Trinity

I say “in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit” a lot: mostly when I start praying. I generally make the sign of the Cross at the same time.

The sign of the Cross is a very “Catholic” gesture. It “reminds us in a physical way of the Paschal Mystery we celebrate: the death and Resurrection of our Savior Jesus Christ.”1

It’s a prayer, a blessing, and a sacramental; and that’s another topic. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1668–1670)

Dali’s “Crucifixion (Corpus Hypercubus)” is very “Catholic,” too; although not it’s not like the mass-produced 19th-century stuff many associate with our faith.

I wouldn’t be surprised if a half-millennium from now, some tight-collar Catholics will be upset by new art that doesn’t present the Cross as an unfolded tesseract, and that’s yet another topic. Topics.

This morning’s readings, Genesis 12:1–4A; 2 Timothy 1:8B-10; and Matthew 17:1–9; cover something like a dozen centuries, from the time Abram went west — literally, not figuratively — to about two millennia before today.

Abram was re-named Abraham, and now is honored by the Abrahamic religions. (November 29, 2016)

Abraham is “our father in Faith,”2 but almost certainly not among my ancestors. I can’t be sure, but in his day my forebears were probably well north and west of the Holy Land. (February 1, 2017)

There’s been scholarly debate of late, leading some to assume that Abraham lived a whole lot more recently than we thought; or is basically a fictional character.

I’m not surprised that we’ve got precious little documentation on him. The Late Bronze Age collapse, a few really bad decades between 1200 and 1150 BC, happened a few centuries after he left Haran. I’m surprised we remember as much as we do.

We haven’t had anything quite like the Late Bronze Age collapse since, happily.

Hypothetical Smith

Let’s say that today God tells a Mr. Smythe to move from Baltimore, Maryland, to Fremont, Nebraska.

This is all hypothetical. I’m just making a point about how record-keeping isn’t always up to 20th century standards.

Mr. Smythe moves, and changes his name from Smythe to Smith. Then, around the 24th century, something catastrophic happens. It might be a global war, overconfidence in a system that looked good on paper, whatever. Think the 2012 India blackouts on a global scale, micromanaged by an incompetently paranoid bureaucracy.3

Details would be different from the Late Bronze Age collapse, but the effects would be similar.

We still don’t know exactly what happened some 3,200 years ago.

I’ll be optimistic, and assume that survivors start rebuilding civilization; as we did before. A few would even have enough free time to teach their kids how to read and write.

Different folks would tell different stories about what happened. Some would pass along lore from earlier ages. Many records would be lost.

We could get tales as historically accurate as Homer’s account of the Trojan War and Plato’s Atlantis. These would get passed on, too. We like good stories.

Around the year 5200, some scholars might decide that our Mr. Smith didn’t exist. They’d have a point, sort of, since his Social Security Number isn’t in any surviving records.

Interestingly, many scholars think there’s something real behind Homer’s “Illiad.”

Scholiemann finding what’s left of Troy probably helped. I’ve heard that he dug through, and obliterated, what might have been evidence that would have supported some of his claims, and that’s yet again another topic.

Remembering

I’m pretty sure that Plato’s Atlantis, from his “Timaeus” and “Critias,” is fictional. It’s a good story, though, and I enjoyed George Pal’s “Atlantis, the Lost Continent.”

Enthusiastic folks like Ignatius L. Donnelly helped fuel my culture’s occasionally-misguided interest in lost civilizations, and assorted New Age goofiness.4

Plato might have gotten the idea for his fictional city from real events.

A civilization flourished on Crete from around the time construction started at Ġgantija to when Thutmose III was making Egypt a superpower. We started uncovering their ruins about a century back. Somewhere along the line, we started calling them Minoans.

Scientists and archeologists aren’t sure how, or if, the explosive eruption at Santorini affected Minoan civilization. They survived the eruption, but someone or something burned at least some of their cities not all that long after.

The “Minoan eruption” may or may not be half-remembered in the Titanomachy described in Hesiod’s “Theogony.”

As a Wikipedia page put it, “there are no clear ancient records of the eruption.” Again, I’m not surprised.

Descendants of Abraham’s son Isaac and Rebecca remembered who they were. Some of them, anyway.

But even after a 40-year reality check on their way out of Egypt, some decided that they’d rather put someone or something besides God at the top of their priorities. Repeatedly. That’s a bad idea. (Deuteronomy 8:2–3; Catechism, 2112–2114)

Exiles

Assyria was a major power a bit over 27 centuries back, around Duke Zhuang of Zheng’s day.

Assyria’s leaders were trying to unite the (western) world into a single empire. They were succeeding: for the moment.

We call their outfit the Neo-Assyrian Empire.

The Old Assyrian Empire predates the Late Bronze Age collapse. The Middle Assyrian Empire — our name for it, not theirs — survived the cataclysm, but shrank considerably. That was a resilient civilization.

Assyria had invaded Israel back in Menahem’s day. He paid them to leave. (2 Kings 15:19–21)

Ahaz had trouble with Assyria, too, of a different sort. He’d seen an altar in Damascus, and been so impressed that he “…sent to Uriah the priest a model of the altar and a detailed design of its construction.” (2 Kings 16:7–18)

Hezekiah — son of Elah and Abi, daughter of Zarchariah — sorted the mess out, to an extent. 2 Kings 18-1 and following tells about that.

The Assyrian captivity didn’t happen all at once. Tiglath-Pileser III started the process. Sargon II and Sennacherib finished the job, although they didn’t take Jerusalem.

“However, they offended the God of their fathers by lusting after the gods of the natives of the land, whom God had cleared out of their way.

“2 Therefore the God of Israel incited against them the anger of Pul, king of Assyria, and of Tiglath-pileser, king of Assyria, who deported the Reubenites, the Gadites, and the half-tribe of Manasseh and brought them to Halah, Habor, and Hara, and to the river Gozan, where they have remained to this day.”
(1 Chronicles 5:25–26)

I’m not sure why the chronicler wrote “Pul … and Tiglath-pilesser.” Tiglath-Pileser III’s name was Pulu when he had the Assyrian royal family killed, and took over. Two more-legitimate rulers had been named Tiglath-Pileser before that, which could explain it.

Later, around the time that Zhou dynasty’s King Kuang died, Egypt’s Necho II planted Jehoiakim on the throne in Jerusalem. (2 Chronicles 36-3–6)

That was after one of the battles at Meggido. This one was between Nebuchadnezzar II’s Babylonian forces and Necho II’s Egyptian army. We call that iteration of the Babylonian Empire the Neo-Babylonian Empire.

Nebuchadnezzar II and Necho II lost the Battle of Carchemish. That’s not the way Nebuchadnezzar told it. In fairness, Nebuchadnezzar still had a fairly-effective army.

Jehoiakim switched sides. Nebuchadnezzar returned the favor by sacking Jerusalem, which started the Babylonian captivity. 2 Chronicles 36-3–6 sums up Jehoiakim’s regrettable reign.

Nebuchadnezzar didn’t last. Neither did the Neo-Assyrian or Neo-Babylonian empires. (October 2, 2016)

Many folks, myself included, think highly of Cyrus the Great. For good reason:

“‘Thus says Cyrus, king of Persia: “All the kingdoms of the earth the LORD, the God of heaven, has given to me, and he has also charged me to build him a house in Jerusalem, which is in Judah. Whoever, therefore, among you belongs to any part of his people, let him go up, and may his God be with him!”‘”
(2 Chronicles 26:23)

“And they lived happily ever after?” No. We’re not there yet.

The Transfiguration, Briefly

Today’s Gospel reading, Matthew 17:1–9; talks about the Transfiguration. So do Mark 9:2–8; and Luke 9:28–36. John’s Gospel doesn’t, but does have this:

“And the Word became flesh 9 and made his dwelling among us, and we saw his glory, the glory as of the Father’s only Son, full of grace and truth.”
(John 1:14)

That could be John’s description of the Transfiguration, or not. I don’t know.

God said “this is my Son” at our Lord’s baptism, too: Matthew 3:13–17; Mark 1:1–11; and Luke 3:21–23.

The Transfiguration is a sort of sneak preview of God’s kingdom. Peter, James, and John, briefly saw Jesus as, unmistakably, the Son of God. They also perceived the Trinity. (Catechism, 554–556)

“…the whole Trinity appears—the Father in the voice, the Son in the man, the Holy Ghost in the bright cloud…”
(“Summa Theologica,” Thomas Aquinas, III, 45, 4)

As I said, I can’t claim Abraham as an ancestor. Not physically. I do, however, take the “Shema” very seriously:

“שְׁמַע יִשְׂרָאֵל יְהוָה אֱלֹהֵינוּ יְהוָה אֶחָֽד
“Sh’ma Yisra’eil Adonai Eloheinu Adonai echad.
“Hear, Israel, the Lord is our God, the Lord is One”
(From Shema, Judaism 101)

God is ONE

I don’t understand the Trinity. Not on an operational, nuts-and-bolts level.

God’s God, I’m not, so I can’t.

The Trinity is a mystery — 20-20 hindsight lets us see hints of the Trinity in the universe and Old Testament, but we weren’t going to reason it out. God had to tell us. (Catechism, 237)

The best way I’ve found of quickly describing the Trinity is a “Shield of the Trinity,” or “Scutum Fidei.” It’s that diagram with “The Father,” “The Son,” and “The Holy Spirit” in the corners.

Christians are baptized in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. We’re following orders our Lord gave us, right before leaving:

“11 Then Jesus approached and said to them, ‘All power in heaven and on earth has been given to me.
“Go, therefore, 12 and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the holy Spirit,
“teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you. 13 And behold, I am with you always, until the end of the age.'”
(Matthew 28:18–20)

It’s the name, not the names. That’s because God is One: “the almighty Father, his only Son, and the Holy Spirit: the Most Holy Trinity.” (Catechism, 233; “Summa Theologica,” Thomas Aquinas, I, 31, 1)

We still aren’t at the “happily ever after” part.

What we read about in Matthew 28:18–20 and Acts 1:10–11 happened about two millennia back. Our Lord is doing whatever’s mentioned in John 14:3, and our standing orders haven’t changed. He told us to “be prepared” for his return, which I think is a good idea.

And that’s still another topic. (November 27, 2016; October 30, 2016; October 2, 2016)

More, mostly about taking Jesus seriously:


1 Sign of the Cross:

2 “Our Father in faith:”

3 I don’t intend that as a description of India’s handing of the 2012 situation. I chose those incidents because it affected so many folks, and it is a pretty good example of how having the technology isn’t enough. Knowing how to manage the tech matters, too.

I think preparations and responses could have been better, but they could have been a lot worse. I also think letting folks build their own backup systems helped:

4 I have some sympathy for folks who like “New Age” stuff. However, I also am quite convinced that it is a bad idea, along with letting anything — money, politics, pleasure, family, fame, whatever — except God take first place in my priorities. (Catechism, 1723, 2112–2114, 2289, 2424)

At nearly 25,000 none-too-easy-reading words, it’s more than a one-sitting read; but I recommend this as a serious analysis:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Earliest Life: Maybe

We’re not sure how skulls found in central China fit into the family tree. They’re a bit like Neanderthals, a bit like folks still living in that part of the world, and not quite like anyone else.

Other scientists found what may, or may not, be the oldest evidence of life known so far. That’s in Quebec, Canada.

  1. Xuchang Skulls
  2. Oldest Evidence of Life: Maybe

Being Human

I see eyes, nostrils, and a mouth when I look in a mirror. It’s the face of human. (July 15, 2016)

I’m made from the stuff of this world, and filled with God’s ‘breath:’ matter and spirit, body and soul. Each of us is a person: someone, not something, (Genesis 2:7; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 355, 357, 362–368)

We’re made “in the divine image,” rational animals who can control our actions. (Genesis 1:26–27; Catechism, 355–361, 1730, 1951)

“Rational animals?!” Let’s check that face again: it’s pretty obvious that I’m an animal, a vertebrate. The hair shows that I’m a mammal. Forward-facing eyes, an oversize cranium, and features that don’t show in the photo say I’m a primate.

More precisely, I’m a hominid: the sort of critter we used to call “great apes.”

I could decide that I don’t like that. We’ve got free will, remember? I could even be offended at the very idea that I have anything in common with animals.

That doesn’t make sense, not to me. I know what I see in a mirror, and I’ve seen other animals. The similarities are pretty obvious.

I could decide that I don’t like truth, but that would be a bad idea.

Order, Harmony, and God

Whether it’s expressed in words, “the rational expression of the knowledge of created and uncreated reality;” or “the order and harmony of the cosmos;” or in other ways; truth is beautiful — and important. (Catechism, Prologue, 27, 74, 2500)

Thirst for truth and happiness is written into each of us. It should lead us to God. (Catechism, 27)

Faith, the Catholic version, is a willing and conscious “assent to the whole truth that God has revealed.” (Catechism, 142–150)

The whole truth: not just the bits I like. Happily, I like living in a universe that’s almost unimaginably ancient, and “in a state of journeying” toward perfection: but not there yet. (Catechism, 302)

Noticing “the world’s order and beauty,” which reflects God’s infinite beauty, helps us learn about God. (Catechism, 31–32, 341)

Using the brains God gave us, seeking the Almighty and studying this wonder-filled universe, is what we’re supposed to do. (Catechism, 35, 50, 159, 2292–2296)

If this sounds familiar, it should. I say it fairly often. (February 3, 2017; January 8, 2017; October 23, 2016; October 28, 2016)

Aristotle, Ussher, and Linnaeus

From Eric Gaba, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.Aristotle divided critters by γένος, génos, or kind; and εἶδος, eidos, forms within a kind. Birds were a génos; cranes, eagles, sparrows, and such, were various forms within that kind.

Aristotle also thought that young inherit traits from their parents, and that forms and kinds never changed.

He was right about the first item, and for a long time folks thought he was right about the second.

I’ve talked about God, Aristotle, Hildegard of Bingen and Albertus Magnus, before. (December 2, 2016; November 6, 2016)

Fast-forward to about 1650.

That’s when James Ussher wrote “Annales veteris testamenti….” The Dublin-born Calvinist said the day of creation was near the autumnal equinox in 4004 BC.

Some folks still insist that the universe started at nightfall on Saturday, October 22, 4004 BC. I don’t.

John Ray gave the word “species” a biological definition in 1686, or thereabouts. Like Aristotle, he assumed that species never changed.

Carl Linnaeus published his “Systema Naturae” in 1735.

Our genus-species system for naming critters arguably started with the book’s 10th edition, published in 1758. The system’s called binomial nomenclature, a phrase with about eight syllables that you needn’t memorize.

Noticing that humans are a lot like monkeys and vice versa, Linnaeus assigned both to his Anthropomorpha category.1 Some folks didn’t like the idea, and still don’t. Me? What I see in a mirror doesn’t bother me. (July 15, 2016)

Here’s where it starts getting interesting.

Opportunities for Admiration

Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace published an evolutionary theory in 1858.

Assumptions started hitting the fan when Darwin published “On the Origin of Species” in 1859.

Over-simplifying 19th century science, politics, and culture something frightful — scientists debated and argued over the ideas; quite a few non-scientists read the book, with varying reactions; and “evolution” became part of everyday English.

Some felt that a rational and orderly God can’t exist — because life changes in an orderly and rational way. I suspect that assumptions about God didn’t help.

A remarkably number of Christians agreed, loudly, and still do.

I don’t: but I’m a Catholic who understands our faith.

Wondering about our origins is a good idea. We’re “called to a personal relationship with God,” and can learn something of God by studying God’s creation. (Catechism, 32, 282–289, 299, 301)

I think seeing our increasing knowledge as opportunities for admiration of God’s work makes sense. (Catechism, 283, 341)

Getting upset when answers don’t fit old assumptions, not so much.

No Way Back

Where was I? Humans, Aristotle, Ussher, Lamarck, assumptions. Right.

Working with names in Genesis 2:10–15, folks have decided that the Garden of Eden was Armenia, Azerbaijan, Mesopotamia, or near Tabriz.

Like I said, wondering about origins is okay. I’ve wondered about where Eden could have been myself.

There’s also that “fiery revolving sword” wielded by cherubim — plural. I don’t assume that a contemporary American wrote Genesis 3:24, so I don’t think it’s something like Steven Hawking’s proposed gigawatt laser. That’d be a cool idea, though.

But since I’m a Catholic, I figure Catechism, 386–390 and Gaudium et spes, 13, have it right. We’re still dealing with consequences of a really bad decision our first parents made. The “way” back to Eden is blocked. (March 5, 2017; November 6, 2016)

That’s not even close to assuming that Adam and Eve are German.2

Going back isn’t an option. I could moan and groan about that, but I won’t.

We’ve been passing along the best news humanity ever had for two millennia now. God loves us, and wants to adopt us. All of us. (Ephesians 1:3–5; John 3:17; Catechism, 52, 1825)

We’re also helping build, with the help of all folks of good will, a better world. (February 5, 2017; October 30, 2016; October 2, 2016)


1. Xuchang Skulls


(From Xiujie Wu, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Xuchang 1 has a ‘remarkable’ brain size”
(BBC News))

“Ancient skulls give clues to China human history”
Paul Rincon, BBC News (March 3, 2017)

“Two skulls found in China shed light on the ancient humans who inhabited the region before our own species arrived.

“We know that Europe and western Asia was dominated by the Neanderthals before Homo sapiens displaced them.

“But remains belonging to equivalent populations in East and Central Asia have been scarce.

“It’s unclear if the finds are linked to the Denisovans, a mysterious human group known only from DNA analysis of a tooth and finger bone from Siberia….”

Scientists found the “Xuchang skulls” at the Lingjing site in Xuchang County of Henan Province between 2007 and 2014.3 Apparently it’s called Jian’an District now.

The county, or district, is administered from Xuchang, 许昌, a city where upwards of 4,000,000 folks live. The city’s name goes back to Xu, a state led by Xuyou in the Zhou Dynasty’s Spring and Autumn period.

That’s from around the time Ashur-dan III was battling plagues instead of battles for Assyria, to when Pericles moved the Delian League’s treasure from Delos to Athens. And that’s another topic.

Paul Rincon says that modern humans started in Africa about 200,000 years back, followed earlier explorers and settlers, and by now are living on every continent except Antarctica. So have I. (September 30, 2016)

“Modern humans,” anatomically modern human, are folks who look more or less like me, Tȟašúŋke Witkó, Rajesh Khanna, Cíxǐ Tàihòu, and Kobe Bryant.

Scientists generally say modern humans, Homo sapiens sapiens, are the only currently-living subspecies of Homo sapiens.

The other subspecies, Homo sapiens idaltu, is the name for folks who lived about 160,000 years ago, in real estate we call Ethiopia. We’ve all changed a bit since then.

That’s okay. Things, and people, change. Old family photos of my Campbell forebears still show the clan’s characteristic cam béal, wry mouth. I lack that feature. I was also taller by about inch than my father, and my son is substantially taller than me.

Darwin, DNA, and Genesis

We’ve learned quite a bit since folks started having conniptions over Darwin’s ideas.

Friedrich Miescher discovered nucleic acids in in 1869.

In 1927 Nikolai Koltsov said that a “giant hereditary molecule” could have coding for inherited traits.

Frederick Griffith’s 1928 tests and the Avery-MacLeod-McCarty experiment, reported in 1944, showed that DNA was involved in passing genetic information.

The Human Genome Project published an initial analysis of the Human Genome in 2001. That gave scientists another tool for studying human evolution, answered some questions, and raised others.

I could decide — like everyone else, I have free will — that science is a Satanic plot, and that I am literally made of clay: just like Genesis 2:7 says.

Or I could decide that being made of clay and in the image of God is how Genesis expresses “this reality in symbolic language.” (Catechism, 362)

I’m not surprised that Genesis reflects the language, culture, and knowledge of folks living when it was written. That’s probably between the time Amenompe was running Egypt and when Cambyses II inherited the Achaemenid Empire; 25 to 30 centuries back.

Expecting it to reflect what we’ve learned in the last 150 years, or will have learned between 5050 and 5200 AD, isn’t reasonable.

Fitting Into the Family Tree: Somewhere


(From WU Xiujie, via Chinese Academy of Science, used w/o permission.)
(“Fig.1 The Xuchang 1 (A, superior view) and 2 (B, posterior view) crania….”
(Chinese Academy of Science))

The Xuchang skulls are between 105,000 and 125,000 years old. That’s after the time modern humans showed up, and while Neanderthals still lived in my ancestral homelands.

“…Prof Erik Trinkaus, one of the authors of a study on the remains in Science journal, said it was not possible to say at this stage whether the ancient people from Xuchang were connected to the Denisovans.

“‘The issue here is the patterns of variation and the population dynamics of ‘archaic’ populations during the later part of the Pleistocene,’ Prof Trinkaus, from Washington University in St Louis, told BBC News….”
(Paul Rincon, BBC News)

Having a complete skull, and teeth, would help us know more about them. So would having their family photo albums, journals, and home videos. But that tech wasn’t around at the time, so scientists work with what they’ve got.

Denisovan is our name for folks who lived in or near the Altai Mountains about 41,000 years back. We have their DNA, a couple teeth, a few bits of bone, and that’s it. I’ve mentioned them before. (January 13, 2017)

Without DNA, or teeth, it’s hard to say if these folks were related to Denisovans.

Features at the back of their heads, and the shape of their semicircular canals, are a bit like Neanderthals. The general shape, though, fits folks who have lived in and around eastern Eurasia for the last 781,000 years.

Like Neanderthals and quite a folks with northwestern-European ancestry, I’m a bit dolichocephalic. In other words, I’ve got a longer-than-average head.

Quite a few, not all, folks with east Asian ancestry are brachycephalic, with a shorter-than-average head. The ‘Xuchang skull’ folks were a bit brachycephalic, too.

However they fit into humanity’s family tree, these skulls are a welcome addition to eastern Asia’s fossil record.

Cephalic Index


(From Popular Science Monthly, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Popular Science Monthly’s 1896 cephalic index map: interesting, maybe not all that generally useful.)

Cephalic index is a head’s width to length ratio. We get the number by multiplying the width by 100 and dividing by the head’s length. Anders Retzius apparently defined it first. That was 1800, give or take a few decades.

It’s useful for categorizing cats, dogs, and rabbits. Physical anthropologists used the cephalic index to sort out different human populations until around the 1960s. Retzius thought human head shapes were so different that we couldn’t all have a common ancestor.

Samuel George Morton, who lived around the same time, was a famous doctor and scientist in his day. He studied three Egyptian mummies and decided that Caucasians and Negros were distinct species.

On the other hand, he apparently realized that folks from the different “races” could have kids. Links to more than you probably want to know about polygenism, monogenism, and some of what we’re learning of humanity’s long story, are near the end of this post.4

Origins and Statistics

Quite a few folks started moving to the United States in the 19th century. That struck fear into the hearts of some “real Americans,” still does, and that’s yet another topic. (January 22, 2017)

The point is that by 1910, quite a few immigrants to America had been raising families. Statistically significant numbers of 2nd-generation Americans gave Franz Boas a good data set. The kids didn’t have the same cephalic index as their parents.

The environment-heredity debate is still going on, and cephalic index isn’t as widely-used for sorting humans any more.

About polygenism, the idea that each “race” has a different origin; and monogenism, that we all share a common ancestor — I’d be a “monogenist.”

That’s not entirely because fewer mental gymnastics are needed to make monogenism fit the Genesis creation accounts.

Mostly it’s because I think we’re all a huge and very diverse family.

Denisovan and Neanderthal DNA in today’s gene pool say that. So do the “multiracial” kids who give some folks fits. Honestly, if we’re different “species,” how can we have kids?!

I also think “species” is an idea that’s long-overdue for a reevaluation, and that’s yet again another topic.


2. Oldest Evidence of Life: Maybe


(From M Dodd, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Ancient life: These clumps of iron and filaments show similarities to modern microbes”
BBC News))

“Earliest evidence of life on Earth ‘found’”
Pallab Ghosh, BBC News (March 1, 2017)

“Scientists have discovered what they say could be fossils of some of the earliest living organisms on Earth.

“They are represented by tiny filaments, knobs and tubes in Canadian rocks dated to be up to 4.28 billion years old.

That is a time not long after the planet’s formation and hundreds of millions of years before what is currently accepted as evidence for the most ancient life yet found on Earth….

“…Matthew Dodd, who analysed the structures at University College London, UK, claimed the discovery would shed new light on the origins of life.

“‘This discovery answers the biggest questions mankind has asked itself – which are: where do we come from and why we are here?

“‘It is very humbling to have the oldest known lifeforms in your hands and being able to look at them and analyse them,’ he told BBC News….”

“…where do we come from and why we are here?” I’m assuming that Matthew Dodd meant “why” in the “cause of” sense. Again: wondering about origins is a good idea. (Catechism, 282–289,)

I’ve talked about secondary causes before. (January 13, 2017)

We’re reasonably sure that Earth formed 4,540,000,000 years back, give or take 50,000,000.

Depending on who’s talking, life began 4,100,000,000, 3,700,000,000, or 3,480,000,000 years ago.

Or, if the high-end estimate of these scientists is right, 4,280,000,000 years ago.

The 3.7 billion year old evidence is carbon in metasedimentary rocks found in western Greenland.

Scientists found 3.48 billion years old microbial mat fossils in Western Australia. That’s near where other scientists found carbon encased in zircons: 4.1 billion years old. Or maybe 4,250,000,000 years. There’s being debated.5

‘All of the above’ are billions of years before Ussher’s date for creation. I’ll get back to that.

One of the reasons it’s so hard to find evidence of early life on Earth is that critters didn’t develop skeleton-like parts until a bit over a half-billion years ago. Squishy critters like jellyfish fossilize even less often that those with hard parts.

Another reason is that anything organic usually gets recycled/eaten by living critters. That’s what would have happened to the Australian carbon, if it hadn’t been encased in zircons.

That gets me back to Quebec’s Nuvvuagittuq Greenstone Belt, where the “tiny filaments, knobs and tubes” were. Scientists using different dating methods got ages of 3,750,000,000 and 4,388,000,000 years. Either way, the rocks are very old.

Finding out exactly how old is important, since that will help us work out how soon life started on Earth.

If it’s as old as it may be, life began very shortly after the Solar System’s planets formed: which means we could have been looking for life on Mars in the wrong places. That’s a topic for another post.

Following St. Augustine’s Advice

Some folks still think Ussher’s assertion that the universe started in 4004 BC. must be so, since it’s “Biblical.”

I don’t.

Ussher’s estimate was pretty good scholarship in 1650, but we’ve learned a great deal since then.

Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon carefully measured how fast iron cools, extrapolated from that data, and found that Earth was about 75,000 years old. That was in 1778.

The Sorbonne condemned Leclerc’s ideas, he issued a retraction, and it turns out that he was wrong by several powers of ten.

Earth is a lot older.

William Thomson, 1st Baron Kelvin, used similar methods in 1862. He calculated an age of Earth at somewhere between 20,000,000 and 400,000,000 years.

He was wrong, too, but his estimate was reasonable: given what we knew at the time.

Jean-Baptiste Lamarck wasn’t the first chap to think species can change, but that’s where I’ll start. He gave a lecture in 1800, outlining a theory about evolution.

He wrote about it in 1802, 1809, and in a seven-volume doorstop called “Histoire naturelle des animaux sans vertèbres” that hit the press from 1815 to 1822.

Nicolas Steno’s 1616 “De glossopetris dissertatio” helped launch paleontology as a science. Steno was brought up as a Lutheran, started asking questions, became a Catholic, and that’s still another topic.

Or maybe not so much.

I’m convinced that using the brains God gave us doesn’t offend the Almighty. (Catechism, 159)

I also think St. Augustine was right, and still is:

“Question the beauty of the earth, question the beauty of the sea, question the beauty of the air…. They all answer you, ‘Here we are, look; we’re beautiful.’…
“…So in this way they arrived at a knowledge of the god who made things, through the things which he made.”
(Sermon 241, St. Augustine of Hippo (ca. 411) (from www.vatican.va/spirit/documents/spirit_20000721_agostino_en.html (December 6, 2016))

Asking questions, seeking knowledge:


1 We’ve learned a lot since 1735:

2 I keep saying that:

3 Regional coverage:

4 Humanity’s long story, what we’re learning so far:

5 Studying early Earth:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments

Living With Consequences

I’ve missed one morning set, and several of the evening prayer sequences, in the routine I started February 13. (February 19, 2017)

I’m doing a little better so far with the Lenten Chaplet. I started that Ash Wednesday.

Emphasis on “so far.” I nearly forgot twice, which doesn’t surprise me. There’s a very good reason for my wife handling the household’s schedules, and that’s another topic.

This is where I could quote Romans 7:19 and launch into a ‘wretcheder than thou’ lament. It’d be accurate, on one level, since I’ve felt this way often enough:

“For I do not do the good I want, but I do the evil I do not want.”
(Romans 7:19)

But I won’t, since I think hypocrisy, inverted or otherwise, is a bad idea. I’ve talked about Luke 18:9–14; Colossians 2:18; and Uriah Heep; before. (October 23, 2016; July 31, 2016)

Feeling that I generally do what is wrong, not what I know is right, is understandable.

Spending decades with undiagnosed depression and an autism spectrum disorder left me with quite a few regrettable perceptions and habits. (February 12, 2017; October 14, 2016; October 5, 2016)

Feelings aside, I know that I have trouble doing what I know is right and avoiding what is wrong.

Jonathan Edwards, Mark Twain, and Me

There’s a reason for that, and it’s not that I’m “some loathsome insect:”

“…every unconverted Man properly belongs to Hell….”
“…The God that holds you over the Pit of Hell, much as one holds a Spider, or some loathsome Insect, over the Fire, abhors you….”
“…you will be wholly lost and thrown away of God….”
(“Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God,” pp. 6, 9, 15, 18; Jonathan Edwards (July 8, 1741) (via Digital Commons@University of Nebraska-Lincoln))

Edwards had, and has, a remarkable influence on America’s religious assumptions. I think that helps explain Mark Twain’s attitude, and my sympathy for it:

“I don’t like to commit myself about heaven and hell – you see, I have friends in both places.

“When I think of the number of disagreeable people that I know who have gone to a better world, I am sure hell won’t be so bad at all.”
(Mark Twain, p.377 of Evan Esar, “20,000 quips & quotes” (1968))

“[H]eaven for climate, Hell for society.”
(Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain), Speech to the Acorn Society (1901); via Wikiquote.org)

“I studied a minute, sort of holding my breath, and then says to myself: ‘All right, then I’ll go to Hell.”
(Mark Twain, Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (1885), via Bartlett’s Quotations, 16th ed.)

I also think, and hope, Jonathan Edwards meant well.

I was going somewhere with this. Let’s see: prayer, Uriah Heep, Jonathan Edwards, Mark Twain. Right. Got it.

Having sympathy for Twain’s “[H]eaven for climate…” quip doesn’t mean I think Heaven is filled with folks who wouldn’t associate with hellbound sinners and other riffraff.

One more thing, about Genesis and all that. As I keep saying, Adam and Eve aren’t German. (October 21, 2016; September 23, 2016; August 28, 2016)

“The Man Replied….” Sound Familiar?

Today’s Bible readings start with Genesis 2:7–9, 3:1–7.

That’s where Eve listens to the serpent, Adam listens to Eve, and they both make a really bad decision.

Then Adam firmly plants both feet in his mouth with this gem:

“The man replied, ‘The woman whom you put here with me – she gave me fruit from the tree, so I ate it.'”
(Genesis 3:12)

Right. They’re both in trouble, so what does Adam do? Tries blaming his wife and God. That did not end well.

Making sense of Adam, Eve, Genesis, and my erratic success with prayer, means backing up a little. A lot, actually.

Still Basically Good

The universe is basically good. So are we — basically. (Genesis 1:26–27, 31; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 299, 364, 369, 374)

Humanity was made “in the divine image.” We still are. (Genesis 1:27; Catechism, 31, 355–361)

Each of us is a rational creature with free will. We can decide what we do or do not do. We are also responsible for the consequences of our decisions. (Catechism, 1730–1742)

The first of us listened to Satan, ignoring what God had said. (Genesis 3:5–13)

We’ve been living with consequences of their decision ever since. (Catechism, 396–412)

That was a very, very long time ago.

I’m not personally responsible for those consequences. But I either deal with them, or pretend they’re not there, which doesn’t seem prudent.

“Original sin” is what we call the mess we’re in. Here’s how the Catechism defines it:

“ORIGINAL SIN: The sin by which the first human beings disobeyed the commandment of God, choosing to follow their own will rather than God’s will. As a consequence they lost the grace of original holiness, and became subject to the law of death; sin became universally present in the world. Besides the personal sin of Adam and Eve, original sin describes the fallen state of human nature which affects every person born into the world, and from which Christ, the ‘new Adam,’ came to redeem us (396–412).”
(Catechism, Glossary)

Loving ourselves, others, and God, is a struggle. That’s because the harmony we had with ourselves and with the universe, and our friendship with God, is broken. (Catechism, 374–379, 398, 400)

That’s the bad news. The good news is that human nature is wounded: but not corrupted. (Catechism, 405, 1701–1707, 1949)

Seeking Understanding

I don’t understand God. Not fully. I can’t. (November 13, 2016)

God’s God, I’m not. I’m a created being, like everyone else. (Genesis 1:1; Catechism, 279, 285)

God is beyond time and space, and “here” in all places and all times. The Almighty is infinitely good, “a mystery beyond words.” (Catechism, 206, 230, 268, 284, 300, 385, 639, 647–648, 2779)

On the other hand, ‘faith seeks understanding.’ St. Anselm wrote that, more or less. His first title for “Proslogion” was “Fides Quaerens Intellectum.”

Latin isn’t my strong suit, but I think “Fides Quaerens Intellectum” is “Faith Seeking Understanding” in my language.

That was about a thousand years back now, and the slogan stuck.

What I’m trying to say is that wanting to better understand God is a good idea. (Catechism, 156–159)

Understanding God would be easier if we weren’t dealing with original sin. Our current default settings give us a distorted picture of God. (Catechism, 399)

I strongly suspect that’s why it seems so easy to imagine ourselves as targets in a shooting gallery, and God as someone blowing off steam.

“… There is no Want of Power in God to cast wicked Men into Hell at any Moment….
“…They are now the Objects of that very same Anger & Wrath of God that is expressed in the Torments of Hell….
“…In short, they have no Refuge, nothing to take hold of, all that preserves them every Moment is the meer arbitrary Will, and uncovenanted unobliged Forbearance of an incensed God….”
(“Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God,” pp. 5, 6, 12; Jonathan Edwards (July 8, 1741) (via Digital Commons@University of Nebraska-Lincoln))

Jonathan Edwards was not a Catholic, by the way.

God the Father: Really

God wants to adopt us. All of us. (John 1:12–14, 3:17; Romans 8:14–17; 2 Peter 1:3–4; Catechism, 27–30, 52, 1825, 1996)

I decided to accept the Almighty’s offer. (February 26, 2017)

Seeing God as a father can be scary.

Some fathers aren’t good at our jobs. Some are quite simply bad at being fathers: taking out anger and frustration on other members of the family, and that’s yet again another topic — a sad one.

Happily, God isn’t that sort of father. I can expect love, compassion, and help when I needed it. (Psalms 103:4; Catechism, 268)

I can also expect learning opportunities.

My experience strongly suggests that God will keep letting me experience first-hand why some daft decision was a bad idea: like drinking too much. (July 10, 2016)

I don’t see that as a lack of love. I do see it as a good, if occasionally painful and embarrassing, way to help me learn why doing the right thing actually does make sense.

In the long run.

Making use of these opportunities in a timely fashion is — still another topic.

More of how I see God, love, and being human:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , | 5 Comments

TRAPPIST-1: Water? Life??

TRAPPIST-1’s planets may support life: or not. We don’t know. Not yet.

We’re pretty sure that all seven are rocky worlds, like the Solar System’s inner planets.

Three are in the star’s habitable zone. The inner two definitely do not have one sort of atmosphere that would make life as we know it impossible.

Even if we don’t find life there, we’ll learn a great deal while looking.

  1. Size, Comparisons, and a Little Math
  2. Alien Life, Tourists, and Robots
  3. Voyage to a Distant Star
  4. Beyond Setting Records

Bigger than Jupiter: But Not by Much


(From ESO/O. Furtak, used w/o permission.)

TRAPPIST-1 is a small, very dim, very cool, star. Its diameter is about 158,600 kilometers, bigger than Jupiter’s 142,900, but not by much. TRAPPIST-1 b through h orbit very close to their sun.1


(From NASA/JPL-Caltech, used w/o permission.)

We know how big the TRAPPIST-1 planets are, but not what they look like.

Like I said, we don’t know if there’s life on any of them; or even if it’s possible.

But I won’t claim that God can’t have life anywhere but Earth. I’ve talked about Aristotle, 1277, and getting a grip, before. (December 16, 2016; December 2, 2016)

Truth cannot contradict truth, being curious is a good idea, and scientific discoveries are opportunities for greater admiration of God’s creation. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 159, 214–217, 283, 294, 341)

I’ve been over that before, too. Quite often, actually:

A Belgian Telescope, Monks, and Beer


(From TRAPPIST/ESO, used w/o permission.)
(“TRAPPIST–South First Light Image of the Tarantula Nebula”
(ESO))

“…TRAPPIST (TRAnsiting Planets and PlanetesImals Small Telescope) is a project led by the Department of Astrophysics, Geophysics and Oceanography (AGO) of the University of Liège (Belgium), in close collaboration with the Observatory of Geneva (Switzerland). TRAPPIST is mostly funded by the Belgian Fund for Scientific Research (FNRS) with the participation of the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF).

“The team is composed of Emmanuël Jehin, Michaël Gillon, Pierre Magain, Virginie Chantry, Jean Manfroid, and Damien Hutsemékers (University of Liège, Belgium) and Didier Queloz and Stéphane Udry (Observatory of Geneva, Switzerland).

“The name TRAPPIST was given to the telescope to underline the Belgian origin of the project. Trappist beers are famous all around the world and most of them are Belgian. Moreover, the team members really appreciate them!”
(eso1023 — Organisation Release (June 8, 2010))

“Trappists” is what folks call monks in the Order of Cistercians of the Strict Observance. If you’re into Latin acronyms, that’s O.C.S.O.: Ordo Cisterciensis Strictioris Observantiae. They’re contemplative monks and nuns, part of the Benedictine family. (August 14, 2016)

The monastic order got its name from La Trappe Abbey. It doesn’t have much to do with Maria von Trapp and “The Story of the Trapp Family Singers.” Not directly.


1. Size, Comparisons, and a Little Math


(From ESO/O. Furtak, via Space.com, used w/o permission.)

“What Would Life Be Like on the TRAPPIST-1 Planets?”
Calla Cofield, Space.com (February 24, 2017)

“The TRAPPIST-1 system is home to seven planets that are about the size of Earth and potentially just the right temperature to support life. So how would life on these alien worlds be different than life on Earth? Here are some of the major differences.

“Amazing night-sky views

“Perhaps one of the most dramatic things that visitors to the TRAPPIST-1 system would notice is the view of the other six planets in the sky. In some cases, a neighboring planet might appear twice as large as the full moon seen from Earth. [Images: The 7 Earth-Size Worlds of TRAPPIST-1]

“‘If you were on the surface of one of these planets you would have a wonderful view of the other planets,’ Michaël Gillon, an astronomer at the University of Liège in Belgium and an author on the new paper, said in describing the discovery. ‘You wouldn’t see them like we see Venus or Mars, like dots of light. You would see them really as we see the moon. … You would see the structures on these worlds.’…”

I’m pretty sure that Michaël Gillon had “structures” like Lunar mare in mind, not artificial structures.

Even so, a half-dozen ‘moons’ in the sky would make landscapes on TRAPPIST-1’s planets resemble (very slightly) Golden Age of Science Fiction magazine covers.

How big each of the other planets would look would depend on where they were in their orbits. Those closer to TRAPPIST-1 than the observer would go through phases, like we see on our moon.

I like to check assertions I read, so I looked up the TRAPPIST-1 system’s orbits.

The semimajor axis for TRAPPIST-1b, the first planet out from its star, is 1,660,000 kilometers. In other words, the planet’s center is 1,660,000 kilometers from the star’s center, on average.

TRAPPIST-1c’s semimajor axis is 2,280,000 kilometers. The distance between the two orbits is around 620,000 kilometers.

Comparison time. The semimajor axis for our moon’s orbit is about 384,400 kilometers. The distance between the orbits of TRAPPIST-1b and c is only about 1.6 time the distance to our moon.

Each planet is about the size of Earth, so when they’re close, the other world would look a lot larger than our moon does from Earth.

If any have water and support life, that’s a big “if,” I suspect poets will eventually wax eloquent about crescent worlds over the sparkling waters of distant lands.

Their “sun” would look much larger than ours, too, but TRAPPIST-1 is much smaller than our star.

That may be why its planets orbit so closely: or not. We’ve learned quite a bit about how stars and planets form, and there’s a great deal left to learn.


2. Alien Life, Tourists, and Robots


(From NASA-JPL/Caltech, via NPR, used w/o permission.)

“Trappist-1 Planet Discovery Ignites Enthusiasm In Search For Alien Life”
Marcelo Gleiser, Op-ed, NPR (February 23, 2017)

“A group of astronomers announced Wednesday that seven Earth-size planets orbit a small, red, dwarf star 40 light-years away.

“The findings were published in the journal Nature. Observations indicate that at least three of the planets may be at temperate zones where liquid water may exist.

“The extraordinary finding — discovered by astronomers from an international collaboration led by Michaël Gillon from the University of Liège in Belgium, places the search for Earth-like planets and, more spectacularly, the search for alien life, under a brand-new lens. NASA released a fun poster about the findings….”

That poster is from NASA’s strictly-for-fun “Exoplanet Travel Bureau.”

Space tourism is real enough. Folks have been on Soyuz flights to the ISS since 2001. Not many folks can afford it, though, and that’s another topic.

Elon Musk says his SpaceX company will fly tourists around Earth’s moon in late 2018. (BBC News (February 28, 2017))

Sending human explorers to Mars may happen in the 2030s. Reaching the stars — I’ll get back to that.

Finding alien life depends, basically, on two things: extraterrestrial life existing; and knowing what to look for.

There’s a lively debate going on about how, exactly, to define “life” in the physical sense. Searching for alien life depends on knowing what we should look for.

Defining “life” seems simple enough. A Wikipedia page says “Life is a characteristic distinguishing physical entities having biological processes, such as signaling and self-sustaining processes….”

Another Wikipedia page says biological process are “processes vital for a living organism to live…” That definition brings us back to defining “life,” both of which are not particularly helpful, so far.

If “signalling and self-sustaining processes” are what makes something “alive,” then rovers like Curiosity are close to being “alive.” That definition isn’t particularly useful, assuming that most folks don’t think robots are “alive.”

Living critters on Earth are “organic” in the sense that we’re made of organic compounds.

“Organic” in that sense means that the compound contains carbon. The term goes back to when vitalism still made sense, and that’s yet another topic.

Stretching Definitions

We’ve downgraded hopes for Mars from finding Martian people to finding Martian microbes. (December 16, 2016)

We’re also learning a great deal about how to look for extraterrestrial life.

Oxygen in a planet’s atmosphere seemed like an obvious biomarker. Then the National Institutes of Natural Sciences’ Norio Narita and Shigeyuki Masaoka showed how non-biological processes could oxygenate a planet’s atmosphere.2

Making the search more interesting, some critters don’t need oxygen. Or sunlight, for that matter.

Definitions of life-as-we-know-it got stretched in 1977. That’s when researchers found critters living around hydrothermal vents in the Galápagos Rift.

Up to that point, assuming that all life needed sunlight seemed reasonable. After all, plants photosynthesize using sunlight, which provides food for other critters.

Since then, we’ve found extremophiles, critters living in “extreme” places, in quite a few ‘uninhabitable’ spots.

No matter where they live, though, all living critters need water.

Probably.

Life as We Know It: and Otherwise, Maybe


(From NASA/JPL-Caltech, used w/o permission.)
(TRAPPIST-1 and Solar planetary systems. The green areas are the two stars’ habitable zones, where liquid water could exist on an Earth-like planet.)

I’ve talked about habitable zones before. (September 2, 2016; July 29, 2016)

It’s where a planet like Earth is far enough from its star for water to be liquid, but not so far that it freezes. But they’re not the only places where we can look for life.

We’ve learned that liquid water can, and almost certainly does, exist in the outer Solar System. Subsurface oceans of Europa and Enceladus, moons of Jupiter and Saturn, may support life. (September 30, 2016)

That’s “life as we know it:” organic chemistry with water serving as a solvent.

That may be the only way “life” can work. Properties of the elements and compounds in our bodies seem ideally suited for life’s complex chemistry.

Carbon can bond with a great many other elements, and will form extremely complex molecules.

Water is a really good solvent, and stays liquid over a wide temperature range. It doesn’t get hotter or colder easily, and has other properties that make it an obvious choice for life’s working fluid.

Maybe it’s the only possible choice. Then again, maybe not.

In the ’60s, a former professor at Boston University suggested more-or-less-plausible life chemistries for temperatures ranging from near red-hot to near absolute zero.

We’re third down, nucleic acid/protein (O) in water:

  • Fluorosilicone in fluorosilicone
  • Fluorocarbon in sulfur
  • Nucleic acid/protein (O) in water
  • Nucleic acid/protein (N) in ammonia
  • Lipid in methane
  • Lipid in hydrogen
    (“View from a Height” Isaac Asimov (1963), Lancer Books (p. 63))

Isaac Asimov’s grasp of ecology and physics was a trifle shaky in his fiction: but this time he was speculating in his professional field, chemistry.

Since then, quite a few scientists have started taking non-organic life chemistries seriously.3


3. Voyage to a Distant Star


(From ESO/M. Kornmesser/spaceengine.org, via Space.com, used w/o permission.)

“TRAPPIST-1: How Long Would It Take to Fly to 7-Planet System?”
Hanneke Weitering, Space.com (February 23, 2017)

“The discovery of seven Earth-size planets around a nearby star, TRAPPIST-1, is certainly exciting news. But what would it take to visit one of these potentially Earth-like alien worlds?

“TRAPPIST-1 is 39 light-years away from Earth, or about 229 trillion miles (369 trillion kilometers). It would take 39 years to get to its current location traveling at the speed of light. But no spacecraft ever built can travel anywhere near that fast.

“That said, people have sent some pretty fast vehicles into outer space. With today’s technology, how long would it take to get to TRAPPIST-1?…”

Eventually, we’ll probably send a ship to orbit and study each of its planets; like the Dawn mission to Vesta and Ceres.

I doubt it will be our first interstellar destination. That could be Proxima Centauri b, about 4.2 light-years away. (September 2, 2016)

We’ll have to be patient. Light from TRAPPIST-1 takes about 39 years to get here, and today’s spacecraft are a whole lot slower.

New Horizons would make the trip in 817,000 years. Voyager 1 is faster, and would cover the distance in 685,000 years.

Stephen Hawking’s Breakthrough Starshot initiative microprobes would be much faster, once folks develop the technology. They’d go 39 light-years in roughly 200 years.

Meanwhile, scientists are studying the TRAPPIST-1 system the way Galileo studied Mars and other Solar planets: using telescopes. (December 16, 2016)

Starchips and Laser Cannons

Something like Hawking’s Breakthrough Starshot is probably our best option for interstellar probes using technology that’s not too far from off-the-shelf hardware.

Instead of building a single probe, Hawking’s Starshot would be a fleet of 1,000 StarChip mini-probes.

Each StarChip would be a light sail, like NASA’s NanoSail-D: only smaller. A lot smaller. Each mini-probe would be a centimeter across, equipped with a tiny camera, electronics, and a transmitter.

Once in space, several gigawatt lasers — this is tech we don’t quite have yet — would push them up to about 20% speed of light.

They could reach Proxima Centauri in about two decades. A quarter-century after launch, pictures taken by the probes and transmitted back to Earth would give us the first close(ish) pictures of Proxima Centauri b.

We’ve made lasers, like the Argus, handling gigawatt-level emissions.

Getting the things to last more than a few moments, and focusing the beam, is another matter. Besides, I’m not sure how national leaders would take the idea of someone building what amounts to a laser cannon.


4. Beyond Setting Records


(From ESO, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“Star’s seven Earth-sized worlds set record”
Paul Rincon, BBC News (February 22, 2017)

“Astronomers have detected a record seven Earth-sized planets orbiting a single star.

“The researchers say that all seven could potentially support liquid water on the surface, depending on the other properties of those planets.

“But only three are within the conventional ‘habitable’ zone where life is considered a possibility.

“The compact system of exoplanets orbits Trappist-1, a low-mass, cool star located 40 light-years away from Earth.

“The planets, detected using Nasa’s Spitzer Space Telescope and several ground-based observatories, are described in the journal Nature….”

Folks at SETI checked the TRAPPIST-1 system for radio signals last year, using the Allen Telescope Array. They ‘heard’ no obviously-artificial signal, but will try again.4

That could mean there’s nobody there.

Or maybe radio isn’t the only long-range communication technology. We started using wavelengths between 1 millimeter and 100 kilometers about a century back. I’ve talked about tech, time, and SETI, before. (December 16, 2016; September 16, 2016)

Finding life, intelligent or otherwise, would be enormously exciting. But that’s not the only reason scientists study TRAPPIST-1 and its planets.

Because the star is so dim, and fairly close, studying its planets will be comparatively easy. As BBC Science Editor David Shukman said, “telescopes studying the planets are not dazzled as they would be when aiming at far brighter stars.” (BBC News)

Besides being much closer than most of our galaxy’s stars, TRAPPIST-1’s planets pass between their star and ours once each of their years. That lets scientists study light that passes through their atmosphere. Assuming they have atmospheres.

TRAPPIST-1 b and c: Learning What’s Not There


(From NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, used w/o permission.)
(“To determine what’s in the atmosphere of an exoplanet, astronomers watch the planet pass in front of its host star and look at which wavelengths of light are transmitted and which are partially absorbed.”
(NASA))

J. de Wit’s artwork shows TRAPPIST-1 and two of its planets. It’s a good illustration, but includes details that are educated guesses: not facts.

The first low-resolution images of a star other than ours, Betelgeuse, go back to the 1970s. But that star is very bright, giving instruments lots of light to work with.

Scientists got a picture of TRAPPIST-1 last year, but they were looking for a companion star or brown dwarf. Those images were very low-resolution, too; and confirmed that TRAPPIST-1 is a single star.5 The pictures didn’t show planets, and weren’t intended to.

We use something like transmission and absorption spectroscopy each time we look at something and notice what color it is. Different materials reflect, transmit, and absorb, light in distinct ways.

I could explain that by saying “energy associated with the quantum mechanical change primarily determines the frequency of the absorption line.” If you’re interested, I put a few links to geek-speak resources near the end of this post.6

You can blame Isaac Newton for spectroscopy. He called the colors we get when light passes through a prism a spectrum. William Hyde Wollaston noticed dark absorption lines in our star’s spectrum in 1802.

Joseph von Fraunhofer noticed them in 1814. I don’t know why we call them Fraunhofer lines, not Wollaston lines.

Anyway, each element emits a particular set of wavelengths if it’s heated enough; and absorbs those wavelengths if it’s not. I’m over-simplifying it: a lot.

Wondering why elements act that way helped scientists develop quantum mechanics, and that’s yet again another topic.

Scientists got a ‘look’ at the atmospheres of TRAPPIST-1 b and c last year. (July 29, 2016)

They found a “featureless spectrum,” which rules out a puffy atmosphere of mostly hydrogen.

We’re still not sure what their atmospheres are like, but we know their masses and diameters. Scientists think the odds are good that each of the seven planets found so far are rocky, like the Solar System’s inner worlds.

X-rays, Life, and Surprises


(From NASA/JPL-Caltech, used w/o permission.)
(“This illustration shows the possible surface of TRAPPIST-1f, one of the newly discovered planets in the TRAPPIST-1 system….”
(NASA/JPL-Caltech))

TRAPPIST-1 is upwards of 500,000,000 years old. How much older is hard to say, since low-mass stars change very slowly after settling on to the main sequence. A star like TRAPPIST-1 could last a hundred billion years.

That could mean that habitable planets in such systems stay habitable for a very long time.

On the other hand, last year scientists measured x-rays from TRAPPIST-1. That’s nothing unusual. Our star produces about as much x-ray radiation during its quiet phase.

TRAPPIST-1’s planets are so close, though, that these x-rays could do a lot more than the ones hitting Earth. That may affect the TRAPPIST-1 planetary atmospheres, or not.7

The planets are almost certainly either tidally locked, with one side always facing their sun, or in a spin-orbit resonance like Mercury. Either way, life on such worlds wouldn’t be entirely like its terrestrial analog.8

That could mean that life on the TRAPPIST-1 planets is impossible — or that this amazing puzzle collection we call the universe has more surprises for us.

More about how I see life, science, and the Fermi paradox:


1 TRAPPIST-1, still learning:

2 Oxygen, atmospheres, and life:

3 Life, science and informed speculation:

4 SETI and TRAPPIST-1:

5 Getting images of other stars:

6 More than you may want to know about spectroscopy:

7 X-rays and TRAPPIST-1:

8 Habitability and habitable zones, informed speculation:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Olathe: Death and Hope

Murder and attempted murder in the Kansas City metropolitan area last week is international news.

If the suspect’s neighbor is right, the ‘drunken mess’ who killed an engineer from India was having trouble dealing with his father’s death.1

I think he could have found a better outlet for his grief.

Bad, But It Could be Worse


(From Facebook, via the BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(Srinivas Kuchibhotla, Alok Madasani, and Ian Grillot.)

Srinivas Kuchibhotla and his friend were enjoying a beer after work last Wednesday. A man started yelling racial slurs at them.

That didn’t sit well with other folks at the bar and grill. The man left, came back with a gun, apparently told Srinivas Kuchibhotla and Alok Madasani to “get out of my country,” and shot them. He also shot Ian Grillot, who trying to help the first two victims.

Srinivas Kuchibhotla is dead, his friend isn’t, and Ian Grillot is in a hospital.

Alok Madasani was hurt, but not hospitalized. He stopped by Ian Grillot’s room to thank him for trying to help.

The man who apparently caused the trouble has been arrested and charged with one count of premeditated first-degree murder, plus two counts of attempted premeditated first-degree murder.

The FBI is looking at his motives, so hate crime may be added to his legal troubles.

It could be worse.

I think it’s likely that the man responsible will be kept from hurting anyone else. Whether he will be treated with justice or vengeance is another topic. (January 11, 2017)

Quite a few Americans aren’t like that man. Donations to GoFundMe pages, including Srinu’s Family/Recovery Support, passed $1,000,000 yesterday. This won’t bring Srinivas Kuchibhotla back, but it should help his widow.

“$1 million and counting: GoFundMe donors step up for Olathe shooting victims”
Eric Adler, The Kansas City Star (February 25, 2017)

“Well, that didn’t take long.

“By Saturday afternoon — less than three days after shootings that are being investigated as a possible hate crime at an Olathe bar — donations of more than $1 million had poured into four GoFundMe sites established for one man fatally shot and two victims wounded.

“The donations — more than 26,000 in all — came from all 50 states and at least 38 countries, according to GoFundMe….”

“Which country are you from?…”

I think Srinivas Kuchibhotla’s widow has been taking this very well, under the circumstances:

“… ‘Just last week we drove to Iowa to see our friends and their new baby,’ she said. ‘When we came back, he was working in the car while I was driving. That’s how much he loved working… He personally wanted to do so much for this country.’

“Mr Kuchibhotla worked at the US technology company Garmin, alongside his friend Mr Madasani, who has now been released from hospital. The pair were regulars at Austin’s Bar and Grill where they enjoyed sharing a drink after work.

“But on Wednesday night another customer, Adam Purinton, was shouting racist slurs and told the two men they did not belong in America, witnesses said….

“…In a separate interview, Mr Madasani told the BBC: ‘This guy just randomly comes up and starts pointing fingers… We knew something was wrong… He said: “Which country are you from? Are you here illegally?”‘…”
(Rajini Vaidyanathan, BBC News (February 25, 2017))

Srinivas Kuchibhotla came from Hyderabad, India. He’s been in America since 2005. Since then, he earned a master’s degree in electrical engineering, and worked as a software and systems engineer in Iowa and Kansas.

I don’t think that makes him a threat.

That’s no great virtue on my part. I like living in a world where everybody doesn’t look and act like me.

More to the point, loving God and my neighbors — all my neighbors — is important. So is treating other folks the way I want them to treat me. (Matthew 5:43–44, 7:12, 22:36–40; Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31 10:25–27, 29–37; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1789, 1825)

I’ve said that before. A lot. (February 26, 2017; February 1, 2017; January 22, 2017; November 29, 2016)

I’m “from America,” and look “American” in the WASP sense.

Again, that’s no great virtue — and hardly surprising. I look a bit like my ancestors, who came from Norway, Ireland, and Scotland. All folks with northwestern European ancestry look a bit like me.

So how come I’m not raving about America being overrun by “foreigners?”

That’d be daft, since I’m among the 99% of Americans whose ancestors were immigrants no more than a few centuries ago.

Besides, I take my faith seriously.

Equal Dignity

I think human beings are people: all human beings. Each of us has equal dignity: no matter where we are, who we are, or how we act. (Catechism, 360, 1700–1706, 1929, 1932–1933, 1935, 2334)

Part of my job as a citizen is contributing “to the good of society in a spirit of truth, justice, solidarity, and freedom.” (Catechism, 2239)

America doesn’t have the world’s highest gross domestic product (GDP) per capita. That’s Liechtenstein or Luxembourg, depending on whose numbers you use. But we’re in the top 10, and America and the European Union are in the top two spots for GDP.

That makes America one of the world’s wealthier countries. We’re obliged to welcome folks looking for a safer and more prosperous place to live and work. (Catechism, 2241)

Treating newcomers decently is hardly a new idea.

“You shall not oppress an alien; you well know how it feels to be an alien, since you were once aliens yourselves in the land of Egypt.”
(Exodus 23:9)

“‘When an alien resides with you in your land, do not molest him.
“You shall treat the alien who resides with you no differently than the natives born among you; have the same love for him as for yourself; for you too were once aliens in the land of Egypt. I, the LORD, am your God.”
(Leviticus 19:33–34)

“For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, a stranger and you welcomed me,”
(Matthew 25:35)

Mr. Kuchibhotla may not have been fleeing violence and poverty, but I don’t think that means he shouldn’t have been working here. “Access to employment and to professions must be open to all without unjust discrimination….” (Catechism, 2433)

Political leaders can make rules about immigration, within reason. Immigrants have responsibilities, too. (Catechism, 2241)

But I have seen no indication that Mr. Kuchibhotla was in America illegally, or that he was doing anything other than contribute to my nation’s economy — and enjoying an occasional beer with his friend.

He will be missed.

At least some folks in India are upset about this murder, and don’t want their kids coming to this country. I can’t say that I blame them.

The sad, and hopeful, side of this is that apparently quite a few folks in the Kansas City area are showing support and sympathy for their “foreign” neighbors.2

“…The Civilization of Love….”

Jubilee of Mercy, Rome, from the Vatican, used w/o permission.That’s a step toward building a “civilization of love.”

“…The answer to the fear which darkens human existence at the end of the twentieth century is the common effort to build the civilization of love, founded on the universal values of peace, solidarity, justice, and liberty….”
(“To the United Nations Organization,” Pope St. John Paul II (October 5, 1995))

And that’s yet another topic. (November 29, 2016; November 27, 2016)

More about acting as if God and love matter:


1 Response, background and news:

2 More news and views:

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments