. Alexander Dyce (1870))

Wait. What? “Thrasymene?” “Carthagens??” “Where Mars did mate???!”

And why, oh why does Marlowe have Chorus lead with what “Faustus” isn’t about?!

Trying to explain an Elizabethan playwright’s creative choices isn’t hard. Explaining them plausibly is another matter, but I’ll try.

But first —


A Punic Parenthesis

Rome and Carthage at the Beginning of the Second Punic War, 218 B.C. - from William R. Shepherd's 'Historical Atlas' (1926) via Perry-Castañeda Library's Map CollectionThat bit about Mars mating the “Carthagens” might suggest a reverse twist on today’s ‘guidance suggested’ ratings. But I’m pretty sure it’s not.

I figure that Marlowe counted on at least some of his audience seeing “Thrasymene” “Carthagens” as references to the Battle of Lake Trasimene, an incident during the Second Punic War.

That debacle has little or nothing to do with the “Faustus” narrative. Maybe it’s there to showcase Marlowe’s historical knowledge.

Or to give his audience preening opportunities, assuming that they knew their ancient history.

Or assuming that they didn’t.

Mars was the Roman god of war. I’ll assume that “Thrasymene” and “Carthagens” referenced the Battle of Lake Trasimene.

Using today’s chess jargon, I’d see “Mars did mate” as meaning that Roman forces defeated the Carthaginians. Which doesn’t make sense. Because that’s not what happened.

Before the battle, Rome’s Gaius Flaminius was known mostly for his great piety and regrettable habit of treating commoners like people. Regrettable by upper-crust Roman standards, that is.

After the battle, he was praised for his courage and determination. And breathtaking lack of military savvy.

Details of how he died vary considerably. But bottom line? He led his troops into an ambush. Like General Custer, but with arguably-different motives.

The Battle of Lake Trasimene was a defeat for Rome and, metaphorically, Rome’s Mars.

Reshef, or maybe Baal Shamem, was the Carthaginian war god. Maybe.

My guess is that we’d know more about Punic beliefs if Roman authorities had been less thorough in their dismantling of Carthage. Which happened while Parthia’s first Mithridates was founding the Parthian Empire.1 And that’s another topic.


Contents: Links to What’s Ahead

For my convenience, and in case you want to skip ahead to hubris or maybe film noir, a table of contents:


A Millennium of Western Theater

Ancient Greek relief: an aulos player and his family standing with Dionysos and (Artemis?), with theatrical masks above. (4th century BC)

Euripides wrote “Medea” and invented theater in 431 BC. According to at least one version of Western Cultural History Lite.

But, as usual, it’s not nearly that simple. Take dithyrambs, for example: one way folks retold the story of Dionysus, Pentheus, and a world-class daft decision.

From Dithyrambs to the Renaissance: In Brief

Antonio Tempesta's 'The Death of Pentheus.' (ca. 1606)Dionysian dithyrambs predated Euripides by a good bit. A dithyramb is a hymn of sorts. An enthusiastic one.

Whether and to what extent dithyrambs inspired ancient Greek tragedies is debatable and debated.

I’d be surprised if Greeks like Euripides hadn’t been influenced by their culture’s dramatic traditions.

And even more surprised if any folks didn’t have theater or its equivalent in their traditions. My guess is that theater of some sort was ancient long before Karl Jaspers’s Axial Age.

My ancestry and culture has European roots, so that’s the sort of theater I’ll focus on. Briefly.

And I’ll start with Ancient Greece, since that’s about as far back as detailed records go.

Greeks saw tragedy and comedy as completely different genres. And their actors were, I gather, always men.

Ancient Roman theater wasn’t exactly like Greek theater. But it wasn’t all that different.

Dominican doctor taking a pulse; in a set of standard 13th-century medical texts; bound in Paris between 1225 and 1275. From the Lawrence J. Schoenberg Collection, Penn University, used w/o permission.Fast-forward a millennium, give or take a few centuries. Rome’s empire had become a rose-colored memory.

Europeans were staging what we call mystery plays.

They weren’t plays by today’s standards.

More like narrated and/or sung stories from the Bible or Christian folklore, illustrated by folks representing Adam, Eve, a Saint or whoever.2

And then the Renaissance happened.

Elizabethan Theater, Actors and Other Threats

Hogarth's 'The Bad Taste of the Town' - first version. (ca. 1723)

By the 1500s, performances we’d recognize as plays had joined Europe’s mystery plays. And English producers were building the first English theaters: structures designed to bring an audience and actors together.

That didn’t sit well with London’s Lord Mayor and other civic authorities. Actors, they felt, brought crime and disorder to their fair city.

Possibly because ancient Rome’s first actors were foreigners: Etrurians.

It had been a millennium since the Roman Empire’s day. But the Italian Renaissance, with its passion for all things Roman, was contagious: and spreading throughout Europe.

Maybe that explains the London Lord Mayor’s anti-actor attitude. Or maybe not.

At any rate, Rome’s first actors weren’t Romans. As such, they were barred from Roman military service. And that, on top of being non-Roman, kept them out of Roman politics.

Actors weren’t on the bottom rung of ancient Rome’s social ladder, but they were close.3

Meanwhile, in Elizabethan London

1574 map of London: MAP L85c no.27., Exhibited in 'Open City: London, 1500–1700'; Folgerpedia.Either way, in 1567 citizen and Grocer (capital “G”) John Williams built the Red Lion: the first purpose-built London theater.

The first one we know of. And the Red Lion wasn’t actually in London.

J. Williams built his theater on a farm just outside the city limits.

We’re not sure exactly where. Maybe between today’s The Royal London Hospital and Whitechapel Post Office and Sidney Square.

In any case, a struggle for the hearts and minds of London followed the Red Lion’s opening and subsequent lawsuit.4

That’s Entertainment: or “Immorality, and Profaneness”

Will Kempe, dancing a jig from Norwich to London. (1600)
(From Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Will Kempe: an enemy of the people? (1600))

Often as not, the Queen and Court didn’t mind actors and entertainment: particularly when actors entertained them.

Some Lord Chamberlains took the Queen’s lead.

Some tried protecting London from the likes of Shakespeare and Marlowe. They lost.

James Burbage — an Elizabethan tradesman, actor and producer — built The Theatre a few hundred yards southwest of where Arnold Circus is now.

But Elizabethan theater wasn’t promoted exclusively by tradesmen, Grocers and other non-aristocrats. Although that’d play well for fans of class-struggle yarns. And that’s another topic.

Henry Carey, 1st Baron Hunsdon; Charles Howard, 1st Earl of Nottingham; and Queen Elizabeth sponsored acting companies.

Maybe the Lord Chamberlain’s, Lord Strange’s and the Admiral’s Men were strictly entertainment. Queen Elizabeth’s Men were blatantly political. Which provided employment for London lawyers.

Besides political headaches, London’s civil authorities had practical concerns. Theaters, if they’re successful, draw large crowds. And large crowds can spread disease.5

Then there’s the religious angle. Angles.

“But then such People ought to be kept in dark Rooms and without Company”

Jeremy Collier's 'Short View of the Immorality and Profaneness of the English Stage' antitheatrical pamphlet. (1698)I’m pretty sure that Londoners who saw Henry VIII’s home-brew church as insufficiently purged of popish pomp influenced city policy.

And at least one foe of “Immorality and Profaneness” strove to save England from Shakespeare’s Ophelia.

“…Had Shakespear secur’d this point for his young Virgin Ophelia, Hamlet. the Play had been better contriv’d. Since he was resolv’d to drown the Lady like a Kitten, he should have set her a swimming a little sooner. To keep her alive only to sully her Reputation, and discover the Rankness of her Breath, was very Cruel. But it may be said the Freedoms of Distraction go for nothing, a Feavour has no Faults, and a Man non Compos, may kill without Murther. It may be so: But then such People ought to be kept in dark Rooms and without Company. To shew them, or let them loose, is somewhat unreasonable. But after all, the Modern Stage seems to depend upon this Expedient….”
(“A Short View of the Immorality, and Profaneness of the English Stage…,” Jeremy Collier, M.A., (1698))

Antitheatricality, moral panic and perceptions of mental illness — are cans of worms I’ll save for another day.

Something like a century and a half after Marlowe, Hogarth was appalled at English drama’s decline and fall. By Hogarth’s day, “Doctor Faustus” had been re-imagined as a commedia dell’arte pantomime.6 And that’s yet another topic.


Today’s America, Elizabethan London: Compared and Contrasted

Walt Kelly's Deacon Mushrat and Simple J. Malarkey. (11953)Chaos reigns while terror stalks the streets!

Fear of foreigners grips the populace!

Censorship abounds!

Disease and immorality in media threaten the very heart of our fair nation!

Overripe style aside, that’s what I see in today’s headlines. Although details have changed, it’s what I’ve seen in the news ever since I started paying attention.

If I thought today’s angst parade was something new, then maybe I’d latch onto someone’s End Times Bible Prophecy — read all about it, only $19.99. 🙄

On the other hand, I could embrace a more trendy topic. Maybe supporting some ‘save the endangered critter of the month’ movement.

Or I could simply stop caring. Which doesn’t strike me as reasonable, either.

True, we’re living in ‘interesting times.’ But that’s nothing new.

“…Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world….
…The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity….”
(“The Second Coming,” W. B. Yeats (1919))

“O tempora, o mores!”
(“Oh the times! Oh the customs!”)
(First Oration against Catiline, Cicero (63 BC))

We’ve got COVID-19, Elizabethan London had bubonic plague. Along with smallpox, measles, diphtheria, chickenpox, no sewer system and no antibiotics.

We’ve got politicos and their supporters demonizing the ‘bad guys,’ while the folks in charge try to control what the rest of us can read. So did they.7

What’s changed is that the printing press isn’t our scary new tech. Now it’s the Internet and particularly social media.

I talked about this last month. At length:


The Postdoctoral Dilemma of Dr. Faustus

A frontispiece for 'Historia Mundi Naturalis,' by Pliny the Elder, published Sigmund Feyerabend, Frankfurt am Main. (1582)
(From Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(From Sigmund Feyerabend’s reprint of Pliny the Elder’s “Natural History.” (1582))

My academic career, such as it was, left me with two undergraduate degrees, a year of library science and half of an undergraduate degree in computer science.

I’d have majored in general studies, but that wasn’t an option. So I studied history and English for grade points, and researched everything else for fun. Having access to their libraries and archives is a big perk for college students. It was for me, at any rate.

But, doctorate-free though I am, I’ve learned a bit about the ivory tower’s turrets.

If I’d earned a Ph.D. in history, then I could could have become a history professor, museum curator, archivist or author.8 Or, at least as likely, a sales clerk.

As it is, I’ve been a sales clerk, along with a medley — or mess — of other jobs. And I have been and still am a writer.

Getting back to Marlowe’s play, Chorus finally gets around to Faustus: a bright kid “…born of parents base of stock,” who studies his way to academia’s highest degree:

“CHORUS. … So much he profits in divinity,
That shortly he was grac’d with doctor’s name,
Excelling all, and sweetly can dispute
In th’ heavenly matters of theology;…”
(“…Faustus…,” Marlowe (1604, From The Quarto Of 1616) Edited by The Rev. Alexander Dyce (1870))

That’s when he considers his postdoctoral options.

“…FAUSTUS. Settle thy studies, Faustus, and begin
To sound the depth of that thou wilt profess:…
…Sweet Analytics, ’tis thou hast ravish’d me!
Bene disserere est finis logices.
Is, to dispute well, logic’s chiefest end?
Affords this art no greater miracle?…”
(“…Faustus…,” Marlowe (1604))

“What a World of Profit and Delight”

From the 'Faust' collection, central library, German Classic, National Research and Memorial Sites, Weimar.Faustus soliloquizes for 415 words.

Basically, he sees “Sweet Analytics,” economics, medicine and law as unworthy of his brilliance.

Harsh words, but Faustus has high standards.

Take, for example, his reason for rejecting a career in medicine (“physic”) — a subject that’s already earned him honors.

“…Couldst thou make men to live eternally,
Or, being dead, raise them to life again,
Then this profession were to be esteem’d.
Physic, farewell! …”
(“…Faustus…,” Marlowe (1604))

At this point, Faustus considers theology. Elizabethan theology, at any rate, as presented by Marlowe. Faustus doesn’t like it.

“…Why, then, belike we must sin, and so
consequently die:
Ay, we must die an everlasting death.
What doctrine call you this, Che sera, sera,
What will be, shall be? Divinity, adieu!…”
(“…Faustus…,” Marlowe (1604))

Maybe “Che sera, sera” is Marlowe’s jab at predestination, as understood in his England. Maybe not. Either way, at this point he finds something he likes.

“…These metaphysics of magicians,
And necromantic books are heavenly;
Lines, circles, scenes, letters, and characters;
Ay, these are those that Faustus most desires.
O, what a world of profit and delight,
Of power, of honour, and omnipotence,
Is promis’d to the studious artizan!
All things that move between the quiet poles
Shall be at my command: emperors and kings
Are but obeyed in their several provinces;
But his dominion that exceeds in this,
Stretcheth as far as doth the mind of man;
A sound magician is a demigod:
Here tire, my brains, to gain a deity.”
(“…Faustus…,” Marlowe (1604))

Then — at last — Wagner enters, and we get some dialog. Also Good Angel and Evil Angel, but I’ll talk about them some other day.

We’ve also learned that Faustus has titanic self-esteem, with ambitions to match.

Hubris

WiNG's photo of the Beijing Television Cultural Center fire. (February 9, 2009)Having good self-esteem makes sense, but Marlowe’s ambition takes him deep into the “hubris” zone.

Oddly enough, “hubris” isn’t ancient Greek for “hold my beer.” But it’s close.

The word’s meaning is more like “outrage:” trying to do something that violates the natural order, or goes against reason.

Oedipus, for example, committed hubris by trying to dodge the Delphic oracle’s doom; that he was destined to kill his father and sleep with his mother.

Both Icarus and Prometheus offended the natural order, as imagined by at least some ancient Greeks, by trying to fly and giving fire to humanity.9

I don’t see either trying to fly or developing new technology as a problem.

But I’m a contemporary American, not an ancient Greek, raised back when the establishment praised science and technology. Then, during and following my teens, a conviction that science and technology will kill us all came into vogue.

And at least a few folks still assume that science and religion, particularly Christianity, get along as well as mongoose and cobra.

I haven’t heard an ‘if God meant man to fly’ joke in years, so that may not need explaining.

Alarm and despondency over new tech is another matter. Along with the assumption that religion and seeking knowledge don’t mix. I’ll get back to that.

Pride

'The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things,' detail; by Hieronymus Bosch or someone else. (1505-1510 or thereabouts)But first, I’d better say why I’m not denouncing self-esteem.

Basically, it’s because I’m a Catholic.

Pride is a bad idea, a sin. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1866)

But pretending that we’re miserable wretches, fit only for eternity’s ashcan, isn’t a good idea.

We’re made “in the image of God.” And, like all of God’s creation, we’re basically “very good.” The first of us put personal preference above God’s will, a monumentally bad idea. But God didn’t change our nature. We’re wounded, but not corrupted. (Genesis 1:27, 31, 3:1–19; Catechism, 31, 299, 355-361, 374-379, 398, 400-406, 405, 1701-1707, 1949)

Backing up a bit, sin is something that offends reason, truth, “right conscience” — and God. (Catechism, 1849-1851)

Self-Esteem, Within Reason

Fred Barnard's Uriah Heep, from 'David Copperfield. (1870s)So, if pride is a sin, then shouldn’t I be trying to believe that I’m a lousy writer? Or at least saying that I am?

No. It doesn’t work that way.

Accepting truth matters, so that’s not a reasonable option. Uria Heep’s oily servility is no more reasonable than a Faustian quest for omnipotence.

In my case, I’ve been a researcher/reporter and an advertising copywriter, so there’s evidence that I’m a pretty good writer.

Saying that I’m not wouldn’t be reasonable.

So would be claiming that my knack for writing was entirely my own doing.

Sure, I’ve worked at developing my talents and skills. But having something to work with? That’s from God.

“HUMILITY: The virtue by which a Christian acknowledges that God is the author of all good. Humility avoids all inordinate ambition or pride, and provides the foundation for turning to God in prayer (2559). Voluntary humility can be described as ‘poverty of spirit’ (2546).”
“PRIDE: One of the seven capital sins. Pride is undue self-esteem or self-love, which seeks attention and honor and sets itself in competition with God.”
(Catechism, Glossary)

Summing up: truth matters, pride is a bad idea and self-esteem can make sense.

“Odious to the Lord and to mortals is pride,
and for both oppression is a crime.”
“My son, with humility have self-esteem;
and give yourself the esteem you deserve.”
(Sirach 10:7, 28)

“Little Less Than a God”
TRAPPIST–South first light image of the Tarantula Nebula, detail. (2010) From TRAPPIST/E. Jehin/ESO, used w/o permission.

Faust’s desire for God-level power doesn’t make sense.

That said, humanity is pretty hot stuff. We really are made “in the image of God,” with awesome abilities, authority — and responsibilities.

That last bit is scary, but I don’t see a point in either pretending that we’re just like every other critter on the planet or that doing whatever we want is a good idea.

And I am quite sure that using the brains God gives us does not offend a dyspeptic deity.

Noticing the beauty and order in this universe is a good idea. So is learning how it works. And using our knowledge wisely. (Catechism, 16, 341, 373, 1704, 1730-1731, 2293)

Again, we’re pretty hot stuff.

“When I see your heavens, the work of your fingers,
the moon and stars that you set in place—
“What is man that you are mindful of him,
and a son of man that you care for him?
“Yet you have made him little less than a god,
crowned him with glory and honor.
“You have given him rule over the works of your hands,
put all things at his feet:”
(Psalms 8:4–7)

That said, “little less than a god” isn’t God. Our position comes with daunting accountability.


Soliloquies: Monologues, Dramatic and Otherwise

E. W. Kemble's 'Hamlet's soliloquy' for 'Huckleberry Finn.' (1885)Basically, a soliloquy is what I do when I’m talking to myself. Which happens fairly often, particularly when digital glitches or writer’s block strike.

It’s a monologue, addressed to whoever’s speaking. And the audience. Or reader, in the case of the Soliloquies of Augustine.

Soliloquies, the sort committed by actors, aren’t limited to Elizabethan theater. But that period’s grand perorations are particularly famous.

There’s the ‘to be or not to be’ soliloquy in Act 3, Scene 1 of Shakespeare’s Hamlet, for example.10

This is profoundly not how it goes:

“To be, or not to be; that is the bare bodkin
That makes calamity of so long life;
For who would fardels bear, till Birnam Wood do come to Dunsinane,
But that the fear of something after death Murders the innocent sleep,
Great nature’s second course,
And makes us rather sling the arrows of outrageous fortune
Than fly to others that we know not of….”
(“Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,” Chapter XXI, Mark Twain; Charles L. Webster & Company (1885)

Soliloquies are a dandy way to show audiences what’s happening in a character’s head. More accurately, they’re an easy way to tell audiences.

Playwrights like Shakespeare and Marlowe get away with it. In large part, I suspect, because they’re exceptional writers.

Whether Elizabethan theater was famous for soliloquies because they had Shakespeare and Marlowe, or those two wrote soliloquies because monologues were fashionable? I think that’s a good question, and I don’t have a good answer.

I do, however, think that soliloquies enjoyed a comeback in the 20th century. But I suspect that many serious devotees of the thespian arts would disagree.

Some of them, at any rate.

Film Noir (or) A Soliloquy By Any Other Name

'Laura' trailer title frame.' (1944)
(From 20th Century Fox, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Trailer for Otto Preminger’s “Laura.” (1944))

I gather that the closest thing to an academic consensus regarding film noir is that it’s either a genre, or it isn’t. It’s an American style, or it’s international. Film noir’s mood is dreamlike, brutal or something else. It’s melodrama. Or it’s not.

Adding my two cents, I’ll say that film noir is pretty much the opposite of “Oklahoma!” and “Abbott and Costello Go to Mars.”11

That’s one cent. Now, the other one.

Film noir’s soliloquies are shorter than Marlowe’s. The ones I’ve run across have been, at any rate. And scholars call them narratives.

But I don’t see all that much difference between the two. Apart, like I said, from length. And film noir’s non-Elizabethan dialect.

“WALDO LYDECKER: [narrating off screen] I shall never forget the weekend Laura died. A silver sun burned through the sky like a huge magnifying glass. It was the hottest Sunday in my recollection. I felt as if I were the only human being left in New York. For with Laura’s horrible death, I was alone. I, Waldo Lydecker, was the only one who really knew her, and I had just begun to write Laura’s story when another of those detectives came to see me…. “
(“Laura” (1944) via IMDB.com)

I also think that scholars who see film noir as a legitimate creative experiment are right. And I’m pretty sure that the style, or genre, or whatever, will eventually be assigned a label. Several, most likely, as time passes.


Coming Soon: Faustian Follies

Huntingdon Library's 'Faustus' manuscript.
(From Ken Eckert, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)

But film noir controversies don’t have a whole lot to do with Marlowe’s “Dr Faustus” — who soliloquizes even in dialogue with Valdes and Cornelius.

“…Philosophy is odious and obscure;
Both law and physic are for petty wits:
‘Tis magic, magic that hath ravish’d me.
Then, gentle friends, aid me in this attempt;
And I, that have with subtle syllogisms
Gravell’d the pastors of the German church,
And made the flowering pride of Wittenberg
Swarm to my problems, as th’ infernal spirits
On sweet Musaeus when he came to hell,
Will be as cunning as Agrippa was,
Whose shadow made all Europe honour him….”
(“…Faustus…,” Marlowe (1604, From The Quarto Of 1616) Edited by The Rev. Alexander Dyce (1870))

I’ve talked enough, maybe too much, about soliloquies. So next time I’ll look at Faust’s GOOD ANGEL and EVIL ANGEL. Also “the prince of parma,” and maybe grapes. Then again, maybe not.

I’ve also talked about faith and reason, truth and options, humility and freedom:


1 Republican Rome in retrospect:

2 Medea, mystery plays and more:

3 English traditions, Roman roots:

4 Something new:

5 Primarily producers and politics:

6 Perceptions and panic:

7 Elizabethan England; just like today’s America, except for how it’s not:

8 Academia’s deep end:

9 Hubris? Outrageous!

10 To be, or tomorrow, Birnam Wood comes to Dunsinane:

11 Movies:

Posted in Discursive Detours, Marlowe's Faustus, Series | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

April Showers, Minnesota Style, and More (or Less)


(Wednesday morning, my webcam’s view. (April 14, 2021)

Minnesota’s April showers can be rain, snow, or anything in between. Tuesday afternoon and evening’s were snow, which was gone by Wednesday afternoon.

I gather that folks don’t generally talk about weather as much as we do here. Maybe that’s because we’re more rural than, say, New York City. Then again, maybe not.

At any rate, it’s neither raining nor showing at the moment — Thursday afternoon, April 15, 2021 in case your ‘today’ is my ‘tomorrow.’

At the moment, I’m taking a break from researching and writing a ‘Marlowe’s Faustus’ essay; and finally saying something about the Elizabethan play.

I’m also getting around to sharing photos I took during Lent.

The idea at the time was illustrating some point or other about prayer. And how we’re coping with the COVID-19 pandemic.


(Crucifix on this year’s Lenten chaplet prayer necklace. “Jesus Nazarenus Rex Judieorum” is a version of the Latin inscription on our Lord’s cross: usually represented by “INRI.”)


(A change in Adoration chapel rules last month. They’ve changed again.)

I still don’t know how I’ll start the next section in that “Faustus” thing. But It won’t get written if I don’t get back to working on it. After, I think, a cup of coffee.

Stuff that’s related to this, and some that’s probably not:

Posted in Journal | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Sunshine, Holy Water and a Trip to the Emergency Room

Between Saturday’s sunshine and today’s patches of green grass, I’ve enjoyed this weekend. For the most part.

I picked up a bottle from the first of this year’s holy water last Sunday, following up with blessing the house on Tuesday. I hadn’t done that for quite some time.

About holy water: it’s a sacramental, a reminder of baptism. Sacramentals aren’t sacraments, they’re “sacred signs which bear a resemblance to the sacraments,” and those are topics I’ll save for another day. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1667–1676)

Early Friday evening, my wife told me that she was taking our son to the emergency room. And then they were out the door. A few hours later, I’d picked him up and driven him home.

The incident wasn’t exactly good news. But it wasn’t all bad news either. Thanks to tests they ran at the hospital, he’s got data that says something was going wrong. Given time, we may figure out what’s been causing the issue(s).

So, on the whole, I’d say this has been a good week.

One more thing. Two, actually.

Eligible and Willing to Wait

The Masked Minnesotan.For one thing, I checked the hospital’s ‘your medical information’ online service. Seems that I’ve been eligible for COVID-19 vaccine since late February. I figure that’s due to my age, and maybe health issues.

Maybe I’ll get the shot at my next scheduled appointment, next month.

I’m in no hurry, at least partly because I don’t get out much, and am careful when I do. The odds of my catching the disease are non-zero, but slim.

More, or Less, of the Same

Now, my usual list of vaguely-related stuff:

Posted in Journal | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Space Aliens: Perceptions, Assumptions

Apollo 11's photo: Earth. (1969) via NASA Johnson Space Center, used w/o permission.

Throughout the ages, Saints and sages have pondered the big questions.

Who are we?

What are we?

Why are our lives so messed up?

Storytellers and movie makers — these groups overlap — also reflect on human nature from time to time. Sometimes they use use space aliens as placeholders for ideas and ideals, strengths and failings.

I’ll be talking about that, and why I don’t “believe in” space aliens: but think we may have neighbors.

Then again, maybe we don’t. Which hasn’t kept folks from wondering “what if?”


Aliens and Allegorical Figures

Sci-fi movie poster collage; including 'Plan 9 from Outer Space,' 'Earth vs. the Flying Saucers,' 'The Thing.'Storytellers have been weaving yarns about space aliens at least since Lucian wrote “A True Story.”

Some follow Lucian’s lead, imagining extraterrestrials as reflections of ourselves. (July 20, 2019)

And sometimes as caricatures, humanity viewed in fun house mirrors.

Or as personifications of our bad habits.

That arguably helps explain films like “Invaders from Mars” and “Plan 9 From Outer Space.”

Another explanation for the ‘alien invaders’ film genre is that the menacing Martians and/or monsters are abstractions of the era’s fears. And I’m drifting off-topic again.

Or maybe not so much.

Space aliens have been presented as stand-ins for humanity as a whole, or personifications of our vices and virtues. And occasionally as allegorical figures of a sort.

So are those whose main, or only, character trait is invading Earth.

Memorable Tales

'Atheist Laughing at Christian and Hopeful.' from 'The Pilgrim's Progress,' Bunyan (1678), 1909 editionI don’t have a problem with allegory or allegorical figures.

They’ve been in many memorable tales. Bunyan’s “The Pilgrim’s Progress,” for example, is still in print: Lord Hate-Good, Apollyon and all.

“…So he went on, and Apollyon met him. Now, the monster was hideous to behold: he was clothed with scales like a fish, and they are his pride; he had wings like a dragon….”
(“The Pilgrim’s Progress,” Chapter IV, John Bunyan (1678) Edited by Rev. Jesse Lyman Hurlbut (1909))

Apollyon’s name means “the Destroyer” in Greek, more or less. I figure Bunyan added that “hideous to behold” description, just in case his readers didn’t know Greek.

But Bunyan’s allegorical figures weren’t all bad guys. There’s Christian, of course, the main character. Goodwill and Watchful, too. And these folks:

“…Now, as he stood looking and weeping, behold, three Shining Ones came to him, and saluted him with ‘Peace be to thee.’…”
(“The Pilgrim’s Progress,” Chapter III, John Bunyan (1678)…)

More than four centuries later, publishers are still reprinting “The Pilgrim’s Progress.” I’d be very surprised if such recent cinematic works as “Earth vs. the Flying Saucers” and “The Thing from Another World” are as well-remembered.1

But I’ll talk about a couple films anyway.

One of which featured Bunyan’s “Shining Ones.” Sort of.


Angels, Demons —

Space alien movies.

Movies often provide answers to life’s big questions.

Not particularly profound answers, but answers nonetheless.

“…It’s become a cliché of science fiction that we can look to the stars for deliverance from our base impulses. The more enlightened beings that live there will give us a leg up and free us from ourselves. Roddenberry, Spielberg, and Sagan looked at outer space and found hope in the guise of figurative angels.
“Quatermass did so and literally found the Devil.”
(“Quatermass & the Pit,” David S Zondy’s Tales of Future Past)

Zondy’s “…literally found the Devil” is more like hyperbole. Or maybe metaphor. Simile, maybe; then again, maybe not.

At any rate, construction of a fictional subway line under London’s Hobb’s lane stops when workers find a skull. That’s intact, as a result of having been inside — something.

“Quatermass and the Pit” (or) Beware the Demonic Martian Nazis!

Frames from 'Quatermass and the Pit'/'Five Million Years to Earth,' director Roy Ward Baker, writer Nigel Kneale, Hammer Film Productions (1967)
(From Hammer Film Productions, via IMDB.com, used w/o permission.)
(Two snippets from “Quatermass and the Pit”/”Five Million Years to Earth.” (1967))

'Quatermass and the Pit.' (1967) Doctor Roney (James Donald) and Quatermass (Andrew Keir) carrying a long-dead Martian.My hat’s off to Hammer Film’s version of “Quatermass and the Pit,” a BBC 1958-1959 television drama.

It reflected a good-faith effort to make the story’s science seem scientific.

The space aliens looked alien, and the film offered a clever take on original sin. Which isn’t science. I’ll get back to that.

In the Quatermass universe, Mars was a dying world.

Mariner 4 image of Martian surfaceThat wasn’t “scientific” in 1967, two years after Mariner 4 sent back pictures of a cratered and desolate Mars.

But when Nigel Kneale wrote the original “Pit” serial, in the late 1950s, a marginally-habitable Mars was (barely) plausible.

Besides, a Lowellian “…Abode of Life” scenario has become an accepted science fiction tradition. Or cliche.

Meanwhile, in the ‘Pit’ universe — Martians couldn’t save their planet or themselves. So they turned at least a quorum of early humans into folks who would carry on Martian culture. Not a bad idea, from the Martian viewpoint.

'Lebensunwertes Leben,' Eugenics poster.Problem was, the Martians were heavily into ethnic cleansing and suchlike pursuits.

So they programmed their values into these enhanced humans.

Along with, if my memory serves, a destructive and irrational respect for authority. Let’s remember that the movie was released in 1967.

In the film, authoritarian oppressor Martians corrupted our nice ancestors with their nasty values. that’s why some humans do bad stuff. Like purging Lebensunwertes Leben, life unworthy of life, from the population.

And why a London street over a buried Martian spaceship got called Hobbs Lane.2

Historical Context: The British Empire

'The Flags of a Free Empire,' Arthur Mees. (1910) Map of the British Empire.
(“The Flags of a Free Empire,” Arthur Mees. (1910); from Cornell University Library, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(The British Empire in 1910, from a British viewpoint.)

“Quatermass and the Pit” had a Message: following in the footsteps of “Sherlock Holmes and the Secret Weapon” and “Confessions of a Nazi Spy.”

Which I suspect explains some favorable reviews of both the serial and the film.

Work on the BBC television serial began in 1957.

The 1958 Notting Hill race riots hadn’t happened yet, but trouble was obviously brewing.

Folks who had lived in British imperial territories were moving to England.

Some, not all, ethnic English weren’t at all happy about their new neighbors.3 Today’s news media would probably call them white supremacists and/or racists. I’ll get back to that, and the Quatermass Martians.

More Historical Context: the Darien Disaster

Herman Moll's Isthmus of Darien and Panama map. (1697)
(From Herman Moll, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(“Isthmus of Darien.” Bay of Caledonia was south of “I. of pines.” (1697))

Backing up a bit, European warlords started building empires around five centuries back. England and Scotland were two distinct kingdoms then.

H.G. Moll's Map of the Bay of New Caledonia in Darién, Panama. (1729)The Darien scheme, building a colony on the Isthmus of Darien, looked like a good idea to many Scots investors.

English investors saw it as a threat. So did Spain’s movers and shakers. That’s partly because Mercantilism was in vogue: an economic theory that said if Scotsmen do more trade with the natives, then Englishmen or Spaniards will do less.

Thinking that trade can and should benefit everyone still seems to be a hard sell, and that’s another topic.

Meanwhile, back in 1698, 1,200 people reached a bay they called Caledonia and began building New Edinburgh.

Establishing their city on a harbor that ate ships was, in retrospect, a mistake.

So was building a fort with 50 cannon and no fresh water supply. On a site near Spanish shipping routes.

Crop failures and at-best-inept leadership didn’t help.

Locals hadn’t been interested in combs and trinkets offered as trade goods. But as settlers started dying in lots of 10 daily, they gave the immigrants fruit and a sort of banana.

Even so, all but 300 settlers died.

One of two resupply ships reaching Caledonia in August of 1699 caught fire. Then a ship with more settlers arrived, and after that Spanish forces attacked.

The Darien scheme collapsed, taking maybe 20% of Scots currency with it.

That, and English succession issues, gave us the Kingdom of Great Britain. It’s what we call the United Kingdom these days, basically.

Fast-forward about 108 years, and the British Empire is a world power.4

Racist Martians and Pax Britannica

'A busy stacking room in the opium factory at Patna, India,' lithograph after W. S. Sherwill. (ca. 1850)I could wax rhapsodic on those halcyon days between 1815 and 1914.

For in those days Pax Britannica bestowed peace and prosperity upon a baseborn world. From a British viewpoint.

British rulers abolished slavery and apprenticeship within their domain.

I see that as good news. The slavery part, certainly; apprenticeship because it had arguably become a sort of short-term slavery. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2409, 2414)

England ruled the waves. And, with help from France during the second Opium War, forced China’s Qing dynasty to allow opium imports.

That last wasn’t good news.

And so, although I could wax rhapsodic, I won’t.

But I see no point in either demonizing or idolizing England’s empire.

Remembering what went right, and what didn’t? I think that’s a good idea.

One of the things going right, my opinion, was that the United Kingdom allowed and still allows folks from former colonies to relocate in England. Even if they lacked English ancestors.

One of the things not going right was intolerance. It’s still a problem in the UK. And elsewhere. How much of a problem, and how many folks are responsible, depends on who’s talking.

Which gets me back to “Quatermass and the Pit” and BBC television’s racist Martians.

Non-English folks immigrating from the Caribbean were giving some Brits fits in the 1950s. The BBC television bunch apparently figured that presenting ethnic intolerance as something alien to humanity made sense.5

Origin Stories

Pre-human after Martian meddling, from “Quatermass and the Pit” wasn’t the first story about alien influence on human evolution and civilization.

I read two such tales in my youth.

I can’t remember the titles or the authors. Frustrating. Given time, maybe I could ferret out those details. Lots of time. Instead, I’ll work from memory. And hope that you’ll bear with me.

One tale was a straight-up rewrite of the second Genesis creation story. Parts of it. (Genesis 2:7–9, 15–25, 3:1–24)

The author recast God as an alien scientist. Eden was the scientist’s research facility and the tree was a tree-shaped symbol on one of the doors.

His science project included making two humans. He told them to not open the ‘tree’ door. Which the humans, being human, did. And got expelled from the facility.

Backwater Babylon and the Ancient Astronauts

The other story was an early, honestly-fictional and comparatively probable, version of later ‘ancient astronaut’ claims.

In the story, a two-alien spaceship landed on some backwater planet.

They were considerably less ‘alien’ than Frank R. Paul’s “man from Venus.”

Think Michael Rennie or Chris Hemsworth. (“The Day the Earth Stood Still” (1951), “Thor” (2011))

Anyway, the aliens did their job. Which in this case included learning how to talk with the locals.

Then they got a message from home. Something had gone horribly wrong. A war had started, and they were being recalled.

The aliens were unwilling to completely abandon their job.

They gave the local they’ve been talking with a highly condensed version of what they’d intended to share. And, lending verisimilitude to their narrative, a flashlight. Or something like that.

Then they left. The local walked back to his village, ‘which would become Babylon.’

I’d probably enjoy reading the story again.

I’m not sure about the ‘Eden as a laboratory’ tale. And I’ve drifted off-topic.

The Martians Made Me Do It?

I said that “Quatermass and the Pit” had a clever take on original sin.

The story assumes that there’s something wrong with humanity.

And tells us that we’re a mess because Martians meddled with our nice, natural ancestors.

That sounds a bit like original sin from a Catholic viewpoint. Or the noble savage and Rousseau’s natural man — the notion that if we chucked society’s corrupting influence, then our problems would go away. Which is a massive oversimplification.

Maybe the Quatermass writer and directors had the Catholic version of original sin in mind, with their Martians as Satan’s stand-in.

Or maybe not. Given England’s history and post-Enlightenment ‘enlightened’ attitudes towards religion, it seems unlikely.

But, likely or not, I see parallels.6

Feel free to skip the next section. I’ve talked about sin, original and otherwise, recently. (February 9, 2021; June 28, 2020)

Love, Sin and Consequences

Rembrandt's 'Jesus and the adulteress' drawing.Ideally, I’d always love God and my neighbor. And see everyone as my neighbor. (Matthew 5:43–44, 22:36–40; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31 10:25–27, 29–37; Catechism, 1033, 1931, 2055, 2196)

When I fail to love God and neighbor, that’s sin. (Catechism, 1849-1851)

So, if all I need to do is love God and my neighbor, then how come I don’t always act as if I believe that?

And how come so many folks act as if they see their neighbors as annoyances, obstacles or worse? Explanations for why folks behave badly abound.

This isn’t even close to a comprehensive list.

  1. The gods are bored, yanking our chains for amusement
  2. We’re living with consequences of a bad decision
  3. Humans and humanity are depraved: bad to the bone
  4. Society’s rules make us crazy

I’m a Catholic, so number three won’t wash. Neither will numbers one or four.

About number three, I don’t think humanity is the proverbial dunghill with an optional coat of snow. Luther may not have said that justification is like putting snow on a dunghill. But the quote started somewhere, and reflects an all-too-common opinion of humanity.7

Original Sin, Catholic Style

'Expulsion from the Garden of Eden,' Thomas Cole (1828) Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.I think that God creates a world, including us, that’s “very good.” The visible world is not, from God’s viewpoint, icky. (Genesis 1:26–31; Catechism, 337-385)

And neither are we.

But we live in a world where allegedly-civilized nations supported drug pushers, and where calumny oozes from election-year politics.

Our problems started when the first of us put ‘what I want’ ahead of what God said. Then we got caught. After that, the man blamed his wife, and God. The interview did not end well. We’re still dealing with consequences of that choice. (Genesis 3:1–20; Catechism, 385-412)

That’s original sin, Catholic style.

But we’re still human. We’re made in God’s image. Each of us is a someone, not a something: able to decide how we get along with each other and with God. And we’ve still got our old job: taking care of this world. (Genesis 2:15; Catechism, 307, 355-373, 2415-2418)

Recognizing humanity’s transcendent dignity, and doing our job, is much harder than it could have been. (Catechism, 374-378, 1929)

I’m not personally responsible for a decision made by the first of us. (Catechism, 405)

But I inherited humanity’s legacy: dignity, responsibilities and all.

It’s good or bad news, depending on which bits I look at, and how I deal with what I’ve got. And that’s yet another topic.

Close Encounters of the Shining Kind

Aliens leaving the mothership in Columbia Picture's 'Close Encounters of the Third Kind.'Spielberg’s “Close Encounters of the Third Kind” made a lot more sense when I realized it was a religious film. Of sorts.

Complete with a contemporary analog of Bunyan’s Shining Ones: space aliens using really bright lights.

“Close Encounters” won assorted awards, was put on America’s National Film Registry and gave film critics something to talk about.

Apparently it’s rife with Judaeo-Christian analogies and spiritual yearnings. I’ll agree with the yearnings part.

Equating the film’s Devils Tower with Mount Sinai seems like a stretch.

I think it’s more likely Spielberg picked Devils Tower/Bear Lodge Butte because it looks cool. And because humanity has a habit of associating mountains with mythology and the sacred: Mounts Athos, Damavand, Kailash and Miwa, for example.8

So maybe Devils Tower in “Close Encounters” is like Mount Sinai, in a generic sense.

Spiritual Yearnings and Kidnapping on an Epic Scale


(From Science Examiner, used w/o permission.)
(The big alien in “Close Encounters of the Third Kind.” (1977))

Then again, maybe Spielberg didn’t have spiritual yearnings and UFO religions in mind when he made “Close Encounters.”

Which seems unlikely, given how much of the film is dedicated to signs in the heavens. And the big alien’s ‘bless you, my children’ gesture. Granted, that’s how I saw it. Folks with different backgrounds and personalities probably have their own ideas.

One of my interpretations of the alien’s arms-out gesture involves pretending that “Close Encounters” is a documentary, not a movie: that incidents in the film really happened.

Think about it. Scientists and officials learn that folks from somewhere else have committed crimes including grand theft bulk carrier (Emergency Fleet Corporation’s SS Cotopaxi) and kidnapping on an epic scale.9

The aliens arrange a meeting. In a remote spot. Their ship is bigger than the landmark they specified. And they start negotiations by having dozens and dozens of folks they’ve kidnapped walk out of the ship.

Walk? That’s not quite right.

Like I said, it’s been a while since I’ve seen the film. But I think “shambled out” of the ship might be a better description.

Maybe the alleged abductees had been sitting in the space-alien equivalent of economy class all those decades.

Or maybe they weren’t — or weren’t quite — what they looked like. Which might explain why they didn’t talk.

And none of the scientists or officials saw anything odd about shambling non-talking maybe-abductees.

Or, apparently, wondered why the aliens wanted a fresh supply of humans.

Small wonder that I never felt like joining a UFO religion.

‘Believing in’ Space Aliens

Diorama of a Grey space alien at the Roswell UFO Museum; Roswell, New Mexico, USA; G. W. Dodson. (2011)UFO religions started in the 1930s, after 1947, or in the 1950s. The roster of UFO religions is variable, too.

Outfits like the Aetherius Society, Raëlism and sometimes Scientology generally make the cut.

I don’t know whether members would self-identify as UFO cult members.

Many UFO religions have lasted longer than Heaven’s Gate. Hardly surprising, since that bunch committed mass suicide.

I gather that they thought they were shedding they corporeal bodies as a “…’graduation’ from the Human Evolutionary Level….”

The Heaven’s Gate website apparently said that they were “…happily prepared to leave ‘this world’….” They seem to have believed that their souls would go to a spaceship hiding behind Comet Hale-Bopp.

For their sakes, I hope that the Heaven’s Gate folks really believed that they were graduating “from the Human Evolutionary Level.”10

Death, Judgment and Doing my Job

Precipitating circumstances for suicide from 16 American states. James Heilman, MD (2008)About that the Heaven’s Gate deaths — Suicide strikes me as a really bad idea. I’ve talked about this before, but figure it’s worth repeating.

Human life is sacred. All human life. Yours, mine, everyone’s. It’s a gift from God. (Catechism, 2258)

That’s why murder is a bad idea. If I killed someone, I’d be taking that person’s God-given life. (Catechism, 2258–2317)

Killing myself would be murder, with me as perpetrator and victim. I’d have committed an extremely serious offense while giving myself no time to repent. (Catechism, 1021-1022, 2280-2283)

That kind of trouble I don’t need.

I’m also strongly disinclined to pass judgment on folks who commit suicide. Judging persons is God’s job, not mine. (July 7, 2018; February 4, 2018)

I suspect that today’s UFO religions have roots in 19th century spiritism, theosophy, Western esotericism and even older beliefs.

And some, like Church of the SubGenius, seem to be strictly for laughs.11

Priorities and Respect

Illustrating a spherical Earth in 'L'Image du monde.' (Gautier de Metz (1245))Another point — obviously, or maybe not so much — I can’t be a Catholic and ‘believe in’ space alien celestial spirit guides.

Giving anyone or anything other than God first place in my priorities is a bad idea and I shouldn’t do it. (Catechism, 2112-2114)

Even less obviously, I suspect — judging from screed I occasionally see — I shouldn’t vilify folks who seriously see space aliens as analogs to folk from Faerie and Álfheimr, sent to help (or hinder) us.

I’m a Catholic and a Christian. I’m as sure as I can be that becoming a Catholic was and is a good idea.

But because I’m a Catholic, I must respect folks who are seeking truth, and have found an echo or reflection of it in, say, devotion to “Cosmic Masters.”11

I think they’re wrong. But I also think folks pursue truth within the limits of their experience. Part of my job is passing along the best news humanity’s ever had. (Catechism, 811-865)

Alien Abductions and Ufology

I think it’s possible, but extremely unlikely, that little grey men from Zeta Reticuli ambushed Barney and Betty Hill in 1961.

That’s ‘extremely unlikely’ as in winning the Irish Sweepstakes and Powerball on the same day. More than seven times running.

B & B Hill’s little grey men arguably inspired ufology’s Greys, AKA Grays. And decades of lurid tabloid cover stories.

Folks who take alien abduction stories seriously say that Greys are not alone. They’ve cataloged at least a half-dozen distinct varieties of space aliens visiting Earth.

Someone apparently sorted the perpetrators of 138 alleged abductions into six types: Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta, Sigma and Omega.

That list’s Omega aliens are “energy beings.”12

An Ology by Any Other Name

My guess is that ufologists come in two basic varieties. Those who:

  1. See UFO claims as subjects for psychological or sociological research
  2. Believe that ‘we are not alone’
    • Organizing their research around that assumption

I also think sticking “logy” onto UFO doesn’t make ufology of the ‘we are not alone’ persuasion a serious science.

Interesting, sometimes fascinating, yes. Entertaining, occasionally. But as solidly grounded in physical evidence and rigorous analysis as, say, geology? No, I don’t think so.13

That said, I think using Greek letters as labels for classifying 138 alleged abductions is cool. So are the Omega energy beings. Or would be, if they were presented as fictional characters.


— and Used Spaceship Dealers

'Canis Major,' Frank R. Paul. (1943)Both demonic and angelic space aliens are variations of the ‘planet of hats’ storytelling gimmick. Trope. Whatever.

Science fiction abounds with such planets.

I figure it’s because painting a word-picture of plausibly complex non-human people and their societies would take a great many words.

On top of that, editors have only so much space available for each story.

And they’re probably looking for engaging tales, not essays on hypothetical psycho-sociology.

Basically, isolating and dramatizing a single aspect of the human experience is arguably easier than imagining plausible non-human people. And takes far fewer words. Or screen time.

And readers have only so much patience. Having space aliens who fit into familiar pigeonholes lets writers and readers skip essays on non-human psychology, and start enjoying the story.

Screenwriters have the additional issue of production budget.

As a result, we get Captain Burke and Science Officer Hare negotiating with a planet of hairdressers one week, saving Cobblers on Planet Boot from Flip-Flop fanatics the next: and viewers accepting actors with rubber masks as real space aliens.

Then there’s alien physiology.

I put Fred Hoyle’s “The Black Cloud” at or near the top in that category. But that story’s perception and communication issues are something I’ll save for another day.

I suspect the odds are good that if we do have neighbors, and that’s still an emphatic “if,” then we’ll learn that they’re no more monotonously monolithic than we are. So maybe that pulp science fiction’s “Stories of the Stars” reflects, however dimly, what we’ll find.

Although why Our Heroes landed in an open-pit mine — is yet again another topic. Topics.

“…Our Cousins in the Cosmos….”

A point I’m trying to make is that if we have neighbors, they will almost certainly not be just like us.

But they’ll also almost certainly be very much like us:

“…Frankly, if you think about it, any creatures on other planets, subject to the same laws of chemistry and physics as us, made of the same kinds of atoms, with an awareness and a will recognizably like ours would be at the very least our cousins in the cosmos. They would be so similar to us in all the essentials that I don’t think you’d even have the right to call them aliens.”
(“Brother Astronomer,” Chapter Three, Would You Baptize an Extraterrestrial? — Brother Guy Consolmagno (2000))

They may even have individuals specializing in transferring ownership of used spaceships.

Questions and “a Mighty Soberin’ Thought”


(From Efbrazil, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)

Another angle of the ‘are we alone’ question is whether we’ll find them, or they’ll find us.

Assuming, again, that ‘they’ exist.

If we have neighbors who are even remotely like us, then I figure they may find us. Unless we’re the first people in this universe.

If the ‘remotely like us’ neighbors were only a million years older than us, then odds are good that they’ve long since started exploring this galaxy. And may have at least left a probe near our star.

Which reminds me of this bit of clear thinking regarding extraterrestrial intelligence.

“I been readin’ ’bout how maybe they is planets peopled by folks with ad-vanced brains. On the other hand, maybe we got the most brains…maybe our intellects is the universe’s most ad-vanced. Either way, it’s a mighty soberin’ thought.”
(Porky Pine, in Walt Kelly’s Pogo (June 20, 1959) via Wikiquote)

I think Porky Pine’s right, and that the inspiration of “a mighty soberin’ thought” isn’t necessarily a threat.

Whether and how much we should fear “folks with ad-vanced brains” — is more than I want to talk about to day. So I’ll save that topic for another day.


Agents and Angels

James Tissot's 'The Angel Seated on the Stone of the Tomb.' (ca. 1890)The Omega energy beings in that Greek-letter list remind me of the Matthew 28 angel.

“His appearance was like lightning and his clothing was white as snow.”
(Matthew 28:3)

But I emphatically do not think space aliens are angels.

Or that angels are “energy beings.”

Before I tie myself in semantic knots, I’d better define my terms.

“Angel” comes from a Greek word that means messenger.

The Greek word is a translation from Hebrew malʾāḵ, which also means messenger.

In a way, anyone who serves as a messenger or agent for God is an “angel.” St. Augustine of Hippo, and others, talked about that.14

But humans aren’t angels. Not the way Gabriel and Raphael are.

People, But Profoundly Different

On the other hand, angels and humans have much in common. We’re both people: creatures with intelligence and free will.

But we’re made from spirit, “created in the image of God,” and made with the stuff of this world. We live in time and space. (Genesis 1:27, 2:7; Catechism, 302, 355-373)

They’re made of pure spirit. And, although they can and do interact with us, they aren’t limited to our space-time. (Catechism, 328-336)

We’ve known about angels for millennia. Some of humanity’s best minds have studied them.

But we know very little about them. I figure that’s partly because they’re so profoundly not like us. Those hypothetical Omega energy beings, by comparison, would be close cousins. Which gets me into mass-energy equivalence and ontology.15

And tells me that it’s time for me wrap this up.

After adding the usual links to somewhat-related stuff:


1 Allegory and Bunyan’s tale:

2 Five Million Years to Martian Nazis:

3 Perceptions & problems:

4 Pax Britannica, mostly:

5 Slow progress:

6 Outlooks, opinions:

7 Views of a dunghill:

8 Shining Ones, 1977:

9 SS Cotopaxi, real and imagined:

10 Beliefs:

11 More beliefs:

12 Possible, yes; likely, no:

13 Serious, maybe; science, no:

14 Angels, very briefly:

15 Stuff I’m not talking about today:

Posted in Discursive Detours, Exoplanets and Aliens, Series | Tagged , , , , , | 6 Comments