Last Judgment: Still Pending

You’ve heard this one before.

At the Vatican, a Cardinal’s secretary bursts into a meeting. “Your Eminence! He’s here! Jesus! He landed in St Peter’s Square! What do we do?!” The Cardinal runs to the Pope’s office, repeats the news and question. The Pope says, “look busy.”

It’s pretty good advice, actually, which brings me to this morning’s Gospel reading: Luke 12:32–48 — or Luke 12:35–40, which covers the main idea:

“8 ‘Gird your loins and light your lamps …
“… You also must be prepared, for at an hour you do not expect, the Son of Man will come.’ ”
(Luke 12:35, 40)

Fizzled Predictions Through the Ages

It’s been about five years since Harold Camping and the silly side of American Christianity gave reporters and cartoonists something to work with.

He’d been wrong earlier, about September 6, 1994 being Judgment Day.

Undeterred, he recalculated, collected money, and advertised our Lord’s impending arrival on May 21, 2011. That didn’t happen, neither did the obligatory fire and brimstone, and the world was still around after October 21, 2011.

I figure we’re due for another high-profile End Times Bible Prophecy any time now. Or maybe not. But I’d be surprised if someone doesn’t trot out another ‘Biblical’ prognostication in the next few decades: and have Camping’s success at publicizing it.

Fizzled predictions of that sort are nothing new. Wikipedia has a partial list that runs from the triple header around the year 500 to Tipler’s assertion that the big day will be in 2057. We had another cluster around the year 1000.

My favorite one, in terms of originality, is Swedenborg’s. His “The Heavenly Doctrine,” published in 1758, said that the Last Judgment had already happened: in 1757.

Interestingly, European architects went into overdrive and started designing Gothic cathedrals a couple centuries after the thousand-year apocalypses didn’t happen. I won’t claim that it’s cause-and-effect, but think that their patrons might have realized that we could have a long wait ahead.

The Last Judgment

As described, the Last Judgment will make Shanghai’s Word Expo 2010 look like a cozy little rural gathering:

14 ‘When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, he will sit upon his glorious throne, and all the nations 15 will be assembled before him. And he will separate them one from another, as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats.
(Matthew 25:31–32)

Just getting the 7,000,000,000 or so folks alive today together in one place would be spectacular. Add everybody who’s lived and died? Just finding a venue big enough might qualify as a miracle.

The Last Judgment is part of the four last things: death, judgment, Heaven and Hell.1

It’s when everyone who died will be resurrected — that’s a topic for another post — our Lord returns, and we see what’s happened: and why. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1038–1038)

As for when that happens, that information seems to be given on a ‘need to know’ basis. Our Lord didn’t know, so I sure don’t expect to get inside information. I’ll get back to that.

Folks in Thessalonica, it’s often called Thessaloniki, is named after Thessalonike of Macedon, half-sister of Alexander the Great, and wife of Cassander, king of Macedonia, who had been named after Cassander, brother of Antipater — where was I?

Harold Camping, Swedenborg, the Last Judgment, getting a grip. Right.

The Big Picture and Me

Paul’s advice to the Thessalonians still applies, I think:

“1 We ask you, brothers, with regard to the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our assembling with him,
“not to be shaken out of your minds suddenly, or to be alarmed either by a ‘spirit,’ 2 or by an oral statement, or by a letter allegedly from us to the effect that the day of the Lord is at hand.”
(2 Thessalonians 2:1–2)

Like I said, our Lord didn’t know when the big day would be — and recommended being ready, no matter when it comes:

“21 ‘But of that day and hour no one knows, neither the angels of heaven, nor the Son, 22 but the Father alone. …
“… So too, you also must be prepared, for at an hour you do not expect, the Son of Man will come.”
(Matthew 24:36, 44)

“Therefore, stay awake, 5 for you know neither the day nor the hour.”
(Matthew 25:13)

” ‘But of that day or hour, no one knows, neither the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.
“Be watchful! Be alert! You do not know when the time will come.”
(Mark 13:32–33)

It’s been two millennia now, our Lord still hasn’t returned, and folks are still second-guessing God the Father. If it had been anyone else, we’d have given up long ago; but our Lord isn’t anyone else.

Me? I’m quite content to leave the ‘big picture’ decisions up to God. I’ve got my hands full, ‘working out my salvation,’ as Philippians 2:12 puts it. and that’s yet another topic.


Background:
1 Where to start reading about the four last things in Catechism of the Catholic Church:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , | 5 Comments

Bulldogs, Transgenics, and a Robot

English Bulldogs aren’t what they used to be: which is a problem for folks who want the breed to survive. A team of scientists says that the British mascot’s bloodline is more than a bit too pure.

Other scientists developed MouSensor, mutant mice with open slots for plug and play genetic code.

Finally, a tiny robot with rat muscles that swims like a fish.

  1. English Bulldogs: Pedigree and Survival
  2. Mutant Mice and Transgenics
  3. A Rat-Powered Robotic Ray

Using Our Brains

Despite a youthful habit of watching more-or-less-dreadful B-movie ‘mad scientist’ films, my first impulse, on learning that we’ve discovered something new, is not fearing that we’ll offend God by using our brains.

Giving writers and directors of “Revenge of the Zombies,” “The Brain That Wouldn’t Die,” and the like, credit: their mad scientists were, arguably, crazy enough to animate powerful creatures — and then engage in shockingly inadequate safety protocols.

Or demand unswerving obedience without realizing that something/someone that’s smart enough to understand the orders is sharp enough to get upset.

Now that I think of it, scientists learned why “tickling the dragon’s tail” is a bad idea back in 1946. Taking crazy chances happens.

They weren’t the first to die while studying something new. Georg Wilhelm Richmann, for example, learned how an insulated rod reacts to a nearby thunderstorm. More accurately, other scientists did — by examining what was left of Herr Richmann.

However, like I keep saying, thinking is not a sin. (July 22, 2016)

Part of our job is learning about the universe, and using that knowledge. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 154–159, 2292–2296)

Where was I? Scientists, mad and otherwise, using our brains, doing our job. Right.

Frankenstein and Free Will

Victor Frankenstein‘s do-it-yourself alchemy project didn’t end well, Shelly’s story was a great deal more thoughtful than “Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein,” and I’m wandering off-topic.

H. G. Wells called “The Island of Doctor Moreau” “an exercise in youthful blasphemy.” I see his point, since Dr. Moreau was slicing and dicing live animals in an effort to make them human.

I’m an animal: as a Catholic, that’s something I must believe. I also must believe that I’m able to think, and can decide what I do. (Genesis 1:27; Catechism, 35–38, 1704–1709, 1749–1754, 1804, 1951)

Genesis 1:27–29 says that we’re made “in the divine image,” which doesn’t mean that we’re ‘lords of creation,’ free to commit any daft act we like.

We can, actually, since we’ve got free will; but we shouldn’t. I’ll get back to that.

“Tampering With Things Man Was Not Supposed to Know”

There’s a (very) old story about an elderly lady on an airliner, clearly uneasy about flying. “We should all doing what God intended,” she told her fellow-passenger, “staying home and watching television.”

Over the decades, I’ve heard ardently-expressed denunciations of new tech, like telephones: ‘kids don’t communicate any more, they spend all day talking on the telephone.’ (I am not making that up.)

On the other hand, we seem to have accepted an 18th century ‘affront’ to the Almighty: “metalline conductors,” lightning rods:

“I have read in the Philosophical Transactions the account of the effects of lightning on St. Bride’s steeple. ‘Tis amazing to me, that after the full demonstration you had given, of the identity of lightning and of electricity, and the power of metalline conductors, they should ever think of repairing that steeple without such conductors. How astonishing is the force of prejudice even in an age of so much knowledge and free enquiry!”
(Letter, To Benjamin Franklin from John Winthrop, 6 January 1768, via founders.archives.gov)

The basic question is whether humans should “…intervene in the created order, perhaps even modifying some of its aspects?”1

About 600 words later, the Pontifical Academy for Life finished explaining why following the orders given in Genesis 1:28 is okay.

Our “dominion” isn’t the sort of ‘we can do what we please’ attitude that made the London death fog and hydraulic mining possible.

For example, we can use animals for food or clothing, put them to work or enjoy their company — within reason. But we shouldn’t let them needlessly experience pain, or lavish attention on them at the expense of our fellow-humans. (Catechism, 2415–2418)

Our world is God’s property. We live here, and part of our job is taking care of the place. It’s sort of like being shop foreman or steward: with the power, authority, and frightening responsibilities that go with the position. (Catechism, 339, 952, 2402–2405, 2456)

The Hapsburg Disaster

Most — I suspect all — cultures practice a mix of exogamy and endogamy: marrying outside one group, but within another group.

The culture I grew up in, for example, thought marrying anyone closer than a second cousin was a bad idea. We’d gotten used to the Irish by then, and were getting around to repealing anti-miscegenation laws.

Can’t say that I miss the ‘good old days.’

Then there were the Habsburgs. They were an up-and-coming aristocratic family a thousand years back.

Somewhere along the line they started marrying their first cousins, or having an uncle marry a niece. On the ‘up’ side, they kept outsiders from getting control of Habsburg holdings.

On the ‘down’ side, all that inbreeding gave recessive genes a chance at self-expression — which may help explain why Charles II of Spain earned the nickname el Hechizado, the Bewitched.

He managed to not die for nearly 39 years; despite an impressive collection of physical, intellectual, and emotional disabilities.

He was the last of the Spanish Hapsburgs. Descendants of the family’s Austrian branch are still around: Otto von Habsburg had seven children, 22 grandchildren and two great-grandchildren by the time he died in 2011.


1. English Bulldogs: Pedigree and Survival


(From Getty Images, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“English Bulldogs are loving family dogs. But as a breed they suffer from health problems”
(BBC News))

“English Bulldog health problems prompt cross-breeding call”
Paul Rincon, BBC News (July 29, 2016)

“Crossing the English Bulldog with another breed is the best way to ensure its survival, scientists have argued.

“Due to centuries of selective breeding for physical traits, the Bulldog has become so inbred it cannot be returned to health without an infusion of new bloodlines, a genetic study suggests.

“The US researchers say the Olde English Bulldogge, a related breed from America, is a viable candidate….”

Don’t let the name fool you. The “Olde English Bulldogge” is the Leavitt Bulldog, and didn’t exist before the 1970s.

David Leavitt crossed English and American Bulldogs to get a breed that looks like the 1820s version, with the currently-preferred friendly temperament.

That’s a good thing, at least for folks who want to keep the British mascot around.

Predictably, some folks don’t like the notion of polluting the bloodline — and others are a tad more interested in keeping the breed alive.

“…Breeders differ widely on what should be done to tackle the illnesses. Some argue that any deviation from the breed’s standards would no longer make it an English Bulldog.

“Others argue that the English Bulldog has constantly evolved over the centuries and favour the introduction of new genetic material, known as outcrossing….”
(Paul Rincon, BBC News)

My attitude comes partly from knowing my family history. One of my ancestors, asked about the family connections of an unsuitable person who was sniffing around her daughter, replied “he doesn’t have family, he’s Irish.”

The kids got married anyway, which eventually resulted in my father, who married a five-foot-nothing black-haired Norwegian.

I married a Dutch-German-English-Swiss-whatever woman, so by now we’re close to reverse-engineering the Celts, and that’s another topic.

Bulldogs, Brexit, and the Munchkin Cat

Bulldogs go back at least five centuries, when they were called Bondogges or Bolddogges. Today’s Bulldogs wouldn’t be much good for bull-baiting; which doesn’t matter, at least in England, since it’s been illegal since the Cruelty to Animals Act 1835 passed.

New York Province’s first English Governor used Bulldogs for a more practical job: a citywide roundup of wild bulls. The dogs were trained to hold a bull’s nose long enough for humans to get a rope around the critter’s neck.

Today’s English Bulldogs aren’t quite in the Spanish Hapsburg’s position: but they’re getting there. They couldn’t get an effective grip on a bull’s nose with those excessively-short jaws — which doesn’t matter any more.

But that short snout, broad-based tongue, and oversize palate, makes it hard for them to cool off, which can be a problem. Chondrodysplasia, a cartilage disorder that interferes with bone growth, is part of the English Bulldog’s heritage, too.

My personal preference in dogs, cats, and pets in general, is for those whose ancestry is like mine: mixed. That said, I understand that some folks are passionately dedicated to the purity of their pet Pug‘s pedigree. Or Bulldog’s, in this case.

I’ve met a few Bulldogs, like their combination of tough looks and laid-back attitude, and hope that the breed’s handlers decide that fixing its health problems is more important than strict adherence to a 20th-century look.

“…The feelings of individual English bulldog breeders about the health of their breed and what if anything should be done about it may ultimately be taken out of their hands. English bulldog breeders across the world must take seriously constitutional amendments on the rights of animals. The European Union has recently updated their rules on animal welfare in 2015.21 Although it was written specifically for farm animals; it holds that ‘animals’ have rights of ‘freedom from discomfort’ and ‘freedom from pain, injury and disease.’…”
(“A genetic assessment of the English bulldog” (2016))

That was written before Brexit passed, in June of this year. Whatever the legal issues are now, the practical one of keeping the breed alive is still in play.

Researching this post, I ran into dachshunds and Munchkin cats. As far as I know, nobody’s up in arms because low-slung dachshunds get more than their share of back problems. The Munchkin cat is another matter.

The Fédération Internationale Féline won’t recognize the breed, and says that the critters have a “genetic disease.” The Governing Council of the Cat Fancy says they’ve got “abnormal structure or development.”

That’s technically accurate, on both counts, but their short legs don’t seem to bother Munchkin cats. I didn’t dig into why they don’t balk at cats like the Sphynx, and that’s yet another topic.

More:


2. Mutant Mice and Transgenics


(From SPL (Science Photo Library), via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“Mutant mice become ‘super sniffers’ ”
Helen Briggs, BBC News (July 8, 2016)

“US scientists have mutated mice to turn them into ‘super sniffers’.

“The aim is to create a new generation of rodents that can sniff out drugs or explosives, with the scientists saying the experiment is a proof of concept.

“In the future, rats, mice, and perhaps dogs, could be genetically altered to track down certain scents, they report in the scientific journal Cell Reports….”

Mice already seem to be pretty good sniffers. They’ve got 1,035 protein-coding olfactory receptor genes, while we get by with only 387 — many of which we share with mice, which is why this research should help us understand how we smell.

Life is very modular on the sub-cellular level, so scientists can plug human ‘sniffer’ genes into the new MouSensor tech.

Since we’re not in the Animaniacs world, I don’t fear mousy plots to take over the world.

I do, however, need to think about the ethics of mixing human and non-human genetic coding.

Taking a line through movies like The Fly, Island of Lost Souls (1932 film), and The Island of Dr. Moreau, I could assume that MouSensor will inevitably lead to pain, death, and perturbed puma-women.

Since I’m a Catholic, I looked at recent discussions of bioethics and transgenics — specifically, putting human genes in non-human animals. Since the mice involved in this case will still be unequivocally mice, my main concerns will be for their welfare.2

More:


3. A Rat-Powered Robotic Ray


(From Harvard, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“Artificial stingray is ‘living robot’ ”
Wilko Duprez, BBC News (July 8, 2016)

“Scientists have designed a robotic stingray that could help our understanding of the human heart.

“The miniature robot, one-tenth the scale of the actual fish, moves using heart cells taken from a rat.

“Researchers hope the robotic ray will give new insight into the heart’s ability to pump blood and its potential implications in heart disease….

“The research is published in the journal, Science….

“…’It turns out the musculature in the stingray has to do the same thing as the heart does: it has to move fluids,’ said lead researcher, Prof Kevin Kit Parker of Harvard University, US.

The scientists reverse-engineered the marine animal to understand how it glides in liquid environments.

They then built a robotic prototype, which contains a gold skeleton and a single layer of 200,000 cardiac cells wrapped in a gel-like material similar to the gel used for breast implants….”

The robotic ray is tiny: 16 millimeters, about 5/8ths of an inch, long; takes an hour to move 9 meters, 29½ feet; and is not particularly maneuverable.

It’s not smart, either. Instead of a nervous system, scientists added an optogenetic molecular switch to the muscles. Shining a blue light makes it go, changing the light’s frequency slows it or speeds it up, more light on one side or the other makes it turn.

What they’ve got so far is a prototype that’s not so much remarkable for what it can do, as the fact that it works at all.

Studying it, and more advanced biological robots like it, may help scientists understand how our hearts work — and maybe grow replacement hearts, instead of waiting for a donor.

Meanwhile:

“…Parker regards his team’s miniature ray robot as a piece of art as well as technology: ‘Everyone is going to see something different’ in it, he says. ‘I’m looking at it and I’m trying to understand the heart—and impress my 7-year-old daughter.’ ”
(Elizabeth Pennisi, Science)

More:

More of my take on life, tech, and being human:


1 From “Prospects for Xenotransplantation – Scientific Aspects and Ethical Considerations;” Part Two – Anthropological and Ethical Aspects, Preliminary issues; Pontifical Academy for Life (September 29, 2001)

2 Since the modified mice are still, basically, mice, my ethical concerns involve the critters; and possible environmental impacts:

  1. Concern for the well-being of genetically modified animals should be guaranteed so that the effect of the transgene’s expression, possible modification of the anatomical, physiological and/or behavioural aspects of the animal may be assessed, all the while limiting the levels of stress and pain, suffering and anxiety experienced by the animal
  2. The effects on the offspring and possible repercussions for the environment should be considered
  3. Such animals should be kept under tight control and should not be released into the general environment
  4. The number of animals used in experiments should be kept to a bare minimum
  5. The removal of organs and/or tissues must take place during a single surgical operation
  6. Every experimental protocol on animals must be evaluated by a competent ethics committee
    (Source: “Prospects for Xenotransplantation – Scientific Aspects and Ethical Considerations;”Bioethical Issues, 15 (Pontifical Academy for Life (September 29, 2001))

Background:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , | 10 Comments

Humility isn’t Being Delusional

Truthfulness and humility are virtues, pride is a sin, and we’re supposed to practice humility.1

So Olympic athletes should say they’re puny?

Small wonder some folks think faith makes no sense.

Accepting Reality

'The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things,' detail; by Hieronymus Bosch or someone else. (1505-1510 or thereabouts)Humility is a good idea, within reason:

“Humility restrains the appetite from aiming at great things against right reason: while magnanimity urges the mind to great things in accord with right reason.”
(“The Summa Theologica,” St. Thomas Aquinas, translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province (Benziger Bros. edition, 1947))

“It was pride that changed angels into devils; it is humility that makes men as angels.”
(Augustine of Hippo …, via Wikiquote)

“2 My son, conduct your affairs with humility, and you will be loved more than a giver of gifts.
“Humble yourself the more, the greater you are, and you will find favor with God.
“3 For great is the power of God; by the humble he is glorified.”
(Sirach 3:17–19)

A key idea in that Aquinas quote is “right reason.”

Humility isn’t a psychotic delusion: a morose counterpart to megalomania. Then there’s false humility, what Aquinas calls “irony,” that he talked about in Summa, Question 113.2

Humility is accepting reality.

For me, it involves acknowledging that I’ve got creative talents — including freakishly enhanced language skills.

That’s the kit God gave me.

My contribution has been deciding to do something with the package.

On the other hand, I was born with defective hips — swapping them out a few years back was a huge improvement — which aren’t quite so obviously a blessing. Neither was enduring decades of undiagnosed depression and something on the autism spectrum.

Those are part of the kit I was issued, too.3

On the ‘up’ side, my circumstances helped me learn to see beauty in just about everything: and that’s another topic.

‘Umbleness’ and Reality

Uriah Heep’s unctuous “umbleness” is, happily, fictional.

Self-deprecation can, I suppose, be a useful tool for easing tension. I’m not convinced that it’s a good idea, though: particularly when someone starts believing negative self-talk.

Wanting to seem like more than I really am is definitely a bad idea. That’s what the sin we call pride is about. That sort of pride is as unreasonable as trying to believe I’m stupid. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1784, 1866, 1931, 2093–2094)

St. Thomas Aquinas wrote about boasting, humility and pride, including this:

“…The sin of boasting may be considered in two ways. First, with regard to the species of the act, and thus it is opposed to truth; as stated (in the body of the article and Question [110], Article [2]). Secondly, with regard to its cause, from which more frequently though not always it arises: and thus it proceeds from pride as its inwardly moving and impelling cause….”
(“The Summa Theologica,” Question 112, St. Thomas Aquinas)

“…Humility restrains the appetite from aiming at great things against right reason: while magnanimity urges the mind to great things in accord with right reason. Hence it is clear that magnanimity is not opposed to humility: indeed they concur in this, that each is according to right reason….”
“The Summa Theologica,” Question 161, St. Thomas Aquinas)

“…’A man is said to be proud, because he wishes to appear above (super) what he really is’; for he who wishes to overstep beyond what he is, is proud. Now right reason requires that every man’s will should tend to that which is proportionate to him. Therefore it is evident that pride denotes something opposed to right reason….”
(“The Summa Theologica,” Question 162, St. Thomas Aquinas)
(translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province (Benziger Bros. edition, 1947))

Definitions — Humility, Pride, Sin, and Temperance; Catholic Style

That’s a Pythagorean cup, a thinking person’s dribble glass, sort of; and yuza no ki — gadgets used for teaching moderation.

Since I’m a Catholic, I take balance and moderation very seriously. it’s what we call temperance. I talked about that three weeks ago. (July 10, 2016)

Since I’m a recovering English teacher, I like to include definitions in these posts:

“HUMILITY: The virtue by which a Christian acknowledges that God is the author of all good. Humility avoids inordinate ambition or pride, and provides the foundation for turning to God in prayer (2559). Voluntary humility can be described as ‘poverty of spirit’ (2546).”
(Catechism, Glossary, H)

“PRIDE: One of the seven capital sins. Pride is undue self–esteem or self–love, which seeks attention and honor and sets oneself in competition with God (1866).”
(Catechism, Glossary, P)

“SIN: An offense against God as well as a fault against reason, truth, and right conscience. Sin is a deliberate thought, word, deed, or omission contrary to the eternal law of God. In judging the gravity of sin, it is customary to distinguish between mortal and venial sins (1849, 1853, 1854).”
(Catechism, Glossary, S)

“TEMPERANCE: The cardinal moral virtue that moderates the attraction of pleasure and provides balance in the use of created goods. It ensures the mastery of the will over instinct, and keeps natural desires within proper limits (1809).”
(Catechism, Glossary, T)

Hubris, Science, and Getting a Grip

At least as far back as Mary Shelly’s Frankenstein, we’ve had tales of scientists driven by hubris — self-confidence above and beyond the call of reason.

Cautionary tales like Marlowe’s Faustus, the legend of Daedalus and Icarus, and ‘mad scientist’ movies, can teach useful ideas: like ‘trying to do the impossible may end badly.’

They also give us this sort of dialog:

“Dr. James Xavier: I’m blind to all but a tenth of the universe.

“Dr. Sam Brant: My dear friend, only the gods see everything.

“Dr. James Xavier: My dear doctor, I’m closing in on the gods.”
(“X: The Man with the X-Ray Eyes” (1963), via IMDB.com)

Maybe hubris contributed to hoaxes like Piltdown Man and archaeoraptor; and atrocities like the Auschwitz, Dachau, Tuskegee, and Willowbrook State School experiments.

But I wonder if movies like “Cosmic Monsters,” “The Fly,” and “The Brain That Wouldn’t Die,” teach that curiosity is bad: particularly when it’s scientific curiosity.

As I said Friday, Using the brains God gave us does not offend the Almighty. (July 29, 2016)

Science and technology, studying this universe and developing new tech, is part of being human. Ethics apply, same as everything else we do.4

This isn’t a new idea. One of the Genesis creation stories has Adam, not God, naming critters:

“So the LORD God formed out of the ground various wild animals and various birds of the air, and he brought them to the man to see what he would call them; whatever the man called each of them would be its name.”
(Genesis 2:19)

A scientist occasionally embraces the notion that smart folks are “beyond good and evil,” or that we don’t need God because we’ve discovered that Ussher was wrong by several orders of magnitude.

Interestingly, Anaxagoras got in trouble with Athenian authorities a little over two dozen centuries back for claiming that our sun isn’t the chariot of Helios.

Science and Humility

Folks knew that the universe is vast and ancient when Hemiunu helped build the Great Pyramid of Giza.

That was around the time folks started replacing timber with stone at Stonehenge. A place we call Mohenjo-daro was a major city then, and I’m wandering off-topic.

Learning that the world is bigger and older than some European scholars thought, a few centuries back, doesn’t bother me a bit.

I see it as an opportunity for “even greater admiration” of God’s greatness. (Catechism, 283)

“4 Indeed, before you the whole universe is as a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth.

“But you have mercy on all, because you can do all things; and you overlook the sins of men that they may repent.

“For you love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for what you hated, you would not have fashioned.

“And how could a thing remain, unless you willed it; or be preserved, had it not been called forth by you?”
(Wisdom 11:22–25)

We’re created by God, designed with a thirst for truth and for God — made from the stuff of this world — and made “in the image of God,” creatures who are matter and spirit.(Genesis 1:26, 2:7; Catechism, 27, 355–361)

Using our senses and reason, we can observe the world’s order and beauty: learning something of God in the process. (Genesis 1:26, 2:7; Catechism, 31–35, 282–289)

I think the sensible — and humble — approach to reality is studying God’s universe, accepting what we find, and learning more about it. Insisting that God conforms to ideas published in 17th-century Britain: not so much.

We wouldn’t have science, arguably, if the Church hadn’t been insisting that the universe operates under rational, knowable, physical laws. And that’s yet another topic, for another post.


(From NASA, ESA, and the Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA); ESA/Hubble Collaboration; used w/o permission.)


1 Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1866, 2468, 2482–2486, 2540.

2 St. Thomas Aquinas discusses truth, boasting, humility, and getting a grip, in Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Question 112 and 113. He had a lot more to say, including this:

“…Pride is directly opposed to the virtue of humility, which, in a way, is concerned about the same matter as magnanimity, as stated above (Question [161], Article [1], ad 3)….”
(“The Summa Theologica,” St. Thomas Aquinas, translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province (Benziger Bros. edition, 1947))

3 “Autism spectrum disorder” is the current name for a cluster of mental/neurological quirks. I’m not convinced that it’s a single disorder, but for now it’s a useful diagnostic label for part of what happens in my head.

It’s also a condition that’s fairly well-known, and generally spotted in infancy or early childhood: today. Back in the mid-20th century, not so much.

There’s almost certainly a genetic aspect to “autism spectrum disorder,” so my wife and I weren’t surprised when some of our kids were blessed with something very much like my quirks. Depression is another matter. The genetic link isn’t as obvious, although I’m guessing that some of us are more likely than others to get hit with it.

More:

4 (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 159, 2292–2296)

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , | 11 Comments

Studying Thousands of New Worlds

Scientists studied the atmospheres of two exoplanets, planets orbiting another star, earlier this year. Both planets are roughly Earth-sized, with atmospheres a bit like the Solar System’s terrestrial planets.

Juno arrived at Jupiter last month, and will start its science mission in October.

Finally, scientists found more than a thousand new planets; including more than a hundred Earth-sized ones.

  1. TRAPPIST-1 b and c
  2. Juno at Jupiter
  3. Kepler: More than 100 Earth-Sized Planets Discovered

As usual, I’ll start by talking about science, faith, and dealing with reality.


Joshua, Job, and Poetic Imagery

It’s been decades since an enthusiastic Christian informed me that our sun goes around Earth, not the other way around — because Joshua 10:12–13 says so.

He may have been sincere, but I’m quite sure he’s wrong.

Oddly enough, I’ve never known a Christian who said that Earth is flat. — despite what Job 9:6–7 says.

I could be a Christian, following our Lord, and believe that a solid dome kept the ‘ocean of heaven’ from flooding the earth I walk on.

I could even believe that a 17th century Calvinist was right about the universe being created on the nightfall preceding October 23, 4004 BC.

But ignoring what we’ve learned in the two dozen or so centuries since Mesopotamian culture provided poets with imagery we read in the Old testament is not vital to Christian belief.

Informed Faith

I’m a Christian and a Catholic, so studying this wonder-filled universe and using what we learn to develop new tools is okay. Science and technology are part of being human. Ethics apply, of course. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2293–2295)

Besides, as I say rather often, scientific discoveries are invitations “to even greater admiration for the greatness of the Creator.” (Catechism, 283)

Studying this immense and ancient creation honestly and methodically cannot interfere with an informed faith, because “the things of the world and the things of faith derive from the same God.” (Catechism, 159)

Faith isn’t reason: but it’s reasonable, and certainly not against an honest search for truth. (Catechism, 31–35, 159)

This isn’t a particularly new idea.

Dominican friar and Catholic bishop Albertus Magnus, born around 1200, is now patron saint of scientists, students, medical technicians, philosophers, and the natural sciences.

Catholic bishop and scientist Nicolas Steno helped launch paleontology as a science in 1669.

And the Pontifical Academy of Sciences hosted a “Study Week on Astrobiology” in November of 2009.

On the other hand, Third Order Dominican Nicolaus Copernicus delayed printing of “De revolutionibus orbium coelestium” until after his death in 1543.

Can’t say that I blame him. His newfangled ideas upset some folks who apparently had a shaky grasp of distinctions between poetry and science. European politics since 1517 didn’t help, and that’s another topic.

Not My Decision


(From NASA/JPL-CalTech/R. Hurt, used w/o permission.)
(Comparison of the Kepler-186, Kepler-452, and Solar planetary systems. The green area in each is the star’s habitable zone, where liquid water could exist on an Earth-like planet.)

It’s been a year since “Earth 2.0,” Kepler-452b, was in the news. One of the first “Earth 2.0” op-ed pieces I saw was by scientist and former White House Senior Policy Analyst, Jeff Schweitzer.

He has a Ph.D. in marine biology/neurophysiology, probably knows his field very well, and made some all-too-familiar assumptions about Christianity:

“Earth 2.0: Bad News for God”
Jeff Schweitzer, Huffington Post (July 23, 2015)

“…Let us be clear that the Bible is unambiguous about creation: the earth is the center of the universe, only humans were made in the image of god, and all life was created in six days. All life in all the heavens. In six days….”

Some Christians apparently agree with Dr. Schweitzer — that Christianity depends on believing one of the Genesis creation narratives is word-for-word true, from the viewpoint of a contemporary Western literalist.

I don’t see it that way, but I figure that part of my job is appreciating God’s handiwork: not insisting that ancient Mesopotamians were spot-on accurate.

Even if I didn’t approve of the way reality works, it’s not my decision:

“Our God is in heaven; whatever God wills is done.”
(Psalms 115:3)


1. TRAPPIST-1 b and c


(From NASA/ESA/STScl, via MIT News, used w/o permission.)
(“An artist’s depiction of planets transiting a red dwarf star in the TRAPPIST-1 System”
(MIT News))

“First atmospheric study of Earth-sized exoplanets reveals rocky worlds”
Jennifer Chu, MIT News (July 20, 2016)

“Two potentially habitable planets in nearby system are confirmed to be rocky.

“On May 2, scientists from MIT, the University of Liège, and elsewhere announced they had discovered a planetary system, a mere 40 light years from Earth, that hosts three potentially habitable, Earth-sized worlds. Judging from the size and temperature of the planets, the researchers determined that regions of each planet may be suitable for life.

“Now, in a paper published today in Nature, that same group reports that the two innermost planets in the system are primarily rocky, unlike gas giants such as Jupiter. The findings further strengthen the case that these planets may indeed be habitable. The researchers also determined that the atmospheres of both planets are likely not large and diffuse, like that of the Jupiter, but instead compact, similar to the atmospheres of Earth, Venus, and Mars….”

True enough, Earth, Venus, and Mars have atmospheres that stick pretty close to the planet; but those atmospheres are very different.

The atmospheres of Venus and Mars are mostly carbon dioxide — but Venus is hot, 740 K/467 °C/872 °F at the surface, with air pressure 93 times Earth’s. Martian surface pressure is only about 6% Earth’s, and cold enough for carbon dioxide frost in winter.

Earth’s atmosphere is mostly nitrogen and oxygen, and it’s the only ‘habitable’ planet of the trio.

TRAPPIST-1 b and c, the ones studied during this transit, are probably too close to TRAPPIST-1 for life.

They’re almost certainly tidally locked to the star, one side in constant sunlight, with years roughly 1.5 and 2.5 Earth days long. That close to TRAPPIST-1, the star’s ‘wind’ probably blew away whatever water they started with.

TRAPPIST-1d, orbiting at or just beyond the star’s habitable zone1 may have kept its water, but wasn’t studied this time around.

Refined orbital data and calculations, finished only two weeks before the double transit, didn’t give the researchers much time to coordinate with the Hubble team.

A Star, a Telescope, and Colors


(From ESO/IAU and Sky & Telescope, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(TRAPPIST-1’s location in Earth’s sky.)

“…’We thought, maybe we could see if people at Hubble would give us time to do this observation, so we wrote the proposal in less than 24 hours, sent it out, and it was reviewed immediately,’ [MIT’s Julien] de Wit recalls. ‘Now for the first time we have spectroscopic observations of a double transit, which allows us to get insight on the atmosphere of both planets at the same time.’

“Using Hubble, the team recorded a combined transmission spectrum of TRAPPIST-1b and c, meaning that as first one planet then the other crossed in front of the star, they were able to measure the changes in wavelength as the amount of starlight dipped with each transit….”
(Jennifer Chu, MIT News)

TRAPPIST-1 is a very small star. Compared to our sun, its mass is about 8%, with a diameter a little more than Jupiter’s: 11.4% of our sun’s.

TRAPPIST, the Belgian robotic telescope at ESO’s La Silla Observatory in Chile, is named after Trappists: nuns and monks in the O.C.S.O. — Order of Cistercians of the Strict Observance.

The monastic order got its name from La Trappe Abbey, TRAPPIST stands for Transiting Planets and Planetesimals Small Telescope, and TRAPPIST-1 is an ultra-cool dwarf star.

An ultra-cool dwarf star is a red dwarf with a surface temperature below 2,700 K/2,430 °C/4,400 °F: very roughly the temperature and color of a ‘warm’ LED or incandescent bulb. (www.topbulb.com)

The “artist’s depiction” and that NASA/ESA/STScl animation make TRAPPIST-1 look a whole lot redder than it would seem to someone close enough to see the star as a “sun.”

More:


2. Juno at Jupiter


(From NASA, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“Juno probe enters into orbit around Jupiter”
Jonathan Amos, BBC News (June 5, 2016)

“The US space agency has successfully put a new probe in orbit around Jupiter.

“The Juno satellite, which left Earth five years ago, had to fire a rocket engine to slow its approach to the planet and get caught by its gravity.

“A sequence of tones transmitted from the spacecraft confirmed the braking manoeuvre had gone as planned….

“…Tuesday’s orbit insertion has put Juno in a large ellipse around the planet that takes just over 53 days to complete.

“A second burn of the rocket engine in mid-October will tighten this orbit to just 14 days. It is then that the science can really start….”

Data from Juno’s instruments should tell scientists how much of Jupiter is water, and help them map the planet’s magnetic and gravitational fields. That will help sort out theories of how Jupiter, and the Solar System, formed; and what powers its magnetic field.

Another science goal is measuring orbital frame-dragging around Jupiter. Frame-dragging is what happens when moving concentrations of mass-energy drag space-time along with them. It’s also called Lense-Thirring precession, and there will not be a test on this.

Data from Gravity Probe B, in Earth orbit, confirmed that frame dragging happens — after heavy-duty statistical analysis. The phenomenon should be easier to measure near Jupiter, since the planet has 317.8 times Earth’s mass and spins more than twice as fast.

Hardware and Science


(From NASA, JPL; via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Juno’s path into Jupiter orbit.)

“Juno Armored Up to Go to Jupiter”
NASA/JPL (July 12, 2010)

“…’Juno is basically an armored tank going to Jupiter,’ said Scott Bolton, Juno’s principal investigator, based at Southwest Research Institute in San Antonio. ‘Without its protective shield, or radiation vault, Juno’s brain would get fried on the very first pass near Jupiter.’…”

Jupiter’s intense magnetic field is much stronger than Earth’s, trapping and accelerating charged particles, forming a doughnut of radiation like Earth’s Van Allen radiation belt; but a whole lot stronger.

Juno‘s path avoids the worst of the radiation, and much of the spacecraft’s sensitive electronics are inside a titanium “radiation vault” with one-centimeter-thick walls.

That should keep the spacecraft working for all 37 planned 14-day ‘science’ orbits. Some of the instruments may not last that long.

The Jovian Infrared Auroral Mapper (JIRAM) should keep working through at least eight orbits, and Jet Propulsion Lab’s microwave radiometer is good for at 11 orbits. That’s the idea, anyway.

After the 37th orbit, Juno is supposed to start a controlled deorbit; a five-and-a-half day maneuver that drops it into Jupiter’s atmosphere — following NASA’s planetary protection policy. Jupiter almost certainly doesn’t support life of our variety, but one of its moons is another matter.

One of the simpler explanations for Europa‘s smooth surface is that the Jovian moon has a large ocean under its icy crust.

If that’s the case, we might find critters living in that ocean. Meanwhile, NASA wants to be sure than any critters on Jupiter’s moons grew there — and aren’t survivors from a crashed spaceship. And that’s yet another topic.

More:


3. Kepler: More than 100 Earth-Sized Planets Discovered


(From NASA, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)

“Kepler telescope discovers 100 Earth-sized planets”
Paul Rincon, BBC News (May 10, 2016)

“Nasa’s Kepler telescope has discovered more than 100 Earth-sized planets orbiting alien stars.

“It has also detected nine small planets within so-called habitable zones, where conditions are favourable for liquid water – and potentially life.

“The finds are contained within a catalogue of 1,284 new planets detected by Kepler – which more than doubles the previous tally….”

As of this week, we’ve found 3,472 planets orbiting 2,597 other stars; 589 of them have more than one known planet. That’s enough to make some educated guesses about planets we haven’t spotted yet.

Scientists figure about one in five sun-like stars have at least one ‘Earth-like’ planet — a planet that’s between one and two times Earth’s diameter — in the habitable zone.1

That seems reasonable, since the Solar System very nearly has two: Earth, and Venus. Granted, Venus is 94.99% Earth’s diameter, and at the inside edge of Sol’s habitable zone.

Assuming 200,000,000,000 stars in our galaxy, that gives us 11,000,000,000 ‘habitable’ planets: 40,000,000,000, if we add red dwarf stars to the mix. That’s a lot of planets, and the nearest one may be within 12 light-years of us.

So where is everybody?

First of all, there’s a big difference between (potentially) ‘habitable’ and ‘inhabited.’

Venus, Earth, and Mars, are (barely) in our star’s habitable zone for terrestrial planets. In the outer Solar System life might find a home in or on Ceres, Europea, Enceladus, and Titan.

The only place in that list that we know has life is Earth. Venus almost certainly is lifeless, Mars might have enough water left to keep microorganisms going, and the rest — we simply don’t know yet.

The rest of the universe may be ‘more of the same,’ or we may learn that life got started on billions of worlds. We may even hit the jackpot, and meet folks who are as chatty as we are. And that’s yet again another topic.

More:


1 A star’s habitable zone, or circumstellar habitable zone, is the volume surrounding a star where a planet like Earth isn’t baked to a crisp, like Mercury, or frozen, like the Solar System’s outer planets.

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , | 11 Comments

Citizenship and Being Catholic

I like being an American, most of the time.

I know that my country is far from perfect, but I’d rather be here than anywhere else on Earth.

Living in Sauk Centre, a smallish central Minnesota town, probably helps. I really like it here.

But it’s no Brigadoon, unchanged and unaffected by the outside world.

We’ve even got pretty good Internet service — and clean air, except when someone upwind is stirring a manure pit. On the other hand, crimes happen. Last year the biggest problems were larceny and drug abuse, 68 and 53 offenses respectively.1

Being a good citizen includes not committing that sort of crime, but there’s more to it.

I’ll get back to citizenship, Catholic style, which does not mean trying to force everyone to act just like me.

Being Good Citizens, Wherever We Live

I drove on the right side of the road before I became a Catholic. I also wore pants instead of a kilt, seldom ate with chopsticks, spoke English with one of the American accents, and used “guess” as a verb.

Then I became a Catholic, and kept doing pretty much the same thing.

In a sense, becoming a Catholic made me ‘more of an American.’

Being a good citizen isn’t an option for Catholics. We must contribute to the good of society and take part in public life, wherever we are. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1915, 2239)

Being Catholic doesn’t mean being American, though: or Western.

Japan is a pretty good example. By the end of the 1500s, something like 130,000 folks in Japan were Catholics. Alessandro Valignano’s insistence on respect for Japanese culture and customs probably helped.

The new faith appealed to locals from one end of the economic spectrum to the other: peasants, traders, sailors, warriors, and courtesans.

That’s the good news. The bad news is that some daimyos apparently liked Christianity because getting baptized meant easier access to saltpeter, a vital part of gunpowder.

Then the San Felipe, headed from Manila to Acapulco, ran into a storm and anchored in Urado Bay. I gather that after Japanese authorities seized the cargo, the Spanish ship’s captain said Portuguese missionaries were setting Japan up for European conquest.

That got Toyotomi Hideyoshi‘s attention. He outlawed Catholicism, probably thinking that he was protecting his country from western imperialism.

Given a choice between abandoning our faith or death, some folks chose death. Six European Franciscan missionaries, three Japanese Jesuits and 17 Japanese laymen, three of them young boys, were crucified on February 5, 1597.2

Other Japanese Christians were deported, or went underground. Two and a half centuries later, the Meiji Restoration restored imperial rule — and religious freedom. Many of the Kakure Kirishitan rejoined the Catholic Church, and that’s another topic.

Emperors, Tyrants, and the Common Good

Japan’s imperial family goes back about 2,600 years. I’m impressed by that sort of continuity.

My civilization’s history is — different.

Back when Emperor Jimmu conquered Yamato, or thereabouts, Psamtik I re-unified Egypt, and the Neo-Assyrian Empire dissolved.

Meanwhile, Corinth was among the first Greek city-states to replace their traditional hereditary priest-kings with tyrants.

Eventually “tyrant” got unpleasant connotations and Rome’s Republic became an empire, which crumbled after about five centuries.

Then Charlemagne became Emperor of the Romans, starting the Carolingian dynasty. After another four dynasties, Saxons and Franks were emperors of the Holy Roman Empire. That lasted until 1809.

Henry VIII of England was, by act of Parliament, ‘imperial:’ but never an emperor.

A little over two centuries later, English colonists in North America got fed up with micromanagement, revolted, and set up a federal republic. A few more centuries, and we may try something else.

Meanwhile, back in Japan, Akihito is the world’s only emperor. It’s a largely ceremonial role at the moment, but that could change in the next millennium.

Japan’s cultural continuity impresses me, but I’m used to the Western habit of kicking over the traces every few centuries.

Happily, the Church doesn’t expect me to insist on a monarchy, democracy, or any other particular form of government.

As long as a local regime works for the common good, and the citizens are okay with how their country’s authorities work, Catholics can live with any system. (Catechism, 1901)

Concern for the “common good” involves balancing individual and community needs, having respect for folks, and that’s yet another topic. (Catechism, 1905–1912)

Unity, Diversity, and Christmas Trees

I like some traditions, like Jack-o’-lanterns.

Some, like Easter eggs, tie in with Christian holidays. The parish church on Sauk Centre’s south side, for example, brings a tree inside during the Christmas season.

The Christmas tree’s origins aren’t entirely certain — but northwestern Europeans liked trees: like Donar’s Oak.

We’re not the only folks who had sacred groves: deodar and Nang Tani are Asian varieties. Then there’s the sad tale of mistletoe and Höðr, and that’s yet again another topic.

Where was I? Faith, culture, Norse mythology. Right.

Catholic Church is καθολικός, universal: united and diverse, not tied to one era or region. I’m not forced into a particular cultural mold.3

I could receive the heart of our faith, the Eucharist, in any parish — and recognize what’s central in the Mass.

The essentials in our re-presentation of the Last Supper haven’t changed in two millennia. Details in how we celebrate vary, according to local culture; and This is okay. (Matthew 26:26–28; Mark 14:22–24; Luke 22:17–20; Catechism, 1145–1149, 1202–1209, 1322–1419, 1668)

Catholic Tradition,4 with a capital T, is a “living transmission, accomplished in the Holy Spirit.” (Catechism, 77–78)

Desperately clinging to old habits and customs — is still another topic.

Citizenship, When to Say “No,” and Voting

Citizenship, Catholic style, includes taking an active part in public life; contributing to the good of society “in a spirit of truth, justice, solidarity, and freedom;” and submitting to legitimate authorities. (Catechism, 1915, 2239)

Submission to legitimate authority is not unthinking obedience.

Sometimes the local or regional boss tells us to do something that violates natural law.5 (Catechism, 2242)

Saying ‘no’ to England’s Henry VIII got Saints Thomas More and John Fisher killed. Nobody said this was going to be easy.

Interestingly, genocide is specifically mentioned as something we’re not supposed to do, and voting when we have that right is an obligation. (Catechism, 2240, 2313)

Elections and Freedom

America’s 2016 national elections are coming in November. The usual blather started in the last election cycle.

I’m not “political.”

I don’t claim that one party or candidate is always right and anyone who disagrees with me is in league with Satan.

Much as I’d like to ignore all the braying and trumpeting, though, I have to pay attention to candidates and issues. Voting responsibly is part of being a good citizen here.

One of the issues I’m concerned about is religious freedom: which does not mean forcing everyone to agree with me. As a Catholic, I must support religious freedom — for everybody. (Catechism, 2104–2109)

And that’s another topic, for another post.

More about life, love, and getting a grip:


1 State of Minnesota Department of Public Safety 2015 Uniform Crime Report, p. 147.

2We celebrate 日本二十六聖人, Nihon Nijūroku Seiji, Saints Paul Miki and his Companions, on February 6. February 5 was already the feast day of Saint Agatha of Sicily.

3 Background:

4 Definitions:

  • “BIBLE: Sacred Scripture: the books which contain the truth of God’s Revelation and were composed by human authors inspired by the Holy Spirit (105). The Bible contains both the forty-six books of the Old Testament and the twenty-seven books of the New Testament (120). See Old Testament; New Testament.”
  • “MAGISTERIUM: The living, teaching office of the Church, whose task it is to give as authentic interpretation of the word of God, whether in its written form (Sacred Scripture), or in the form of Tradition. The Magisterium ensures the Church’s fidelity to the teaching of the Apostles in matters of faith and morals (85, 890, 2033).”
  • “TRADITION: The living transmission of the message of the Gospel in the Church. The oral preaching of the Apostles, and the written message of salvation under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit (Bible), are conserved and handed on as the deposit of faith through the apostolic succession in the Church. Both the living Tradition and the written Scriptures have their common source in the revelation of God in Jesus Christ (75–82). The theological, liturgical, disciplinary, and devotional traditions of the local churches both contain and can be distinguished from this apostolic Tradition (83).”

And see Catechism, 95, 113, 174, and 126.

5 Natural law is the set of ethical principles woven into reality. These principles do not change. How we apply them changes as our circumstances change. (Catechism, 1952, 1954–1960)

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 6 Comments