Dealing With Cystic Fibrosis

A “Benefit for Teri (Sanden) Starkey” notice was on the Our Lady of Angels bulletin board this Sunday.

The event was Saturday, July 29, and in Litchfield; a town south and a bit east of here, about an hour and half away.

I saw the notice a day late to do anything by Saturday, but figure I could pass along what I learned.

She has cystic fibrosis, and needs new lungs. The clinic in her area wouldn’t or couldn’t do the procedure.

The good news is that an outfit in North Carolina will. However, getting a chance to keep her alive means raising money to move her to North Carolina, plus her two kids and husband. That’s something like a thousand miles away.

My guess is that the family has above-average medical expenses, too.

That’s pretty much all I know. A little additional information clipped to the notice helped me find these links:

I didn’t know about the Lungs4Life Foundation before today, and haven’t learned anything more than what’s on part of their website. It looks like a good idea, though. No pressure.

Cystic Fibrosis

Cystic fibrosis doesn’t kill folks, not exactly. Folks affected by it often die from infections or other trouble in their lungs.

It’s a genetic glitch that probably showed up about five millennia back.

Scientists started noticing connections between not-obviously-related disorders and deaths in the 19th century.

Dorothy Hasine Anderson put the pieces together and described it in 1938.

We can’t cure cystic fibrosis yet. There’s some promising gene therapy research in progress, but that won’t help folks who need new lungs now.1 Happily, we’ve been getting better at organ transplants. It’s not ‘just routine,’ though.

“Risky Double Lung Transplant” in the News


(From AlexiusHoratius, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Delano, Minnesota.)

“Minnesota woman moving to North Carolina for risky double lung transplant”
Paul Blume, KMSP/Fox9 News (July 4, 2017)

“A Delano, Minnesota woman with cystic fibrosis is fighting for her life. And with options running out, she’s set to move her family more than 1,000 miles.

“Teri Starkey needs a double lung transplant, and if that’s not risky enough, she has a condition that could attack the new organs.

“‘It’s like when you have the flu,’ Teri said. ‘You are knocked out for a week, and you think you are dying. That’s a good portion of my life.’…”

Transplanted lungs or other organs will be affected by biochemical effects of the defective gene in other parts of the body.

But a transplant can give folks with cystic fibrosis, like Teri, a few more years of life.

I see that as a good idea. (July 21, 2017; March 31, 2017; February 24, 2017)

Life and health are both gifts from God. Taking good care of them is a good idea, within reason. Making either my highest goal would not. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2288, 2289)

Organ transplants are ‘within reason,’ if expected benefits outweigh the risks. We’re told that donating organs after death “…is a noble and meritorious act…” We’re also told that killing someone and breaking them down for parts is a bad idea, and we shouldn’t do it. (Catechism, 2296)

That makes sense to me.

Other ‘health’ posts:


1 More:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , | 5 Comments

Infallibility?

The “most disturbing image” gag in Wiley Miller’s Non Sequitur comic depends on a fairly common misunderstanding of Catholic belief. The important word in that sentence is misunderstanding. Papal infallibility doesn’t mean that.

I’m none too pleased that Catholic beliefs are misunderstood by non-Catholics: and by some Catholics. But I can’t fault a cartoonist for poking fun at cultural quirks I see as silly. Not reasonably.

Besides, strips featuring the Church of Danae’s “so-called holy scriptures” have given me pretty good illustrations of what I don’t believe. (March 31, 2017)

The Magisterium

A few of the world’s Catholics may believe that a pope is infallible about everything: that popes can’t ever make mistakes.

Like I said, some of us don’t know or remember what we’ve been taught.

Infallibility isn’t limited to popes. It’s a characteristic of the Church. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 889)

I could stop right there, but that’d be a bad idea.

We’re also told that not everything the Magisterium does is infallible. Although when the Magisterium clarifies some aspect of our faith, I’m obliged to take it seriously. (Catechism, 892)

“Magisterium” isn’t a fancy word for “Pope.” It’s the position of authority held by the Church. The Magisterium’s job is explaining the Bible and Tradition — capital “T.” (Catechism, 85, 890, 2033)

I take Tradition very seriously. I must, if I’m going to be a Catholic. That’s not even close to trying to live as if 1954 never happened. (June 18, 2017; June 4, 2017)

Where was I? Comics, infallibility, the Magisterium. Right.

Terms and Conditions

Infallibility is strictly limited to a particular sort of formal declaration.

It applies when the Pope, acting as the Pope, officially declares a doctrine of faith or morals “by definitive act.” (Code of Canon Law, Book III, 749 §1)

“Morals” in this case isn’t limited to the zipper issues you see in tabloids. It’s pretty much the same as “ethics.”

The College of Bishops can do the same sort of thing, with similar requirements.

When they declare a “doctrine of faith or morals is to be held definitively,” it’s infallible. (Code of Canon Law, Book III, 749 §2)

That happens when they exercise the Magisterium in an ecumenical council, working with the Pope. After that, the doctrine applies to everyone in the Church. All those conditions must be obviously met. (Code of Canon Law, Book III, 749 §2, 749 §3)

The idea of papal infallibility is old, even by Catholic standards. As a dogma it’s a fairly recent development. The First Vatican Council defined it in “Pastor Aeternus,” issued July 18, 1870. Predictably, some folks didn’t like it.1

I had an interesting discussion with a Catholic who seemed convinced that the Church hadn’t been really “Catholic” since the Council of Trent.

He had a firm grasp of some historical details. That, I appreciate. His assumption that we went wrong around the time Elizabeth Tudor got sprung from the Tower of London? I am quite sure he was mistaken.

My guess is that a few Catholics will have similar attitudes about post-1870 developments during the mid-25th century.

I get the impression that ‘the Pope isn’t Catholic’ folks are also upset each time they hear that Canon Law has changed.

I’m not, but that’s no great virtue.

Long before I became a Catholic, I knew that ad hoc rules aren’t the same as unchanging ethical principles.

I don’t expect rules that worked in the 1st or 11th centuries to be practical in the 21st or 41st. (July 14, 2017; February 5, 2017; June 4, 2017)

Judging from the nitpicking I occasionally see, some folks won’t think the conditions for infallibility are met unless the Pope starts agreeing with them.

“Divine Assistance”

Rules like the Code of Canon Law are important, and serve to define how the Catholic Church works.

But I don’t think any set of rules could keep humans from mismanaging an organization into oblivion, given time.

We’ve had two millennia, and ample opportunities, to do just that.

But the Church has endured major social, political, and economic upheavals — including the Roman Empire’s dissolution and Renaissance.

Human institutions don’t do that.

After two millennia of wildly improbable survival, I’m inclined to believe what the Church says about what keeps us going.

We’ve had help. (June 4, 2017)

“Divine assistance” is what holds up the Church. It’s also what makes papal infallibility work. (Catechism, 888-892)

That’s an extreme claim. But it explains how the Church survived Popes like Benedict IX. I’ll get back to him.

The terms we use to describe this assistance have changed over the millennia. But we’ve known we wouldn’t be on our own ever since our Lord left. Before, actually. (Matthew 28:18–20; John 14:15–18)

Reasoned Obedience

The notion that we blindly do whatever the Pope says may be a root of papaphobia. It’s a real word.

I probably wouldn’t have become a Catholic if it meant unthinking conformity. Happily, that’s not required: or recommended.

Obedience to legitimate authority, including the Pope’s, is part of my faith.

Turning my brain off isn’t. (Catechism, 1778, 1951, 2217)

Faith and reason should get along. (Catechism, 35, 154-159)

The Catholic version of faith is a willing and reasoned obedience to God’s will. (Catechism, 143-152)

Our number one role model for this obedience is Mary. (Catechism, 148-149)

She was obedient, and asked a reasonable question. Zachariah, not so much. And that’s yet another topic. (December 18, 2016)

I’ll grant that much of the Catechism’s discussion of obedience and using our brains deals with everyday examples: like children and parents, citizens and secular authorities.

My guess is that for most Catholics, those are generally the situations where we have to think about whether rules make sense.

Between living in an era that’s far from serene, and growing up as a non-Catholic in a very non-Catholic culture, I’ve had to think about what Popes say pretty often.

But when I hear or read that the Pope said something that doesn’t make obvious sense, my first impulse is not to assume I’m right and the Pope must be wrong.

Instead, I start learning what the Pope actually said and how it relates to faith and my life. And that’s yet again another topic.

Perfect Popes? No Such Thing

Some Popes are recognized Saints, including two in the 20th century. Some were pretty much the opposite.

My favorite ‘poster child’ for appalling Papal role models is Benedict IX.

Nothing wrong with the name “Benedict,” by the way. The first Pope Benedict lived about a half-millennium before number nine. We’re up to Benedict XVI now.

We don’t know much about Benedict I. Being Pope after Theodoric’s successors lost the Gothic War may explain that.

The Goths and their Ostrogothic Kingdom had been maintaining a semblance of order in Italy and lands east of the Adriatic. Italy was a mess after the war. The other side didn’t exactly win, either. Those were interesting times. (April 28, 2017)

Anyway, Benedict IX was pope three times between October 1032 and July 1048. He was kicked out twice, and sold the papacy once. Maybe.

The sale isn’t well-documented, for obvious reasons. Even during the worst of our rough patches, and we’ve had some doozies, I don’t think anybody would want a receipt for that.

About 28 years and a half-dozen Popes after Benedict IX, we got Pope Gregory VII and the Gregorian Reform.2

My guess is that the Gregorian Reform upset some folks as much as Vatican II did. Does.

Living in an era of good and occasionally-Saintly popes helped me take the Church seriously. But I didn’t join because I liked the good popes.

Oddly enough, it was the monumentally bad Popes who helped convince me that our “divine assistance” was real. That wasn’t my only reason for conversion.

I decided to become a Catholic, grudgingly, after finding the Church’s logic impeccable: and learning who held the authority our Lord gave Peter. At that point, I had a choice: but only one viable option.

It’s like Simon Peter said in John 6:68: “to whom shall we go?”

Part of my take on authority, obedience, and building a civilization of love:


1 Councils, rules, and a few documents:

2 A few successors to Peter, and a little history:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments

Fukushima, Six Years Later

The Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster could have been much worse. But it may have been avoidable.

Meltdowns and non-nuclear explosions at the power plant didn’t directly kill anyone.

More than 40 patients who were evacuated from a nearby hospital died later. They had been critically ill. Getting rushed away from a nuclear incident in progress wouldn’t have been good for their health.

Three former power company executives now face criminal charges.

The earthquake, tsunami, and meltdowns in 2011 killed nearly 16,000 folks and left many others homeless. Many folks still can’t return to their homes. Quakes happen. This one was nobody’s fault.

What happened in Fukushima is another matter. I’ll be looking at the disaster, what’s happened since, and why questioning authority can be a good idea.


Earthquake and Tsunami: March 2011

Earth’s mantle is sinking near Japan’s east coast, pulling part of the crust under the Okhotsk Plate. But not smoothly.

On Friday, March 11, 2011, about 32 kilometers below the surface, Earth’s crust moved abruptly.

About 31 seconds later, the Japan Meteorological Agency’s detectors had sensed the event and broadcast warnings to several million folks. That probably saved many lives.

Japan is now up to 2.4 meters, 7 feet 10 inches, closer to North America.

The 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami destroyed about 45,700 buildings and damaged about 144,300 more.

It’s stronger than any other recorded in Japan during the last 16 centuries, and the fourth strongest recorded anywhere on Earth since 1900.1

Tsunami: Over the Wall and Into the Generator Room


(From Shigeru23, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Diagram of the #1 Fukushima reactor building and seawall. A – Plant building, B – Tsunami’s peak height, C – Ground level of site, D – Average sea level.)

TEPCO’s Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant is the famous, or infamous, one.

The crew of its sister plant, Fukushima Daini, were what my culture calls ‘lucky.’ Most of them. One person, trapped at a console during the quake, died later.

The tsunami flooded Fukushima Daini’s standby generators, too. The 2,000 folks working there still had one remaining high-voltage power line connecting the plant to Japan’s power grid. That kept the plant’s control systems online.

Part of the crew remained at the plant while others assembled a nine-kilometer emergency power connection. Each 200-meter section of cable weighed over a ton.2

Meanwhile, folks at the Daiichi facility were dealing with their own disaster.

The Fukushima Reactors 1, 2, and 3 automatically shut down immediately after the earthquake.

They’re supposed to do that.

If a reactor’s going to be shaken, it should be comparatively inactive and cooling.

Reactors 4, 5, and 6 were already shut down and cooling. They were due for refueling.

During normal operation, these reactors provided power for their own cooling systems. Reactors stay hot for a long time after shutting down, so the cooling systems must keep running.

Diesel-powered generators started normally and were providing power to the cooling systems when the tsunami hit.

The tsunami was about 13 to 15-meters, 43 to 49 feet, high. It reached the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant about 50 seconds after the earthquake started. The plant’s seawall was 5.7 meters, 19 feet, tall.

The tsunami went over the wall and kept going.

The diesel generators were in a low-lying room. They promptly flooded, and failed shortly after submersion. That cut power to cooling systems for reactors 1, 2, and 3.

Temperatures rose inside the reactors.

Water, instead of cooling the reactor reactor cores, circulating through radiators, and returning to to the cores, stayed in the reactors’ containment vessels. It turned to steam.

Explosions

Pressure began rising in the reactors’ containment vessels.

By about 6:50 Saturday morning, reactor one’s core had completely melted, dripping to the reactor pressure vessel’s base.

Something exploded inside reactor one’s building at 3:36 Saturday afternoon. The concrete building collapsed. By that time, folks near Fukushima reactors one or two were being evacuated.

The explosion was non-nuclear.

It’s a near-certainty that very hot steam reacting with the zircaloy fuel assembly cladding produced hydrogen. This wouldn’t normally happen, but this was not a normal day.

The containment vessel wasn’t designed to hold hydrogen, and was already under excessively high pressure.

Hydrogen — again, almost certainly — leaked into the the rest of the building. It rose to the top of the building, mixing with oxygen. Eventually the hydrogen-oxygen mix reached something hot, and exploded.

That was Saturday morning, March 12.

Pretty much the same thing happened in the reactor three building on Monday, March 14. Nobody died, but 11 folks were injured. A vent pipe connected buildings holding the number two and three reactors, letting hydrogen flow into the reactor two building.

An explosion in the number two reactor’s building on Monday caused more damage.

Japanese and world nuclear authorities may have been trying to reassure folks and prevent panic. During a March 15 news conference, the IAEA’s director general, Yukiya Amano, said that there was a “possibility of core damage” at Unit 2 of less than 5%.

That may have been an accurate estimate, based on valid data. But it was an estimate. Radiation levels near most of the damaged reactors were too high for humans. Even wearing hazmat suits.

The good news is that fires at the Fukushima power plant didn’t last as long as the Chernobyl blaze. Nowhere near as much radioactive material leaked out.

But folks responsible for the plant’s design should have known that the seawall wasn’t nearly high enough. Given the circumstances, putting the generator room below what would be sea level was also a regrettable decision.3


1. Radiation, Bacteria, and a Robot


(From AFP, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Lava-like rocks were spotted underneath one of the damaged reactors”
(BBC News))

“Fukushima disaster: Robot finds possible melted nuclear fuel”
(July 23, 2017)

“An underwater robot has captured what is believed to be the first images of melted nuclear fuel deposits inside Japan’s stricken Fukushima nuclear plant, its operator Tepco says.

“Large amounts of solidified lava-like rocks and lumps in layers were seen underneath its unit three reactor.

“If confirmed, it would be a major milestone in the clear-up operation.

“The power plant was hit by a tsunami in 2011, causing the most serious nuclear accident since Chernobyl….”

A few bacteria, like Deinococcus radiodurans, thrive inside nuclear reactors. It’s no place for most critters, though.

That’s why researchers working with Toshiba developed the “little sunfish” submersible robot.

It looks like a high-tech loaf of bread, and is about the same size, trailing a cable. “Little sunfish” carries two cameras, a dosimeter, and uses tail propellers to maneuver.

Folks recently sent the submersible robot into what’s left of the Fukushima’s unit 3 reactor. The melted and re-solidified stuff they found looks a bit like icicles and layered lumps.

It’s probably from the reactor’s core: melted fuel and metal that dripped to the containment vessel’s base and burned through, ending near the bottom of the vessel’s concrete pedestal. We’ll know more as the investigation continues.

Why Design Matters


(From Japan Atomic Industry Forum, Tepco; © British Broadcasting Corporation; used w/o permission.)
(“How Japan managed to get Fukushima’s reactors stable during the disaster”
(BBC News))

What happened at Fukushima could have been worse. I think folks who were at the plant, working with the equipment, deserve credit for dealing with the disaster.

Higher-ups who decided where the equipment was, and what tasks the crew was allowed to do — not so much.

Nuclear reactors always produce heat when they’re active. That’s part of what makes them such good energy sources for power plants.

Once a nuclear reactor becomes active, it stays hot for a long time: even after it’s shut down. The ‘up’ side of this is that nuclear reactors can make a great deal of very steady heat for a long time.

When their cooling and safety systems aren’t well-designed, carefully maintained, or regularly tested, we’ve got problems.

Happily, competent folks with an interest in public safety took control of what was left of the Fukushima Daiichi power plant after the meltdowns started. Thanks to past disasters, we’re getting better at containing broken reactors and cleaning up afterward.4


2. Ignorance?


(From AFP, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Tsunehisa Katsumata (L), Ichiro Takekuro and Sakae Muto all deny the accusations”
(BBC News))

“Fukushima nuclear disaster: Tepco executives on trial”
(June 30, 2017)

“Three former power company executives have gone on trial in Japan on charges linked to the Fukushima disaster.

“It is the first criminal trial over the 2011 meltdown at the nuclear plant.

“The meltdown, triggered by an earthquake which caused a massive tsunami, was the world’s worst nuclear accident since Chernobyl in 1986.

“All three have pleaded not guilty to professional negligence resulting in death and injury of patients evacuated from a hospital near the plant….”

The former TEPCO chairman and two vice-presidents could get up to five years in prison.

Maybe that doesn’t sound like much, but it’s still much more than a ‘slap on the wrist.’ Particularly since they seem to be around my age. Five years is a good-size chunk of how much time I’ve got left.

I don’t know whether to be sympathetic or not.

On the one hand, they were old enough to know better when they made their decisions. ‘Boys will be boys’ isn’t an excuse for some behavior, but youthful inexperience helps explain some daft things we do.

On the other hand, They’re probably around my age. They might not have had opportunities to stay informed about what’s happened over the last half-century.

That’s be a lousy defense, I think, since they were responsible for nuclear power plants.

Ignorant managers and executives make good characters in comics and stories. In real life, they’re somewhere on a continuum between ‘annoying’ and ‘dangerous.’

I have no idea what motivated them or how much they knew. For their sake, I hope they really did not understand the risks they were taking with lives and health.


3. Fears, Reasonable and Otherwise


(From Reuters, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Tens of thousands of families were forced to leave their homes as the reactors melted down”
(BBC News))

“Fukushima: Japan court finds government liable for nuclear disaster”
(March 17, 2017)

“A Japanese court has ruled for the first time that the government bears partial responsibility for the 2011 Fukushima nuclear disaster.

“The court was responding to a case brought by a group of evacuees who had been forced to flee their homes.

“It ruled that the disaster could have been averted if government regulators had ordered plant operator Tepco to take preventive safety measures.

“The government and Tepco were both ordered to compensate the evacuees….”

International news is focusing how folks are coping with the Fukushima Daiichi disaster’s lasting effects. So am I.

But let’s remember that the quake and tsunami caused severe damage along much of eastern Japan, and indirectly affected the entire country.

The worse of it was along a 670-kilometer, 420-mile, section of Japan’s coast: from Erimo, Hokkaido, to Ōarai, Ibaraki. Well over 100,000 folks are still homeless.5

This court’s ruling, holding both Japan’s government and TPECO responsible for not planning ahead, seems reasonable. Nobody involved in decisions that led to the Fukushima meltdowns came out looking good.

Some harm is obvious. About 80,000 folks had to abandon their homes. Many would have been well-advised to leave anyway, since a tidal wave set off this SNAFU. Concerns about radiation were legitimate, too.

However, this isn’t a “Beginning of the End,” “It Came from Beneath the Sea,” or “Creature with the Atom Brain” scenario, where radioactive monsters attack a city. Most folks, happily, realize that atomic grasshoppers, octopi, or zombies, are make-believe.

I think we’re still working on reasoned caution where radiation is involved.

Radiophobia

“Radiophobia,” obsessive fear of ionizing radiation, isn’t new. The term goes back to “Radio-phobia and radio-mania,” a 1903 paper by Dr Albert Soiland.6

Some folks had unreasonable fears of radio broadcasting and receiving technology.

Their fears were slightly fact-based.

Sticking my head in an active microwave oven wouldn’t be healthy. That’s why we’ve got safety switches that cut power when we open the door. Usually.

Opening the door while the oven is working will, occasionally, release a very short burst of microwaves. It’s not enough to hurt anyone.

The microwaves are, however, strong enough to register on a radio telescope’s receiver.

A hastily-opened microwave oven ‘sounds’ a lot like a Fast Radio Burst, or FRB. But not not quite.

Astronomers at the Parkes, Australia, observatory eventually realized that some odd FRBs were from their break room: not from still-unknown sources beyond our galaxy. And that’s another topic.7

My guess is that Dr. Soiland’s “radio-mania” described folks who were entirely too willing to use ‘cures’ like Bonnore’s Electro Magnetic Bathing Fluid. One chap, an eager imbiber of Radithor, “Perpetual Sunshine,” wound up buried in a lead-lined coffin. (October 14, 2016)

Feeling Stressed

Getting back to sorting out the Fukushima mess, I strongly suspect that psychological and emotional disorders will account for some compensation. I’d better explain that.

I think “intentional infliction of emotional distress” is a form of assault, and a legitimate legal accusation.

I also think that ‘you made me feel bad, give me money’ can turn into a legal scam, if judges and juries trust their feelings more than their reason.

Many folks who lived near Fukushima are ‘stressed out’ because they can’t go back home and get on with their lives.

That’s understandable. Folks who lived near Chernobyl felt the same way. What’s happened to them since suggests that at least some Fukushima evacuees will develop serious psychosomatic disorders.

Technically, it’s ‘all in their heads:’ like posttraumatic stress disorder. Or brain cancer.

We’re learning, sometimes the hard way, that psychological disorders can be as real as physical ones.8

Unlike what happened at Chernobyl, radiation exposure didn’t kill anyone at Fukushima. Not yet, anyway.

Folks living in the area may eventually have a higher than average risk of developing cancer. Their exposure was and remains very slight. We simply don’t know for sure.

No wonder they’re feeling a bit stressed.

What a few ‘experts’ said didn’t help, I think.

Safety Protocols and “Tickling the Dragon’s Tail”

Folks living in Japan have more reason than most to understand why being careful with nuclear energy is a good idea.

Aside from radiation burns, ionizing radiation can damage DNA and other molecular machinery in our cells.

Some damaged cells become cancerous, malfunction in other ways, or simply die.

Ignoring safety protocols is a bad idea for folks using any technology, from campfires to nuclear devices.

Some researchers at a Los Alamos laboratory in 1946, and added “tickling the dragon’s tail” to my culture’s vocabulary.

Reasonable caution is one thing. Publishing bogus research is — less than helpful. So, I think, are overly-eager news reports. More about that in the next section.

Perhaps someday more reporters will write as if they have a basic understanding of what they’re covering. Editors showing more interest in factual articles might help, too.

I also hope that someday we will have a competent international authority that will deal with conflicts before they become wars. I’m not sure which hope may be realized first.

Understanding Statistics

Some facts about Fukushima aftermath are, by themselves, alarming.

In 2013, for example, the World Health Organization reported that “…for thyroid cancer, the estimated lifetime risk increases by up to around 70% over baseline rates in females exposed as infants….”

Scary, right? I could use that excerpt to ‘prove’ that WHO is trying to scare folks — or that we should all be scared silly.

Instead, I’ll quote the next sentence from that report:

“These percentages represent estimated relative increases over the baseline rates and are not absolute risks for developing such cancers….”
(“Health Risk Assessment from the nuclear accident after the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake and Tsunami based on a preliminary dose estimation,” Executive Summary, World Health Organization (2013))

Women who live near Fukushima should probably make sure they get tested for thyroid cancer a bit more often than average. But the odds are very good that something else will kill them first. Like old age.

The WHO report goes on to say that the baseline lifetime risk of thyroid cancer in women is just three quarters of one percent. Being exposed to Fukushima-level radiation over a lifetime raises that by one half of one percent. One half of one percent is not much.

Fast-forward to October of 2015. Someone at Okayama University got his 15 minutes of fame by publishing research that inspired headlines like “Experts Link Higher Incidence of Children’s Cancer to Fukushima Radiation.”

Children, cancer, and the biggest nuclear disaster since Chernobyl: now that’s news!9

Epidemiologists, professional ones, pointed out that the fellow’s numbers were accurate. Sort of. But his conclusions were misleading, at best. He’d done an ‘apples to oranges’ comparison.

His Fukushima data was real enough. It was the result of careful screening of kids — using advanced ultrasound tech. He compared those results to exam results from old-school clinical exams: the sort I might have had back in the ‘good old days.’

Careful screening with the latest diagnostic tech actually did show thyroid “cancer” in an alarming number of kids living in the Fukushima area. Again, this is with cutting-edge tech; used by folks looking for this sort of thing.

Even if the numbers really were more than might be expected, publishing an illogical conclusion is not the way to get attention.

More accurately, it’s not how to get the right sort of attention for situations like this.

Following the usual ‘cancer — experts — radiation’ line and getting creative with a carefully-chosen excerpt, I could ‘reveal’ that a third of all adults have thyroid cancer:

“…close inspection of the thyroid by sonographic imaging shows that as many as one-third of women and one-fifth of men have small nodules in their glands….”
(Goiter & Thyroid Nodules, University of California San Francisco)

With or without all-caps and exclamation marks, that sort of thing gets attention.

But don’t rush out and demand that your doctor remove your thyroid.

Those nodules are “cancer” only in the sense that they’re abnormal growths. At least we think they are. We may learn that they’re normal but unusual. Or simply normal and previously-unnoticed.10

Getting Attention, Making Sense

We’ve been learning a lot recently, partly thanks to new imaging technology.

Low-resolution ultrasound imaging tech goes back to 1939 or 1940, depending on whose work you count.

The first medical use of industrial ultrasound tech was in 1941. That was apparently quite experimental, and didn’t catch on. Someone tried again in 1953, again using industrial testing tech.

Again, it didn’t catch on. But medicos kept trying. A contact scanner designed specifically for medical imaging was tried in the early 1960s. That, finally, caught on. Slowly.

Much more recently, we’ve developed high-resolution scanners.11

Just as important, I think, we’ve started using the tech around the world: and are learning to understand what we see.

When specialists look very carefully at high-resolution scans, they find that about a third of all women and a fifth of all men have small nodules on their thyroid glands.

The growths are, technically, “cancerous.” But they don’t do much except grow, slowly, as we age and die of unrelated causes.

Without careful examination with a specialist using advanced tech — most of us will never know we’ve got the growths. Or care. They don’t hurt us. But I suppose ‘relax, we’re okay’ wouldn’t be an exciting headline.

I think the World Health Organization got it right. That outfit said a 2013 thyroid ultrasound screening program uncovered an unexpected number of thyroid growths. But did not say we should panic.


4. Question Authority: Wisely


(From Digital Globe, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“Japan panel: Fukushima nuclear disaster ‘man-made’”
(July 5, 2012)

“The crisis at the Fukushima nuclear plant was ‘a profoundly man-made disaster’, a Japanese parliamentary panel has said in a report.

“The disaster ‘could and should have been foreseen and prevented’ and its effects ‘mitigated by a more effective human response’, it said.

“The report catalogued serious deficiencies in both the government and plant operator Tepco’s response.

“It also blamed cultural conventions and a reluctance to question authority….”

I don’t know enough about Japanese culture to have a well-informed opinion on their conventions or general willingness to question authority.

My guess is that all countries have cultural conventions that could use review and revision. Or, occasionally, replacement.

I do remember the 1960s, when American culture was going through a major sea change.

Timothy Leary-style ‘question authority’ made more sense at the time. Even then, though, I thought it took skepticism well past reasonable limits:

“…To think for yourself you must question authority and learn how to put yourself in a state of vulnerable open-mindedness, chaotic, confused vulnerability to inform yourself….”
(Timothy Leary, as quoted in “Cosmic Trigger I: The Final Secret of the Illuminati,” p. 170, Robert Anton Wilson(1977) via Wikiquote)

I also think Benjamin Franklin had a point:

“Distrust & caution are the parents of security.”
(“Poor Richard’s Almanack,” Benjamin Franklin, (1733))

Respect for authority comes with being a Catholic. So does obedience. Within reason.

Two Saints and a King

Rational respect for authority is important.

Communities work better if someone’s coordinating things. How we choose our leaders is up to us. There isn’t one ‘correct’ method. What matters is how closely we pattern what we do on natural law.12 (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1897–1917, 1954–1960)

Ideally, secular law would always follow natural law and promote the common good. (Catechism, 1951–1960)

We don’t live in an ideal world. That’s why unthinking obedience is a bad idea. No king, president, or other boss, is above the natural law. (Catechism, 1902, 1960, 2155, 2242–2243, 2267, 2313, 2414)

When someone in charge forgets that, we have trouble. Folks who think God outranks any secular leader sometimes get killed. That’s what happened to Thomas More and John Fisher.

A bit shy of five centuries later, they’re recognized as Saints. England’s Henry VIII is often remembered chiefly for his many wives. I think they made the right decision. Not an easy one, though.

Hindsight and Preparing for the Next One

Some ‘I told you so’ claims that TEPCO and Japanese official ignored obvious dangers may come from frustration and anger.

Even adjusting for 20-20 hindsight, I strongly suspect that TEPCO’s Fukushima Daiichi power plant could and should have been much less vulnerable to disaster.

What I don’t know is how much information TEPCO executives had, and when they received it.

And how much of it they understood.

Geologists have been learning that earthquakes are sometimes periodic, with major ones happening at fairly regular intervals in a given area.

The Tōkai earthquakes, for example, come every 100 to 150 years: roughly. The last one was in 1854.

It’s not a question of whether there will be another. It’s when it’ll happen. It’s already due. Maybe a bit past due. The Japan Meteorological Agency is trying to predict just how much time folks in cities like Nagoya have to get ready.

The 2011 Tōhoku earthquake gave them more data, but it’s not exactly reassuring. There’s a good chance that the next big quake near Japan will be another in the Tōkai series.13

Putting a nuclear power plant near the coast makes sense. For one thing, there are precious few places in Japan that aren’t near the ocean. I am pretty sure there are good logistic and technical reasons for the plant’s location, too.

However, building a seawall that was so dramatically inadequate seems shortsighted. So does putting generators in a low-lying part of the plant. Again, with 20-20 hindsight.

It’s starting to look like TEPCO leadership knew, or should have known, that what happened in 2011 was likely: sooner or later.

If they knew, and did not act on that knowledge, that’s a problem.

If they weren’t told because someone was too in awe of their authority to say that their plant was badly designed, that’s also a problem.

If government officials or inspectors wouldn’t act for similar reasons: more problems.

That’s all speculation, of course. My point is that respect for authority is a good idea: but only within reason.

Authority: Three Quotes

Context counts.

Timothy Leary’s ‘question authority’ remark came as America was recovering from McCarthyism. I quoted him earlier.

More accurately, I quoted someone who quoted him. That’s as close to the original as I got.

I remember when quite a few Americans acted as if patriotism and unthinking support of their views were the same thing. That attitude still colors my perceptions. Not positively.

Now, about the folks I’ll quote next.

Albert Einstein was writing about an editor’s rejection of a young Einstein’s criticism of the editor’s electron theory of metals. The editor apparently hadn’t bothered to read, or think about, Einstein’s critique.

Hin-mah-too-yah-lat-kekt delivered his Lincoln Hall speech while negotiating for his people’s right to settle near their homeland. The powers that be apparently respected him. But they went along with what ‘civilized’ folks who had taken over the territory wanted.

Claudius Claudianus wrote in the days of Flavius Honorius Augustus, an emperor with the dubious honor of being in charge during the first sack of Rome. He composed many of his poems for either the Emperor or the Emperor’s chief general.

“Autoritätsdusel ist der größte Feind der Wahrheit.
“Unthinking respect for authority is the greatest enemy of truth.”
(Albert Einstein, from “The Private Lives of Albert Einstein,” quoting a letter to Jost Winteler (1901))

“I have asked some of the Great White Chiefs where they get their authority to say to the Indian that he shall stay in one place, while he sees white men going where they please. They cannot tell me.”
(Hin-mah-too-yah-lat-kekt, “Chief Joseph;” Lincoln Hall Speech (1879)

“…Peragit tranquilla potestas
quod violenta nequit; mandataque fortius urget
imperiosa quies….”
“…Quiet authority accomplishes what violence cannot, and that mandate compels more which comes from a commanding calm….”
(Panegyricus dictus Manlio Theodoro consuli, lines 239-241; Claudius Claudianus, Claudian (lived c. 370 – 404))

My reasoned respect for authority includes the Pope’s authority. That doesn’t mean I think popes never make mistakes, and that’s yet another topic.


Dangerous Technology

Anti-nuclear protests have been a recurring news item for decades.

Oddly enough, despite the obvious dangers of using fire, and disasters like the 2009 Beijing Television Cultural Center fire or the recent incident in London, I’ve yet to hear or read of folks protesting another dangerous technology: fire.

Fire-related disasters, particularly the avoidable ones, produce protests often enough. Particularly when folks feel that nobody’s trying to fix the problem.

But I don’t think we’ll see protesters chanting “freeze fire now” or “ban the burn.” I suspect that’s partly because we’ve been controlling exothermic chemical reactions for a very long time. Cooking and camp fires don’t seem artificial.

More exotic or indirect applications, like coal-burning power plants, seem to be perceived apart from their underlying fire tech. But the simplest cooking fires are technology, practical application of knowledge to a practical use. (oxforddictionaries.com)

What’s changed recently is how much energy we use. I don’t see that as a problem.

Not using our brains? That’s as potentially lethal as it ever was.

The Chernobyl and Fukushima disasters both involved explosions. Neither were nuclear explosions.

The Chernobyl explosion happened when too much steam formed in the reactor’s pressure vessel. Prototypes of Denis Papin’s steam digester had the same problem, on a smaller scale. That’s why today’s steam cookers have safety values.

Descriptions of the Chernobyl disaster generally use more technical language, but the blast was basically a boiler explosion.

That photo shows the results of a boiler explosion in Strømmen, Norway, around 1889.

We learned that using redundant valves, pumps, and instrumentation, was worth the additional expense.

I think we’re on a similar learning curve with the newer tech.

The steam explosion at Chernobyl started fires that burned for about nine days, producing updrafts that spread about as much fallout as the original explosion. That helped make the 1986 Chernobyl disaster the worst nuclear accident we’ve had.

The Chernobyl disaster happened after a late-night test of reactor number four’s safety systems.

Periodic testing is a necessary safety procedure. So is making sure folks running the tests know how the equipment should be run.

The lesson from Chernobyl and Fukushima is not, I think, that technology is evil. I’ll get back to that.

It’s certainly not that periodic safety tests are Satanic plots, or that reactors should never be assigned the number four.

What we should learn, I think, is that any technology can be useful: or harmful. What matters is how we use it, and whether we use our brains.

Power Plants and Pedal Power

Most power plants generate electricity by converting kinetic energy into electricity by spinning magnets inside closed loops of conductive material.

It doesn’t matter what’s spinning the magnets. Interaction of moving magnetic fields in the loops is what counts.

It’s the same principle that runs a bicycle’s ‘light generator.’ That’s the little gizmo often mounted near the rear wheel.

Water running downhill can provide the power. The Hoover Dam generators work that way. It takes a lot of water, so hydroelectric power plants can’t be built anywhere.

Chemical fuels like coal will burn anywhere we live, so coal burning power plants were an obvious choice for most places.

Burning coal produces its own problems, like London’s death fog. That’s why we’re looking for alternatives.

I’m a little surprised that someone hasn’t insisted that we generate electricity by making everyone sit on bicycle generators and pedal until they produce their quota.

My guess is that too many folks know about Northern Arizona University’s Bicycle Generator Project. Or something like it. It’s a good learning tool for high school students.

The project takes a modified bicycle, belt, scooter motor serving as a generator, battery, display, and peripherals like a phone charger.

Folks get hands-on experience, learning how much energy it takes to power gadgets like a light bulb or leaf blower. Feet-on, actually.

Living in Tomorrow’s Yesterday

Like I said, technology isn’t our problem.

It’s whether we use our brains while using it. Learning about this universe and using that knowledge is part of being human. (Catechism, 2292–2295)

Most Americans probably wouldn’t be like the inventor’s neighbor, “…a local clergyman in a state of considerable distress who had mistaken his carriage …. for the devil….” (February 5, 2017)

Steam engines are now nostalgic technology, symbols of a bygone era.

A few centuries from now, some may daydream about ‘simpler times,’ when many a horizon was graced by the gentle curves of a power plant’s cooling towers.

This photo’s of the Ohaaki Power Station, by the way. Its generators are run with geothermal power, and that’s yet again another topic.

Vaguely-related posts:


1 About earthquakes:

2 Two Fukushima power plants and TEPCO:

3 Fukushima Daiichi disaster:

4 Reactors and a little history:

5 The March 2011 quake:

6 When radio was new:

7 (March 17, 2017) The Parkes Observatory break room and all that:

8 Risks, physical and psychological:

9 Radiation, informed-and-otherwise news, a WHO report, and my opinions:

10 Goiter nodules:

11 New tech:

12 Natural law, ethical principles written into reality’s source code:

13 Looking back and ahead:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , | 7 Comments

Jesus, the Parable Teller

16th Sunday in Ordinary Time, 2017:


16th Sunday in Ordinary Time, 2017

By Deacon Lawrence N. Kaas July 23, 2017

Deacon Dick Folger writes a simple little footnote to the readings of this day: he writes, that Dolly Parton was probably not thinking about today’s Gospels when she said “the way I see it, if you want a rainbow, you got to put up with the rain.” In the first parable today the farmer planted good wheat in his fields. His enemy tried to sabotage the crop by sowing weeds in the fields. The wise farmer decides to put up with the weeds until the harvest. Then he had the weeds removed. Afterwards, with full barns he enjoyed the rainbow of the good harvest.

The gospel teaches us that at the end of the world the evildoer will be hurled into a fiery furnace. The Saints will shine like the sun in their father’s kingdom. So writes Deacon Dick.

Today’s readings can be seen as part two of last week’s passages. This is the clearest in the gospel, as Jesus explains the parable of the sower and the seed that we heard last week.

The first reading reminds us that God “has the care of all,” which surely means all of God’s creation, not just humans. Paul again speaks of groaning, but this time he refers to the spirit groaning within us. Since the God Spirit is in all things, this could also remind us to care for all that God has made. So, if you didn’t address creation’s care last week or if you want to make it a double-header, you could easily focus on it this weekend.

On the other hand the stronger message of these texts calls attention to God’s mercy and the need for repentance. The first reading ends by reminding us that God gave God’s children good ground for hope permitting repentance for their sins. The Psalm proclaims God is “merciful and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in kindness and fidelity.” Paul speaks of the Spirit coming to the aid of our weakness and the gospel includes a call to repentance for “all who cause others to sin and all evil doers.”

This might be a good time to think about summer penance because now it has been months since Lent and there are moths before advent. Because those two seasons are close to each other the bulk of the year can go by with no invitation to repentance and reconciliation. Can we find effective ways to invite people to gather to celebrate God’s mercy together outside these two seasons?

Getting back to the subject at hand: storytelling was a good part of the life of Jewish families and clearly a means to instruct members of one’s family, and was often used at meal time, I’m sure in much the same way as we would have table-talk today. These stories became known as parables and Jesus was an expert at them. Through familiar, parables, and Jesus’ culture, they were not meant to be entertaining children’s stories or moralistic fables. Instead Jesus’ first listeners would have known that parables and tellers of parables were there to prompt them to see the world in a different way, to challenge, and at times to indict, (meaning to charge with an offense). Today’s Gospel offers three such parables.

In the gospel, Jesus begins each parable by saying “the kingdom of heaven is like….” It is important for us to remember that this mystery that Jesus speaks about, the mystery of the kingdom of heaven, cannot be reduced to just one image. It is a mystery so fast and incomprehensible as to require a multiplicity of similes to explore as we grapple with what it might mean. Unlike proclamations or definitions, which can be passively received, teaching through parables requires active participation on the part of the listener. In the parables, answers and insights aren’t doled out in neatly packaged portions, instead we have to work for them.

What might be the meaning today as we listen again to the familiar words of the wheat and weeds, the mustard seed, and leaven? All three parables speak of a slow, silent growth. Almost in secret, wheat and corn and mustard seed planted in the ground crack open to allow a sprout of new life to take hold in the soil.

By the time the tiniest green shoot is visible to a passing human, a vast system of roots has already firmly established itself below the ground. Nourished by the roots the plant grows and grows, day by day transforming itself into something that can bring forth fruit and offer shelter. What might this every day transformation tell us about the kingdom of heaven’s silent growth in the here and now? By the way right now I’m thinking of our cornfields.

The fast majority of Jesus’ parables that deal with everyday occurrences such as a merchant buying pearls, a woman searching for a coin, or a traveler in need of help. Instead of pointing to the fantastical, Jesus calls attention to reality. As he tells the crowds in Luke’s gospel, “the kingdom of heaven is among you.” In order to live in this kingdom we need only eyes to see it and ears to hear it.

To enter into a parable we must be willing to let go of the security offered by answers and definitions. What might we discover if we dare to open ourselves to the incomprehensible mystery of the kingdom of heaven? Perhaps like the seeds of mustard and wheat, we will also experience transformation. The only way to find out is to trust Jesus, the parable teller, as he gently causes us to become a “parable people.”

So you all be Good, be Holy, preach the Gospel always and if necessary use Words!


(‘Thank you’ to Deacon Kaas, for letting me post his reflection here — Brian H. Gill.)


Related posts:

Posted in Reflections | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Adam and the Animals

I think pursuing knowledge and truth is a good idea. That’s probably why Tennyson’s “Ulysses” is one of my favorite poems.

It’s the source of my Google Plus tagline: “To follow knowledge like a sinking star, Beyond the utmost bound of human thought.” (March 26, 2017)

I’ll be talking about science, faith, and why I see no problem with admiring God’s work. Also the Flat Earth Society’s origin, and my own silly notion: a doughnut-shaped Earth.

But first, an excerpt from Apollodorus that reminded me of the pottery metaphor in Genesis 2:7:

“…Prometheus moulded men out of water and earth and gave them also fire….”
(Apollodorus, The Library, Book 1, 1.7.1; via The Theoi Classical Texts Library)

Bible translations I grew up with often called the material in Genesis 2:7 “clay.” The Hebrew word is אדמה, adamah/adama. It means ground, land, or earth — dirt.

I use the The New American Bible these days, where Genesis 2:7 says that God formed Adam “out of the dust of the ground.” Dust, earth, or dirt: the meaning seems clear enough. We’re made from the stuff of this world and God’s breath.

‘My Name is Mud’

My Bible’s translation of the Hebrew word אָדָם, adam, is “the man” in Genesis 2.

It’s not shown as a name, “Adam,” until Genesis 4:25. The original adamah-Adam play on words doesn’t work in my language. Not unless I check the footnotes.

Anyway, instead of telling Adam what to call each critter, God hands that off to “adam.”

“So the LORD God formed out of the ground all the wild animals and all the birds of the air, and he brought them to the man to see what he would call them; whatever the man called each living creature was then its name.”
(Genesis 2:19)

It looks like God lets us work out some details ourselves. That’s hardly surprising, since we’re made “in the image of God,” and in charge of this creation. (Genesis 1:26–27)

The second creation story, in Genesis 2:4–7, doesn’t agree with the one in Genesis 1:1–2:4.

Not if I assume that an American wrote both; or at least someone with no sense of poetry. I’m a Catholic, so that’s not necessary. Or a good idea. (April 21, 2017)

Getting back to Genesis, you know what happens next. We break the lease on Eden, the man tries blaming his wife and God. We’ve had trouble ever since. Genesis 3:1–24 describes the debacle. No wonder Eve’s husband’s name is “Mud” in the next chapter.

Our problems don’t happen because God is smiting us for something done uncounted generations before our time. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 386–390; Gaudium et spes, 13, Paul VI (1965)

We were made “in the image of God,” “in a state of holiness,” as Blessed Pope Paul VI put it. We were basically good. We still are.

The first of us decided that acting on an impulse was more important than what God wanted. That was a massive lapse in judgment. Our problems aren’t God’s fault. They’re consequences of that decision. (Catechism, 390, 396–401)

Original sin, for Catholics who understand our faith, isn’t the notion that we’re rotten to the core. It’s recognition that consequences happen. We can’t ‘go back’ to the way we were. But we have the option of moving forward with hope. (March 10, 2017; April 16, 2017)

About Adam, Genesis, and all that: I take the Bible seriously.

I have to. It’s ‘Catholicism 101,’ sort of: Catechism, 101–133.

I think Genesis is true. I also know it wasn’t written by an American. I don’t expect the Bible to be a computer manual or science textbook.1

Genesis 3 describes a real event in figurative language. (Catechism, 390)

I think we are made “in the image of God,” matter and spirit, body and soul. Each of us is a person — someone, not something — made from the stuff of this world and filled with God’s ‘breath.’ (Genesis 1:26–27, 2:7; Catechism, 355, 357, 362–368)

That’s not even close to thinking Adam and Eve were German. (September 23, 2016)

Zeal and Cosmology

A doughnut-shaped Earth like the one over that ‘cosmic coffee cup’ would look like the real one. Near where where I live, that is. If you don’t look up and to the north.

I’m pretty sure nobody’s going to think our home is really shaped like that. But there are some downright odd notions about our universe in my culture’s background noise.

Some are several centuries past their expiration date. Millennia, in at least one case.

I knew someone who was a Christian and insisted that our sun goes around Earth, not the other way around. His proof was that ‘it said so in the Bible.’ From his other remarks, my guess is that he had Joshua 10:12–13 in mind. Maybe Job 9:7, too. (December 2, 2016)

What’s a bit odd, from my viewpoint, is that he apparently did not try to adjust his cosmology to include the pillars beneath Earth. Those are mentioned in Job 9:6.

In a way, I admire the young Christian’s zeal in upholding Aristotle’s cosmology as described in Ptolemy’s “Almagest.”

Happily, I did not assume that all Christians had similar views, or that Christianity was founded on the principle that ancient Mesopotamians knew everything there is to know about this universe. (March 24, 2017)

Judging from my experiences, however, someone could easily get the idea that Christianity and reality don’t mix.

I’ve met Christians who don’t approve of science, or what we’ve learned in the last few centuries.

I don’t expect everyone to have my enthusiasm for humanity’s growing knowledge of the universe.

But the actions of folks who seem to have trouble dealing with the reality we live in are sometimes embarrassing.

A flat Earth crackpot might be harmless. Folks with similarly-inaccurate beliefs who seem convinced that they must defend ‘their’ country from folks like my ancestors can be anything but. Sadly, there can be some overlap of the two sets. (February 1, 2017; November 29, 2016)

Faith, Catholic Style

I could be upset over cartoonists who poke fun at the wacky side of American Christianity. Sometimes I am. But mostly I sympathize with those who see humor in “creation science.” (March 31, 2017)

Anti-evolutionists are easy enough to notice. Sometimes they even run billboard campaigns.

Although some American Christians may believe that Earth is flat, I’ve yet to meet one. That’s a bit surprising, since Samuel Rowbotham released his 16-page pamphlet, “Zetetic Astronomy,” in 1849. His 430-page book, “Earth Not a Globe,” followed in 1881. It was republished online in 2016.

Rowbotham had fans in his day, including the loudly-Christian John Hampden and the more discrete Lady Elizabeth Blount.

But he didn’t gain Darwin’s lasting name-recognition. That could be because he wrote under a pseudonym, Parallax. Flat Earth cosmography’s failure to get entangled in Victorian-era politics probably didn’t help, either. (March 10, 2017; October 28, 2016)

I’ll get back to Rowbotham, the Flat Earth Society, and evidence that scientists are human.

Evolution seems to be a big hot-button topic for many tightly-wound Christians. I don’t know how many there are, but they’re often quite vocal.

Again, I admire their zeal. The impression they give of my faith is another matter.

I’ve met Christians who insist that evolution mustn’t happen. Generally because it’s not in the Bible.

Some also declare that Earth must be many orders of magnitude younger than scientists have determined.

Maybe we’ll learn that radioactive decay rates changed dramatically, and recently. That could make samples like zircons found in Australia’s Jack Hills much younger than we think.

Maybe erosion rates changed too, and all the other evidence we’ve been analyzing for the last few centuries is a sort of divine practical joke. That seems a trifle unlikely to me. (January 13, 2017)

I figure God has a sense of humor: we get that quality from somewhere, and our creator is the most obvious source. But planting intellectual land mines? That seems a bit extreme.

The Copernican principle, the idea that this universe works the same way everywhere, still seems like a pretty good match with reality. (June 23, 2017)

That hasn’t stopped scientists from discussing unlikely and unprovable ideas. Discussing, not insisting that the ideas must be true. (June 2, 2017)

One of these is that the gravitational constant and Sommerfeld’s constant may have changed since this universe started. At the moment, it’s intriguing academic speculation and little more.

Inconstant constants might fit the Lambda-CDM model. That’s the standard model of cosmology we’ve developed in the last few decades. Or maybe astronomers and other scientists will learn that this universe is — different.

Which reminds me; physicists and mathematicians have worked out hypothetical models of continua that are very unlike the space-time we live in.

The math works fine. Whether or not there are ‘universes’ with more or fewer dimensions than ours is another question. And that’s another topic.

I can almost understand Christians at one end of America’s beliefs insisting that evolution is bad, and that science threatens their religion. If their faith is based on unyielding allegiance to a 17th-century chronology — my view is that science isn’t their problem. (August 28, 2016)

I think faith and science are both pursuing truth, from different directions; so I don’t see conflict between their goals.

Being Catholic helps. We’re told that science gives us opportunities for admiration of God’s work, and that faith is a willing and conscious embrace of “the whole truth that God has revealed.” (Catechism, 142–150, 283, 341)

Now, time for some fun and quotes.

Flat Earth, 1849-2014

Rowbotham’s research was based on the Bible and the Bedford Level experiment: the 1838 one.

Newspaper editor Ulysses Grant Morrow conducted his own experiments elsewhere in 1896. He did even better than Rowbotham. Mr. Morrow got results showing that Earth has a concave curvature: like the inside of a bowl.

If I was serious about my ‘cosmic coffee cup’ cosmology, I’d claim that every Bedford Level experiment and Mr. Morrow’s claim were exactly accurate.

The different results are, ‘obviously,’ due to the doughnut-Earth’s surface moving along the doughnut’s surface. Never mind the distortions in horizontal scale that’d involve.

I’d also say that similar experiments, done elsewhere, get their varying results for the same reason. If any still didn’t fit my claims, I’d say this was proof that an international cabal of non-dairy creamer manufacturers is even more powerful than I feared.

The cabal may even be in league with Mondelez, the multinational conglomerate behind aerosol cheese. The very name craftily conceals “mond,” the Latin word for “world.” Suspicious!

There are several other conspiracy theories waiting to be hatched there, and maybe a new religion or two. All thoroughly bogus.

I trust that my cheesy cabal will be taken as a lighthearted spoof.

I also hope that nobody will wonder if I’m being serious about the cosmic coffee cup and aerosol cheese machinations. Considering some wackadoo notions that get believed, that might be a reasonable concern. Or not. Moving on.

I see flat Earth beliefs as silly, and potentially funny.

By themselves, they’re arguably harmless, except possibly for the ‘believers.’

When politics and ‘God agrees with me’ beliefs get into the mix, I’m not so sure.

The International Flat Earth Society, founded in 1956, recruited members by denouncing the U.S. government, particularly NASA.

Reasoned consideration of government actions is, I think, a good idea. Encouraging unreasonable fears, not so much. And that’s yet another topic.

The 1956 Flat Earth outfit apparently became the International Flat Earth Research Society of America and Covenant People’s Church in California in the 1970s. They had several thousand members in their prime.

The last two folks maintaining the membership database died around 2001. An online Flat Earth Society started in 2004, and by 2014 had grown to a global membership of 500.

My guess is that some folks join ‘flat Earth’ outfits because it amuses them. Others may well be devoted to the “extreme Biblical-literalist theology” Eugenie Scott discussed.

I might take both, or all, sides of the debate more seriously — if they didn’t seem to have about as much influence on national and world affairs as believers in Icke’s lizard men. The state of their minds concerns me a bit, but there isn’t much I can do about that.

I think experiments like Rowbotham’s and Morrow’s are the sort of thing that happen when folks are overly focused on getting a particular result, and less on uncovering truth.

Some scientists have acted that way, too. I think it shows that scientists are human, not that science is a fraud. (April 28, 2017)

“Pursuit of Truth”

I can’t reasonably be afraid that I’ll learn too much, or that my interest in science offends God.

Being human includes being curious, thinking, and — for some of us — studying this universe. We’re supposed to notice the order and beauty surrounding us. It’s one way we can learn about God. (Catechism, 31–32, 35–36, 301, 303–306, 311, 319, 1704, 2293–2296)

“…It’s something too many of us forget, that reality has layers. Occasionally people ask me how I can be Catholic and a science journalist. The answer is simple: Truth does not contradict truth. Both science and religion are pursuit of truth. They’re after different aspects of truth, different layers of reality, but they’re still both fundamentally about truth….”
(Camille M. Carlisle, Sky and Telescope (June 2017))

“…faith must be there first, if one wishes to see God in Creation.”
(Brother Guy Consolmagno, Vatican Observatory, in a Zenit interview (May 2017))

“No matter where and how far we look, nowhere do we find a contradiction between religion and natural science. On the contrary, we find a complete concordance in the very points of decisive importance. Religion and natural science do not exclude each other, as many contemporaries of ours would believe or fear. They mutually supplement and condition each other. The most immediate proof of the compatibility of religion and natural science, even under the most thorough critical scrutiny, is the historical fact that the very greatest natural scientists of all times—men such as Kepler, Newton, Leibniz—were permeated by a most profound religious attitude.”
“Religion and natural science are fighting a joint battle in an incessant, never relaxing crusade against scepticism and against dogmatism, against disbelief and against superstition, and the rallying cry in this crusade has always been, and always will be: ‘On to God!’”
(“Religion and Natural Science,” Lecture about the relationship between religion and science. Originally entitled Religion und Naturwissenschaft. (1937) Complete translation into English: “Max Planck: Scientific Autobiography and Other Papers” (1968); via Wikiquote [emphasis mine])

“…Even if the difficulty is after all not cleared up and the discrepancy seems to remain, the contest must not be abandoned; truth cannot contradict truth…”
(“Providentissimus Deus,” Pope Leo XIII (November 18, 1893))

Pursuing truth occasionally lets us see “wonderful things.”

“Lord Carnarvon: “Can you see anything?”
Howard Carter: “Yes, wonderful things!”
(First look into Tutankhamen’s tomb (1922) via Wikipedia)

I think the pursuit is always worthwhile, within reason:


1 Background:

“…Know what the Bible is – and what it isn’t. The Bible is the story of God’s relationship with the people he has called to himself. It is not intended to be read as history text, a science book, or a political manifesto. In the Bible, God teaches us the truths that we need for the sake of our salvation….”
(“Understanding the Bible,” Mary Elizabeth Sperry, USCCB)

From “10 points for fruitful Scripture reading:”

  1. Bible reading is for Catholics
  2. Prayer is the beginning and the end
  3. Get the whole story!
  4. The Bible isn’t a book. It’s a library
  5. Know what the Bible is – and what it isn’t
  6. The sum is greater than the parts
  7. The Old relates to the New
  8. You do not read alone
  9. What is God saying to me?
  10. Reading isn’t enough
    (From “Understanding the Bible,” Mary Elizabeth Sperry, USCCB)
Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment