Bogs and Bison

The good news is that bison are back in Banff, and Britain’s bogs may bounce back, too. Keeping wetlands wet isn’t what many folks had in mind, back in my youth.

But as I keep saying, we’ve learned quite a bit since then.

  1. Saving Britain’s Bogs?
  2. Banff Bison Rebound

This post’s afterword is a quick look at how folks have perceived natural resources, plus a bit about pessimism and being human:


Stewardship and Learning Wisdom

I agree with God’s assessment: this world is “very good.” Basically. So are we: basically. The first of us made an appalling decision that broke our original harmony. (Genesis 1:31; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 355, 364, 374–379, 396–401)

That makes it hard to do what is right, and that’s another topic. (November 6, 2016)

Humanity is created in the image of God, rational creatures whose nature includes curiosity. We’re supposed to notice beauty and order in the universe, learn its natural laws, and use that knowledge: wisely. (Genesis 1:26–27, 2:7; Catechism, 16, 341, 373, 1704, 1730–1731, 2293)

Part of our job is managing this world and its resources: for our reasoned use, and for future generations. (Catechism, 2415–2418, 2456)

Our “dominion” is not ownership. God owns this place. We’re stewards, a position that comes with authority and responsibilities. (Genesis 1:29, 2:15; Catechism, 306–308, 2293)

We’ve got free will; so acting responsibly is an option, not a requirement. (Catechism, 311, 396, 1704, 1730)

Increasingly-effective tools we’ve developed over the last few centuries made the Green Revolution possible. Also killer fog and the Boston Molasses Disaster.

Fearing science and technology isn’t reasonable. Learning wisdom is. (January 20, 2017; July 22, 2016)

Don’t Blame the Tools

I said earlier that I think this world is basically good. That doesn’t mean I think it is “safe.” There are hazards here.

St. Thomas Aquinas had a few words to say about living in a world where we can get hurt. Quite a few, actually:

“In the words of Augustine (Super. Gen. contr. Manich. i): ‘If an unskilled person enters the workshop of an artificer he sees in it many appliances of which he does not understand the use, and which, if he is a foolish fellow, he considers unnecessary. Moreover, should he carelessly fall into the fire, or wound himself with a sharp-edged tool, he is under the impression that many of the things there are hurtful; whereas the craftsman, knowing their use, laughs at his folly. And thus some people presume to find fault with many things in this world, through not seeing the reasons for their existence. For though not required for the furnishing of our house, these things are necessary for the perfection of the universe.’ And, since man before he sinned would have used the things of this world conformably to the order designed, poisonous animals would not have injured him.”
(“The Summa Theologica,” First Part, Question 72; St. Thomas Aquinas [emphasis mine])

“…Now action is properly ascribed, not to the instrument, but to the principal agent, as building is ascribed to the builder, not to his tools. Hence it is evident that use is, properly speaking, an act of the will….”
(“The Summa Theologica,” First Part of the Second Part, Question 16, Article 1; St. Thomas Aquinas)
(translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province (Benziger Bros. edition, 1947))

St. Thomas Aquinas was quoting St. Augustine of Hippo. Falling into a fire or getting cut isn’t a good idea. But if a dummkopf wanders into a workshop and gets hurt — it isn’t the fire’s fault, or the sharp-edged tool’s.

I think the principle can be extended to all tech. When using our tools leads to unintended and unpleasant results, blaming the tools doesn’t make sense. Re-evaluating how we’re using them, and what we’re trying to do, does.


1. Saving Britain’s Bogs?


(From BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The team carried out the laboratory experiments using lowland peatland agricultural soil and crops of radishes”
(BBC News))

“Boosting water table can curb climate risks, says study”
Mark Kinver, BBC News (February 6, 2017)

“Increasing the water table under the UK’s arable peatland can help boost yields and the amount of carbon stored in the soil, a study has suggested.

“University of Sheffield researchers are encouraging farmers to increase the water table to 30cm under the surface, rather than the recommended 50cm.

“Under current practices, the nation’s farmed peatlands could be lost by the end of the century, they add.

“The findings appear in the Science of the Total Environment journal….”

I suppose peatland or sounds better than mire, bog, or fen, but all mean land that’s saturated with water and doesn’t have trees growing on it. Add trees, and we call it a swamp. In my ‘good old days,’ swamps and mires were mostly places to ignore or drain.

We’ve learned a lot since then, and I’m sure there is a great deal left to learn.

The old ‘ignore it or drain it’ attitude made some sense, before we learned what they do.

Bogs and fens are great places to live for critters like frogs and herons. Humans, not so much. Folks who wander into wetlands don’t always come out, particularly if they follow a will-o’-the-wisp, and that’s yet another topic.

For botanists and ecologists “peatland” is any terrain that’s mostly peat, down to a depth of at least 30 centimeters, 12 inches: even if it’s been drained.

Peat is what we get when organic stuff doesn’t quite decay. Given time, it would become coal. Folks have used it as a fuel, and still do.

I’ve read that burning peat caused the 1997 Southeast Asian haze, and that fires from slash-and-burn agriculture were to blame. I couldn’t find much data about the mess, but the 1997 Indonesian forest fires were spectacular.

Peatlands are found around the world, covering about 3% of Earth’s land: something like 4,000,000 square kilometers, 1,500,000 square miles. That’s a lot of swamp and mire.

It looks like peatlands hold and process something like a third of the carbon in Earth’s soil, and around 10% of the world’s fresh water.

That makes them an important part of life on Earth. We’ve learned that much since my youth. Ecology and environmental science emerged as distinct disciplines in the last century. So like I said, there is a great deal left to learn.1

Raising the Water Table: Possible?


(© Copyright Barbara Cook)
(“Greylake sluice on King’s Sedgemoor Drain”
(Wikipedia))

“…Peatlands are widely recognised as important habitats in need of preserving because they are a carbon-rich landscape, estimated to hold half of England’s soil carbon.

“However, they also are an important component of the UK farming landscape.

“Mr Musarika observed: ‘We want to maintain food production because we know the population is growing.

“‘We are realising that it is important to keep not just food but it is also important to maintain the peatlands because if we lose them then we will lose more carbon storage capabilities.’

“Co-author Prof Walter Oechel from the University of Exeter said the findings were important because climate change mitigation was a dominant fixture on the global policy table….”
(Mark Kinver, BBC News)

Hats off to Mark Kinver and BBC News, for not presenting this as a choice between either feeding folks or protecting a presumably-delicate Mother Nature. I’ve talked about Earth’s ecosystem, the last few billion years, and Captain Planet, before. (August 12, 2016)

Assuming that raising the water table by 20 centimeters under farmed peatland is a good idea, is it possible?

I think the answer is “yes.” Folks have been managing water levels in farmland for a long time. Probably not as long as we’ve been planting crops, though.

We don’t know exactly how and why folks near the Mediterranean’s east end started planting crops, roughly 11 millennia back.

The Holocene climatic optimum started about the same time, flooding Doggerland and — probably — making the Neolithic Revolution possible and/or necessary.2

Scientists sometimes call the Holocene climatic optimum the Atlantic period. It’s the moistest Blytt-Sernander period, pollen zone and chronozone during the Holocene in northern Europe.

Don’t bother trying to remember all those names, unless you’re a science geek, maybe.

The point is that Earth had been a lot colder, then it got a bit warmer, than it is today, and that’s when we developed agriculture. (January 20, 2017)

Oddly enough, I haven’t seen anyone blame neolithic farmers for ending the last glacial maximum and creating the Sahara Desert.

Irrigation: Still Learning

Someone developed the first irrigation system, almost certainly within a few hours flight time from Lachish.

Not that airlines existed back then. Nobody’s lived in Lachish since Alexander the Great’s time and that’s yet again another topic.

Where was I? Beauty, order, radishes, neolithic farmers. Right.

Irrigation goes back a long time. Sunshu Ao designed dams and reservoirs during the Zhou’s Spring and Autumn period, Ximen Bao did the same in the Warring States period. And yes, things can be worse than the recent American election.

Amenemhat III, he and Erra-imitti were roughly contemporary, probably used the Faiyum Oasis as a reservoir. Nubians had been using sakia, a sort of waterwheel, before that; someone in ancient Persia may have done the first irrigating.

Or maybe it was someone else, somewhere else.

Bottom line, folks have been managing water resources for a long time. We’re getting pretty good at it. We’re also learning to avoid irrigation’s technical, legal, and environmental problems.

That doesn’t make irrigation bad, or good. It’s just another tool we’ve developed. Learning to use it wisely and well is up to us.


2. Banff Bison Rebound


(From Parks Canada; via Reuters, BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Bison returned to Banff last week after an absence of more than 100 years”
(BBC News))

“Bison return to Banff national park in Canada”
BBC News (February 6, 2017)

“A herd of plains bison have been successfully reintroduced to Canada’s oldest national park, more than 100 years after they were nearly hunted out of existence.

“The 16 bison were moved to the Banff National Park in Alberta last week.

“On Monday officials said the transfer had gone smoothly and the animals were adapting well to their new home.

“The move will restore their role in the park’s ecosystem, officials say, and has been welcomed by indigenous groups.

“The bison will be kept under observation in an enclosed pasture of the park in the foothills of the Rockies until the summer of 2018, Parks Canada officials say….”

Hunting the American bison to near-extinction was among my civilization’s more egregious lapses in judgement of the late 19th century. By 1900, an estimated bison population of about 60,000,000 was down to a few hundred.

That was then, this is now, and we’ve learned that natural resources aren’t infinite. I’ll get back to that. The American bison population is up to about 360,000 now: although some of the critters aren’t, or aren’t quite, purebred bison.

Critters with three-eighths bison DNA are beefalo, and generally look more like the Bos Taurus cattle we’re used to. First-generation B. Taurus-bison hybrids generally look like buffalo.3

Folks who say that American bison with a bit of Bos taurus DNA aren’t “real” bison have a point. On the other hand, maybe it’s a good thing that many of today’s critters are a trifle more genetically diverse than survivors of that population bottleneck.

I’ve opined on bulldogs, racial purity, and the Habsburgs, before. (January 13, 2017; August 5, 2016)

The American bison won’t be galloping across North America’s windswept prairies again. Not any time soon, apart from some areas we’ve set aside for colorful critters. Vast herds of bison and cropland wouldn’t get along.

That said, I’m glad that we gained a measure of wisdom in time to save the bison. The dodo and passenger pigeon were another story: so far.

Getting a Grip About the Walghvogel

My guess is that you read about the dodo in high school, or ran into the story in a discussion of endangered species. It’s a classic tale of man’s inhumanity to bird.

Heedless of their peril, the story goes, innocent dodos of Mauritius fell before the relentless onslaught of vicious club-wielding sailors.

The tale has an element of truth. Humans have eaten dodos, which most likely explains a Dutch name for them: walghvogel — “tasteless/insipid/sickly-bird.” Humans are omnivores, so we can eat just about anything.

But we do have our preferences, and dodo apparently wasn’t one of them.

Writhing in agony over the evils of man is still an option, though, since humans introduced egg-eating critters to Mauritius. Scientists have suggested that the dodo declined because dogs, pigs, cats, rats, and crab-eating macaques, ate their eggs.

I think the passenger pigeon’s demise makes a more convincing narrative.

Remembering the Passenger Pigeon


(From Smith Bennett, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(A passenger pigeon hunt, from The Illustrated Shooting and Dramatic News (July 3, 1875))

When the 19th century began, the passenger pigeon was the most common bird in North America: maybe in the world.

From the Rocky Mountains to the east coast, from the Gulf Coast to Lake Winnipeg and Lake Nipigon, they filled the sky:

“…The air was literally filled with Pigeons; the light of noon-day was obscured as by an eclipse….”
(“Ornithological biography…,” pp. 319–327John James Audubon, via Wikipedia)

That was in 1813.

Unlike the dodo, humans think passenger pigeons taste good. More accurately, we did. That may help explain a pre-16th-century close call they had with extinction: and conservation procedures developed by folks who were here before Columbus.

America’s Gilded Age was a good time for at least some northern factory owners and workers. We’ve learned quite a bit since then, but not in time for passenger pigeons.

Cutting down a great deal of this continent’s forests, and industrial-level hunting, made the passenger pigeon what we now call an endangered species by the 1880s.

Some laws intended to protect the birds resulted in the arrest of a few non-wealthy trappers, and that was about it. I give them and “E” for effort.

Audubon said that he’d sent 350 passenger pigeons to assorted English nobles. The London Zoo had a few on display at one point. At the start of the 20th century, there were three known flocks of captive passenger pigeons: in Milwaukee, Chicago, and Cincinnati.

Then, on September 1, 1914, the last known passenger pigeon, named Martha, died in the Cincinnati Zoo.

The good news is that we’ve still got a bit of passenger pigeon DNA. No one sample is complete, but piecing then together should be possible. Reviving the species may be a bit beyond what we can do today: but not by much.4

The real challenge may be in raising enough passenger pigeons at one time to re-start the species. Passenger pigeons were very social birds.

Some of 19th century in America was bad news, like pre-lawsuit hydraulic mining, extinction of the passenger pigeon, and near-extinction of the American bison. But it wasn’t all bad.

A remarkable number of folks in America finally decided that slavery was a bad idea. New technologies like antiseptics and the McCormick reaper helped reduce the number of folks killed by epidemics, famines, and doctors. (October 30, 2016)

On the other hand, some folks got the notion that science and technology will solve all our problems, which I think is as daft as assuming the opposite.5


Perceptions and Resources


(From NASA, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center’s map of Earth, from satellite images.)

Back in my ‘good old days,’ which I don’t miss, I’d occasionally read about Earth’s “infinite” resources.

That’s daft. Earth is a pretty big place, about 8,000 miles across, but infinite it’s not. The universe we live in, maybe, cosmologists aren’t sure about that.

If the mean spatial curvature of space-time is zero or negative, the universe has infinite volume. Maybe. That’s one of the many questions we didn’t know existed a few centuries back, and we’re still working on the answer(s). (January 29, 2017; September 30, 2016)

Getting back to resources and perceptions, folks like John Filson were probably trying to encourage others to settle in places like Kentucky:

“…Many mills are already built on this stream, some of which are represented in the map, and will have a plentiful supply of water in the dryest seasons. … Here is great plenty of fine cane, on which the cattle feed, and grow fat….”
(“The Discovery, Settlement and Present State of Kentucke,” John Filson (1784) via Libraries at University of Nebraska-Lincoln)

Real estate marketing isn’t quite so lyrical these days, but I think it’s just as optimistic.

Anything involving people is seldom, if ever, simple; but I’ll try to avoid leaving out major points of the last few centuries.

Folks started coming to North America in wholesale lots somewhere around the 1830s. Immigration has had ups and downs since then. It still gives some folks conniptions, but not me. (February 1, 2017; January 22, 2017; November 29, 2016)

Folks like George Perkins Marsh and John Muir realized that cutting down trees without planting new ones is a bad idea.6

Folks started paying attention a bit before last passenger pigeon died, but I think it wasn’t until the 1960s that many got the message. Stewart Udall arguably gets some credit for the turnaround.

“…The modern land raiders, like the public-land raiders of another era, are ready to justify short-term gains by seeking to minimize the long-term losses. ‘Present the repair bill to the next generation’ has always been their unspoken slogan….”
(“The Quiet Crisis,” Stewart L. Udall (1963) via the Intenet Archive)

By then the notion that science and technology will solve all our problems had worn thin.7

Today’s Needs: and Tomorrow’s

From the International Space Station program and the JSC Earth Science & Remote Sensing Unit, ARES Division, Exploration Integration Science Directorate. ISS007-E-10807 (21 July 2003) - This view of Earth's horizon as the sunsets over the Pacific Ocean was taken by an Expedition 7 crewmember onboard the International Space Station (ISS).Thinking only of myself, or today’s desires, isn’t an option. Private ownership is a good idea, and so is using natural resources: within reason. But when I use today’s resources, I must remember the needs of future generations. (Catechism, 2401, 2415, 2456)

I’ve talked about the universal destination of goods before. (September 25, 2016)

Assuming that irresponsibility is okay because someone will invent a gadget tomorrow that will solve today’s problems doesn’t, I think, make sense.

That’s particularly true if we can at least start learning how to solve the problems now.

I also think that taking time to think through solutions makes sense.

Until the mid-20th century, for example, forest managers assumed that wildfires were always a bad thing.

That started changing in the 1960s, when folks noticed that no new giant sequoia were growing. It took time, but now fire is recognized as an important part of a forest’s life cycle.

My guess is that we still don’t know everything there is to know about life on Earth. But we’re learning.

Pessimism’s Persistent Popularity

I’m not sure why pessimism has such durable popularity.

Maybe it goes back to the days when Greco-Roman doctors figured there were four personalty types: sanguine, choleric, melancholic, and phlegmatic. Folks who were “melancholic” were analytical, wise and quiet.

That’s not a bad set of qualities.

Something like two dozen centuries later, we’ve learned a bit, and words have changed. In my language, melancholy means a persistently gloomy state of mind, or depression.

Along the way, melancholia has been seen as a disease, demonic possession, and an art movement. That last could explain some angsty artist wannabes. Having lived with it for decades, I see nothing ‘artistic’ or attractive about depression, and that’s still another topic. (October 5, 2016; September 4, 2016)

I’m pretty sure that gloominess is not next to Godliness. We’re supposed to desire happiness, and hope is a virtue. (Catechism, 33, 1718, 1817)

Still Learning


(From WiNG, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)

Over the last million years, we’ve learned to use fire without killing ourselves. But it’s still not a “safe” technology.

Cities don’t burn as regularly as they once did, but urban fires happen: like the Edinburgh Cowgate fire and Lac-Mégantic derailment. We’re fine-tuning building codes, and learning that following pesky rules about storing flammable material is a good idea.

The trick is using humanity’s accumulated wisdom, and applying it to everyday life. Most of the time, we do a pretty good job: my opinion.

Sometimes mistakes are made. Then, most of the time, we clean up the mess and move on.

The problem isn’t the tech: it’s us.

“For mischief comes not out of the earth, nor does trouble spring out of the ground;
“2 But man himself begets mischief, as sparks fly upward.”
(Job 5:6–7)

The good news is that we are still learning, getting smarter: and perhaps a little wiser.

Somewhat-related posts:


1 Bogs, fens, swamps, and all that:

2 Climate and agriculture background, the most recent 10 millennia:

3 The fall and rise of American bison:

4 Extinct birds:

5 More of my take on science, technology, and being human:

6 Wood actually does grow on trees. Tree farms are part of Minnesota’s economy, and we’re not alone. A very partial list:

7 Resources and perceptions:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Natural Law, Our Rules

Back in my ‘good old days,’ a half-century back, some claimed that science, technology, and a changing culture, made the ‘outmoded morality’ we’d been working with obsolete.

Others apparently believed that moral decay was caused by newfangled gadgets like the telephone and television: and, of course, ‘Satanic’ rock music.

About rock music, I agreed that many songs were an attack on society’s values:

“…Creature comfort goals
They only numb my soul
And make it hard for me to see….”
“Pleasant Valley Sunday” (1967)
The Monkees, via lyrics.wikia.com

But I was one of those crazy kids who thought buying stuff you don’t need with money you don’t have to impress folks you don’t like — made no sense. And that’s another topic.

Folks who claimed that a changing world made ‘conventional morality’ obsolete were right: sort of.

That may seem odd, coming from a Catholic who agrees with Fulton Sheen:

“Right is right if nobody is right, and wrong is wrong if everybody is wrong.”
(“Life Is Worth Living” (1951-1957), Program 19, The Venerable Fulton J. Sheen, via Wikiquotes)

I’m quite sure that “right is right” in all places and all times, and that the rules we use occasionally need changing: like when horses are no longer the fastest things on the road.

EEK! The Devil!!!

The trouble started around 1672, when Ferdinand Verbiest, a Jesuit missionary, designed a steam-powered vehicle for the Kangxi Emperor.

Verbiest’s notes say the ‘car’ would have been 65 centimeters, 25.6 inches, long: too small for practical use. We don’t know if the prototype was ever built.

The design may have been based on the aeolipiles of Vitruvius and Hero of Alexandria, with an open steam turbine added.

Fast-forward to 1769. Nicolas-Joseph Cugnot’s fardier à vapeur/steam dray may not have knocked down a wall, but it didn’t pass the test-drive stage.

Cugnot was rewarded for his innovative work, and the fardier was eventually moved to the Conservatoire national des arts et métiers.

William Murdoch built a working prototype “road locomotive” in 1784. James Watt and Matthew Boulton said it wasn’t practical, and that’s yet another topic. Topics.

“…One story often told, … is that one night Murdoch decided to test his carriage outside on the open road and it soon outpaced him, leaving him to chase after it. Whilst chasing it he encountered a local clergyman in a state of considerable distress who had mistaken his carriage, with its billowing smoke and fire burning under the boiler, for the devil. This story may be accurate, however is more likely to relate to a model than to a full size steam carriage….”
(“William Murdoch: Steam Carriage,” Grace’s Guide to British Industrial History)

The “local clergyman” wasn’t the only one upset by new ideas and tech in the 1700s. I’ve talked about ‘affronts’ to the Almighty like lightning rods and smallpox inoculations, and a Pope’s response to “a precious discovery,” before. (October 16, 2016; August 21, 2016)

New Circumstances, New Rules


(Amédée Bollée’s L’Obéissante, 1875)

Steam-powered road vehicles apparently gave some folks conniptions, so the United Kingdom’s Parliament started churning out Locomotove Acts in 1861. The best-remembered one may be the Red Flag Act of 1865.1

That’s the one requiring a crew of three for each self-propelled vehicle: a driver; a stoker; and a man with a red flag walking at least 60 yards, 55 meters, ahead. They could legally scoot along at four miles an hour, two in towns.

Legislators in America passed similar laws, but the genie was already out of the bottle.

Dr. J.W. Carhart’s 1871 steam-powered vehicle led to the State of Wisconsin’s 1875 offer of $10,000 reward for the first practical substitute for the use of horses and other animals. The Legislature awarded half of the prize in 1879.

Amédée Bollée developed and started building steam-powered road vehicles in 1873.

Lawmakers on both sides of the Atlantic eventually realized that red flags and a four mile an hour speed limit were impractical, unnecessary, and more than a little ridiculous.

Ideas behind the regulations weren’t completely daft, though. We still have vehicle registration, registration plates, speed limits,2 and maximum vehicle weights.

Some of the ideas behind the Roman Republic’s multi-tier status system made sense, too.

Isus Positum, Positive Law: Human-Made Rules

Under ancient Roman law, a person’s status mattered. Someone could be a Roman citizen (status civitatis); free (status libertatis); have a position in a Roman family (status familiae) as head (pater familias), or some lower member; or someone living by another law (alieni iuris).

Below the rest were slaves: but they weren’t persons, not legally.

That last was not a basically sound idea. Treating a person like merchandise is a bad idea and we shouldn’t to it. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2414)

These days, American law recognizes differences between citizens born here and naturalized citizens, foreign visitors, minors and adults. How folks should be treated has been debated since before the Second Continental Congress.

We aren’t all alike, and aren’t supposed to be. Recognizing those differences makes sense. Ignoring our equal dignity doesn’t. (Catechism, 1934-1938, 2334)

The Roman Republic’s system wasn’t perfect, but it worked for five centuries before the Senate bollixed things up to the point where they needed an emperor.

America’s system has been working for nearly 227 years, 240 if you count the Articles of Confederation. It’s not perfect, either, which is why we’re still fine-tuning it.

Roman and American laws are an examples of ius positum, or positive law: human-made laws that define how folks may act, and what rights we have.

The ‘conventional morality’ that some folks got fed up with in ‘the good old days’ was positive law: something that folks, mostly Anglo-Saxon Protestant men, had concocted.

Like Roman law, it had worked pretty well. But by the 1960s, that system of positive law was long overdue for overhaul.

I do not miss living in a society where “she’s as smart as a man” was supposed to be a compliment, and a person had to look like me to get a decent job. I remember the ‘good old days:’ and they weren’t.

Lex Naturalis, Natural Law: Universal Principles, Changing Applications

Folks at least as far back as Plato and Aristotle discussed what we call natural law, lex naturalis.

I’m Catholic, so I accept St. Thomas Aquinas’ idea that natural law is universal, unchanging, and designed by God. (Catechism, 1952-1960)

Natural law is ‘programmed’ into us, part of reality that we can understand through reason. It lets us recognize good and evil, truth and lies. (Catechism, 1954)

Natural law does not change. Doing evil so that good will follow is never acceptable. The Golden Rule always applies; we must always respect our neighbor, and our neighbor’s conscience. (Matthew 7:12; Catechism, 1789, 1958)

How natural law is applied varies a great deal. Folks in different cultures and eras face different circumstances. But the underlying principles of natural law do not change. (Catechism, 1957)

Ideally, following natural law would be easy. We would all love God, love our neighbor, and see everyone as our neighbor; and act accordingly. (Matthew 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Matthew 5:43–44; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 10:25–30; Catechism, 1825)

We do not live in an ideal world.

When the first of us decided to break God’s rule, we lost the harmony we had with God and with this world. We’ve been dealing with consequences of that decision ever since. (Catechism, 397-406)

But we are still human: made in the image of God, with responsibilities and the freedom to choose right or wrong. (Genesis 1:26–27; Catechism, 307, 355-361, 1701-1709, 1730, 1853, 2293-2295, 2415-2418)

Building a Better World

Positive law works best when it’s close to natural law, universal ethical principles built into the universe.

Positive law changes: and must change, as conditions we live in change.

Natural law is the same now as it was when Abram moved out of Ur.

Killing innocent people, for example, was wrong then. It will still be wrong when the Code of Hammurabi, United Nations Charter, and whatever comes next, are seen as roughly contemporary. (Catechism, 1954-1960, 2259-2262, 2268-2270)

Part of our job is bringing the positive laws of our cultures closer to natural law. (Catechism, 1928-1942)

I don’t think we’ll have a perfect society two millennia, or ten millennia, from now.

But if we keep working with all people of good will, keeping what is true and good in our societies, changing what is not, we have a reasonable hope of building a better world. We certainly must try:


1 More:

2 Speed limits vary, depending on where you are. Some roads, like some autobahns, have no speed limit, some parts of the United States only have speed limits if you get caught, and that’s yet again another topic. More:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Footprints in Ancient Ash

Scientists are pretty sure that Saccorhytus coronarius is an ancestor of lancets, sea squirts, fish, amphibians, reptiles, dinosaurs, and mammals: including us.

Much more recently, about 3,660,000 years back, five Australopithecus afarensis strolled across volcanic ash. One of them was “astonishingly larger” than any other A. afarensis we know of. Exactly what that means isn’t, I think, clear. Not yet.

  1. Tiny Critter, Big Mouth; and an Early Ancestor
  2. Footprints

Humility, Catholic Style

Humility, the Catholic version, is accepting reality and acknowledging that God’s God.

“HUMILITY: The virtue by which a Christian acknowledges that God is the author of all good. Humility avoids inordinate ambition or pride, and provides the foundation for turning to God in prayer (2559). Voluntary humility can be described as ‘poverty of spirit’ (2546).”
(Catechism of the Catholic Church, Glossary)

I’ve talked about humility, hubris, and getting a grip, before. (August 28, 2016; August 26, 2016; July 31, 2016)

Rejecting reality, avoiding truth, isn’t an option for me. Not if I take my faith seriously.

Faith, the Catholic version, is a willing and conscious “assent to the whole truth that God has revealed.” (Catechism, 142–150)

Truth, whether it’s expressed in words, “the rational expression of the knowledge of created and uncreated reality;” or “the order and harmony of the cosmos;” or in other ways — is important, and beautiful. (Catechism, Prologue, 27, 74, 2500, 2505, more under Truth in the index)

Noticing God’s infinite beauty reflected in “the world’s order and beauty” tells us a little about God. Again, if we’re paying attention. (Catechism, 31–32, 341)

A thirst for truth and happiness is written into each of us. If we’re doing our job right, it’ll lead us to God. (Catechism, 27)

I went over this last month, and almost certainly will again. (January 13, 2017)

Reality and Faith

There are some odd notions about faith and reason, science and religion, floating around. But I’m a Catholic, so using my brain is okay. It’s a requirement, actually. (Catechism, 154, 159, 1951, 1778, 2293)

I’ve said that before, too. Often. (December 23, 2016; December 9, 2016; October 5, 2016; August 28, 2016)

Basically, I think accepting reality makes sense: even if — particularly if — that means learning something new.


1. Tiny Critter, Big Mouth; and an Early Ancestor


(From Cambridge University, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Artist’s reconstruction of Saccorhytus coronarius, based on the original fossil finds. The actual creature was probably no more than a millimetre in size”
(BBC News))

(From Jian Han et al., via Nature, used w/o permission.)
(“Reconstruction of Saccorhytus coronarius … Lateral, hind and ventral views….”
(Jian Han et al., via Nature))

“Scientists find ‘oldest human ancestor’”
Pallab Ghosh, BBC News (January 30, 2017)

“Researchers have discovered the earliest known ancestor of humans – along with a vast range of other species.

“They say that fossilised traces of the 540-million-year-old creature are ‘exquisitely well preserved’.

“The microscopic sea animal is the earliest known step on the evolutionary path that led to fish and – eventually – to humans….”

Saccorhytus coronarius lived about 540,000,000 million years back, during the early Cambrian explosion. That was when most phyla we have today showed up.

A phylum is the taxonomic rank below kingdom and above class. Phyla can be define by genetic or body plan similarities, thinking of plants having a body plan seems odd, and that’s another topic.

“Taxonomy” is a five-dollar word for the habit we have of sorting critters into categories: like plant, animal, or fungus. We’ve probably been doing that since day one, but the current systems go back to Carl Linnaeus.

I’ve talked about taxonomy and what we’ve been learning since my high school years before. (September 23, 2016)

Artist’s reconstructions like the one in the BBC News piece help folks ‘see’ what scientists are talking about, but necessarily involve a little imagination. I doubt that we can be sure about the colors, for example.

On the other hand, these fossils really were remarkably well-preserved.

Identifying Parts


(From Jian Han et al., via Nature, used w/o permission.)
(“Saccorhytus was also covered with a thin, relatively flexible skin and muscles. It probably moved around by wriggling”
(BBC News))

(From Jian Han, Northwest University, China; via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Saccorhytus coronarius gen. et sp. nov. from the Cambrian Kuanchuanpu Formation, South China….”
(Jian Han et al., via Nature))

This is what the scientists had to work with. As I said, the level of detail is impressive, particularly since the critters were only about a millimeter across.

Jian Han and the rest are reasonably sure that the feature marked “M” is a mouth, and they’re pretty sure there weren’t any eyes.

Features other than the mouth almost certainly had some function, but exactly what they did is still a mystery. For now, they’re mostly labeled by what they look like.

Lbc1 through Lbc4 and Lbc1 through Lbc4 are the left (L) and right (R) body cones one through four, for example.

Now, about these critters being the “earliest known ancestor of humans.”

Saccorhytus coronarius is the the earliest-known deuterostome, a broad category of animals that have the same general pattern of embryonic development. Some scientists call it a superphylum, since it includes three phyla.1

Life on Earth has changed, a lot, over the last half-billion years, and that’s yet another topic.


2. Footprints


(From Dawid A. Iurino, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The footprints may have been made by a male walking with smaller females and juveniles”
(BBC News))

“Fossil footprints tell story of human origins”
Helen Briggs, BBC News (December 14, 2016)

“Footprints made by early humans millions of years ago have been uncovered in Tanzania close to where similar tracks were found in the 1970s.

“The impressions were made when some of our distant relatives walked together across wet volcanic ash.

“Their makers, most likely Australopithecus afarensis, appear to have had a wide range of body sizes.

“Scientists say this gives clues to how this ancient species of human lived….”

Australopithecus afarensis lived in east Africa between 3,900,000 and 2,900,000 years ago. I’m not sure whether they’re a ‘what’ or a ‘who,’ but I’m guessing it’s ‘who.’

“Lucy,” our name for a now-famous A. afarensis skeleton, was about 1.1 meters (3 feet 7 inches), tall and weighed around 29 kilograms (64 pounds).

That’s short by today’s standards, even in places like Bolivia and Indonesia, where women average 1.42 meters (4 feet 8 inches) and 1.47, meters (4 feet 10 inches).

I talked about Lucy and A. afarensis last year. (September 23, 2016)

What’s “average” depends on who you listen to, and where you are. I grew up among Norwegian- and German-Americans, so although I’m about “average” height for man, globally, I still think of myself as “short,” and that’s yet again another topic.

Anyway, the Australopithecus afarensis model was much shorter than today’s. They had slightly longer arms, for their height, than we do; and were probably a bit better at climbing trees. They walked like we do, though. The big differences were above the neck.

A. afaransis had room for about 380 to 430 cubic centimeters of brain. Today’s model, the European version at least, runs from about 975 to 1499 cubic centimeters.

Size isn’t everything, but my guess is that most if not all A. afarensis would have had a terrible time trying to pass their ACT or SAT: or blending into a crowd.

Tools and People

That doesn’t, I think, make them not-people.

The earliest stone tools we’ve found are about 3,300,000 years old and were in the same area.

Quite a few animals use tools, but it’s likely that A. afarensis made these.

They’re not up to the standards I’d expect to see in a Home Depot; but upwards of three million years later, I’d hope that we’d made some improvements.

Oldowan tools, like those choppers, came along later, about 600,000 years after Lucy’s day.

They were a leading technology in east Africa from around 2,600,000 to 1,700,000 years ago, before folks invented Acheulean tools in east and southern Africa

Oldowan tools were still in use a hundred thousand years after that, where northern China is today.

But the new tech eventually caught on, showing up in today’s France and China.

Oldowan choppers are like a hatchet without a handle.

They’re good for — well, for chopping — food, wood, or other softish materials.

An equivalent kitchen item is today’s mezzaluna. Obviously, the design has changed a bit over the last few million years.

I think it’s likely that “Lucy” was “human” in the sense of being a person.

It’s not just tool use or walking upright.

We’ve learned that ArhGAP11B, a gene that’s unique to humans, showed up roughly 5,000,000 years back. The gene affects brain size: particularly the neocortex.

Another uniquely-human ‘brain gene,’ SRGAP2, showed up later. (January 13, 2017; September 23, 2016)

Between making tools, looking a bit like us, and being around long after a uniquely-human gene appeared: yeah, I’m willing to think that “Lucy” may have been a person.2

“Astonishingly Larger”


(From Raffaella Pellizzon, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(The footprints were made in volcanic ash about 3,660,000 years ago)

“…The newly discovered footprints may have been made by a male walking with smaller females.

“‘This novel evidence, taken as a whole with the previous findings, portrays several early hominins moving as a group through the landscape following a volcanic eruption and subsequent rainfall. But there is more,’ said lead researcher Prof Giorgio Manzi, director of the archaeological project in Tanzania.

“‘The footprints of one of the new individuals are astonishingly larger than anyone else’s in the group, suggesting that he was a large male member of the species.

“‘In fact, the 165cm stature indicated by his footprints makes him the largest Australopithecus specimen identified to date.’…”
(Helen Briggs, BBC News)

“…A possible tentative conclusion is that the various individuals represented at Laetoli are: S1, a male; G2 and S2, females; G1 and G3, smaller females or juvenile individuals….”
(Fidelis T Masao et al, eLife3)

165 centimeters, 1.65 meters, 5 feet 5 inches, is taller than some men in my extended family. Either that individual was really tall by then-contemporary standards, or our sampling of A. afarensis is skewed: which is far from impossible.

We haven’t found all that many examples of A. afarensis.

Not all critters, people included, become fossils. I’m not convinced that our preferred habitats favor fossilization.

The habit of burying our dead might or might not help, particularly since that’s not the only option we’ve developed for dealing with death, and that’s still another topic. Topics. (November 11, 2016; September 23, 2016)

I’m reasonably sure that the five individuals were about as tall as the scientists say they were. We’ve learned a great deal about how critters, people included, move since Aristotle realized that animals can be viewed as mechanical systems.3

Analysis, Sexual Dimorphism, and Dignity

The size, depth, and spacing of the footprints tell us a lot: including how big the folks were, and how fast they were moving. In this case, they were all walking; slowly. The scientists got speeds of about 0.44 to 0.9 meters per second, depending on which analysis method they used.

That sort of analysis I’m pretty confident about.

Whether we’re looking at a family group that’s organized along ‘gorilla’ lines or not: that, I’m not so sure about.

We may learn that the Laetoli footprints were made by a good 50th percentile sample of the A. afarensis population. If they are, that model’s sexual dimorphism was probably a lot greater than today’s.

Sexual dimorphism is the (average) difference between males and females in a species.

Like most, but not all, primates, human males are bigger than females. My side of humanity, for example, is on average 15% heavier than my wife’s, and a bit taller.

That’s on average, of course. Humans aren’t particularly dimorphic, so I’ve known quite a few women who are taller than I am, and men who are around my wife’s height.

Screwball politics of the last few decades being what they are, I’d better say that I don’t think I’m better than folks who are shorter than I am. But I also think pretending that women and men are identical, apart from cultural conditioning, is daft.

We have equal dignity, and that’s — what else? — another topic. (Genesis 1:27; Catechism, 2334)

Assumptions

Getting back to the Laetoli footprints, assuming that those five individuals were all part of the same family seems reasonable.

Assuming they were typical of all A. afarensis, not so much. But maybe they were. That’s something that’ll be easier to figure out when we have more data.

For now, just looking at the footprints, we could be looking at all individuals in one family; where the father is much taller than the wife/wives and kids. That doesn’t make the family structure gorilla-like.

They could have been a family not unlike mine; where the son is the tallest, followed in descending order by the father, some of the kids, the mother, and another one of the kids.

Or they could be the mothers and kids from two or more families, being escorted across an ash field by “Tiny.” The other menfolk might figure they could trust Tiny to deal with any dangers along the way, and that their wives would keep him in line.

Besides, if they were scouting out a good place to stop for the night, the outsize one of their number might not have been a good choice for a ‘stealth’ mission.

I’ll grant that having a mostly-Irish father and five-foot-nothing black-haired ekte norsk mother gives me a particular viewpoint.

I’m quite sure there are other possible ways to look at the data: and that scientists will be discussing them.

Had enough? If not, there’s more:


1 More than you need, and possibly want, to know about:

2 Australopithecus afarensis, ‘brain genes,’ and humanity’s past:

3 Footprints and using our brains:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

Who is My Neighbor?

Folks were hanging around after an evening prayer service Sunday, when someone came into the building and started shooting. 19 of the 50-plus folks there were injured, five hospitalized in critical condition. Six are now dead:

  • Ibrahima Barry
  • Mamadou Tanou Barry
  • Khaled Belkacemi
  • Abdelkrim Hassane
  • Azzeddine Soufiane
  • Aboubaker Thabti

They were fathers, a grocer, a professor, civil servants, an IT worker: and like I said, now they’re dead.

I am not happy about that, at all.

This week’s news hasn’t been all bad. A GoFundMe page raising funds for the Islamic Center of Victoria, Texas, that burned last Saturday has collected upwards of $900,000 so far.1

I’ve never met the men who died Sunday night, I don’t know their families. The same goes for folks affected by Saturday’s fire. Why should I care what happens to them?

I’ve got reasons: some involving enlightened self-interest.

Love and the Samaritan

Between associating with tax collectors and other “sinners,” and making sense about what God had been saying, Jesus gave at least some of the Pharisees and Sadducees fits. One of our Lord’s run-ins with those pillars of the community shows up in Matthew 22:15–46.

That’s when a scholar of the law asked Jesus for the greatest commandment, and our Lord gave two:

“He said to him, 22 ‘You shall love the Lord, your God, with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.
“This is the greatest and the first commandment.
“The second is like it: 23 You shall love your neighbor as yourself.
“24 The whole law and the prophets depend on these two commandments.'”
(Matthew 22:37–40)

Those two ‘first’ Commandments show up in Luke 10:25–28, too. That time, the conversation is followed by the ‘good Samaritan’ story.

The Samaritan: An Unexpected ‘Good Guy’

Two millennia later, the shock of a Samaritan being the ‘good guy’ in this sort of story has worn off. Jews and Samaritans did not get along: at all.

These days, it’d be like telling a story in a redneck bar: where a coal miner, poor farmer, and truck driver wouldn’t help the accident victim; but a Muslim immigrant did.

“Love your neighbor” wasn’t a new idea:

“1 Take no revenge and cherish no grudge against your fellow countrymen. You shall love your neighbor as yourself. I am the LORD.”
(Leviticus 19:18)

Jesus wasn’t redefining “neighbor.” Our Lord was reminding anyone who would listen that principles outlined in Exodus 23:9 and Leviticus 19:33–34 still matter.

Humanity is a single — sadly dysfunctional — family.

Again, that’s not a new idea. Genesis 10:1–32 describes folks known by the ancient Israelites as descendants of Noah.

My ancestors aren’t included in the list: most likely. My family records don’t go back that far. Not nearly. That doesn’t mean I don’t exist, or that I’m a Cimmerian.

It’s another example of the Bible having been written by folks who didn’t have knowledge we’ve gathered so far: or will have when the 30th, 40th, and following centuries roll past.

When Genesis 10 was being transferred into writing, some 29 centuries back, my forebears were almost certainly living somewhere well north and west of the Ashkenaz. Where they were before settling in and near places later called Hibernia and Ánslo, I can’t be sure.

I’ve explained why I think Adam and Eve aren’t German, Earth isn’t flat, and all that, before. (September 23, 2016; August 28, 2016)

I also keep saying that since I take Jesus seriously, I think loving God, loving my neighbor, and seeing everybody as my neighbor, makes sense. (Matthew 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Matthew 5:43–44; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 10:25–30; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1825)

“Everybody” means everybody. No exceptions.

Weeping With Those Who Weep


(From Getty Images, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Khaled El Kacemi, vice-president of the Islamic Cultural Center of Quebec, grieves during a news conference”
(BBC News)

“6 Bless those who persecute (you), bless and do not curse them.
“Rejoice with those who rejoice, weep with those who weep.”
(Romans 12:14–15)

I haven’t been persecuted by folks in Quebec City. But I think it’s okay to weep with them, anyway; and rejoice that the folks in Victoria, Texas, are getting help rebuilding.

I also weep for Alexandre Bissonnette, the young man who apparently killed those folks.2

I think what he’s accused of doing is very wrong, but like I keep saying, “everybody” means “everybody.” (January 11, 2017; November 15, 2016; September 20, 2016)

I shouldn’t pick and choose who I see as a real person. The divine image is in each of us; no matter who we are, who our ancestors are, or what we’ve done. (Genesis 1:27; Catechism, 357, 361, 369–370, 1700, 1730, 2268–2269, 1929, 2273–2274, 2276–2279)

Apparently Mr. Bissonnette has been studying political science and anthropology, and plays chess.

I don’t think that’s a good reason to hate political science majors and anthropologists, or outlaw chess.

Hating any person is a bad idea, and I shouldn’t do it.

I can’t love my neighbor and hate my neighbor. That doesn’t mean I need to like what my neighbor does.

Forgiving is a good idea, pretending that an injustice never happened would be crazy, and I’ve talked about that before. Also respecting the “transcendent dignity” of humanity and working for justice. (Catechism, 976–980, 1929–1933, 2820)

Indulging in the verbal equivalent of leaving a pig’s head on someone’s front steps3 — is a bad idea on several levels.

So would be letting myself start hating folks who indulge in vandalism and similar acts of self-expression at Catholic Churches.4

On the ‘up’ side, it could be worse. Father James Coyle‘s execution in 1921 was, by some standards, justified. Hours before his death, he had performed a wedding between a Ku Klux Klan member’s son and a Puerto Rican.

I don’t see a problem with ‘mixed marriages’ like that: but I’m about half Irish: and that’s another topic. (January 13, 2017)

Why the Rights of Muslims Matter to This Catholic

The Catholic Church teaches that freedom of religion is important. (Catechism, 2104–2109)

That’s religious freedom for everybody. (Catechism, 2106)

Defending the rights of non-dominant folks to practice religion as they see fit is the right thing to do. It’s also, I think, simple self-interest.

Although there are over a billion Catholics in today’s world, here in America my faith makes me part of a religious minority. Some Americans apparently feel that what America needs is fewer Catholics: and none in “their” country.

I don’t think that all Protestants share the Pillar of Fire Church’s view of Catholics. (January 22, 2017)

I also don’t think that all Muslims are terrorists.

I’ve heard and read some fairly wild claims about ‘those Muslims over there.’

They remind me of what radio preachers and others were saying about ‘those Catholics over there’ in my youth.

Vendors of malignant virtue5 indirectly helped me become a Catholic, and that’s yet another topic.

Defending the rights of others as a way to defend one’s own rights is a point made in “First They Came….”

Martin Niemöller, a German pastor, is credited with writing the poem: or speech, depending on which version you’re reading.

Over the decades I’ve seen rewrites of “First they Came” that were politically correct, some reflecting a conservative viewpoint.

The more imaginative versions I read a few years back aren’t online any more. I figure that folks who put them up changed their minds and deleted that page, or lost interest and closed their site. But more — colorful? — explanations are possible.6

All versions have the same basic message.

“First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Socialist.
Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Trade Unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”
(Martin Niemöller: “First They Came for the Socialists…”, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum)

“There were no minutes or copy of what I said, and it may be that I formulated it differently. But the idea was anyhow: The communists, we still let that happen calmly; and the trade unions, we also let that happen; and we even let the Social Democrats happen. All of that was not our affair. The Church did not concern itself with politics at all at that time, and it shouldn’t have anything do with them either. In the Confessing Church we didn’t want to represent any political resistance per se, but we wanted to determine for the Church that that was not right, and that it should not become right in the Church, that’s why already in ’33, when we created the pastors’ emergency federation (Pfarrernotbund), we put as the 4th point in the founding charter: If an offensive is made against ministers and they are simply ousted as ministers, because they are of Jewish lineage (Judenstämmlinge) or something like that, then we can only say as a Church: No. And that was then the 4th point in the obligation, and that was probably the first contra-anti-antisemitic pronouncement coming from the Protestant Church.”
(The Martin-Niemöller-Foundation “classical” version of a 1976 speech, via Wikipedia)

“When Pastor Niemöller was put in a concentration camp we wrote the year 1937; when the concentration camp was opened we wrote the year 1933, and the people who were put in the camps then were Communists. Who cared about them? We knew it, it was printed in the newspapers.
“Who raised their voice, maybe the Confessing Church? We thought: Communists, those opponents of religion, those enemies of Christians – ‘should I be my brother’s keeper?’
“Then they got rid of the sick, the so-called incurables. – I remember a conversation I had with a person who claimed to be a Christian. He said: Perhaps it’s right, these incurably sick people just cost the state money, they are just a burden to themselves and to others. Isn’t it best for all concerned if they are taken out of the middle [of society]? — Only then did the church as such take note. Then we started talking, until our voices were again silenced in public. Can we say, we aren’t guilty/responsible? The persecution of the Jews, the way we treated the occupied countries, or the things in Greece, in Poland, in Czechoslovakia or in Holland, that were written in the newspapers.
“I believe, we Confessing-Church-Christians have every reason to say: mea culpa, mea culpa! We can talk ourselves out of it with the excuse that it would have cost me my head if I had spoken out.”
(Partial translation of Niemöller’s speech for the Confessing Church in Frankfurt on 6 January 1946, via Wikipedia)

Catholics in America probably won’t be herded into internment camps in the immediate future, or fined if we try to hold office. But I think history strongly suggests that ‘my end of the boat isn’t sinking’ isn’t a reasonable position.

Uniting in Prayer

I’m a Catholic, and take my faith seriously. That’s why I must recognize the “goodness and truth” in all religions that search for God. (Catechism, 39–43, 839–845)

It’s also why the Pope’s urging us to unite in prayer with our Muslim neighbors isn’t a surprise, or shouldn’t be:

“…Pope Francis stressed the importance of for all, Christians and Muslims, to be united in prayer….
“…The full text of the telegram, written in French, is provided below in an English translation…

“Most Eminent Cardinal Gérald Cyprien LaCroix
“Having learned of the attack which occurred in Quebec in a prayer room of the Islamic Cultural Centre, which claimed many victims, His Holiness Pope Francis entrusts to the mercy of God the persons who lost their lives and he associates himself through prayer with the pain of their relatives. He expresses his profound sympathy for the wounded and their families, and to all who contributed to their aid, asking the Lord to bring them comfort and consolation in the ordeal. The Holy Father again strongly condemns the violence that engenders such suffering; and, imploring God for the gift of mutual respect and peace, he invokes upon the sorely tried families, and upon all persons touched by this tragedy, as well as upon all Quebecers, the benefits of the divine Blessing.
“Cardinal Pietro Parolin
“Secretary of State of His Holiness”

(from Vatican Radio)

Asking “for the gift of mutual respect and peace” makes sense to me — particularly considering the alternative.

Somewhat-related posts:


1 This week:

2 The accused:

3 Last year, a pig’s head:

4 From last year’s news:

5 From a fictional discussion of dope runners and their victims:

“There are times, Charles, when even the unimaginative decency of my brother and the malignant virtue of his wife appear to me admirable.”
(Lord Peter Wimsey, in Murder Must Advertise, Dorothy L. Sayers (1933))

6 Conspiracy stories can be entertaining, in fiction, but are a poor substitute for reality:

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Making a Universe: Why Bother?

“The heavens declare the glory of God; the sky proclaims its builder’s craft.”
(Psalms 19:2)

Okay, so who is this message proclaimed to?

Us, apparently.

One of the ways we can learn about God is by noticing order and beauty in the universe. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 31–32, 319)

St. Bonaventure said that the universe communicates God’s glory, St. Thomas Aquinas said that the Almighty creates because God is good and loving. (Catechism, 293)

I think they’re right.

God creates the universe, and humanity, because God loves us and wants to adopt us; all of us. It’s that simple. (Matthew 5:45; John 1:12–14, 3:17; Romans 8:14–17; Peter 1:3–4; Catechism, 1, 27–30, 52, 1825, 1996)

Paying Attention

It’s not simple, too.

For one thing, neither of the Genesis creation narratives mentions angels. Not specifically, anyway. (Genesis 1:1–2, 3, 2, 4–2, 25)

Thomas Aquinas had something to say about that. (“Summa Theologica,” First Part, Question 61, via dhspriory.org)

Then there’s the possibility that we have neighbors; people with bodies, like us, but not human. Or maybe we don’t. Either way, as Walt Kelly’s Porky Pine said, “it’s a mighty sobering thought.” (December 2, 2016)

Some physicists say quantum mechanics makes more sense if we’re not, or not quite, living in the only universe.

Multiverse hypotheses, Schrödinger’s cat, and quantum gears are topics for another post.

We’ve learned a bit since the Psalms were written, about two dozen centuries back, give or take a quarter-millennium.

Living in a universe that’s immensely bigger and older than Ussher’s tidy little version of a Mesopotamian model upsets some folks.

I’m not among them. I figure part of my job is appreciating God’s creation: not telling the Almighty how it should work. (September 23, 2016)

No matter where we look, God’s creation is filled with beauty and wonders that we’re just beginning to understand.

Paying attention to God’s work can’t hurt an informed faith.

Truth cannot contradict truth, we’re supposed to be curious, and scientific discoveries are opportunities for greater admiration of God’s creation. (Catechism, 159, 214–217, 283, 294, 341)

Everything and everyone ultimately points back to God. (1 Corinthians 15:27–28; Catechism, 294)

I’ve talked about faith, reason, science, and getting a grip, before. Often. (January 27, 2017; December 23, 2016; October 28, 2016; July 29, 2016)

Developing a Sense of Scale

“4 Indeed, before you the whole universe is as a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth.
“But you have mercy on all, because you can do all things; and you overlook the sins of men that they may repent.
“For you love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for what you hated, you would not have fashioned.
“And how could a thing remain, unless you willed it; or be preserved, had it not been called forth by you?”
(Wisdom 11:22–25)

God isn’t merely big and strong. God is “…infinite … almighty and ineffable … infinitely greater than all his works….” (Catechism, 202, 300)

What we’re learning about the scale of this universe doesn’t, I think, make God ‘more infinite.’ But I think it adds emphasis to verses like these:

“When I see your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and stars that you set in place –
“4What are humans that you are mindful of them, mere mortals that you care for them?
“5Yet you have made them little less than a god, crowned them with glory and honor.”
(Psalms 8:4–6)

I also think remembering who and what we are is important. And that’s another topic.

More about faith and paying attention:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , | 1 Comment