Gems, Metal, and Earth’s Core

The Fire of Australia, a whacking great chunk of opal, isn’t particularly interesting from a ‘science’ viewpoint.

But I’m human, which is probably why anything big and shiny gets my attention: including that rock.

Wrenching myself back on-topic, scientists found a stream of liquid metal flowing at the edge of Earth’s core. Studying it may help us learn why Earth’s magnetic field flip-flops at apparently-irregular intervals. What we’ll learn is beyond me: we didn’t know much about geomagnetic reversal when I started school.

We still don’t, for that matter. As I keep saying, there is a very great deal left to learn.

  1. The Fire of Australia Changes Hands
  2. Iron ‘Jet Stream’
  3. Earth’s Core: Halley, Pellucidar, and Reality
  4. Diamonds From Liquid Metal

‘Once it Was Believed, Now We Know’

Back in my ‘good old days,’ scientists were getting past the notion that Neanderthals were “cavemen,” and I’ve talked about that before. (January 13, 2017; September 23, 2016)

I don’t know how often the “once it was believed, now we know” phrase popped up; but the science-related stuff I read often had a triumphalist tone. That was morphing into the currently-fashionable ‘and we’re all gonna die’ attitude during my youth, which was well-established the last time I did time in academia.

I think both assumptions make about as much sense as believing that using the brains God gave us offends the Almighty.

Recapping what I’ve said before: acting like humans is okay.

We’re supposed to be curious. A thirst for truth and happiness is written into each of us. If we’re doing our job right, the search will lead us to God. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 27)

Seeking the Almighty and studying this wonder-filled universe is part of being human. (Catechism, 35, 50, 159, 2292–2296)

So is keeping this world in good working order. (Genesis 1:26–29, 2:15; Catechism, 339, 952, 2402–2405, 2456)

I talked about that last week. (January 20, 2017)

Learning That There’s More to Learn

Maybe I could endear myself to some folks by claiming that Earth has always been pretty much the way it is today: unchanged since the universe popped into existence at nightfall on 22 October 4004 BC.

That seems unreasonable. (July 31, 2016)

So does having hysterics over an impending environmental apocalypse. Some folks still apparently take Ehrlich’s prognostications seriously. I don’t. (August 12, 2016 )

I do think Earth’s climate is changing: and has been ever since our home formed, some 4,540,000,000 years back; give or take 50,000,000. I’d be astonished if it stopped changing during my lifetime.

I also think what we’ve been doing for the last 11,500 years has had an increasingly noticeable effect, at least on a regional level.

Developing industrial processes made a difference. I showed a global map of nitrogen dioxide levels last week.

But I don’t think this is a good time to try taking control of Earth’s climate. Not on a global level.

In my considered opinion, we don’t know nearly enough to do that safely. Not yet. (January 20, 2017)

Good grief: a few centuries back, it looked like the universe might be no more than a few thousand years old. Nobody suspect that the Solar wind existed until 1859, and the jury’s still out on exactly how Solar activity affects Earth’s climate.

We didn’t know for sure that Earth’s continents have been moving around until I was an adult. That may have helped the current ice age get started: but again, we’re not really sure. Not yet.

It’s not that I think Earth never changes, or that we’re helpless to do anything about our home’s environment. But experimenting with geoengineering should probably wait until we know what we’re doing.


1. The Fire of Australia Changes Hands


(From South Australian Museum, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The Fire of Australia is now on display in South Australia”
(BBC News))

“Fire of Australia: The return of the world’s finest uncut opal”
BBC News (January 23, 2017)

“The world’s finest uncut opal has mostly been kept in a safe deposit box since it was unearthed from the South Australian outback with a pick and shovel 70 years ago.

“Walter Bartram was prospecting in dusty terrain in Coober Pedy, about 750km (466 miles) north of Adelaide, in 1946 when he staked a claim to what became called the Fire of Australia.

“Although his family achieved success in opal trading, their greatest discovery has been seen rarely by the public.

“That has just changed.

“The 998g (35.2oz) opal, valued at nearly A$900,000 (£550,000; $680,000), is now on display in Adelaide’s South Australian Museum….”

Folks who care about such things call opal a mineraloid, not a mineral, since it’s an amorphous solid, not crystalline. It’s a hydrated amorphous form of silica, with water content from 3 to 21% by weight — generally between 6 and 10%.

Don’t bother trying to remember that. There will not be a test on this.

Opals are good for looking at. My language’s word for the stone, “opal,” comes from Latin “opalus.” Romans got that word from Sanskrit “úpala,” probably.

“Opalus” might have come from Ops, the wife of Saturn and goddess of fertility. Part of the Roman Saturnalia — think a major spring break blowout for adults — devoted to Ops was called “Opalia.” Again, you won’t be tested on this.

Maybe “opalus” came from ancient Greek “opallios.” That word meant something like “seeing,” which is where we get “opaque”; it also meant “other” as in “alias” and “alter.” The ancient Greek origin isn’t likely, academics say; but a Sanskrit origin is.

That sort of thing fascinates me. Your experience may vary.

Getting a Grip About Opals and Luck


(From Photo by Ray Bartram/the Bartram family, via The Jewellery Editor, used w/o permission.)
(“The Fire of Australia, discovered by the Bertram family in 1946, is the most valuable piece of rough light opal of its size in the world, weighing approximately 5,000 carats.”
(The Jewellery Editor))

Folks have enjoyed looking at opal for millennia, particularly after giving the rocks a nice polish. Opals were considered lucky — good and bad, depending on which tradition you dip into.

Sir Walter Scott’s “Anne of Geierstein” featured a magic opal with lethal properties. That tale apparently cut the sale of opals in the English-speaking world in half for something like two decades.1

About opals, lucky/unlucky stones, and such things — I have an agate, a geode, a half-dozen California Raisins from a Hardee’s promotion on my desk. They’re there because I think they look nice.

If I thought they magically help me write, or guard my computer’s hard drive, or something like that, I’d have a problem.

Superstition and magic are bad ideas. I don’t mean ‘take a rabbit out of my hat’ stage magic. That’s about as “magical” as me making letters appear on a glowing screen, by twiddling my fingers over a keyboard.

Now that I think of it, maybe that helps explain why some folks are scared of computers, and that’s another topic.

Superstition feels a bit like religion. It can affect worship if someone gets the idea that prayer, for example, depends on ‘going through the motions.’ It’s a bad idea. So is trying to tame occult powers or thinking ‘magic’ charms make sense. (Catechism, 2110–2111, 2117)


2. Iron ‘Jet Stream’


(From ESA, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Artwork: A depiction of where the jet is moving – in the outer core. The Swarm satellites fly a few hundred km above the planet and sense its magnetic field”
(BBC News))

“Iron ‘jet stream’ detected in Earth’s outer core”
Jonathan Amos, BBC News (December 19, 2016)

“Scientists say they have identified a remarkable new feature in Earth’s molten outer core.

“They describe it as a kind of ‘jet stream’ – a fast-flowing river of liquid iron that is surging westwards under Alaska and Siberia.

The moving mass of metal has been inferred from measurements made by Europe’s Swarm satellites.

“This trio of spacecraft are currently mapping Earth’s magnetic field to try to understand its fundamental workings….”

Magnetic north, the point on Earth’s surface where the planet’s magnetic field lines are vertical, was near the rotational pole when Thales of Miletus noticed that lodestones attract iron.

Folks started using lodestones for navigation during the Song Dynasty, about a thousand years back. Being able to navigate between ports is important, so folks have been keeping track of magnetic declination ever since.

We learned that the magnetic pole moves around. It’s been drifting west since about 1400. It had been drifting eastward for about four centuries before that. We call the drift “secular variation, which brings me back to the satellites and those scientists.

A “Jet of Liquid Iron,” Krakatoa, and Jet Streams

“Fast-flowing” is a relative term.

“…’This jet of liquid iron is moving at about fifty kilometres per year,’ explained Dr Chris Finlay from the National Space Institute at the Technical University of Denmark (DTU Space).

“‘That might not sound like a lot to you on Earth’s surface, but you have to remember this a very dense liquid metal and it takes a huge amount of energy to move this thing around…’….”
(Jonathan Amos, BBC News)

About jet streams, Wiley Post often gets credit for discovering Earth’s jet streams, since he noticed his ground speed was higher than the air speed in certain places. The story is a bit more complicated, though.

Folks noticed an “equatorial smoke stream” after the 1883 Krakatoa eruption.

Wasaburo Oishi’s reports from 1926 to 1944 are recognized as evidence of jet streams today. Wasaburo tried making his research available to folks living outside Japan by publishing in Esperanto.

Heinrich Seilkopf called the phenomena Strahlströmung, or “jet flow,” in 1939.

L. L. Zamenhof put Esperanto together in the 1870s and 1880s. Having a common world language is, I think, a good idea. Mandarin would be a pretty good choice these days, except just about everyone who understands it lives in China.

Inventing one and then trying to get folks who aren’t language geeks to go along with the idea — didn’t work out so well. And that’s yet another topic.

Where was I? Thales of Miletus, lodestones, jet streams, Esperanto. Right.

Moving Metal and Questions

These scientists figure that the moving metal stream is about 420 kilometers, 261 miles, wide; and wraps halfway around the planet. How deep it is — is a good question.

They figure it’s the boundary between two parts of Earth’s core. If they’re right, liquid iron approaching the boundary from both sides gets squeezed out sideways; forming the jet, which moves along the tube-shaped boundary.

They don’t have enough data to be sure, but their math suggests that the tube could extend all the way through to the core’s other side, in Earth’s southern hemisphere.

Learning more about this ‘jet stream’ and the rest of Earth’s core should help us understand how Earth’s magnetic field works.2 That, I think, could be very important.

Now, a scary headline from days gone by.

Magnetic Field Reversals


(From NASA, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(“NASA computer simulation … The tubes represent magnetic field lines, blue when the field points towards the center and yellow when away. The rotation axis of the Earth is centered and vertical. The dense clusters of lines are within the Earth’s core.”
(Wikipedia))

“Earth’s magnetic field ‘could flip in the space of 100 years’, scientists warn”
Rob Waugh, Metro.co.uk (October 21, 2014)

“Earth’s magnetic field can flip far faster than previously thought – unleashing a force which Mayan apocalypse believers thought might destroy our planet in 2012.…”

Breathless ‘and-we’re-all-gonna-die’ journalistic enthusiasm aside, I probably won’t live to see Earth’s magnetic field flip over: but you might.

The science behind that Metro.co.uk piece is solid enough, but nowhere near as dramatic:

It’s been about a century since scientists like Motonori Matuyama started finding evidence that “magnetic north” wasn’t always near the north pole. Other scientists didn’t get the memo, or weren’t interested.

Then folks mapping Earth’s seafloors in the 1950s and 1960s noticed alternating magnetic stripes running parallel to Earth’s mid-ocean ridges.

Lawrence Morley eventually got credit for his explanation of seafloor spreading, but editors working for Nature and Journal of Geophysical Research hadn’t felt like publishing it at the time.

Geomagnetic Reversal, Magnetoreception: Still Learning

The magnetic stripes form when particles in iron-rich rock welling up at mid-ocean ridges ‘freezes’ in line with Earth’s magnetic field.

This gives scientists a pretty good record of field reversals for the last 180,000,000 years. That’s the age of Earth’s oldest existing seafloor. The rest has long since been recycled back into the interior.

I’ve read that Earth’s magnetic field reversals happen at “random” intervals. My guess is that there’s a pattern to Earth’s magnetic field reversals, but scientists haven’t found it yet.

How much time passes between reversals has changed: a lot.

Field reversals started coming closer together a bit upwards of 80,000,000 years back, after a long comparatively-stable patch. There was another fast-changing period about 120,000,000 to 160,000,000 years ago.

A few times 10,000,000 years have gone by with no reversals. Earth’s field flip-flopped five times in a million years about 72,000,000 years back, and the Laschamp event, some 41,400 years back — give or take 2,000 ‐ only lasted a few centuries.

Something causes those reversals, and scientists have come up with a few explanations: but none that match available data.3

The idea that mass extinctions happened during field reversals looked good: except there isn’t a particularly good correlation between the two phenomena.

The reversals probably affect critters that use magnetic fields for navigation, like homing pigeons. How magnetoreception works another mystery.4

On the other hand, considering that we didn’t know about that sense just a few decades back: we’re not doing too badly.


3. Earth’s Core: Halley, Pellucidar, and Reality


(From Science Photo Library, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“This study suggests silicon exists in the Earth’s inner core with iron and nickel”
(BBC News))

“New candidate for ‘missing element’ in Earth’s core”
Rebecca Morelle, BBC News (January 10, 2017)

“Japanese scientists believe they have established the identity of a ‘missing element’ within the Earth’s core.

“They have been searching for the element for decades, believing it makes up a significant proportion of our planet’s centre, after iron and nickel.

“Now by recreating the high temperatures and pressures found in the deep interior, experiments suggest the most likely candidate is silicon.

“The discovery could help us to better understand how our world formed….”

We’ve learned quite a bit since Edmond Halley read Sir Isaac Newton’s 1687 Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica.

One of those two got the numbers wrong for Earth and our moon’s density.

Assuming that Earth is much less dense than our moon — it’s not — Halley said Earth could be hollow shell about 500 miles thick, with two more shells inside.

He used the diameters of Venus, Mars, and Mercury to define the inner shells, which makes a nifty picture. There’s a sort of elegance to the notion of nested shells inside Earth, whose diameters match other Solar planets.

But it’s not how reality works.

Maybe because a hollow Earth figures in folklore and mythologies, the idea hasn’t gone away.

Ludvig Holberg’s 1741 novel, “Nicolai Klimii iter subterraneum/Niels Klim’s Underground Travels,” has been followed by Burroughs’s Pellucidar tales, Gears of War, and folks who think Earth really is hollow.

There’s More to Learn

At the moment, the world’s deepest mine is four kilometers deep. The deepest borehole is still the Kola Superdeep Borehole, reaching 12.262 kilometers below Earth’s surface in 1989. That’s part-way through Earth’s crust.

Folks are still trying to get samples of material from the next layer under Earth’s crust, the mantle:

Given humanity’s seemingly-insatiable curiosity, my guess is that we’ll succeed before this century is over.

Meanwhile, studying seismic waves, stuff brought up by volcanoes, and Earth’s gravitational and magnetic fields, help scientists figure out what’s inside.

Technology like diamond anvil cells and laser-driven shock tubes developed over the last century lets scientists approximate extreme pressures and temperatures in Earth’s inner regions. Some inertial confinement fusion devices use similar laser tech, and controlled nuclear fusion is yet again another topic.

The last I heard, opinion is divided on whether Earth’s inner core is solid, or plasma that’s dense as a solid. It’s possible — this is even less certain and more debatable — that our planet’s core is a single huge iron crystal.5

This is not the world I grew up in. It’s a great deal more interesting. For the most part I like living in ‘the future,’ and that’s still another topic.


4. Diamonds From Liquid Metal


(From Nemesis International DMCC/Donald Woodrow photographer, via Science, used w/o permission.)
(“Tiny blobs of material trapped inside large, clear diamonds (such as this one) as they formed suggest the gems formed within pockets of liquid metal deep within Earth.”
(Science))

“Earth’s rarest diamonds formed in pockets of liquid metal”
Sid Perkins Science (Decenber 15, 2016)

“Some of the most prized diamonds on Earth are unusually clear, exceedingly rare, and often extraordinarily large. Researchers have long wondered how such gems formed, but they’ve been hard to study because they’ve typically ended up on ring fingers rather than under a microscope. Now, a new analysis of imperfections trapped within the diamonds provides the first direct evidence that they were forged within blobs of liquid metal hundreds of kilometers below Earth’s surface….”

Hundreds of kilometers down is still a long way from Earth’s core, but it’s closer than hat borehole: and these are actual samples from Earth’s interior, not laboratory approximations.6

This research helps scientists learn Earth’s internal chemistry.

It’s also, I think, interesting because diamonds are comparatively rare and sparkly; and have inspired a lot of colorful tales.7

More, mostly about using our brains:


1 Opals and a partly-underground town:

2 Earth’s newly-discovered iron ‘jet stream:’

3 Earth’s changing magnetic field:

4 Earth’s magnetic field and critters:

5 Some of what we know, and what we don’t:

6 Diamonds, science, and people:

7 Diamond stories, and a little more science:

Posted in Diamonds and Gems, Science News, Series | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Fan or Follower of Jesus?

Third Sunday in Ordinary Time, 2017:


Third Sunday in Ordinary Time, 2017

By Deacon Lawrence N. Kaas January 22, 2017

I found a story that I wish to share with you today because it poses a question, fans or followers?

A man by the name of Kyle Idelman, wrote an article where he posed the statement, “why I’m not a ‘fan’ of Jesus.” He began by noting that, according to recent surveys, something like over 75% of the people in our country call themselves Christian. Really? He stated, three out of four people are followers of Christ? Bringing the number of Christians in our country in the neighborhood of 233 million.

He goes on to write, that the numbers just don’t add up. If 75% of Americans are Christians… Then why are there more than 120 thousand children waiting to be adopted? Further he claims that 35 million people in America go to bed hungry each night which includes 13 million children?

He poses a comparison, as he speaks of the new “vegetarians.” One of them explains to him that she was a vegetarian but she likes to eat bacon. (And so she eats it.) Now claiming themselves to be Flexitarians.

“A Christian,” continue Idelman, “by definition, is a follower of Christ. So I’m thinking that may help make sense of the 233 million number as a new word to describe people who identify themselves as Christians but have little interest in actually following the teachings of Jesus. Perhaps instead of followers, it would be more accurate to call them fans.

The word fan is most simply defined as, an enthusiastic admirer. And I think Jesus has lots of fans these days. Some fans may even get dressed up for church on Sunday and make their ring tone a worship song. They like being associated with Jesus. Fans want to be close enough to Jesus to get the benefits, but not so close that it requires anything from them. They want a no strings attached, relationship with Jesus. So a fan says, I like Jesus but don’t ask me to serve the poor. I like Jesus, but I’m not going to give money to the people who are in need. I like Jesus, but don’t ask me to forgive the person who hurts me. I like Jesus, but don’t talk to me about money or sex that’s off-limits. Fans like Jesus, but they don’t want to give up the bacon.

Today’s reading from Matthew’s Gospel is about four men who were called by Jesus to be his Disciples. They were not called to be fans of Jesus, but followers. Their names were Simon Peter, Andrew, James and John, four fishermen, but really, this reading is also about you and me, because we have been called to be disciples as well. We also have been called to be followers and not fans. I’ll let you decide which group you belong. But first let’s ask, what does it mean to be a disciple of Jesus Christ?

Notice, first of all how ordinary these four men were they had no formal education that we know of. Neither did they possess any particular personal attractiveness or extraordinary talent of which we are aware. They were just ordinary fishermen. We often make the mistake of assuming that God calls only the most impressive, the most gifted, the most talented people. Indeed that seems to be the exact opposite of what God does!

God comes to Moses with a summons to go tell Pharaoh to “let my people go.” Moses responds, “who am I that I could go to Pharaoh?” Later Moses protests that he’s too slow of speech to carry out such a mission, we all know the outcome.

God comes to Gideon who would later be a great leader of God’s people, but Gideon responds.” “My clan is the weakest in Manasseh, and I am the least in my family.”

Even the most successful of all Israel’s Kings, David, was flabbergasted by God’s call. “I’m only a poor man and little known,” replies David.

St. Paul tells us in first Corinthians, first chapter, that God has deliberately chosen what the world considers foolish.

You realize he’s talking about you and me. God chooses ordinary people to do his work so that they would all depend on his power and not their own for this reason says, St. Paul, that no one will be able “to boast in the presence of God.”

In the play, Green Pastures, God asks Gabriel to recruit a leader and Gabriel asked in return, “do you want the brainiest or do you want the holiest?” God answers, “get me the holiest, I’ll make him the brainiest.”

Each year at the beginning of ordinary time I pose the question, what is so ordinary about ordinary time? Today I have received my answer, it is a time in which ordinary people respond to the call of God in extraordinary ways.

So maybe Mr. Adelman needs to look more deeply into the ordinary lives of ordinary Christians, who make ordinary time into an extra ordinary response to the call of God! Someone posed the question to me the other day about stewardship and my response simply was, love God, love your neighbor, and do as you will. Once again supporting the statement of ordinary people responding in an extraordinary way to the call of God!

By the way maybe Mr. Idleman wasn’t a fan but a follower!

So you all be Good, be Holy, Preach the Gospel, always and if necessary use words.


(‘Thank you’ to Deacon Kaas, for letting me post his reflection here — Brian H. Gill.)


Posted in Reflections | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

Conservative? Liberal? No: Catholic

Brian H. Gill's '2000 Years and Counting' collage.My father-in-law has been asked if he’s conservative — or liberal.

His answer: “I’m Catholic.”

I’d give the same answer.

Catholic teachings are quite definite, so it’s possible to peg them on the American political spectrum — as long as you don’t look at the big picture.

Taking bits and pieces of Catholic beliefs, and the history of Catholics in America, I could claim that the Catholic Church is conservative or liberal. That would be as big a mistake as seeing all conservatives as hate-fueled foes of diversity, or all liberals as irresponsible lunatics.

Sex, Death, and Immigrants

sporki's photo: World Youth Day, Rome. (2000) via Wikipedia, used w/o permission.
World Youth Day, Rome. (2000)

The Church might seem liberal because we’re told that sex is a good thing, social justice is important, and the death penalty should be a last resort. (Genesis 1:27, 31; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1928-1942, 2267, 2331-2391)

We’re also told that extra- and non-marital sex is a bad idea, private property is a good idea, and both abortion and euthanasia are wrong. That isn’t far from many conservative viewpoints. (Catechism, 2270-2279, 2348-2356, 2380-2381, 2401-2406)

I see immigrants as neighbors I haven’t met yet; folks who are doing pretty much the same thing my ancestors did, not long ago. That makes me a Catholic who takes our faith seriously: not a liberal. (Catechism, 2241)

The Catholic view of immigrants isn’t new, which doesn’t make it “conservative:”

“You shall not oppress an alien; you well know how it feels to be an alien, since you were once aliens yourselves in the land of Egypt.”
(Exodus 23:9)

“‘When an alien resides with you in your land, do not molest him.
“You shall treat the alien who resides with you no differently than the natives born among you; have the same love for him as for yourself; for you too were once aliens in the land of Egypt. I, the LORD, am your God.”
(Leviticus 19:33–34)

“For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, a stranger and you welcomed me,”
(Matthew 25:35)

As a Catholic, my knee-jerk reaction is — irrelevant, except maybe to me. Let’s see what the Church says about defending my life, and the lives of others.

Hawk? Dove?

detail, Aaron 'tango' Tang's photo: Shortly after 2013 Boston marathon bombing, people helping others. (April 15, 2013) via Wikipedia, used w/o permmission.Defending myself from a lethal attack is okay; even if my action results in my attacker’s death. But I must use the least possible force. (Catechism, 2263-2267)

That’s because my life is precious, and so is my attacker’s. My intent should be saving my own life, not killing another person: even if that is the unintended effect of my action. (Catechism, 2258, 2263-2269; “Summa Theologica,” Thomas Aquinas, II-II,64,7)

The same principle applies to decisions national leaders face. War kills people and breaks things, so avoiding war is a good idea.

But sometimes being nice and reasonable won’t keep innocent folks alive. That’s why leaders are allowed to use force when defending the lives they’re supposed to protect. (Catechism, 2307-2317)

“…As long as the danger of war remains and there is no competent and sufficiently powerful authority at the international level, governments cannot be denied the right to legitimate defense once every means of peaceful settlement has been exhausted….”
(“Gaudium et Spes,” Pope Bl. Paul VI (December 7, 1965))

I could edit Catholic teaching to make my beliefs fit — or shun — pigeonholes like ‘hawk,’ ‘dove,’ ‘bleeding heart liberal’ or ‘heartless conservative.’ But that doesn’t seem prudent.

Fear and Politics

Rev. Branford Clarke's cartoon, 'SHALL HE BE ALLOWED TO RULE AMERICA?'; from 'Guardians of Liberty', Published by the Pillar of Fire Church in Zarephath, NJ. (1943) via Wikipedia, used w/o permission.I can see why ‘real Americans’ might fear ‘those Catholics.’ Many of us don’t have English ancestors, for starters.

I’m an American, and speak English. But that doesn’t mean I agree with Alma Birdwell White or her Pillar of Fire Church. The outfit’s called Pillar of Fire International these days.

Catholics lived in the thirteen colonies and other parts of today’s United States long before 1776, but we didn’t start arriving in disturbing numbers until the 19th century.

Catholic immigrants from Germany, Ireland, Italy, and other foreign parts were mostly working-class folks. Not surprisingly, most Catholics voted Democrat: 70% overall, 80% of the Irish Catholics.

That changed, of course. Children or descendants of the immigrants became white-collar workers, developing voting and other habits that were closer to the American norm.1

Blending in with the crowd isn’t necessarily a good thing. I’ve talked about ‘going native’ before. (August 14, 2016)

It’s like Fulton Sheen said:

“Right is right if nobody is right, and wrong is wrong if everybody is wrong.”
(“Life Is Worth Living” (1951-1957), Program 19, The Venerable Fulton J. Sheen, via Wikiquotes)

Why Bother?

Vatican's photo: Saint Peter's Square, photo used in connection with the Extraordinary Jubilee of Mercy. (December 2015) see http://www.im.va/content/gdm/en.html - used w/o permission.
Saint Peter’s Square.

Taking an active part in public life is part of being a Catholic. That starts with my personal responsibilities: in my family, at work, in my community. (Catechism, 1913-1917)

The “at work” part of my life is over now, so I’ve got more time for family and other activity: like researching and writing these posts.

I enjoy learning and sharing what I find, but that’s not why I keep doing all this.

I’m passing along, in my own way, the best news humanity’s ever had.2

God loves us, and wants to adopt us. All of us. (Matthew 5:45; John 1:12–14, 3:17; Romans 8:14–17; Peter 1:3–4; Catechism, 1, 27-30, 52, 1825, 1996)

Our Lord said loving my neighbor, and seeing everyone as my neighbor, is the source for “the whole law and the prophets.” (Matthew 5:43–44, 22:36–40; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31, 10:25–27, 29–37; Catechism, 2196)

Over the last two millennia, folks like Saints Austine of Hippo, Teresa of Ávila, Thomas Aquinas, Hildegard of Bingen, Catherine of Siena, and Thérèse of Lisieux, have thought about what Jesus meant.

It still boils down to love and hope.

I think that makes sense. What you decide is up to you.

More about acting as if God and love matter:


1 Catholics living in America, politics and attitudes:

2 Anyone who tries to do good and avoid evil is on the right track. I became a Catholic after learning who currently holds the authority our Lord gave Peter. (Matthew 16:17–19; Catechism, 551-553, 781-801, 874-896)

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 13 Comments

Climate Change Continues

Climate change is still in the news. So is a growing crack in an Antarctic ice sheet, and a Ladybird Book co-authored by England’s Prince Charles.

The book, “Climate Change,” is a Ladybird Expert Book: written with adults in mind.

  1. A Cracking Ice Shelf
  2. Brunt Breakup
  3. A New Book by Prince Charles

This post has an afterword, mostly my take on climate change and being human:


The Coming Ice Age

I remember when the coming ice age was a hot topic: for science geeks, anyway.

Growing glaciers, miles deep, would spread from Earth’s arctic regions.

Grinding southward, they would obliterate cities and civilization in their inexorable advance.

It made for interesting conversation, forgettable science fiction potboilers, and at least one bit of cover art that I liked. The tale’s premise was that a city on whacking great tractor treads was trundling southward. I can’t remember the title or author.

More serious stories assumed that we didn’t survive, or had to start over in the tropics.

That was the late 1950s and early 1960s. Some folks were talking about “global cooling” in the 1970s, based on a cooling trend from the 40s to early 70s.1

These days, “climate change” has replaced “global warming” as a political slogan, and it’s easy to assume that the whole ball of wax is a bunch of hooey.

Reality isn’t quite what’s in the headlines, and that’s another topic.

“Last” Glacial Maximum?


(From Hansen et al./NASA, used w/o permission.)

If someone asked if I “believe in” climate change, I’d have answer yes — and no.

I don’t “believe in” climate change in the sense that I think it explains my existence, provides a reason for living, or belongs at the top of my priorities list.

On the other hand, I think Earth’s climate is changing. I am also quite sure that the universe is billions, not thousands, of years old; Earth isn’t flat; Adam and Eve aren’t German; and thinking is not a sin. (September 23, 2016; August 28, 2016; July 22, 2016)


(From Robert A. Rohde, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(A reconstruction of recent temperatures, from tree rings and other data.)

I’m also reasonably certain that Earth has getting warmer, on average, since about 1910. It’s certainly warmer now than it was during the Little Ice Age.

We’re enjoying, on average, temperatures Earth hasn’t experienced since the Medieval Warm Period.

It’s certainly warmer now than about 26,500 years back, when glaciers covered my ancestral homelands; and most of today’s Minnesota.

We call it the Last Glacial Maximum, since it’s the most recent. But there’s no guarantee that continental ice sheets won’t come back. Given what we’re learning, it’s likely that the current interglacial period will end ‘soon,’ by geologic standards.2

Let’s put that in perspective.

Milutin Milanković: (Almost) Right


(From Lisiecki and Raymo (2005), via Wikimedia Commons; under GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later; used w/o permission.)

That graph shows average temperatures at Vostok Station in Antarctica — based on analysis of an oxygen isotope in deep-sea ocean sediments. It’s almost certainly not spot-on accurate: but my guess is that it’s pretty close to what actually happened.

More about Earth’s most recent five million years of climate change:

The graph’s “41 kyr cycle” is a Milankovitch cycle: variations in how far Earth’s rotational axis wanders.

Milutin Milanković noticed correlation between these changes and Earth’s climate in the 1920s. His theory wasn’t popular in my youth, but data collected since the ’60s shows that he was on the right track. Earth’s climate changed the way he said it did — almost.

The “100 kyr cycle” is another cyclic variation in Earth’s axis: and an issue for folks trying to make sense of Milanković cycles.

Earth’s equator is tilted 23.44 degrees from the ecliptic today. It tilts up to 24.5 degrees, and is on its way to the 22.1 degree minimum at the moment. The cycle takes about 41,000 years: hence the “41 kyr (kiloyear)” name.

So — once we know everything there is to know about Earth’s last five million years, we’ll fully understand climate change? Probably not.

Our home is much older: and hasn’t been the same since the dinosaurs died.

Climate Change After the Dinosaurs


(From Robert A. Rohde, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)

Again, this graph comes from analysis of deep-sea sediments. It probably isn’t an exact fit with reality: but I think it’s reasonably accurate.

Earth’s current ice age started about 2,600,000 years back. The Isthmus of Panama’s closing was probably one of the triggering events.

So was the Tibetan plateau getting higher: maybe.

Continental glaciers have been spreading, melting, and spreading again ever since. Scientists figure positive and negative feedback processes have been keeping the cycle going. Exactly what those processes are is something we’re still learning.

Vastly oversimplifying the matter, we get more snow near the poles when Earth’s oceans are warmer. Sometimes the snow doesn’t entirely melt during summer. Snow and ice build up until we get glaciers scraping toward the equator.

Much of Earth’s water is tied up in glaciers by then, so sea level is lower. Between a slightly smaller ocean and colder climate, there isn’t as much snow falling: which slows down glacier production.

Somehow or other, Earth warms up and the cycle starts again. I gather that scientists still aren’t sure about what warms things up.

There’s evidence that it didn’t warm up once, more than 650,000,000 years ago.3 One of the problems scientists have with Snowball Earth is that they aren’t at all sure how Earth could have warmed up again.

It did, obviously, and I’ll get back to that.

It’s hardly surprising that we don’t fully understand ice ages.

The first inkling we had that they existed goes back to 1742, when Pierre Martel listened to what folks living in the Alps said about boulders of one sort of rock sitting on a different kind of rock.

I suspect we’re learning how much we don’t know almost as fast as we’re solving existing puzzles these days. The good news is that we’re learning: a lot, very fast.

One more graph, and I’ll get this week’s science news; and the new climate change book.

A Half-Billion Years of Climate Change


(From Dragons flight, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)

Once again, that’s a pretty good estimate of Earth’s average temperature, based on analysis of oxygen isotopes.

The Phaerozoic is what scientists call Earth’s current geologic eon. It started 541,000,000 years ago, give or take 1,000,000, when critters like trilobites and reef-building archaeocyathans appeared.

Earth in humanity’s day is colder than it’s been since the Andean-Saharan glaciation, 460,000,000 to 430,000,000 years ago — when Earth’s second-largest cluster of extinction events happened.

The big one happened about a quarter-billion years later. (September 30, 2016)

We’re accustomed to a world where a mile-deep glacier covers most of Greenland, which isn’t normal for this planet.

Earth has been colder than it is today, but not by much: apart from that Snowball Earth thing I mentioned. The last I heard, scientists still aren’t sure if we’re in an interglacial period: or if the Quaternary glaciation is finally over.

One of the most sensible things I’ve read about Earth and climate change is what Oregon State University’s Christo Buizert said, discussing a polar climate cycle: “We still don’t know….” (BBC News (May 5, 2015))


1. A Cracking Ice Shelf


(From John Sonntag/NASA , via NPR, used w/o permission.)
(“A NASA scientist with project IceBridge took this photo of the crack in November.”
(NPR))

“An Ice Shelf Is Cracking In Antarctica, But Not For The Reason You Think”
Rae Ellen Bichell, NPR (January 16, 2017)

“A group of scientists is gathering today in the U.K. to discuss a slab of ice that’s cracking in Antarctica. The crack could soon split off a frozen chunk the size of Delaware….

“…The ice shelf Sevestre was studying is called Larsen C, and it now has a massive 90-mile crack running through it.

“‘The big rift is slicing the ice shelf from top to bottom,’ Sevestre says. It’s now a third of a mile deep, and as wide across as 25 highway lanes.

“But this is not just another sad climate change story. It’s more complicated….”

Folks wrote about an antarctic region long before 1820. That’s when a folks on a ship spotted the continent.

Which ship was first depends on who’s talking. It was one captained by von Bellingshausen, Imperial Russian Navy, Edward Bransfield, England’s Royal Navy; or Nathaniel Palmer, a sealer out of Stonington, Connecticut.

I’d like to think Vikings got that far, and didn’t bother to file a report with the North Sea Empire. That’s unlikely, though, and yet another topic.

Anyway, Aristotle mentioned an antarctic region in his Meteorology.

Marinus of Tyre invented equirectangular projection, gets credit for being the first to assign latitude longitude to each spot on his map. He also gave us the term “Antarctic,” the Arctic Circle’s opposite.4

My hat’s off to Rae Ellen Bichell and NPR, for this sentence: “It’s more complicated.”

I suspect that reality is, in a sense, very simple. For example, we keep finding close approximations to circles, spheres, and logarithmic spirals. Physicists keep getting closer to a working theory of everything, and that’s yet again another topic.

We’re also learning that reality is, in another sense, very complex: and interrelated.

“When we try to pick out anything by itself, we find it hitched to everything else in the universe.”
(“My First Summer in the Sierra,” John Muir (1869) via Wikiquote)

“Simply a Natural Event”


(From Jeremy Harbeck/NASA, via NPR, used w/o permission.)
(“Calving is a natural process that produces icebergs, as seen here with the Getz Ice Shelf in West Antarctica.”
(NPR))

“…’A lot of things are going on deep inside the ice,’ says Adrian Luckman, a glaciologist at Swansea University in the U.K. He’s also leading a project to track changes in the ice shelf.

“Luckman says climate change is certainly influencing this region. Larsen C used to have two neighbors to the north, Larsen A and Larsen B. As the air and water warmed, those ice shelves started melting and then splintered into shards in 1995 and 2002.

“But the crack in Larsen C seems to have happened on its own, for different reasons.

“‘This is probably not directly attributable to any warming in the region, although of course the warming won’t have helped,’ says Luckman. ‘It’s probably just simply a natural event that’s just been waiting around to happen.’…”
(Rae Ellen Bichell, NPR)

The odds are very good that at least part of this ice shelf will break off in the next few months, years, or decades. It won’t be the first time something like this happened, and almost certainly won’t be the last.

Quite a few glaciers and ice sheets eventually meet open water. As their edges get pushed out, bits and pieces crack off. The process is called ice calving. Scientists study ice calving, tourists watch it, and surfers ride the waves kicked up by falling ice.

Calving on an epic scale happened during October 1998, when a Delaware-size chunk of the Filchner-Ronne Ice Shelf broke off. It’s (remotely) possible that part or all of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet could break off.5

Maybe we’ll see a movie based on that idea. Think “Absolute Zero: The Day After 2012.”

Then the stars could testify before Congress, lending their wisdom to climate change talks. Or maybe not.

The Larsen Ice Shelf is part of the Wenddel Sea’s northwest coast, more-or-less across from the Brunt Ice Shelf. The Brunt Shelf is cracking, too.


2. Brunt Breakup


(From British Antarctic Survey, used w/o permission.)
(“Graphic showing Halley’s current site in relation to its new site further inland”
(British Antarctic Survey))

“Ice crack to put UK Antarctic base in shut-down”
Jonathan Amos, BBC News (January 16, 2017)

“The British Antarctic Survey is to pull all staff out of its space-age Halley base in March for safety reasons.

“The highly unusual move is necessary because the Brunt Ice Shelf on which the research station sits has developed a big new crack.

“BAS officials say neither staff nor the base are in any immediate danger but believe it would be prudent to withdraw while the situation is assessed.

“The plan would be to go back once the Antarctic winter is over, in November….”

Halley Research Station got started with wooden hut built in 1956, part of a Royal Society expedition during the International Geophysical Year.

Snow eventually buried Halley I through IV, obliging researchers to move into newly-built quarters.

Halley V was designed to get lifted above each year’s snow accumulation, lasting until Halley VI was ready. Each of the current Halley Research Station modules stands on skis, so the station can be relocated as needed.6

The “Halloween Crack”


(From BAS, via BBC, used w/o permission.)
(“Aurora: Halley base has become a centre for the study of space weather”
(BBC News))

“…BAS is in the process of conducting such a move right now. The relocation is all but complete, with the last pod currently in the final stage of being shifted 23km to the new site.

“The move was necessitated by a chasm that had opened up in the shelf and which threatened to cut off Halley. But this huge fissure to the west of the station is not the cause of the temporary closure.

“Rather, it is another break in the ice some 17km to the north and east of the new base position. It has been dubbed the ‘Halloween Crack’ because it was discovered on 31 October….”
(Jonathan Amos, BBC News)

The British Antarctic Survey (BAS) folks don’t think part of the Brunt Ice Shelf is going to break off during the Antarctic winter.

But they can’t be sure, and don’t want folks on the ice if it does. A 19-hour power outage during the 2014 winter may have encouraged this common-sense move:

“Power-down at British Antarctic Survey Halley Research Station – Statement”
BAS Press Office (August 6, 2014)

“British Antarctic Survey (BAS) is dealing with a serious operational incident at its Halley Research Station. On Wednesday 30 July 2014 a major technical issue resulted in the station losing its electrical and heating supply for 19 hours. All 13 station staff are safe and in good health….”

With nobody around to keep an eye on equipment, BAS will be deciding whether to leave some of the experiments running and hope for the best, or shut the whole thing down until winter’s end.

It’s not an easy decision, since Halley VI collects data on Earth’s atmosphere, and beyond.7


3. A New Book by Prince Charles


(From Penguin, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The cover of the book was based on an image of flooding in Uckfield, East Sussex”
(BBC News))

“Prince Charles co-authors Ladybird climate change book”
(January 15, 2017)

“Prince Charles has co-authored a Ladybird book on the challenges and possible solutions to climate change.

“It is part of a series for adults written in the style of the well-known children’s books that aims to clearly explain complicated subjects.

“The 52-page guide has been co-authored by former Friends of the Earth director Tony Juniper and climate scientist Emily Shuckburgh.

“Mr Juniper said he hoped the book would ‘stand the test of time’….”

Fear not! Uckfield in East Sussex is not sinking beneath the waves. Not yet, anyway.

The Prince Charles climate change book might become a collectors item, like first edition copies of “Bunnikin’s Picnic Party.”

I suppose anything “royal” has added value in some circles.

I was glad to see that marketing for this book isn’t entirely hysterical, although there’s the usual fear appeal.

“…You’ll learn about the causes and consequences of climate disruption; heatwaves, floods and other extreme weather; disappearing wildlife; acid oceans; the benefits of limiting warming; sustainable farming, new clean technologies and the circular economy….”
(“Climate Change (A Ladybird Expert Book) (The Ladybird Expert Series),” Amazon.com)

The hardcover book, available January 26, 2017, is already a #1 ‘meteorology’ bestseller on Amazon.com.

“Heatwaves, Floods … Disappearing Wildlife; Acid oceans”

It could be worse.

The cover illustration could show Cobb Bakers and Uckfield Pharmacy dissolving in an acid ocean as Godzilla and Hedorah battle on the skyline.

I found listings for several pharmacies in Uckfield, incidentally, but no “Uckfield Pharmacy.” I’m pretty sure both businesses are fictional.

I’m also sure that developing cleaner industrial technologies is a good idea, and that recycling makes sense.

That said, I’m not jumping on the “acid oceans” bandwagon. I’ve seen enough fizzled doomsday predictions, religious and otherwise, to be a bit cautious:

“…in ten years all important animal life in the sea will be extinct. Large areas of coastline will have to be evacuated because of the stench of dead fish….”
(Paul Ehrlich, on first Earth Day, (1970))

“…By the year 2000 the United Kingdom will be simply a small group of impoverished islands, inhabited by some 70 million hungry people….”
(Paul Ehrlich, Speech at British Institute For Biology (September 1971))

I’ve talked about Ehrlich, Yeats, and preacher-prognosticators, before. (August 12, 2016; August 7, 2016)

On the other hand, despite ‘is not/is so’ claims flying like fewmets in a lively primate house debate, climate change is real.


Stewardship: Part of Our Job


(From the European Space Agency, used w/o permission.)
(Nitrogen dioxide (NO2) in Earth’s troposphere, between January 2003 and June 2004.)

As I keep saying, our “dominion” over this world isn’t ownership. We’re more like stewards, responsible for God’s property. (August 12, 2016)

Seeing this universe as beautiful, good, and our responsibility, isn’t an option. It’s a requirement.

Keeping this world in good working order is part of our job. (Genesis 1:26–29, 2:15; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 339, 952, 2402–2405, 2456)

The question isn’t whether or not we can change Earth’s climate. There’s good reason to believe we’ve been doing it, at least regionally, ever since folks started planting crops.

But our croplands and factories aren’t the only forces at work.

Mount Tambora’s eruption probably helped set off the Year Without a Summer.

Krakatoa’s 1883 eruption had a similar effect.

That’s Mount Redoubt in the photo, during its 1989–1990 eruption. It didn’t cause a volcanic winter, but did clog all four engines of a KLM airliner someone flew through its ash cloud.

Earth’s climate was changing long before humanity arrived. It’s changed a lot over the last few billion years.

Learning Wisdom, not Fear

We’re pretty hot stuff:

“4 What are humans that you are mindful of them, mere mortals that you care for them?
“5 Yet you have made them little less than a god, crowned them with glory and honor.”
(Psalms 8:4–6)

But “little less than a god” isn’t “God.”

I’ve talked about hubris, humility, and getting a grip, before. (November 18, 2016; July 31, 2016)

The responsibility that comes with our power is scary. Scary or not, though, we’ve got a job to do: taking care of the world’s resources for our reasoned use, and for future generations. (Catechism, 339, 2402, 2415)

If we’re going to do that job, we must keep studying the universe: and developing new tools using that knowledge. (Catechism, 2293–2295)

I am pretty sure that we know enough today to deliberately change Earth’s climate. I am also quite sure that we do not know enough to do so safely. Not yet.

In the short run, we should keep doing what we’re doing: reducing industrial pollution, and learning more about long-term climate changes. In the long run — that’s still another topic.

Meanwhile, being scared silly won’t help. That makes about as much sense as a shop foreman being scared of power tools.

More about Earth and being human:


1 Global cooling and all that:

2 Living in an ice age:

3 It’s starting to look like we had at least two “Snowball Earth” events: one about 650,000,000 years back, and another upwards of two billion years ago. Most ice ages weren’t that severe:

4 Antarctica, mostly:

5 Glaciers and ice shelves:

6 Britain’s Antarctic research:

7 More about Britain’s Antarctic research:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Life, Death, and Choices

Last week’s Gospel reading, Matthew 2:1–12, ends with a sort of cliffhanger. “Magi from the east” arrived in Bethlehem, found our Lord’s house, and paid their respects:

“They were overjoyed at seeing the star,
“5 and on entering the house they saw the child with Mary his mother. They prostrated themselves and did him homage. Then they opened their treasures and offered him gifts of gold, frankincense, and myrrh.
“And having been warned in a dream not to return to Herod, they departed for their country by another way.”
(Matthew 2:10–12)

Or maybe not so much — we read Matthew 2:13–18 on December 28. I don’t suppose we’ll see the massacre of the innocents1 in an animated Christmas special any time soon. It’s far from the most cheerful parts of the Bible.

That didn’t keep folks in Coventry from including it in their Shearmen and Tailors’ Pageant. We got “Coventry Carol” from that mystery play.2

Rachel Wept

Herod the Great3 liked being in charge, even if it was as a Roman vassal. He wasn’t about to let some upstart take the job.

“When Herod realized that he had been deceived by the magi, he became furious. He ordered the massacre of all the boys in Bethlehem and its vicinity two years old and under, in accordance with the time he had ascertained from the magi.
“Then was fulfilled what had been said through Jeremiah the prophet:
“9 ‘A voice was heard in Ramah, sobbing and loud lamentation; Rachel weeping for her children, and she would not be consoled, since they were no more.'”
(Matthew 2:16–18)

Herod’s massacre most likely wasn’t a large-scale slaughter, like what happened in and around Srebrenica in 1995. Only about 1,000 folks called Bethlehem home in his day. There wouldn’t have been more than maybe 20 boys age two or under.

That’s still a lot of dead kids, particularly from the parents’ viewpoint.

Their deaths didn’t make it into Herodian records. Herod the Great had so many “important” folks killed, I’m not surprised that taking out a few low-status boys in a Podunk town got lost in the shuffle.4

Our Lord had left Bethlehem by then. An angel ordered Joseph to get Mary and Jesus to Egypt ASAP: which he did. (Matthew 2:13–14)

Like I said, this probably wasn’t how Joseph imagined family life, back when he and Mary got betrothed. (December 25, 2016)

Shepherds, Magi, and Herod

I get the impression that folks generally weren’t apathetic about our Lord.

The shepherds glorified and praised God for what they’d seen heard and seen. (Luke 2:20)

The magi “…prostrated themselves and did him homage. Then … offered him gifts of gold, frankincense, and myrrh….” Herod had Bethlehem’s youngest boys killed. (Matthew 2:11, 16)

Let’s look at who — and what — Jesus is.

“1 For a child is born to us, a son is given us; upon his shoulder dominion rests. They name him Wonder-Counselor, God-Hero, Father-Forever, Prince of Peace.”
(Isaiah 9:5)

“5 Rejoice heartily, O daughter Zion, shout for joy, O daughter Jerusalem! See, your king shall come to you; a just savior is he, Meek, and riding on an ass, on a colt, the foal of an ass.”
(Zechariah 9:9)

“24 Jesus said to them, ‘Amen, amen, I say to you, before Abraham came to be, I AM.'”
(John 8:58)

The shepherds and magi didn’t see the big picture. Neither do I, for that matter.

God’s God, I’m not. I can’t fully understand the Almighty and our Lord’s decisions. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 230, 268–274)

I suppose Herod could have seen the “newborn king” as the Messiah, and started planning for an early retirement. Instead, he decided to commit mass murder.

That’s a bad idea, by the way, no matter who the victims are. (January 11, 2017)

Free Will, Toy Monkeys

We could have hardwired responses to God’s presence, like toy monkeys that celebrate at the flip of a switch.

Instead, we’ve got a desire for God — a ‘God-shaped hole’ — in our hearts. We can try filling the hole by pursuing truth. If we do it right, that’ll lead us to God. We can also try ignoring it, which is a bad idea. (Catechism, 27–38)

Either way, we decide what we do.

We are rational creatures, made “in the divine image.” (Genesis 1:27; Catechism, 355–357, 1702, 1738)

We can make reasoned choices. Or we can decide to let our emotions and whims guide us: which is also a decision. Either way, we make choices; and are responsible for the consequences. (Catechism, 1730–1742, 1778, 1784, 1790)

We can decide that our career, entertainment, or some other short-term goal, is more important than eternal happiness with God. That’s a really bad idea, but it is an option. (Catechism, 1020–1037)

Humanity’s been making decisions — good, bad, and disastrous — for a long time, so thinking straight sometimes isn’t easy. And that’s another topic. (Catechism, 385–412, 1735, 1790–1793)

The Light Still Shines in the Darkness

Jesus, Joseph, and Mary, stayed in Egypt until Herod the Great died.

Mary’s home town, Nazareth, seemed safer than Judea, so they settled there. (Matthew 2:19–23)

Our Lord grew up, ran into trouble with Jerusalem’s elite, again, was executed and buried in a borrowed tomb.

Jesus stopped being dead few days later.

And that’s yet another topic.

“3 All things came to be through him, and without him nothing came to be. What came to be
“through him was life, and this life was the light of the human race;
“4 the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.”
(John 1:3–5)

More about life, death, love, and all that:


1 Following the Prince of Peace isn’t easy:

2 Wikimedia Commons has an excellent recording of the U.S. Army Band singing “Coventry Carol:” wikimedia.org/… U.S._Army_Band_-_Coventry_Carol.ogg.

3 Ken Spino called Herod the Great “a madman who murdered his own family and a great many rabbis.” (2010) Herod apparently didn’t kill off the entire family, since two sons took over after his death. The name got recycled a several times:

4 Herod’s legacy:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment