Urban Evolution and Big Brains

Life, and evolution, has been happening for quite a while. Cities are new, but the same processes happen there; with slightly different results. We’re learning how urban environments affect critters, and are piecing together more of humanity’s story.

  1. Evolution in Cities
  2. Big Brains and DNA

Reality and Faith

I occasionally run into someone who feels that religion is silly and science isn’t, or the other way around. I grew up in this country, so I recognize the ‘religion is against science’ attitude.

But I’m a Catholic; so rejecting reality, avoiding truth, isn’t part of my faith.

Faith, the Catholic version, is a willing and conscious “assent to the whole truth that God has revealed.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 142–150)

Truth is important, and beautiful — whether it’s expressed in words, “the rational expression of the knowledge of created and uncreated reality;” or “the order and harmony of the cosmos;” or in other ways. (Catechism, Prologue, 27, 74, 2500, more under Truth in the index)

“Truth or truthfulness is the virtue which consists in showing oneself true in deeds and truthful in words, and guarding against duplicity, dissimulation, and hypocrisy.”
(Catechism, 2505)

We can learn a little about God by noticing God’s infinite beauty reflected in “the world’s order and beauty.” (Catechism, 31–32, 341)

A thirst for truth and happiness is written into each of us. If we’re doing our job right, it’ll lead us to God. (Catechism, 27)

Using the brains God gave us is okay. Seeking the Almighty and studying this wonder-filled universe is what we’re supposed to do. (Catechism, 35, 50, 159, 2292–2296)

That’s one reason I like Thomas. He asked questions, and wanted evidence. That earned him the “doubting Thomas” nickname. He also knew when to accept reality.1

I enjoy understanding things, and learning how to understand more. But fully understanding God is beyond me. The Almighty is “…incomprehensible, almighty and ineffable … a mystery beyond words.” (Catechism, 202, 230)

This universe is another matter.

Secondary Causes

I see no problem with believing that God is creating a universe that’s following knowable physical laws. That’s just as well, since it’s what we’re told to believe. (Catechism, 268, 279, 299, 301, 302–305)

We’ve been learning a bit about God, and this universe, over the millennia.

For starters, God really is “the Almighty.” But God’s power isn’t arbitrary in the sense of capricious. (Catechism, 270–271)

Some facet of the Creator’s truth is in everything we observe. (Catechism, 300–310)

Natural processes, like fire and gravity, involve secondary causes: creatures changing in knowable ways, following laws woven into this creation. (Catechism, 301–308, 339)

Scientists are assuming that evolution is like fire and gravity: something that’s real, and follows knowable rules. I think they’re right.

A big difference between evolution and gravity is that we we weren’t sure that evolution was real until quite recently. And that brings me to Anaximander.

A Changing World: Not a New Idea

Folks like Anaximander and Empedocles speculated that today’s critters — humans included — had changed since the world’s beginning.

Fast-forwarding over the Roman Republic, Empire and upwards of a millennium of European history, Pierre Louis Maupertuis and Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon wrote about more-or-less-systematic change in the 1700s.

Comte de Buffon also used experimental data to estimate Earth’s age. He was wrong by several orders of magnitude: but in the 1700s it was a pretty good estimate, based on his data. (August 28, 2016)

Charles Darwin didn’t single-handedly start the idea that organisms change in a rational way: but his “On the Origin of Species” (1859) was an important contribution to evolutionary theory. It also dropped “evolution” into popular culture.

We’ve learned quite a bit since then, much of it in my lifetime: and there’s a great deal left to learn.

God, Neanderthals, and DNA

I could get upset that God didn’t take a 17th century Englishman’s beliefs into account when designing the universe, but that doesn’t make sense. Not to me.

“Our God is in heaven; whatever God wills is done.”
(Psalms 115:3)

I would much rather take reality ‘as is.’ (October 28, 2016; August 28, 2016)

Scientists still call Neanderthals, Denisovans, and Red Deer Cave people different “species” or “subspecies.”

We don’t have Red Deer Cave DNA yet, but most folks living today have some Neanderthal or Denisovan ancestors. I’m guessing that Red Deer Cave people are no less “human” than the rest of us.

I’ll admit to a bias, since my ancestors are from northwestern Europe, Neanderthal country. I don’t think our profuse body hair and Neanderthal DNA make us less “human” than folks from other parts of the world. But I’m one of ‘them,’ so like I said: I’m biased.2

Ainu apparently aren’t genetically similar to Europeans, although I’m not clear on which Europeans Sforza, Menozzi, and Piazza, used for comparison.

The more we learn about life on Earth, the more scientists revise the old Linnaean taxonomy. And that’s another topic.

Large and In Charge

As I’ve said before, I figure God is large and in charge. Part of my job is noticing this astounding creation, and admiring the Creator’s work.

“The heavens declare the glory of God; the sky proclaims its builder’s craft.
“One day to the next conveys that message; one night to the next imparts that knowledge.”
(Psalms 19:2–3)

“Shout with joy to the LORD, all the earth; break into song; sing praise.”
(Psalms 98:4)

“Of old you laid the earth’s foundations; the heavens are the work of your hands.
“They perish, but you remain; they all wear out like a garment; Like clothing you change them and they are changed,
“but you are the same, your years have no end.”
(Psalms 102:26–28)

“4 Indeed, before you the whole universe is as a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth.
“But you have mercy on all, because you can do all things; and you overlook the sins of men that they may repent.”
(Wisdom 11:22–23)


1. Evolution in Cities


(From BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“For the first time, researchers say they have identified urbanisation’s signature in evolution”
(BBC News))

“Urbanisation signal detected in evolution, study shows”
Mark Kinver, BBC News (January 7, 2017)

“A ‘clear signal’ of urbanisation has been identified in the evolution of organisms, which has implications for sustainability and human well-being.

“In analysis of more than 1,600 cases around the globe, researchers said the changes could affect ecosystem services important to humans.

“More than half of the world’s human populations now live in urban areas, and this proportion is set to grow….

“…’We found that there is a clear urban signal of phenotypic change, and also greater phenotypic change in urbanising systems compared to natural or non-urban anthropogenic systems,’ said co-author Marina Alberti from the University of Washington’s Department of Urban Design and Planning.

“‘So urbanisation, globally, is clearly affecting things.’

“Phenotypic change refers to change in an organism’s observable traits, such as it morphology, physiology, phenology, or behaviour….”

I’m a recovering English teacher, so here’s a vocabulary review. A phenotype is how a critter looks and acts. Genotype is the genetic code in its cells. Anthropogenic is what we’ve started calling stuff that happens or exists because we’re here and acting like humans.

The researchers looked at “habitat modification, biotic interaction, heterogeneity, novel disturbance, and social interaction.”

Taking that one at a time — Habitat modification is turning a forest into a mosaic of parks, buildings, and streets; a meadow into a parking ramp; or a swamp into a housing development. That sort of thing.

Biotic or biological interaction is the effect critters have on each other. Heterogeneity is the degree to which one spot differs from another.

Novel disturbance doesn’t have anything to do with book-length fictional narratives. I gather that it’s stuff that hasn’t happened before.

Social interaction is an interesting one. Cities can bring critters together that wouldn’t have met otherwise.

Changes


(Background from NASA, 2012; data points and legend by Marina Alberti et al; used w/o permission.)

Crepis sancta, hawksbeard, looks like dandelions; and spreads its seeds the same way, on the wind. Hawksbeard in urban areas have bigger, heavier, seeds.

That most likely increases the odds that a seed will land on soil near the parent plant, instead of landing on asphalt or concrete.

I’m not particularly surprised, or upset, that many humans live in cities; that cities are growing; and that cities aren’t like wilderness. I also think learning more about how cities affect critters is a good idea.

That’s partly because I live on Earth. What happens here affects how my family and I live.

“…Prof Alberti and colleagues suggested that these changes meant that the alteration in the functions performed by the species, such as food production or the prevention of the spread of infectious diseases, would also be modified.

“‘There have been a lot of studies on individual cities but there had been no studies that considered the global picture to identify a global urbanisation influence on evolution,’ she added.

“‘We live on an urban planet already. This is a change that has implications for where we are heading in the future.

“‘We are changing the evolution of Earth and urbanisation has a role, a significant role, in that.'”
(Mark Kinver, BBC News)

Doing Our Job


(The U.S. Bank Center in Milwaukee. Peregrine falcons use part of the 41st floor.)

I remember when we were learning that DDT isn’t particularly good for humans, and downright dangerous for some birds.

I think part of the reason we’ve been a bit slow on the uptake where environmental hazards are involved has to do with our biology.

We’re not as spectacularly hard to kill as cockroaches or scorpions, but the Black Death didn’t do more than slow us down, and that’s another yet another topic. (November 6, 2016; September 30, 2016)

As I’ve said before, part of our job is managing this world. (Catechism, 339, 952, 2402–2405, 2456)

A half-century later, we’re more careful about pesticides; and are developing reasonable alternatives. Somewhere along the line, we noticed that peregrine falcons will nest in the artificial cliffs we’ve been building in central North America.

Since we like the birds, and don’t mind their habit of hunting urban critters that bother us, some of us have set aside parts of our taller buildings for their use. I see it as win-win situation.3

Sometimes managing this world means not feeding deer.

CWD, chronic wasting disease, a particularly nasty affliction, showed up in two more deer recently. It gets passed from deer to deer when they touch noses. That happens more often when the critters gather at feeding stations, so the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources added more counties to a feeding ban.


2. Big Brains and DNA


(From Science Photo Library, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“DNA clue to how humans evolved big brains”
Helen Briggs, BBC News (December 7, 2016)

“Humans may in part owe their big brains to a DNA ‘typo’ in their genetic code, research suggests.

“The mutation was also present in our evolutionary ‘cousins’ – the Neanderthals and Denisovans.

“However, it is not found in humans’ closest living relatives, the chimpanzees.

“As early humans evolved, they developed larger and more complex brains, which can process and store a lot of information.

“Last year, scientists pinpointed a human gene that they think was behind the expansion of a key brain region known as the neocortex.

“They believe the gene arose about five or six million years ago, after the human line had split off from chimpanzees….”

This gene’s name is ArhGAP11B, which I tend to ‘hear’ as “argap-eleven-b.” It’s a truncated version of ArhGAP11A, a gene that’s “found throughout the animal kingdom,” as Wikipedia put it.

ArhGAP11B is in every human living today, plus folks we call Neanderthals and Denisovans. Depending on who you read, those folks are two “extinct” species or subspecies of the genus Homo.

Interestingly, it’s found only in humans. A team headed by the Max Planck Institute of Molecular Cell Biology and Genetics’ Wieland Huttner identified it about two years back.

We’re not sure exactly how ArhGAP11B works, but it’s involved in making our neocortex fold and grow.4 I’ve talked about another human-specific ‘brain gene,’ SRGAP2, before. (September 23, 2016)

About Neanderthals and Denisovans being “extinct,” I think that’s about as accurate as saying that víkingr and the Na hÉireannaigh are “extinct.”

Guess Who Came to Dinner

We seem to be getting over the notion that Neanderthals are “cavemen,” brutish half-apes with no appreciation for afternoon tea.

I’m not surprised that we’re learning that Neanderthals “interbred” with folks who look more like me.

The term is accurate, but I don’t like it. I know too much about my more-recent ancestors. From some viewpoints, I’m the result of “miscegenation,” another word for “interracial marriage.”

The daughter of a respectable family caught the eye of an Irishman a couple generations back — to the great dismay of her parents.

As one of my ancestors said, “he doesn’t have family, he’s Irish.”

The youngsters got married anyway, which made me possible. I’ve talked about immigrants, nativism, and English Bulldogs, before. (November 29, 2016; August 5, 2016)

The respectable family coped, most Americans no longer see the Irish as a threat, miscegenation hasn’t been a felony here since 1967, and I am heartily glad that the ‘good old days’ aren’t coming back.

Being Human


(From Captain Blood at de.wikipedia, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Topographic map of Central Asia, including the Altai mountains.)

Denisovans lived in or near the Altai mountains about 41,000 years before we started playing baseball. We don’t know what they called themselves. Our name comes from where we found their remains: the Denisova Cave

We don’t know much about Denisovans yet, apart from a bit of finger bone, two teeth, and a toe bone. It’s not much to work with: but scientists found intact DNA — enough to trace Denisovan descendants among Melanesians and Aboriginal Australians.

Many or most folks in southern and southeast Asia probably have Denisovan ancestors.

I’ll grant that this might be a hoax, like Piltdown Man, the Cardiff giant, and Archaeoraptor: but I don’t think so. Too many scientists agree that Denisovan DNA is about 41,000 years old, is distinctly different, and shows up in folks living today.

Denisovans seem to have been as open-minded in one way as some of my ancestors were. About 17% the Denisovan DNA we found is from local Neanderthal populations: and some is from another variety of human we didn’t know about before.

Acting Like Humans


(From Rick Potts, Susan Antón and Leslie Aiello; via the Smithsonian, used w/o permission.)
(One of humanity’s many migrations.)

Denisovans not preserving ‘racial purity’ doesn’t surprise me. As I see it, they were people acting like humans.

We’ve moved around, a lot, over the last few million years. Each time we do, some of the newcomers’ younger generation generally takes a lively interest in local lads and lasses: to the occasional horror of ‘proper’ parents.

Given the attitude some of my ancestors had toward another set of my forebears, I’m not inclined to be upset at the thought of folks not emulating the Hapsburgs, and that’s yet again another topic. (August 5, 2016)

More, mostly about evolution using our brains:


1 After our Lord stopped being dead, Thomas wouldn’t believe what other disciples were telling him. (John 20:25)

I can’t say that I blame him.

“Then he said to Thomas, ‘Put your finger here and see my hands, and bring your hand and put it into my side, and do not be unbelieving, but believe.’

“17 Thomas answered and said to him, ‘My Lord and my God!’

“18 Jesus said to him, ‘Have you come to believe because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and have believed.’ ”
(John 20:27–29)

I didn’t demand that sort of proof. But nearly two millennia later, I had a whole lot more evidence than hearsay from a few badly-rattled folks to work with.

2 Part of my take on humanity, humility, and getting a grip:

3 Stewardship, practical and theoretical:

4 Two uniquely-human genes:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Deciding Who Dies

Death at a Bible study back in 2015, and at Fort Lauderdale airport last week, has been in the news.

It’s probably not as exciting as what glitterati were wearing and saying at the Golden Globe Awards; but I figured now would be a good time to talk about those deaths, and decisions:


Fort Lauderdale Airport: Death and Luggage

Death happens. I’m not looking forward to it, or the final performance review that follows, but it is inevitable. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1007, 1022)

Death isn’t the end, since in another sense I can’t die; so being prepared is a good idea.1 (Catechism, 1014, 1022, 1682)

I don’t think morbid preoccupation with death and life’s comparative brevity makes sense. But neither does forgetting that death can happen anywhere: even at an airport’s baggage claim area.

Five folks were killed at Fort Lauderdale airport last Friday. Four have been publicly identified so far:

  • Michael Oehme
  • Olga Woltering
  • Shirley Timmons
  • Terry Andres
  • Unknown
    (Wikipedia)

A half-dozen more were injured by Esteban Santiago-Ruiz, three of them were sent to intensive care units. Several dozen more got hurt while getting to comparatively safe areas.

The last I heard, some 20,000 pieces of luggage and their owners are still getting sorted out. That’s non-trivial for folks who were going through airport security at the time, or whose medication is still in their luggage.

Until the mess is cleared up they don’t have personal identification; shoes; or, in some cases, meds that have been keeping them comparatively healthy.

Death at a Bible Study

Dylann Roof sat down with a Bible study group on June 17, 2015. About an hour later, he started killing people.

Some were later identified by their jobs or what they did in the church — a speech therapist and track coach, a member of the church choir, a pastor, a state senator.

One of the dead was a grandnephew of the choir member, another a sister of a state senator who apparently wasn’t at the Bible study:

  • Clementa C. Pinckney
  • Cynthia Marie Graham Hurd
  • Daniel Simmons
  • Depayne Middleton-Doctor
  • Ethel Lee Lance
  • Myra Thompson
  • Sharonda Coleman-Singleton
  • Susie Jackson
  • Tywanza Sanders
    (Wikipedia)

News media and resources like Wikipedia pay more attention to “important” folks like senators, pastors, and coaches. That’s understandable, since their actions effect us in more obvious ways than what “ordinary” folks do.

Some of the jobs held by folks at the Bible study may be more vital to economic and civic affairs in Charleston and South Carolina than most. But that doesn’t make them more or less important as people.

A Good Reason to Care and Think

From Nomader, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.
(The memorial service for victims of the Charleston church shooting filled a church to capacity, with more folks gathered outside.
(Picture from Nomader, via Wikimedia Commons))

My family, friends, and acquaintances, get more of my attention than total strangers; and I’m more aware of folks who get their names in the news than those who don’t.

But I realize that God doesn’t have me and my family on a celestial A-list.

Humanity, all of us, male and female, are made “in the divine image;” with equal dignity. (Genesis 1:27; Catechism, 1700, 1934)

Human life, each human life, is sacred: no matter who we are. (Catechism, 2258)

That is a good reason to care about and grieve for the lives ended that day, and at Fort Lauderdale airport last Friday.

It’s also a good reason to think about the people who are on trial for causing those deaths.


1. Murder at Fort Lauderdale Airport


(From Getty Images, via BBC News; and ABC News; used w/o permission.)

“Florida airport shooting suspect appears in court”
BBC News (January 9, 2017)

“A 26-year-old Iraq war veteran suspected of opening fire in a crowded Florida airport last week has appeared in court to hear charges against him.

“A 26-year-old Iraq war veteran suspected of opening fire in a crowded Florida airport last week has appeared in court to hear charges against him.

“Esteban Ruiz Santiago is accused of murdering five people at the Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International airport on Friday.

“During a 15-minute court appearance on Monday he was told by the judge that he may face the death penalty….

“…Authorities say they have not ruled out terrorism as a motive, and that they are investigating whether mental illness may have played a role in the attack.

“In November 2016, Santiago visited an FBI building in Anchorage to tell agents he was hearing voices and believed that US spies were trying to control his mind….”

It’s easy, with 20-20 hindsight, to say that that someone should have done something other than what they did.

Most of the news/op-ed seems to be focusing on the weapon used, but some folks are talking about whether Esteban Ruiz Santiago should have been forced to get evaluation and treatment.

From what I’ve read, it sounds like he was under a lot of stress; and may have real psychiatric problems. Since he killed five folks for no good reason, restraining him seems like a good idea.

Forcing him to get evaluated for psychiatric disorders may be a good idea, too.

Or maybe not. I’m old enough to remember when locking up folks with the “wrong” way of looking at things was easier.2

Since I’m one of ‘those people’ who aren’t squarely on the 50th percentile,3 I’m not particularly motivated to institutionalize folks who “aren’t normal.”

2. “Nothing Wrong With Me”


(From BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Six of the victims, clockwise from top left: Rev Clementa Pinckney, Susie Jackson, Rev Sharonda Singleton, Tywanza Sanders, Rev Daniel Simmons, Depayne Middleton-Doctor”
(BBC News)

“Charleston church gunman Dylann Roof: Nothing wrong with me”
BBC News (January 5, 2017)

“The man convicted of killing nine worshippers at a South Carolina church has addressed the jury for the first time to deny he is mentally ill.

“‘There is nothing wrong with me psychologically,’ Dylann Roof, 22, told jurors considering a death penalty.

“The white supremacist did not ask to have his life spared, and said he would not present any evidence or witnesses….

“…Earlier on Wednesday prosecutors read other excerpts from a journal that was discovered in his jail cell six weeks after his arrest.

“‘I am not sorry. I have not shed a tear for the innocent people I killed,’ he wrote at the time, leading prosecutors to argue that a death penalty was justified….”

Dylan Roof might not qualify for an “insanity defense” under today’s law. What’s legally crazy4 and what’s not has changed in the English-speaking world since Daniel M’Naghten shot the Prime Minister’s private secretary in 1843.

I do, however, see a problem with Mr. Roof’s reason for rejecting mental health evaluations and testimony:

“…According to a handwritten motion Roof filed, he said he would not call mental health experts to testify at his trial because he is sceptical of psychology.

“‘It is a Jewish invention and does nothing but invent diseases and tell people they have problems when they don’t,’ he wrote separately in a journal….”
(BBC News (January 5, 2017))

I’m not surprised that someone who managed to get labeled as a “white supremacist” would be skeptical of a “Jewish invention.”

I know too much of my family history to see racial or ethnic prejudice as anything but a problem.

I look ‘Anglo,’ but am nearly half-Irish: which is not, by some standards, “white.” I think that’s crazy, in more ways than one, and that’s another topic. (November 29, 2016)

Getting back to insanity, law, and justice; I think there’s a sort of ‘insanity defense’ in Hammurabi’s law code. Punishments for assault were significantly reduced if the accused could say “I struck him without intent:”

“…206. If a man strike another man in a quarrel and wound him, he shall swear: ‘I struck him without intent,’ and he shall be responsible for the physician.
“207. If (he) die as a result of the stroke, he shall swear (as above), and if he be a man, he shall pay one-half mana of silver.
“208. If (he) be a freeman, he shall pay one-third mana of silver….”
(The Code of Hammurabi (Harper translation), via Wikisource)

On the other hand, Hammurabi’s law code assigned the death penalty to crimes that didn’t result in death. (September 25, 2016)

Nearly 38 centuries later, we still have laws; and folks who break the laws.


Justice and the Death Penalty


(Today’s decisions have lasting consequences.)

Killing an innocent person is wrong. That’s because human life is sacred. The divine image is in each of us; no matter who we are, who our ancestors are, or what we’ve done. (Genesis 1:27; Catechism, 357, 361, 369–370, 1700, 1730, 2268–2269, 1929, 2273–2274, 2276–2279)

What we do with our life, and the lives of those around us, is up to each of us: for good or ill. (Catechism, 1701–1709, 2258)

Everyone’s life is precious, including mine: and yours. That’s why defending myself, using the least force necessary, is okay: even if that action results in my attacker’s death. (Catechism, 2263–2267)

I don’t think that makes ‘I thought he was going to hit me, so I killed him’ a legitimate defense. And it sure wouldn’t make it okay for me to kill someone I’d tied up: no matter how angry or insecure I felt.

Killing a prisoner is allowed, if that really is the only way that innocent people can be protected. (Catechism, 2267)

I do not doubt that and Esteban Santiago-Ruiz and Dylann Roof are guilty of murder.

I also think that letting either of them go free would put innocent lives in peril.

But I do not think that the United States of America is so desperately poor or weak that we must kill these two men in self-defense.

And killing them to appease a visceral desire for more death doesn’t make sense.

Not Trusting My Feelings


(From BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“‘Everyone’s plea for your soul is proof that they lived in love and their legacies will live in love. So hate won’t win’, a relative of one victim told the suspect”
(BBC News))

I keep saying this. I’m expected to love God, love my neighbors, see everyone as my neighbor, and treat others as I’d like to be treated. (Matthew 5:43–44, 7:12, 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31 10:25–27, 29–37; Catechism, 1789)

“Everyone” means everyone: no exceptions. (Catechism, 604–605, 1465, 2608, 2844)

Feeling angry about mass murder is a natural reaction. But we’re supposed to think.

Emotions happen. It’s part of being human. So is using my brain, thinking before I act or speak. (Catechism, 1951, 1730, 1763–1767)

Emotions may show that something requires attention. After that, my job is using reason to decide what I should or should not do. (Catechism, 1763, 1765, 1767)

Controlling what happens inside, in my heart, is harder: but that’s also required. (Matthew 5:22–22, 15:18–19)

Letting anger build into a desire to harm or kill someone else is a very bad idea. (Catechism, 1762–1775, 2302–2303)

Forgiving someone who has done something very wrong isn’t easy. But it is a good idea: and not the same as pretending that an injustice never happened. Respecting the “transcendent dignity” of humanity means that we work for justice. The trick is hating the sin — not the sinner. (Catechism, 976–980, 1929–1933, 2820)

I’ve talked about this before:


1 St. Joseph is the patron Saint of a happy death, among other things. I know: “happy death” seems like a contradiction in terms, but it makes sense if you look at if from St. Alphonsus Ligouri’s viewpoint —

“Since we all must die, we should cherish a special devotion to St. Joseph, that he may obtain for us a happy death.”
(St. Alphonsus Liguori)

That’s at the top of the third page of this resource:

2 More:

3 The inside of my head isn’t a nice place, but it’s what I have to work with. I’ve talked about this before:

4 A quick look at insanity and American law:

  • “Insanity defense”
    Wex, Legal Information Institute, Cornell University Law School, Last Updated in July of 2016 by Emanuel Francone

Some of my take on law, history, and being human:

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , | 10 Comments

Epiphany Sunday

Statues1 of Caspar, Melchior, and Balthazar started near the clock in our living room. I took those pictures of them on Wednesday. Their trip to the nativity scene ended today, Epiphany Sunday.

We read about “magi from the east” in today’s Gospel: Matthew 2:1 through 12:

“1 When Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea, in the days of King Herod, 2 behold, magi from the east arrived in Jerusalem,
“saying, ‘Where is the newborn king of the Jews? We saw his star 3 at its rising and have come to do him homage.'”
(Matthew 2:1–2)

“Magi” is how μάγοι, mágoi, looks in my native language. That’s the Greek version of an Old Persian word that would sound something like “magus” if I tried pronouncing it. “Magus” is from Avestan “magauno,” the the religious caste Zoroaster was born into; and don’t bother trying to remember all that.

The point is that magi were astrologers, which didn’t mean what it does today.

Seeking Truth

Folks thought that what happens in the sky affects what happens on Earth back when the Hittite empire was a major Mediterranean power.

That belief, and the very practical need for accurate calendars, made researchers who studied the stars and planets very important. I suppose today’s equivalent might be scientists from CERN.

The point is that when our Lord was born, astrologers had a reputation for having detailed knowledge of things that most folks had barely heard of.

Astronomy and astrology were pretty much the same thing until the last few centuries.2

Albertus Magnus, patron Saint of scientists, studied astrology around the time Pope Honorius III approved the Dominican and Franciscan Orders, and Batu Khan ran the Golden Horde.

Some correspondences between what we see in the sky and what happens on Earth are fairly obvious, like the tides and our moon’s position. Looking for more subtle connections seemed reasonable.

It wasn’t until the last few centuries that more data, increasingly precise timekeeping tech, and a whole lot of analysis showed that astrology’s predictive value was pretty much nil.

Astrology makes a short list of bad ideas under the ‘divination’ heading these days. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2116)

Astronomy, the scientific study of what’s in Earth’s sky, is a good idea. Studying this universe, and using that knowledge, is part of being human. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2293–2295)

Like I keep saying, truth can’t contradict truth, and we’re supposed to be curious. This universe is filled with opportunities for greater admiration of God’s creation. (Catechism, 159, 214–217, 283, 341)

“For You Gentiles”

Epiphany is a big deal for folks like me.

The reason I celebrate the Messiah’s birth, death, and resurrection, is that Jesus came for all nations. (Matthew 28:19; Mark 13:10; Romans 16:25–26)

I’m a gentile, descended from folks in northwestern Europe.

We’re mentioned in the other New Testament reading today: Ephesians 3:2–3a, 5–6. Here’s a longer excerpt from that chapter in Ephesians:

“1 Because of this, I, Paul, a prisoner of Christ 2 (Jesus) for you Gentiles –

“if, as I suppose, you have heard of the stewardship 3 of God’s grace that was given to me for your benefit,

“(namely, that) the mystery 4 was made known to me by revelation, as I have written briefly earlier.

“When you read this you can understand my insight into the mystery of Christ,

“which was not made known to human beings in other generations as it has now been revealed to his holy apostles and prophets by the Spirit,

“that the Gentiles are coheirs, members of the same body, and copartners in the promise in Christ Jesus through the gospel.”
(Ephesians 3:2–3a)

That’s why Epiphany and the magi3 are a big deal for me.

I keep saying this, too: the Catholic Church is pretty much the opposite of an exclusive club. We’re literally catholic, καθολικός, universal: a united and diverse people, embracing all cultures and all times.

We’re doing what our Lord told us to do, just before leaving. That’s in Matthew 28:19–20 and Acts 1:10–11.

At the end of all things, I hope I’ll be in the “great multitude, which no one could count, from every nation, race, people, and tongue.” (Revelation 7:9)

“…The Magi represent the peoples of the whole earth who, in the light of the Lord’s birth, set out on the way leading to Jesus and, in a certain sense, are the first to receive that salvation inaugurated by the Saviour’s birth and brought to fulfilment in the paschal mystery of his Death and Resurrection.
“When they reached Bethlehem, the Magi adored the divine Child and offered him symbolic gifts, becoming forerunners of the peoples and nations which down the centuries never cease to seek and meet Christ….”
(“Epiphany of the Lord,” Pope Saint John Paul II (January 6, 1997))

More:


1 Catholics generally aren’t as jittery about visual aids as the more tightly-wound Christian outfits. We’re told that creating and enjoying art is part of being human. Like anything else we do, art can be misused: but it’s a basically good thing. (July 17, 2016)

We don’t worship statues, pictures, Mary, or anyone other than God: the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2112–2114)

We do, however, recognize that some of us have done a remarkably good job of following our Lord:

“VENERATION (OF SAINTS): Showing devotion and respect to Mary, the Apostles, and the martyrs, who were viewed as faithful witnesses to faith in Jesus Christ. Later, veneration was given to those who led a life of prayer and self–denial in giving witness to Christ, whose virtues were recognized and publicly proclaimed in their canonization as saints (828). Such veneration is often extended to the relics or remains of those recognized as saints; indeed, to many sacred objects and images. Veneration must be clearly distinguished from adoration and worship, which are due to God alone (1154, 1674, 2132).”
(Catechism, Glossary)

2 A bit about astrology, astronomy, and science:

3 More about our Lord, Epiphany and the Magi:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Still Looking Forward to Friday the 13th

My brendans-island.com website, and this blog, are now on a Linux server. The change officially happened about two hours ago, around 11:30 am Central Time, 5:30 pm UTC, Friday, January 6, 2016.

I’m told that it may take up to 24 hours for “new” material to be visible on this website — or blog. “New” content apparently includes previously-published posts in A Catholic Citizen in America. Maybe you can see them, but I can’t. I’m hoping this is a temporary situation, and will keep checking: also trying to learn more about the new setup.

Now, to see if the system will let me publish this post. I’ll be back to my regular schedule when it’s possible.

Posted in Being a Writer | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Looking Forward to Friday the 13th

I still don’t know why I had trouble viewing this blog for a few days after Christmas. (December 29, 2016)

I did, however, learn that having my hosting service switch to a Linux server might lower the odds of running afoul of the law of averages.

After talking it over with my son, and doing a bit of my own research, I decided that making the switch made sense.

You won’t notice any difference, and I probably won’t have to do much — if any — tweaking after the change.

However: A Catholic Citizen in America will be unavailable for a day or two this week. Probably not much longer than that — I hope.

Transferring/copying/whatever-ing this blog and the rest of the website to a new server takes time, and is a process I don’t mind having out of my hands.

Assuming that the technical stuff is done in time, I may have a post ready for next Sunday. If not, I plan and hope to have a ‘science’ post ready for Friday the 13th.

Meanwhile, maybe you’d like to read or re-read one of these:

Posted in Being a Writer | Tagged , | 2 Comments