GSLV, Rocket Lab: Looking Good

Updates:

(A successful landing will make India one of four spacefaring nations with a Lunar presence. Embedded ISRO YouTube live video, a little background.)


Below: “GSLV, Rocket Lab: Looking Good” (June 9, 2017)

India’s ‘monster rocket,’ the GSLV Mark III, successfully put the GSAT-19E satellite in orbit this week.

BBC News called some coverage of ISRO’s launch “euphoric.”

That’s understandable. India is like America in the late 20th century, where spaceflight is involved: and is rapidly catching up. I’m not euphoric, quite, but I see what’s happening as very good news for everyone.

Rocket Lab’s Electron test launch wasn’t entirely successful. But the company thinks they can get the system working, and plan to start commercial launches later this year.


Rockets in Space: “Absurd?”

It’s true: someone actually opined that rockets won’t work in a vacuum.

An op-ed in The New York Times said that Robert H. Goddard “…does not know the relation of action to reaction, and of the need to have something better than a vacuum against which to react….”

That was in 1920. On July 17, 1969, one day after the Apollo 11 mission set out for Earth’s moon, The Times published a clarification:

“JULY 17, 1969: On Jan. 13, 1920, Topics of The Times, an editorial-page feature of The New York Times, dismissed the notion that a rocket could function in a vacuum and commented on the ideas of Robert H. Goddard, the rocket pioneer, as follows: ‘That Professor Goddard, with his ‘chair’ in Clark College and the countenancing of the Smithsonian Institution, does not know the relation of action to reaction, and of the need to have something better than a vacuum against which to react — to say that would be absurd. Of course he only seems to lack the knowledge ladled out daily in high schools.’

“Further investigation and experimentation have confirmed the findings of Isaac Newton in the 17th century and it is now definitely established that a rocket can function in a vacuum as well as in an atmosphere. The Times regrets the error.”
(“150th Anniversary: 1851-2001; The Facts That Got Away,” Tom Kuntz, The New York Times (November 14, 2001) (And see The New York Times/Robert Goddard, Wikisource.)

The Times had cause for concern in 1920, sort of.

Working under a grant from the Smithsonian Institution’s Hodgkins Fund, Goddard had been developing a “multiple-charge rocket for exploring the unknown upper layers of the earth’s atmosphere.” We call them multistage rockets these days.

America’s national government runs the Smithsonian Institution, including the Hodgkins Fund. Since the Hodgkins Fund’s principle may not cover its administrative costs, The Times may have thought Goddard’s research was wasting tax dollars.

Thomas George Hodgkins

The Hodgkins Fund and Medal go back to 1893. By the time he died, Thomas George Hodgkins had given away his fortune: about a half-million dollars.

He was born in London, England, in 1803. His father was a gentleman “in reduced circumstances.” Trouble with a stepmother ended when he was 15.

That’s when he signed on as a crewman on a ship headed for Calcutta. Shipwreck, illness, and determination left him alive but barefoot-poor in India.

Decades later, he was very far from poor; at least financially.

He had no family, no close relatives, and a vast fortune that he wouldn’t be needing when his life was over. Figuring he’d do a better job than some executor, he began giving his money to pubic institutions, including the Smithsonian.

By the time he died in 1892, he’d given away everything.

The Smithsonian got part of his fortune. The institution started awarding the Hodgkins medal, and part of the money, to encourage “important contributions to knowledge of the physical environment bearing upon the welfare of man.”

I don’t know if the fund is still active.1

Folks like Mr. Hodgkins and Jacques Costeau are among the reasons why I have no problem accepting what the Church says about private property. (January 22, 2017)

Knowledge and Rocket Engines

Back in 1920, someone knew enough physics to wonder how Newton’s third law of motion applied to rocket engines.

That’s good. Informed advice and speculation make sense.

Not realizing that a rocket’s exhaust has mass, not so much.

Or maybe “the knowledge ladled out daily in high schools” didn’t include facts about air density and pressure.

Generations taught by folks with that sort of education might help explain more recent articles like this:

In my youth, Goddard was mostly known for his groundbreaking development of liquid-fueled rocket engines.

That was and is very important technology, and probably easier to explain than his work with ‘multiple-charge rockets.’

A rocket’s efficiency matters, a lot, since lifting even a small payload into orbit takes a great deal of reaction mass: the stuff the rocket ‘pushes against.’

For most rockets today, the fuel is also the reaction mass. Burning fuel produces hot gas at high pressure.

The rocket engine ‘pushes against’ the hot gas it’s shooting out its nozzle. The faster the gas gets pushed out, the higher a rocket’s efficiency. The hotter the ‘fire,’ the more energy gets transferred to the gas, also boosting efficiency.

The Dawn spacecraft’s gridded ion thruster is much more efficient than chemical rocket engines. But that sort of engine’s thrust is very low, so they’re useful only after a payload’s lifted off a planet or moon.

Multistage rockets are more efficient, in terms of physics, since they drop parts of the vehicle that have used up their fuel, leaving the rest with a lighter load.

Economically, they’re far from ideal.

After the Shuttle missions ended, and before SpaceX started building reusable boost stages, getting something into orbit meant throwing vehicles away after one use.

Commercial air service wouldn’t work, if a company had to throw away each airplane after one flight.

We still don’t have practical single-stage-to-orbit, or STO, vehicles. As I recall, funding issues stopped development of the McDonnell Douglas DC-X.

Reaction Engine’s Skylon spaceplane is still in the research and development process, though. Even if they don’t succeed, I’m quite sure that others will.

Physics, Rockets, and Faith

The first interstellar probes may use rocket engines for propulsion: or not. There are some intriguing — and testable — ideas on the table. And that’s another topic.

All this talk about physics and rocket engines may seem odd in a ‘religious’ blog. Or maybe not, if you’ve read my stuff before.

As I’ve said before, and most likely will again, I’m a Catholic, so ignoring truth is not an option. Not if I’m going to take what I believe seriously.

Faith, the Catholic version, is a willing and conscious “assent to the whole truth that God has revealed.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 142–150)

That’s the whole truth: including what we learn by paying attention to this universe. (Catechism, 32, 41, 74, 283, 341, 2500)

Even if I felt like it, deciding that I don’t like truth we’ve found since some arbitrary date doesn’t seem prudent. Or humble, in the Catholic sense. (May 7, 2017; March 10, 2017; February 3, 2017)

If we’re doing both right, faith and science work together. Using the brains God gave us, studying this wonder-filled universe and using that knowledge, is part of being human. (Catechism, 39, 159, 282–289, 341, 2293–2295)

What’s changed recently is how much we know about this universe: including the moon and stars mentioned in Psalms.

I see that as an opportunity for greater admiration of God’s work, not a threat to faith. (Catechism, 283, 341)

Space Flight and Psalms


(From NASA/Tracy Caldwell Dyson, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Self portrait: Tracy Caldwell Dyson in the ISS Cupola module, Expedition 24.)

“Manned space flight . . . has opened for us thus far only a tiny door for viewing the awesome reaches of space. Our outlook through this peephole at the vast mysteries of the universe only confirms our belief in its creator.”
(Wernher von Braun, cited in Awake! magazine (June 22, 1999), via Wikiquote)

“O LORD, our Lord, how awesome is your name through all the earth! You have set your majesty above the heavens!

“When I see your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and stars that you set in place –

“What are humans that you are mindful of them, mere mortals that you care for them?

“Yet you have made them little less than a god, crowned them with glory and honor.”
(Psalms 8:2–6)

“The heavens declare the glory of God; the sky proclaims its builder’s craft.”
(Psalms 19:2)

“4 Indeed, before you the whole universe is as a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth.

“But you have mercy on all, because you can do all things; and you overlook the sins of men that they may repent.

“For you love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for what you hated, you would not have fashioned.”
(Wisdom 11:22–24)


1. India’s ‘Monster Rocket:’ Expanding Transportation Services


(From AFP, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The Geosynchronous Satellite Launch Vehicle-Mark III is the heaviest rocket ever made by India”
(BBC News))

“India launches ‘monster’ rocket“
(June 5, 2017)

“India’s space agency has successfully launched its heaviest rocket.

“The 640-tonne rocket blasted off from a launching site off the Bay of Bengal in Sriharikota.

“As one website put it, ‘it’s been a big day for India’. The rocket will reduce the Indian Space Research Organisation’s (Isro) reliance on European vehicles to launch heavy satellites.

“The coverage of the launch has been euphoric, and often colourful, with websites comparing the rocket to the weight of 200 elephants, or five jumbo jets.…”

India’s first भूस्थिर उपग्रह प्रक्षेपण यान, geostationary satellite launch vehicle, the GSLV, combined components from the ISRO Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle and a Glavcosmos third stage.

The vehicle’s first working mission launched ISRO’s GSAT-2 in 2003. Since then it’s been a workhorse vehicle, launching from the Satish Dhawan Space Centre on Sriharikota. Most payloads have been communications satellites.

The GSLV Mk II’s schedule runs at least through 2020.

That’s when, if all goes well, India’s second Mars mission, Mangalyaan 2 and the ISRO/NASA NISAR (satellite) synthetic aperture radar Earth observer will launch.

Not at the same time. Those are two separate missions.

As an American, part of me is glad that the Saturn V is still the tallest and heaviest launch vehicle; and the most powerful, in terms of total impulse.

The last Saturn V launched in 1973. It’s still a huge rocket, although it’s not the largest by as great a margin as it was during the Apollo missions and in the days of Skylab.

I’d be astounded if it’s the biggest vehicle we ever build for Earth-to-space transport. We’re still in the very early days of spaceflight, and off-Earth exploration and development is no longer a governments-only game.

About America, India, and the Saturn V, like I said: I’m an American.

But I’m also human, so I’m glad that folks around the world are developing aerospace transportation systems and infrastructure we’ll use in coming centuries.

Aside from thinking that competition can keep folks from getting sloppy, having backups arguably makes sense.2

Besides, folks in my country engage in trade. More and wealthier potential trade partners and customers aren’t a threat. They’re opportunities. Particularly if my country’s national government doesn’t meddle with business deals, and that’s yet another topic.

A Snapshot From Space


(From AFP, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Isro has been popular for sharing onboard footage from its missions”
(BBC News))

BBC News did a follow-up article, “‘Monster’ rocket ‘selfie’ delights India,” with examples of how folks in India have been reacting to their country’s GSLV Mark III.

They like it. A lot: “The triumph of ‘Baahubali’: Amazing ‘selfies’ from @ISRO rocket” and “Delightful @isro India’s Baahubali rocket….”

I can see why folks call India’s launch vehicle a Bahubali. He’s a legendary figure for Jains. His name means “One With Strong Arms” in my language: or Armstrong, given our habit of compressing phrases.

The experimental LVM-3/CARE Mission in 2014 carried India’s Crew Module Atmospheric Re-entry Experiment.

Both the GSLV Mark III and experimental crew module both worked fine. The module went through its test of yaw, pitch, and roll, attitude control; handled reentry pretty much as expected; deployed its parachutes; and was picked up by India’s coast guard.

Judging from what ISRO is doing with hypersonic aircraft tests, my guess is that one of their objectives is developing a spaceplane along the lines of Reaction Engines’ Skylon.

Folks in India have a great deal to be excited about. So, I think, do the rest of us.


2. Rocket Lab’s Electron, and Spaceports


(From Reuters, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The two-stage rocket did not quite make it to orbit, but the team was very happy with the test flight”
(BBC News)

“New Zealand space launch is first from a private site“
(May 25, 2017)

“An American company has launched a rocket into space from New Zealand, the first from a private launch facility.

“Rocket Lab’s 17m-long (56ft) Electron lifted off from the Mahia Peninsula, in the North Island, the firm said.

“The test flight was the first launch from New Zealand and is a major first step in an emerging market: launching cheap disposable rockets to carry small satellites and other payloads.

“The company plans to start frequent commercial launches later this year….”

The launch was good news, and not-so-good news. The Rocket Lab’s Electron lifted off with no problems, first stage separation worked fine, but the simulated payload didn’t make it all the way to its intended orbit. That’s not at all bad for a first test flight.

This flight also showed that ground facilities at Rocket Lab Launch Complex 1 on New Zealand’s North Island Mahia Peninsula are ready for use. It’s one of several privately-owned spaceports either in use, under construction, or proposed.

Today’s spaceports aren’t all, by my standards, ports. Not yet. Many are strictly launch facilities, since only SpaceX currently builds partly-reusable launch systems. As far as I know, anyway.

But I think it’s just a matter of time before we have freighters and passenger craft coming back for their next flight.

The Mahaia Peninsula is a good location for a spaceport these days, since we still have a far less than perfect record for flawless launches.

There’s pretty much nothing but ocean downrange, and air traffic over that part of the world isn’t as heavy as it is over existing port facilities like the Kennedy Space Center.

Spaceports


(From Virgin Galactic, used w/o permission.)
(Spaceport America, in southern New Mexico.)

Safety issues aside, my guess is that spaceports will require lots of elbow room; at least in the near future. Launch vehicles are noisy, for one thing.

That, and the physics involved, may lead to some of Earth’s major port cities not being where land and water meet. Wide open spaces, particularly those near the equator and not far from existing transportation networks, may become prime real estate.

The Oklahoma Space Industry Development Authority seems to have realized the advantages in being away from existing population concentrations.

I don’t envy folks who will design and maintain aerospace traffic control systems when cities like New York, Singapore, and Mumbai, want their own spaceports.

Even then, I think there’ll be a market for smallish launch systems like the Electron, and sites like the Mahaia Peninsula.

CubeSats and Cautious Optimism

Size isn’t everything. More precisely, sometimes being small is a good thing; particularly for satellites and long range probes. (March 3, 2017)

CubeSats are a case in point. Each is a standardized 10 by 10 by 10 centimeters, maximum 1.33 kilograms.

CubeSat modules cost around $100,000 USD per module these days. That price has been coming down since the first ones launched in 2003, and is still dropping.

Most CubeSats were made by academic research outfits until 2013. Word got around, costs were dropping, and most CubeSats since then have been non-academic projects.

Rocket Lab’s Electron will, if and when its commercial flights start, lift 150 to 225 kilograms, 330 to 495 pounds, of payload into sun-synchronous orbit.3

That’d be a lot of CubeSats. It’s also a good size and orbit for weather and spy satellites. About the latter, I’ll skip the usual hand-wringing about human nature and today’s world.

I’m cautiously optimistic that we’re only a few millennia away from cobbling together a competent international authority.

Centuries, if enough of us decide it’s important. As I keep saying, we’re in this for the long haul, and slow progress is still progress. (June 4, 2017; May 28, 2017; October 30, 2016)


Meanwhile, Back in America

Elon Musk’s SpaceX says their Interplanetary Transport System, ITS, could be ready for their first Earth-Mars cargo run as early as 2020. I’ll be surprised if they’re ready that early.

The ITS isn’t just huge. Like the now-cancelled VentureStar, it’s significantly different from what we’ve done so far.

That includes extensive use of carbon fiber. Carbon fiber polymers are good for aerospace applications inside Earth’s atmosphere. The stuff looks good on paper for deep space missions.

But if I signed on for one of the planned settlement runs, I’d want assurance that the carbon fiber structures had been flight-tested for long missions.

The SpaceX timetable for Mars seems reasonable, if optimistic. The first Earth-Mars cargo run is penciled in for 2022 at the earliest, followed by a passenger run about two years later: one synodic period for Earth and Mars.

“Synodic period” is geek-speak for the time it takes for Earth and Mars, or any other two objects circling another one, to be in the same position relative to each other.

Even if the first colony ship was ready today, I wouldn’t be going. I’m rather old for that sort of thing, for starters.

But I’m certain that many folks would. I don’t see a problem with that, provided that we’ve developed the tech needed to make Martian settlements self-sustaining.

A few years ago, responding to what I’d written about living on Mars, someone expressed the opinion that folks should not be sent to die on Mars. I agree, in the sense that I think forcing someone to go would be a bad idea.

But since I’m no more than a few generations removed from folks who decided to “die in” North America, objecting to others making a similar decision doesn’t make sense. Not to me. And that’s yet again another topic, for another day.

Spaceships and Cities on Mars

Interplanetary spaceships and cities on Mars were ‘science fiction’ in my youth.

Depending on who’s talking, ‘science fiction’ means quite a few things.

Science fiction can be carefully-calculated tales of folks dealing with events and technology that’s not here yet.

Others saw it as escapist fantasy suitable only for preteen boys whose parents didn’t care about their children’s education and reading habits.

I figure it can be all of the above, plus a bit.

And Now for Something Completely Different — Science Fiction’s Silly Side

Some, make that most, movies are made for two reasons: to entertain folks, and make money. Successful ones do both.

Some, like “Plan 9 from Outer Space,” are appreciated by some and put in ‘world’s worst’ lists made by not-so-positively-impressed viewers.

My guess, looking at science fiction films of the last few decades, is that cautious optimism isn’t ‘box office.’

Or maybe studio executives figure there’s no point in trying to top William Cameron Menzies’s 1933 “Things to Come.”

With that in mind, and since I’m feeling slightly snarky, I’ll present a scenario that may be too weird even for the movies.

But who knows? Someone might take this seriously. Now, without further ado, fresh from the murky depths of my mind4 —

Tidal waves and earthquakes and volcanic eruptions caused by global warming and the Antarctic ice cap’s collapse kill everyone in New York, Los Angeles, and places with good ‘disaster’ stock footage.

Survivors keep the angst going. Then they (what else?) die, helpless and hopeless, after lots of preachy dialog and screaming.

Except for a lone survivor, endlessly battling giant flying man-eating zombie cyborg piranha created when unregulated GMO corn pollutes — — — you get the idea. I lost track of how many Alien films featured assorted survivors and cloned victims.

Think Frankenfish and The Terminator meet Splice and Sharktopus in Zombieland. Actual movie titles. I’ve enjoyed The Terminator, haven’t seen the others: and don’t feel particularly compelled to do so.

Happily for studio executives, many folks aren’t like me. “Sharktopus” led to “Sharktopus vs. Pteracuda” and “Sharktopus vs. Whalewolf.”

Like I said, I enjoyed “The Terminator.” I never lost a taste for improbable but exciting tales, developed while watching weekday after-school movies on television.

I’d probably enjoy the films more, if it wasn’t for the uneasy suspicion that they may have encouraged less-than-reasonable attitudes. On the other hand, folks had daft ideas long before the Lumière brothers made “La Sortie de l’Usine Lumière à Lyon.”5

Enough about movies, cringe-worthy and otherwise. Maybe too much.

A Will-be That Hasn’t Been: Yet

About what’s coming in aerospace transportation and humanity’s new horizons, I am quite sure that we’ve taken no more than the first short steps.

I’m also pretty sure our future isn’t nearly as nifty as some hope, or nasty as others fear. Also that we can count on surprises, pleasant and otherwise.

The SpaceX Interplanetary Transport System may go the way of the DC-X and Lockheed Martin VentureStar.

But someone will eventually want to lift something bigger and heavier than the largest existing vehicle will carry. Then, if dividing the cargo into pieces isn’t practical, it’ll be time to build a bigger launch vehicle.

I’ve seen thoughtless optimism about “the future” turn to equally-unconsidered pessimism, and think both make little sense. (October 30, 2016)

Some of today’s plans will almost certainly go the way of other promising developments that fell short of their goals.

Good Ideas, Innovative and Unused: So Far

The VentureStar wouldn’t have been the tallest vehicle, but would have been impressive for its innovations: which included a linear aerospike engine. I think the basic idea shows very great promise.

Lockheed Martin couldn’t get the tech to work, not well enough for flight. So VentureStar development was canceled.

The inelegant but test-flown DC-X is another good, but abandoned, idea. The McDonnell Douglas DC-X was a one-third working scale model of their planned Delta Clipper cargo ship.

I still think the Delta Clipper made more sense for commercial development than the VentureStar. The DC-X used existing tech, and was designed for minimal maintenance and ground support.

I suspect that successful test flights of the DC-X model didn’t endear it to NASA brass who preferred the VentureStar. That’s speculation, and still another topic.

It didn’t help that the last test flight of the DC-X ended in a crash that destroyed the vehicle. There were definitely some bugs that needed work before commercial production. A debatable degree of cross-range maneuverability was another unresolved issue.

I strongly suspect that we’ll see cargo and passenger runs using vehicles like the Delta Clipper, VentureStar, Skylon — and designs we haven’t thought of yet. How soon that happens depends in large part on how badly folks want the service.

One more quote, and I’m done.

“A Planet is the Cradle….”

“Планета есть колыбель разума, но нельзя вечно жить в колыбели”
“A planet is the cradle of mind, but one cannot live in a cradle forever.”
(Konstantin Eduardovich Tsiolkovsky, from a letter written in 1911, via Wikiquote)

More, embracing truth and looking ahead with hope:


1 Hodgkins Fund background:

2 India’s space program:

3 Launch systems, CubeSats, and commercial spaceflight:

4 A tip of the hat to Ortrud, whose sensible response to conventional hopelessness started me thinking:

5 Some of my take on silliness, science, and the movies:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , | 4 Comments

London: Death, Hope, and Love

This is bad, but could have been much worse. Yesterday evening, starting around 10:00, three people in a van drove across London Bridge, deliberately running down pedestrians.1

After crossing the bridge, they left the van and attacked folks out for an evening with friends and family near Borough Market.

A few minutes later, they were dead; shot by police. They had killed seven folks by then, 48 were taken to hospitals, 36 are still hospitalized, 21 in critical condition, as I write this.


(From H. Attai, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“The white van, in the centre of this photo, is believed to have been used in the attack”
(BBC News))

Responses — and Hope

About a dozen folks have been arrested, suspected of helping the attackers. The UK’s official threat level is still one notch below the highest setting, and I’m sure this will be in the news for days. At least.

I hope that folks in the United Kingdom, particularly those who are in charge, stay comparatively calm and rational.

Situations like this help me be profoundly glad that I don’t enjoy the perks — and responsibilities — of leadership, beyond what’s involved in my role as husband and father, and that’s another topic.

There is, I think, cause for hope:

“…Flowers are laid at the scene, as people come to pay their respects to the victims.

“Imam Abdul Arif, 27, from the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community, says he wants to ‘show solidarity’.

“‘I’m a Londoner,’ he says. ‘I came here because it happened to my home city and it happened in the name of my religion.

“‘I came to show solidarity and to show it’s not in my name.’

“Imam Arif was breaking fast and finishing his evening prayer as part of Ramadan when he heard the news of the attack.

“‘Ramadan is a time when you should be worshiping and serving humanity more than ever and these people perpetrated such a crime.

“‘My hope is that everybody is united and show the individuals who want to divide us they won’t be successful.’…”
(Cherry Wilson, BBC News (June 4, 2017))

“…Speaking in Downing Street after a meeting of the government’s emergency Cobra committee, the prime minister said the country ‘cannot and must not pretend that things can continue as they are’….

“…Mrs May said the UK’s counter-terrorism strategy would be reviewed, as she promised to step up efforts to combat Islamist ideology and work with other countries to prevent the internet being a ‘safe space’ for terrorists.

“She said there was ‘too much tolerance of extremism in our country’ and while it would involve ‘some difficult and embarrassing conversations’, that must change….”
(BBC News (June 4, 2017))

“I am appalled and angered by the terrorist attacks at London Bridge and Borough Market, in my home city. These acts of violence were truly shocking and I condemn them in the strongest terms.

“Muslims everywhere are outraged and disgusted at these cowards who once again have destroyed the lives of our fellow Britons. That this should happen in this month of Ramadan, when many Muslims were praying and fasting only goes to show that these people respect neither life nor faith.

“My prayers are with the victims and all those affected. I commend the work of our emergency services working hard to keep us safe and cope with the ensuing carnage.”
(Harun Khan, Secretary General of the Muslim Council of Britain; via Twitter (June 4, 2017))

Not Missing The ‘Good Old Days’

I figure that folks who support the Ku Klux Klan believe they are defending their country and their faith against people like me.2 But I’m quite sure that many American Protestants do not support the KKK.

I certainly do not fear that an Anglo-American will put a burning cross in my front yard.

Most, I think, are much too reasonable; and no more likely to smite the unrighteous than I am. I’ll grant that living in a predominantly-Catholic town encourages my confidence.

Besides, I spent much of my life as an American Protestant: and never torched a cross.

My experience strongly suggests that many if not most of us/them are not white supremacists with latent pyromaniac and homicidal tendencies.

Excerpt from Mamma's Girls, Chick Publications, ©2012 by Jack T. Chick LLC; used w/o permission.Some, however, particularly where I grew up, expressed great concern about the “Whore of Babylon.”

That’s “queen of whores” for at least one outfit these days, but the idea’s pretty much the same.

I’ve since learned that I grew up in an area with more than the usual old-fashioned American antipathy for Catholicism and the Catholic Church.

That, and incidents like Fr. Coyle’s murder, make me glad that the ‘good old days’ aren’t coming back.

James Coyle was a triple threat to ‘American values,’ by some standards. He was Irish, Catholic, and a priest.

That’s not, entirely, what got him killed.

On August 11, 1921, he had performed a marriage ceremony for a young couple in Alabama. The newlyweds were the daughter of a Southern Methodist Episcopal minister and a Puerto Rican. A few hours later, the minister killed Fr. Coyle.

The father’s actions were justified, by some standards. His daughter had recently become a Catholic, and then married a Puerto Rican. He was charged with murder, anyway: but acquitted, after the jury heard details of the incident.

Time brings change, and sometimes change is good.

On February 22, 2012, less than a century after Fr. Coyle’s death, a North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church bishop headed a reconciliation and forgiveness service at Highlands United Methodist Church in Birmingham.

As I keep saying, I see reasons for hope: and I do not miss the ‘good old days.’ At all.

I’m also dubious when folks apparently want protection against Muslims for the same reasons given for defending America against Catholics.

Assumptions and the Psycho Santa Catholic Connection

This is the third high-profile terrorism incident in the UK since March 22, 2017.1

The folks responsible for all three apparently had religious motives. That doesn’t, I think, show that Islam leads to mass murder.

I certainly won’t make an incendiary claim like that. Something we don’t need today is another angry voice online.

My reticence is no great virtue. I remember how unimpressed I was with warnings and innuendo about folks with the ‘wrong’ beliefs. Not favorably impressed, to be more accurate. I see no point in reinforcing the belief that religious folks aren’t reasonable.

I also remember when “former altar boy” was as common in crime news as “Vietnam veteran” had been a decade or so earlier.

About those newspaper catch phrases: it’s true that some vets committed crimes. So did some former altar boys.

There were precious few American men in a particular age bracket who weren’t Vietnam veterans. The “altar boy” connection may have fizzled when a journalist noticed that it would be hard to throw a rock in some neighborhoods and not hit a “former altar boy.”

Many news outlets, including BBC News and Al Jazeera,3 didn’t draw attention to what I called the Psycho Santa Catholic connection. Others put it in their lead paragraphs:

“Man dressed as Santa kills nine at Christmas Eve party”
Toby Harnden, The Telegraph (December 26, 2008)

“Bruce Jeffrey Pardo, 45, a devoted Roman Catholic and aerospace industry worker who may have recently lost his job, shot himself in the head hours after the meticulously planned carnage in Covina, California, 22 miles east of Los Angeles.

“His murderous rampage began late on Christmas Eve when an eight year-old girl opened the two-storey house’s front door in the quiet cul-de-sac to find Pardo, dressed as Father Christmas and carrying a large present….”

Parts of the blogosphere lit up with the usual outrage over those nasty Catholics.

I didn’t join in, partly because I’d become a Catholic by then. I doubt that I’d ever have spat venom quite so enthusiastically. That sort of behavior had started me on the path toward conversion, and that’s yet another topic.

About Mr. Prado, I’m sorry that he’s dead; and that he killed his family.

Valuing Human Life: All Human Life


(From HGiovanni Sagristani, via BBC News, used w/o permission.)
(“Diners threw chairs and bottles at the attacker”
(BBC News))

About that: I think killing innocent people, or myself, is a bad idea.

That’s because I see human life as sacred: all human life. Suicide is a really bad idea, since my life — and everyone else’s — is a gift from God. I have no authority to end my own life. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2258-2317)

I don’t always feel like life is worth living, but am glad that I developed a habit of ignoring suicidal impulses. And that’s yet again another topic. (October 14, 2016)

Because I value human life, I am very unhappy at the loss of life near London Bridge. That includes the attackers.

Given the circumstances, however, I think British police acted reasonably. If they had not, the attackers would almost certainly had killed more innocent folks; and most likely would have ended up dead anyway.

Their suicide vests were fake — that’s a new wrinkle. But they were badly outnumbered.

At least some of their would-be victims defended themselves with improvised weapons. Faced with attackers who might be expected to explode, I doubt that folks would be particularly restrained in their efforts to remain alive. A ballistic bar stool can be lethal.

Valuing human life would require me to avoid killing another person, even if I am attacked. I could, however, protect myself: even if an unintended result of my action resulted in my attacker’s death.

The same principle applies to those responsible for protecting others. (Catechism, 2307-2317)

Love and Working for Future Generations

In one sense, my hope comes from my trust in our Lord’s promises. (Catechism, 1817-1821)

I’m also sure that Johnny Cash was right: being so heavenly minded that I’m no earthly good doesn’t make sense.

Neither does saying that I have one set of beliefs, and acting as if I have another.

That gets me to what our Lord said when asked “…which commandment in the law is the greatest?” (Matthew 22:36)

“He said to him, ‘You shall love the Lord, your God, with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.
“This is the greatest and the first commandment.
“The second is like it: You shall love your neighbor as yourself.
“The whole law and the prophets depend on these two commandments.'”
(Matthew 22:37–40)

That, plus the principle of reciprocity we call the golden rule, is easy to remember: and often very difficult to do. (June 4, 2017)

But, difficult or not, I should love God, love my neighbors, see everyone as my neighbor, and treat others as I’d like to be treated. (Matthew 5:43–44, 7:12, 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31 10:25–27, 29–37; Catechism, 1789)

All that talk about love should apply, no matter how I’m feeling. There’s nothing basically wrong with emotions. They’re part of being human. But I’m expected to think. (Catechism, 1730, 1765-1770, 1730, 1778, 1804, 2339)

That, and not being directly involved in UK or American politics, is why I’m not clamoring for tougher knife control laws or calling for a complete ban on vans. Or staunchly defending the right to drive vans and supporting knife deregulation.

Maybe I shouldn’t joke. At least one of those might be an issue.4

Instead, I’ll repeat what I’ve said before; and almost certainly will again. (April 30, 2017; February 5, 2017)

Part of our job is working with people of good will: all people of good will. By keeping what is good and just in our cultures, changing what is not, I think we can build a better world for future generations. (Catechism, 1917, 1928-1942, 1825, 1996, 2415; “Laudato si’;” “Gaudium et spes“)

It will be a long, hard, process. I do not expect to see much progress in my life. That’s okay. We’re in this for the long haul, and I think we can do better.

I am sure that we must try.

What I think about:


1 Recent UK terrorism, background and news:

2 Attitudes, mostly American, background:

3 Psycho Santa, 2008:

4 Occasional-reasonable rules:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments

We are Many, We are One

One my favorite bits from the Bible is in this morning’s readings:

“…We are Parthians, Medes, and Elamites, inhabitants of Mesopotamia, Judea and Cappadocia, Pontus and Asia,

“Phrygia and Pamphylia, Egypt and the districts of Libya near Cyrene, as well as travelers from Rome,

“both Jews and converts to Judaism, Cretans and Arabs, yet we hear them speaking in our own tongues of the mighty acts of God.'”
(Acts 2:9–11)

A “noise like a strong driving wind” in the sky had gotten their attention.

Maybe they’d seen the “tongues as of fire,” too. Or maybe that was visible only to the disciples inside. Now that I think of it, a loud ‘whooshing’ sound in the sky and descending fire might easily have started a stampede.

Anyway, folks outside were puzzled, since they had been hearing what the folks inside were saying.

That’s not the puzzling part. I gather that Jerusalem in those days didn’t provide nearly as much acoustic privacy as we’re accustomed to. The decidedly odd part was that each person “heard them speaking in his own language.” Hence the roll call of nationalities.

The effect apparently was a bit like audio feeds for UN delegates: nearly two millennia before the United Nations Interpretation Service.

Under the circumstances, passing the whole thing off as an auditory illusion triggered by hearing drunken babbling wasn’t entirely unreasonable. (Acts 2:13–15)

You know the rest. Peter explained that he and his associates weren’t drunk. He said that something major had happened, starting with what Joel had written about:

“1 Then afterward I will pour out my spirit upon all mankind. Your sons and daughters shall prophesy, your old men shall dream dreams, your young men shall see visions….”
(Joel 3:1)

Jesus Died, But He’s Better Now

Jesus was the Messiah they’d been waiting for: “a man commended to you by God with mighty deeds, wonders, and signs.”

Then Jesus had been executed and buried.

Here’s where it gets interesting:

“But God raised him up, releasing him from the throes of death, because it was impossible for him to be held by it.”
(Acts 2:24)

That was about two thousand years ago. Folks are still adjusting to the news.

Change and Constants

Some things have changed.

Phrygia’s land became part of Rome’s holdings about a century after the “tongues as of fire” event. Since then it’s been in the Byzantine, Seljuk, and Ottoman Empires.

These days, it’s part of Turkey; where Afyonkarahisar Province is, more or less. Someone else will probably be running the territory two millennia from now.

Even if Turkey retains its national identity, Afyonkarahisar ili and Türkiye will most likely be called something else. Languages change. Unless we have a really good reason for maintaining the exact syntax, grammar, and vocabulary of a particularly moment in time.

Rome is still a major city, but the last Roman Emperor died more than a dozen centuries back.

My ancestors come from lands beyond the old Roman frontier. I speak English, a West Germanic language that wouldn’t settle into something like its current form until Shakespeare’s day.

Some things haven’t changed, and won’t.

Taking something that doesn’t belong to me is still wrong, even if it’s legal. Lying is still a bad idea. (Exodus 20:15–16; Deuteronomy 5:19–20; Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2401-2449, 2464-2503)

Those are part of natural law, ethical principles built into the universe. They don’t change. Positive law, rules we make to help us live in comparative harmony, can and sometimes must change. (February 5, 2017; November 21, 2016)

Something else that won’t change is the best news humanity’s ever had.

Best. News. Ever.

World Youth Day 2000, Rome, from sporki, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.

This is the message we’ve been passing along for two millennia:

God loves us, and wants to adopt us. All of us. (John 1:12–14, 3:17; Peter 1:3–4; Catechism, 27-30, 52, 1825, 1996)

What we do about it is up to each of us. I became a Catholic.

The Shavuot recalled in Acts 2 was our ‘grand opening’ — making our Lord’s message available to anyone who would listen.1 (Catechism, 731-732, 767)

We call the celebration Pentecost. It’s when we officially received the Holy Spirit, with the gifts needed to do our jobs. (Catechism, 731-732, 767-768, 1287, 2623)

My tool kit seems to include the expression of knowledge. (1 Corinthians 12:8)

And that’s another topic, for another post

We have several visible symbols for the Holy Spirit: including fire, a cloud and light, a dove, and a finger. (Catechism, 694-701)

That doesn’t mean the Holy Spirit is a fire, cloud, bird, or finger. The Holy Spirit is spirit — not material. Not part of matter/energy in this universe. The Holy Spirit is one person in the Trinity.2 (Catechism, 687-741)

Humans are intensely visual creatures,3 which probably helps explain why so many of our symbols are visual symbols.

I suspect that’s why God often gives us something we can see, when getting and holding our attention. (Exodus 19:9, 40:38; Matthew 3:16; Mark 1:10; Luke 3:22; John 1:32)

Love and Blunders

Today, Catholics live on every continent except Antarctica.

Some visit that continent, as scientists or tourists. But nobody, Catholic or otherwise, lives there permanently. Not yet.

We speak Albanian, Brazilian, Japanese, Lebanese, and many other languages.

We worship in Kobe, Japan; Hannover, Germany; Westfield, Indiana; and Kunming, China.

We have lived under emperors, kings, chairmen, and presidents. Sometimes our native leaders let us worship in peace, sometimes they don’t. Occasionally they try to take our Lord’s place.

We are “one in Christ Jesus,” united by the sacraments our Lord gave us: Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist, Penance, the Anointing of the Sick, Holy Orders, and Matrimony. (Catechism, 1210)

We celebrate these sacraments in many ways, reflecting our many cultures. (Catechism, 1200-1206)

Some aspects of Catholic worship haven’t changed, and won’t. Some keep changing, and this is okay. In fact, it’s a good idea. (Catechism, 1200-1206)

“…The mystery celebrated in the liturgy is one, but the forms of its celebration are diverse.
“The mystery of Christ is so unfathomably rich that it cannot be exhausted by its expression in any single liturgical tradition….”
(Catechism, 1200-1201)

That upsets folks who apparently imagine that being Catholic means acting pretty much like they do. They may really think that everyone — in all places and for all time — should worship exactly as they did in their home parish, a few decades back.

I’m sure they’re sincere. I’m also sure they are wrong.

Being Catholic means, or should mean, being part of a truly catholic, καθολικός, universal church — for all people; in every age, including those that haven’t happened yet.

Some of us, as centuries rolled by, have acted as if making “disciples of all nations” meant forcing one culture or political system down everyone’s throat. That’s a huge mistake.

We’re still cleaning up the mess left by the Verden massacre, and that’s yet another topic. (April 30, 2017)

There is no one ‘correct’ culture or political system. (Catechism, 24, 814, 1901, 1957)

There are, however, a few basic principles we should always observe.

I should love God, love my neighbors, see everyone as my neighbor, and treat others as I’d like to be treated. (Matthew 5:43–44, 7:12, 22:36–40, Mark 12:28–31; Luke 6:31 10:25–27, 29–37; Catechism, 1789)

It’s simple, easy to remember: and very hard to do.

Καθολικός, Universal

From Calendar of Major Events, Jubilee of Mercy, 2015; used w/o permission.

As a Catholic, I’m obliged to take our Tradition very seriously. That doesn’t mean following every tradition we’ve accumulated over millennia. I doubt one person could. Not in a single lifetime. (June 2, 2017)

I can’t insist that everyone act just the way we did in the parish I grew up in.

I’m an adult convert, so my childhood memories include pleasant experiences in a nice, normal, mainstream Protestant church.

I take what the Church says about social justice and environmental concerns very seriously. That doesn’t make me a liberal, any more than seeing abortion as a bad idea makes me conservative. I’m a Catholic. (January 22, 2017; February 12, 2017)

I didn’t become a Catholic to preserve youthful ideals I developed in the 60s.

But learning that social justice, Catholic style, makes sense — was nice. So was discovering that popes have been pushing for a competent international authority at least since 1965. (May 28, 2017; November 29, 2016; September 25, 2016)

One more thing: Pentecost is also a traditional (lower case “t”) time for folks who are becoming Catholic to formally wrap up their entry procedures.

That can include a renewal of baptismal promises: something we’ve been doing during Mass in my parish over the last several weeks. I enjoy the review, and the “I do” responses.

I left those out of the text I copied from “The Renewal of Baptismal Promises,” since it’s the same for everything except the closing “this is our faith” thing:”

“Do you renounce Satan, and all his works and empty promises?

“Do you believe in God, the Father almighty, Creator of heaven and earth?

“Do you believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord, who was born of the Virgin Mary, suffered death and was buried, rose again from the dead and is seated at the right hand of the Father?

“Do you believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of life, who today through the Sacrament of Confirmation is given to you in a special way just as he was given to the Apostles on the day of Pentecost?

“Do you believe in the holy Catholic Church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body, and life everlasting?

“This is our faith. This is the faith of the Church. We are proud to profess it in Christ Jesus our Lord.
((From “The Renewal of Baptismal Promises” Order of Confirmation, English translation © 2013, International Committee on English in the Liturgy, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Liturgy Office, England & Wales (www.liturgyoffice.org.uk/Resources/Confirmation/OC-Renewal.pdf (May 26, 2017))

The words during Mass are a tad different in our parish, but the ideas are the same.

I’ve talked about Satan, sin, and getting a grip, before. And that’s yet again another topic. (November 13, 2016; November 6, 2016; July 31, 2016)

Posts about:


1 Definitions:

“HOLY SPIRIT: The third divine Person of the Blessed Trinity, the personal love of Father and Son for each other. Also called the Paraclete (Advocate) and Spirit of Truth, the Holy Spirit is at work with the Father and the Son from the beginning to the completion of the divine plan for our salvation (685; cf. 152, 243).”
“PENTECOST: The ‘fiftieth’ day at the end of the seven weeks following Passover (Easter in the Christian dispensation). At the first Pentecost after the Resurrection and Ascension of Jesus, the Holy Spirit was manifested, given and communicated as a divine Person to the Church, fulfilling the paschal mystery of Christ according to his promise (726, 731; cf. 1287). Annually the Church celebrates the memory of the Pentecost event as the beginning of the new ‘age of the Church,’ when Christ lives and acts in and with his Church (1076).”
(Catechism, Glossary)

2 I am a Christian and a Catholic, so I worship God the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. That does not make me a polytheist. God is one. We don’t worship anyone or anything else, or shouldn’t. God is also three persons, and that’s another topic. (Catechism, 232-260)

3 More about being human:

Posted in Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

New Worlds: The Search Continues

There’s a huge telescope under construction in Chile: the E-ELT. When compete, astronomers using it plan on looking for new worlds, and observing the early universe.

We may have spotted a second super-Saturn. We’ll know more about that in September.


Galileo, Copernicus, and Proof

Telescopes have come a long way since Galileo repurposed the “Dutch perspective glass” for astronomical observation.

About Galileo, Copernicus, the sun, and the Church: it’s true.

Copernicus delayed printing of his “De revolutionibus….” Galileo was tried and condemned by the (Roman) Inquisition. “De revolutionibus…” was on the “Index Librorum Prohibitorum.”

The ‘heroic scientist ultimately triumphs against forces of superstition’ story is dramatic, and familiar. Reality is a tad more complicated.

I talked about Copernicus last month. (April 28, 2017)

Briefly recapping the Copernicus timetable, “De revolutionibus…” was published in 1543, placed on the Index Librorum Prohibitorum in 1616, and taken off the Index in 1620.

The problem had been nine sentences that incorrectly reflected a view that heliocentrism was an established fact: not a hypothesis.

The process would probably take less time today. With 17th century information technology, I think 1616 to 1620 is pretty fast work.

“De revolutionibus…” was, and is, an extremely technical publication: suitable for top-rate mathematicians and astronomers, not folks with my abilities.

Scientists — they were called natural philosophers at the time1 — who could follow the math realized that Copernican equations were valid.

They also realized that there was no proof that the equations described a physical reality. One major objection was a lack of observable stellar parallax.

Aristarchus: a Good First Try

If Copernicus was right, they pointed out, stars would shift their apparent position slightly when viewed from opposite sides of Earth’s orbit. We call the change in position stellar parallax.

Folks reading “De revolutionibus…” weren’t stupid, at all, and knew about Euclid’s geometry. With their 17th-century tech, they could detect no parallax.

They also knew that if the stars were far enough away, they couldn’t detect stellar parallax. Again, not with their tech.

But that would mean that the stars are very distant, indeed. I suspect that some academics discounted the Copernican model because the cosmos it described was much larger than they imagined.

Aristarchus of Samos had worked out distance between Earth and sun about 23 centuries back. He thought maybe Earth goes around our sun, and that the stars might be other suns.

He was right, on both counts, but we couldn’t demonstrate it until recently.

Aristarchus figured that our sun was about 6.7 Earth radii away. The actual number is roughly 150,000,000 kilometers, 93,000,000 miles:  about 14,600 Earth radii. But I think it was a good first try.

The nearest star we’ve found is a bit upwards of 268,200 times as far away as our sun. Let’s see: 14,600 times 268,200? That’s a whole lot of Earth radii.

Telescopes: Big, Bigger, and the E-ELT


(From Cmglee, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Comparison: telescope lenses and mirrors; past, present & planned; 1893-2022.)

The first known optical telescope was made by someone in the Netherlands around 1609.

Middelburg spectacle-makers Hans Lippershey and Sacharias Jansen developed one. So did Jacob Metius. Folks also called him Jacob Metius of Alkmaar. His alternative personal names were Jacobus or James.

European family naming customs were shifting at the time, and most likely still are: but more slowly. (April 2, 2017)

Lippershey applied for, but wasn’t granted, a patent “for seeing things far away as if they were nearby.” He was, however, given a substantial financial reward for developing a practical telescope.

Dutch officials may or may not have realized the tech would revolutionize astronomy. They certainly were aware of the telescope’s value to merchants.

The Netherlands was the Dutch Republic then, a top world trade power. Amsterdam was the New York City of the day.

Spotting and identifying an incoming cargo ship’s house flag before it arrived gave its owners, or their competitors, an advantage. That knowledge let them make deals before everyone on the wharf knew what’s coming to market.

Still Learning

“…we are dwarfs astride the shoulders of giants. We master their wisdom and move beyond it….”
(Isaiah di Trani, quoted in “Standing on the shoulders of giants”
World Heritage Encyclopedia, via http://worldlibrary.eu)

The first telescopes used principles of refraction Ptolemy had studied in the 2nd century. We don’t know who made and used the first rock crystal lens.

Better technology gave astronomers more powerful telescopes, like Johannes Hevelius’ 46-meter/150-foot Keplerian telescope.

Ibn al-Haytham’s work laid groundwork for developing better lenses, and using mirrors in telescopes. Several Europeans, including Galileo, started discussing practical reflecting telescopes after Galileo’s work with the Dutch spyglass.

James Gregory published a design for the Gregorian telescope in 1663. Someone, the name depends on which account you read, successfully measured the distance to 61 Cygni. That was between 1812 and 1814.

Friedrich Wilhelm Bessel arguably got there first, but all of them were building on a couple millennia of work and thought. More, actually.

Hand-held rock crystal lenses are portable, and handy for starting fires, provided there’s direct sunlight. My guess is that we’ve been using them since long before we looked the way we do now, and that’s another topic.


1. Coming Soon: the E-ELT, a Huge Telescope


(From ESO, used w/o permission.)
(“Artist’s rendering of the ELT in operation”
(ESO))

“First Stone Ceremony for ESO’s Extremely Large Telescope”
Press release, ESO (May 26, 2017)

“A ceremony marking the first stone of ESO’s Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) has been attended today by the President of the Republic of Chile, Michelle Bachelet Jeria. The event was held at ESO’s Paranal Observatory in northern Chile, close to the site of the future giant telescope. This milestone marked the beginning of the construction of the dome and main telescope structure of the world’s biggest optical telescope, and ushered in a new era in astronomy. The occasion also marked the connection of the observatory to the Chilean national electrical grid….”

We’ve learned a great deal since folks built Zorats Karer.

Someone, we don’t know who, built those ruins: after Lothal was a major trade center and before Phoenicians developed their alphabet. They used Egyptian hieroglyphs as a starting point. The Phoenicians, that is.

My language uses an alphabet based, indirectly, on their work, I mentioned that last week, and that’s yet another topic. (May 26, 2017)

We’re not even sure why folks built Zorats Karer. Some of the stones and holes line up with astronomical events like solstices and equinoxes. But we could be looking at what’s left of a city wall, or something else. We’re not sure about Stonehenge, either.

The first observatory in the current sense, a facility designed specifically for observing and studying objects in the sky, was probably built by folks funded by Al-Ma’mun, Harun al-Rashid’s son.

Observatories, those built for visual observation, need clear skies. Radio observatories are another matter. City lights weren’t much of a factor back in Al-Ma’mun’s day, or when Tycho Brahe had Uraniborg built.

Uraniborg included an observatory, plus an alchemical laboratory and research support facilities. There were even an aquaculture ponds. Overflow from the ponds powered a paper mill.

This was the late 1500s, when alchemy was still a serious discipline. (October 16, 2016)

Gaslamps and the Atacama Desert

Gas-powered street lighting started replacing link-boys around 1800.

Folks felt safer with illuminated streets, except after gas explosions, which may help explain why we switched to electric lighting.

There’s informed debate on how much — or whether — street lighting interferes with our wake-sleep cycle. What’s more certain is that astronomers can’t count on dark sky in or near cities nowadays.

That, and a need for very clear skies, has encouraged astronomers to build observatories on mountaintops; far from cities.

The European Extremely Large Telescope is, or will be, on Cerro Armazones, a mountain in Chile’s Atacama Desert, Earth’s driest non-polar desert. It will be the European Southern Observatory’s fifth observing site.

Why So Big?


(From ESO, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(The European Extremely Large Telescope, E-ELT; what’s under the dome.)

If it works as planned, the E-ELT will gather 100,000,000 times as much light as the human eye.

That’s 13 times more than the largest optical telescopes we had in 2014, about 256 times as much as the Hubble Space Telescope. Its images should be 16 times sharper than Hubble’s. Again, if the E-ELT works as planned.

Even if there is a glitch in manufacture or construction, fixing the problem should be easier than designing and installing Hubble’s corrective mirror.

Bigger isn’t always better, but collecting more light helps when you’re making telescopes.

The E-ELT’s main mirror is segmented, since there’s a limit to how big we can make precisely-ground mirrors. The twin 8.4 meter, 27 foot, Large Binocular Telescope’s mirrors are pretty close to that limit with today’s technology.

A big mirror is useless if it’s not the right shape. Eight-meter monolithic mirrors need active optics to keep variables like wind, mechanical stress, and temperature from warping them. The same goes for segmented telescope mirrors.

Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star: Dealing With Scintillation

“Twinkling” starlight is the attractive, seemingly-random variations in starlight that has inspired poetry — and technology to handle the changes.

Astronomers can be as poetic as anyone else, but twinkling interferes with detailed observation.

That’s particularly true when an astronomer uses photography, or any other tech. Until a few decades back, the only solution was to wait for a very still night, and hope for the best. That’s still important, but new technology has made things easier.

Telescopes, particularly large ones, now have adaptive optics.

It’s sort of like active optics, but handles momentary distortions. Adaptive optical systems sense distortions in a wavefront, the “twinkling,” tweaking the telescope’s optics to keep the star’s image steady.

The system can use a bright star near the telescope’s target, or generate its own guide stars by shining lasers in the right direction. That’s what those bright lines in the ESO artist’s rendering illustrate. The E-ELT uses six artificial guide stars.2

Seeking Undiscovered Worlds


(From B. Saxton (NRAO/AUI/NSF), ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO); via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Protoplanetary disk around Elias 2-27, infrared image taken at the ESO’s Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array.)

My guess is that when news of the E-ELT’s construction starts cycling through the news, articles will focus on astronomers using it to search for extrasolar planets.

Finding new worlds is an important part of its mission. We’ll also be learning more about worlds we’ve already found.

Astronomers will be looking for water and organic molecules in protoplanetary discs, and studying the atmospheres of some exoplanets.

If an Earth-like planet orbits one of the nearer, brighter, stars; we could get images of it with the E-ELT.

We’ll also be learning more about worlds we’ve already found.

Astronomers will also be searching for previously-undiscovered exoplanets, and studying the atmospheres of some.

The E-ELT’s instruments use visible and infrared light, so scientists can study protoplanetary disks, giving us a better idea of how planetary systems form and develop.

Other research will study extremely distant galaxies, whose light has been heading our way since this universe was young. We’re hoping that the E-ELT will let astronomers directly observe this universe’s expansion.

Over the next several decades we may learn a very great deal about how this universe formed, and whether our current models the workings of matter and energy match reality. If they don’t, we’ll be learning even more.


2. Maybe It’s a Super-Saturn – – –


(From NASA, JPL-Caltech, Space Science Institute; via Scientific American, used w/o permission.)
(“Seen here backlit by the sun in this image from NASA’s Cassini orbiter, Saturn is our solar system’s most majestic ringed planet….'”
(Scientific American))

“Newly Found Exoplanet May Have Ring System Dwarfing Saturn’s”
Nola Taylor Redd, Scientific American (May 25, 2017)

“Although planetary rings are extremely common in our solar system—every gas giant circling our sun has one—they’ve proved harder to spot around worlds orbiting other stars. That’s a shame, because studies of ring systems around younger worlds could help clarify what the giant planets of our nearly five-billion-year-old solar system looked like in their first few million years.

“More than two decades of planet hunting have revealed just one ringed exoplanet—a super-size version of Saturn that researchers have only just begun to study using very large telescopes. But now they may have have found a second super-Saturn half-hidden in a disk of gas and dust surrounding a young star, a world readily observable even with backyard telescopes….”

This planet, or whatever it is, orbits PDS 110; about 1,100 light-years away in Orion. That would put in the general vicinity of, but not in, the Orion Nebula.

Scientists working with the Wide-Angle Search for Planets (WASP) say they may have found a huge version of Saturn and its rings.

What astronomers observed was a 25-day 30% dip in PDS 110’s brightness in November 2008 and January 2011.

A reasonable explanation is that something big passed between us and the star twice, and that it orbits the star every 808 days, give or take two days. That would put it about 2 AU out from the star, twice the distance between Earth and our sun.

It’s probably a planet, or maybe a brown dwarf, with a mass between 1.8 and 70 times Jupiter’s — surrounded by an enormous ring system, 50,000,000 kilometers across. That’s around 200 times as wide as Saturn’s rings.

One of the less-unlikely explanations for variations in light from “Tabby’s Star,” KIC 8462852, is a sort of super-Saturn with irregular rings. On the other hand, maybe — just maybe — someone’s building a very large ‘something’ out there. (December 2, 2016)

– – – or Something Else

Or maybe the PSD object is a less well-organize orbiting cloud of debris orbiting PSD 110.

Another possibility is that it’s clumps of debris in PSD 110’s circumstellar disk. That’s not as likely, since the dips were virtually identical.

At this point, all we’re sure about is that PSD 110’s light dimmed by the same amount, for the same duration, two times running. That might be a statistical fluke.

If it happens three times in a row, the ‘dumb luck’ scenario will be even less likely. We’ll know in September 2017.

Amateur astronomers could get in on the action with this one. Anyone with a modestly dark sky in Earth’s northern hemisphere, and decent backyard telescope, should be able to observe it. PSD 110 is an 11th magnitude star, at 05h 23m 31.008s by -01° 04′ 23.68″.

PSD 110 is a young star, most likely between 7 and 15 million years old. Planets should be forming around PSD 110 about now.

That’s assuming that the nebular hypothesis is fairly accurate. We’re pretty sure that moons of the large outer planets of the Solar System formed from rings like the ones which may have been observed.3

The nebular hypothesis has held up pretty well, with considerable tweaking, over the last few decades. My guess is that it’s not far from accurate: particularly since we seem to be observing planetary systems in the process of forming.

But I don’t know for sure, neither do scientists, and that’s why it’s called the nebular hypothesis. We’re still learning. And that gets me back to Galileo.

Galileo’s legendary confrontation with the forces of superstition and ignorance is real: in the sense that what he said, and how he said it, led to his trial and conviction. But like I said earlier, reality is a tad more complicated.

Putting Galileo in Perspective

I’ve talked about the Thirty Years’ War and Defenestration of Prague before.

The European conflict had a religious angle, but I’m quite sure politics and economics were in the mix, too. (March 17, 2017; November 6, 2016)

The Thirty Years’ war left us with about 7,500,000 dead bodies.

After decades of warfare, famine, and witch hunts, some Europeans started re-thinking old assumptions about authority and business-as-usual.

That, I think, was a good idea. Assuming that religion leads to warfare, famine, and death: not so much.

It doesn’t help that some folks have disturbed views of what God wants. (May 24, 2017; February 1, 2017; January 22, 2017)

The notion that ‘religion kills people’ is still with us. I think it makes about as much sense as assuming that thinking and democracy cause guillotines, mass beheadings, and state-sponsored toga parties. Or blaming Satan. (November 13, 2016; November 6, 2016)

About the Reformation and Thirty Years’ War — there really were problems in clerical practice. My culture’s roots are in the northern end of the mess, so we call the Church’s actions to fix those problems the Counter-Reformation.

The 1545-1563 Council of Trent was, and is, an important part of that process. I figure we’d have ‘countered’ anyway. I’ve mentioned the 910 Cluniac Reforms and 1962-65 Second Vatican Council before. (March 17, 2017)

Self-Confidence and Assumptions

The Thirty Years’ War was about eight years in the future when Galileo published “Sidereus Nuncius” in 1610. And no, I do not think Galileo started the war.

But decades of serenity-shattering peasant revolts in the north and reforms from the Council of Trent had already happened by the time he wrote it.

I strongly suspect current events and recent memory encouraged some folks to be skittish, at best, about new ideas.

Any new ideas.

I also suspect that Galileo could have saved himself a lot of trouble if he’d had a less abrasive personality, and had the good sense to say his heliocentric view was an opinion.

Instead, he insisted that what his “Sidereus Nuncius” expressed incontrovertible facts. There are times and circumstances which warrant that level of self-confidence. This wasn’t one of them.

Like I said earlier, it was decades — centuries — before we had proof that Copernicus and Galileo were on the right track.

Galileo might have had trouble, anyway. He seems to have had a talent for alienating his allies, and infuriating his enemies.

And, as I said, folks who didn’t like new ideas had some reason to be nervous in 1610. Being nervous isn’t, I think, an excuse for acting badly; neither is saying “I meant well.” But I try to understand motives. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1750, 1789)

Galileo’s trial and conviction could have had worse results. He was sentenced to house arrest, and a legend was born.4

Oddly enough, Galileo’s trouble with sunspots isn’t part of the ‘science against the forces of superstition’ story. Not often, anyway.

Galileo observed sunspots, publishing his work in 1613. Depending on who you read, Francesco Sizzi spotted them first, or Christoph Scheiner. Galileo said he was first, which led to another interpersonal spat.

That’s the European sunspot connection. Over in China, some folks say Shi Shen was first, about 23 centuries back. Or maybe it was Gan De. Or someone else.


3. TRAPPIST-1h: It’s Real


(From ESO/M. Kornmesser/spaceengine.org, via Sci-News, used w/o permission.)
(An artist’s impression of the TRAPPIST-1 planetary system.)

“Seventh TRAPPIST-1 Planet Confirmed”
Camille M. Carlisle, Sky and Telescope (May 22, 2017)

“The modest M8 red dwarf star TRAPPIST-1 became famous after astronomers discovered seven small exoplanets in orbit around it. At the time the discoverers made the announcement in February, they couldn’t say much about the outermost world, labeled h: The astronomers had seen the planet — or, at least something they thought was a planet — pass in front of the star only once.

“Rodrigo Luger (University of Washington, Seattle) and colleagues, including members of the original discovery team, have now confirmed planet h’s existence and some of its specs….”

The TRAPPIST-1 planetary system may have more planets, but b through h give us an intriguing look at what may be a pattern for other systems orbiting low-mass stars.

Now that we’ve filled in some of the blanks in our knowledge about h, the outermost of the seven worlds, I suspect we’ve got even more questions than before.

I’m guessing that scientists will start working on explanations for why their orbits are so similar to the Jovian system’s. (March 3, 2017)

Or we may learn that entirely different mechanisms produced similar results.

TRAPPIST-1h is about 75% as wide as Earth, 40% larger than Mars. It’s closer to TRAPPIST-1 than any of the Solar System’s planets, but that star is much dimmer than ours. The planet gets about as much warmth from its sun as objects in the Solar System’s main asteroid belt.

We’re pretty sure that means life-as-we-know-it can’t exist there. On the other hand, that’s what we thought about the outer planet moons, and now NASA is planning a ‘search for life’ mission to Europa.

Or we may learn that our protein-in-water biochemistry isn’t unique. Maybe some of the hypothetical biochemistries being discussed aren’t entirely hypothetical. (March 3, 2017)

Then there’s the TRAPPIST-1 system’s dancing planets.

A Complex Dance


(“A Resonant Dance of the Seven TRAPPIST-1 Planets,” NASA’s Ames Research Center (no audio) (May 22, 2017) via YouTube)

Some, at least, of the Jovian moons are in Laplace resonance orbits. Europa, for example, goes around Jupiter twice for each orbit of Ganymede’s.

TRAPPIST-1 planets are in a more complicated dance. Every two laps of planet h is matched with three of planet g – – – but not quite. The number is exact, but it’s not an integer.

Math geeks, I’m not one, may enjoy working through the relationship: x/P1 – (x+y)/P2 + y/P3 = 0 — where x and y are integers and P1, P2, and P3 are the orbital periods of planet 1, planet 2, and planet 3 in whichever trio you’re looking at. Enjoy.

I wouldn’t know about that equation, but Camille M. Carlisle included it in her article.

We’re a bit less certain about TRAPPIST-1’s age. We know the star’s mass, about 8% the sun’s. The Kepler2 mission’s data gives us its rotation rate, too. TRAPPIST-1’s sunspots go past every 3.3 days. Probably.

That number has changed before, and may again when we have more precise data.

Mass and rotation rate match what we’ve found in most average ultracool dwarf stars. The nearby ones, at any rate.

TRAPPIST-1 had one notable flare while being observed. That lets scientists make an educated guess about the star’s level of activity. All that adds up to a likely age of between 3,000,000,000 and 8,000,000,000 years.

Carlisle is a scientist by training, which explains how she closed her article:

“…That permits all sorts of speculation about habitability and alien life, but given how much remains unknown about this system, I prefer not to dabble in such musings.”
(Camille M. Carlisle, Sky and Telescope)

Not Quite Earth 2.0


(From NASA/JPL-Caltech, used w/o permission.)
(TRAPPIST-1 and Solar planetary systems, habitable zones in green. TRAPPIST-1 system enlarged for clarity.)

The Solar System is about 4,500,000,000 years old. That’s right in the middle of a reasonable estimate for TRAPPIST-1’s age. Its seven known planets are most likely rocky, like the Solar System’s inner worlds.

TRAPPIST-1f is almost exactly the same diameter as Earth, and g is roughly one and an eighth times our planet’s size. TRAPPIST-1f is smack in the middle of the star’s habitable zone, g is in the next track out.

I don’t have a professional reputation to maintain, and I’m not as a scientist, so I can dabble with minimal risk.

Let’s say that TRAPPIST-1 is only 1/4,540th older than the Solar System.

I’m in my mid-60s, so someone one and one 4,540th times older than I am would have been born a few days before I was. For most purposes, that’s practically the same age.

For the Solar System, that’s a million years. Still nearly the same age, on a cosmic scale.

On a human scale, the story’s a bit different. (December 16, 2016)

Speculation

Let’s say that life started on TRAPPIST-1f at exactly the same interval after the star’s formation as life on Earth.

About three and a third million years back, people there developed their equivalent of Oldowan stone tools.

A million years ago, they learned that other stars had planetary systems like theirs, only not quite. They began sending radio messages, getting no replies, toward several promising planetary systems.

A few thousand years later, they developed fast(ish) interstellar travel. Let’s say they’re a bit more risk-averse, on average, than humans. I suspect that wouldn’t take much.

Even after they developed fast interstellar travel, they never visited the Solar System in person.

This star’s high-energy radiation was, they had learned, far beyond what any known or hypothetical form of life could endure. As far as they had learned at that point.

We use some of that radiation, specifically UVB, to synthesize vitamin D. That may, or may not, be why folks whose ancestors lived where mine did look the way we do. We’ve been away from home a long time, and that’s yet again another topic.

These not-human folks did, however, eventually begin sending robotic probes to the Solar System. That’s what we’ve been doing here in the Solar System. I think it’ll likely be our strategy as we begin exploring this part of the galaxy.

Eventually the probes detected life on the third planet. Their scientists confirmed that it wasn’t a sensor glitch, and re-thought their ideas about biochemistry.

The probes also reported statistically-improbable heat concentrations consistent with small fires were often close to one particular sort of critter. That had an obvious, if somewhat unbelievable, explanation. The critters were people. Using fire.

That was about a million years back. Here’s a list of milestones I used when concocting that tale:

The numbers are years-before-now. Back to my imaginary tale.

Taking the ‘we’re all gonna die’ attitude, I could say that they destroyed themselves by waging war and eating too much fatty food — right after they discovered us.

Instead, I’ll assume that they didn’t. If that was all true, why aren’t they here now?

More Speculation

Maybe they’re not as incurably chatty as we are. Maybe they are here, in the form of AI orbiting far out of the ecliptic.

Maybe they want to see what we’ll do next. Maybe they’re trying to figure out why we didn’t become extinct during one of this planet’s temperature/climate changes. (May 26, 2017; January 20, 2017)

Or maybe they’ve spent the last half-million years meditating on the whichness of what and unscrewing the inscrutable, and lost interest in us.

If we do have neighbors who aren’t human, I very strongly suspect we’ll learn that — they’re not human. (December 23, 2016; December 16, 2016)

If you’re a regular reader, you know why I don’t see a conflict between seeking God and seeking truth. I’m not even disturbed by the idea that God’s creation is bigger, older, and filled with more wonders, than some of us thought, a few centuries back.

If you’re new here, no worries. I’ll get back to faith, science, and SETI: after looking at what a scientist-monk said recently.


4. “An Act of Prayer”


(From Zenit – HSM, via Zenit, used w/o permission.)

“Interview: ‘If There Is Faith, to Study the Universe With Science Is An Act of Prayer,’ Says Guy Consolmagno”
Sergio Mora, Zenit (May 9, 2017)

“‘At the beginning of time, God spoke to us through Creation, says the Letter of Saint Paul to the Corinthians. Therefore, to study the universe with science, is an act of prayer, a way of encountering God.’ However, to do so, ‘it is necessary to encounter God first as Father, as Abba, otherwise God cannot be encountered with science.” In other words, “faith must be there first, if one wishes to see God in Creation.’

“Talking with ZENIT, astronomer Guy Consolmagno explained this on the sidelines of the meeting held yesterday, May 8, 2017, in the Holy See Press Office, where the Scientific Workshop on black holes, gravitational waves and the peculiarity of space-time, which will be held in the Vatican Astronomical Observatory in Castel Gandolfo from May 9-12, was presented….”

I’m not sure which “peculiarity of space-time” they’ll be discussing. I hope there’ll be coverage of the workshop.

Guy Consolmagno wasn’t, in a way, saying anything new here; although I like the “act of prayer” quote.

As I keep saying, God gave us brains: pretty good ones. Using them is what we’re supposed to do.

Being curious, thinking, learning how this universe works and using that knowledge, is part of being human. Studying the beauty and wonders around us is one way we learn about God. (Catechism, 31–32, 35–36, 301, 303–306, 311, 319, 1704, 2293–2296)

Or we can decide to ignore the whole thing. As Brother Consolmagno said, science doesn’t force us to believe. But it works with faith, if we let it.

Me? I like learning more about this vast and ancient cosmos. I see scientific discoveries as opportunities for “greater admiration” of God’s work. (Catechism, 283, 341)

About extraterrestrial intelligence? Folks like us, free-willed creatures with physical bodies? I hope we have neighbors. But I will leave that level of design decisions about the universe to God.

God’s God, I’m not. I figure part of my job is appreciating God’s work: not telling the Almighty how to run this universe.


Touch-Tone Telephones and Tradition

I’m a Christian, and a Catholic. Some Catholics apparently think our faith means desperately trying to live as if it’s still 1950, or earlier.

I don’t see it that way, obviously.

I’ve been asked how I can make my faith relevant to life in the 21st century. That was a reasonable question, given the way some of us act. The short answer is that I value Tradition, but don’t try following all traditions.

I take our Tradition, capital “T,” very seriously. I follow some traditions we’ve developed over the ages, but not all. I’d be surprised if one person could, there are so many.

I don’t try living as if the ’60s never happened, or think that touch-tone telephones and Batman doomed civilization. That’s not what Tradition is.

Our Tradition is the living message of the Gospel, maintained and passed along through the millennia.5 (Catechism, 75–83)

Our Tradition is important. It mattered in the 1st century, it still does in the 21st. Unless the Last Judgment comes a lot sooner that I think it will,6 it will matter in the 41st, and 61st, and for the rest of time.

Some are our traditions are important, too. They’re useful habits we’ve developed and adapted to different places and times. Lower-case-“t” traditions are kept, changed, or dropped, as our needs change. This is okay. (Catechism, 83)

Desperately clinging to customs that don’t make sense any more seems like a waste of effort, at best.

Doing what is right, no matter what’s currently popular: that, I think, is worthwhile. (February 5, 2017; August 14, 2016; July 24, 2016)

Seeking strange new worlds, recent developments:


1 My take on natural philosophers, plus some history and science:

2 An excessive number of links to information you most likely don’t need:

3 More about planetary systems and the nebular hypothesis:

4 Galileo, the Reformation, and sunspots:

5 Definitions:

  • “BIBLE: Sacred Scripture: the books which contain the truth of God’s Revelation and were composed by human authors inspired by the Holy Spirit (105). The Bible contains both the forty-six books of the Old Testament and the twenty-seven books of the New Testament (120). See Old Testament; New Testament.”
  • “MAGISTERIUM: The living, teaching office of the Church, whose task it is to give as authentic interpretation of the word of God, whether in its written form (Sacred Scripture), or in the form of Tradition. The Magisterium ensures the Church’s fidelity to the teaching of the Apostles in matters of faith and morals (85, 890, 2033).”
  • “TRADITION: The living transmission of the message of the Gospel in the Church. The oral preaching of the Apostles, and the written message of salvation under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit (Bible), are conserved and handed on as the deposit of faith through the apostolic succession in the Church. Both the living Tradition and the written Scriptures have their common source in the revelation of God in Jesus Christ (75–82). The theological, liturgical, disciplinary, and devotional traditions of the local churches both contain and can be distinguished from this apostolic Tradition (83).”

And see Catechism, 95, 113, 126, and 174.

6 I take the Last Judgment seriously. What wannabe prophets say are End Times Bible Prophecies, not so much:

Posted in Science News | Tagged , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

“The Federation of the World”

Tennyson said “Locksley Hall” expresses “…young life, its good side, its deficiencies, and its yearnings.” I’m inclined to believe him, partly because I was young when I first read the poem. A half-century later, these are still among my favorite lines of poetry:

“…For I dipt into the future, far as human eye could see,
“Saw the vision of the world, and all the wonder that would be;…
“…Till the war-drum throbbed no longer, and the battle-flags were furl’d
“In the Parliament of man, the Federation of the world.
“There the common sense of most shall hold a fretful realm in awe,
“And the kindly earth shall slumber, lapt in universal law….”
(“Locksley Hall,” Alfred, Lord Tennyson)

I still think building something like Tennyson’s “Federation of the world” is a good idea. I’m quite certain that it will be a long, hard, process.

But we’re already making some headway.

Something like the Svalbard Global Seed Vault would have seemed like ‘science fiction’ in my youth. (May 26, 2017)

It’s not just the technology. Norway runs the vault, but it is part of an international effort. So far, 71 sovereign states signed the International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture,”

Even more hopeful, I think, 193 of the world’s 200 or so sovereign states are in the United Nations.

Four Millennia of Empires

International cooperation isn’t new.

We’ve had leagues, alliances, and treaties for longer than we’ve had nations.

Sargon of Akkad achieved a measure of stability by conquering his neighbors.

Sargon’s empire, established about 4,300 years ago, lasted just shy of two centuries.

Ur-Nammu was the first of many folks following Sargon’s example. The empire-collapse-recovery cycle continued for about four millennia.

These days, Ur-Nammu is chiefly known for the Code of Ur-Nammu, the earliest known law code.

The last I heard, Hammurabi’s is the earliest complete code we’ve found. (March 30, 2017; October 30, 2016; September 25, 2016)

Making a serious effort to unite all nations as almost-but-not-entirely-equal members of a global entity: That is new.

Working With What We Have

The United Nations is no more perfect than America’s Congress.

But for all their faults, they’re what we have to work with. Today.

John Rarick’s “spider flag of the United Nations” slogan of 1968-69 is largely forgotten, happily. The attitude hasn’t entirely disappeared, however.

Some Americans still seem uneasy about ‘foreigners:’ or other Americans who don’t look and act pretty much like them.

Others seem willing to try establishing a ‘Pax Americana.’ I’m not. The Pax Romana was an improvement on the Final War of the Roman Republic, but we can do better.

I’ve talked about Roman history, Icarus, and getting a grip, before. (May 26, 2017)

On the whole, I like being an American. I think my nation has much to offer the world.

But humanity has tried maintaining stability and security with empires. They don’t last. Not more than a few centuries. It’s time to try something else.

The UN has fallen far short of my hopes. However, as an alternative to another global war: I think it’s the more reasonable option. (October 30, 2016)

Unseemly Optimism

I know that our world is a mess, and has been since long before we started recording our blunders and achievements.

“For mischief comes not out of the earth, nor does trouble spring out of the ground;
2 But man himself begets mischief, as sparks fly upward.”
(Job 5:7–7)

“Anything that can go wrong, will go wrong”
(Murphy’s law)

“Murphy was an optimist.”
(Otoole’s commentary on Murphy’s law)

I suspect that the ‘gloominess is next to godliness’ attitude, and its secular analogs, have roots in fashionable melancholy. (May 12, 2017; August 12, 2016)

I think seeing this as the best of all possible worlds, or a hopeless and doomed one, are both — incomplete perceptions. And that’s a metaphysical can of worms I’ll leave for another day.

Seeing the future as bleak is something I understand. Feeling hopeless was my default state for decades, thanks to undiagnosed depression. (October 14, 2016)

Feelings, emotions, are real. Mine, however, are highly unreliable guides. I’m better off if I think. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1730, 1778, 1804, 2339)

Learning to do that is a work in progress. (January 11, 2017; October 5, 2016)

I’m not cautiously optimistic because I feel hopeful. I occasionally feel hopeful because I think there is reason for cautious optimism. (October 30, 2016)

Hope, in one sense, is a psychological or emotional state. It is also a virtue. Feeling hopeful is okay, but not necessary. What counts is what I do, not how I feel. (Catechism, 1762–1770, 1817–1821)

“A Civilization of Love”

As I said Friday, I think the Svalbard seed vault is a good idea.

I also think building Pope St. John Paul II’s “civilization of love” makes sense.

I’m sure that at least until there’s a “sufficiently powerful authority at the international level,” some of us must be ready to defend innocent lives.

“…As long as the danger of war remains and there is no competent and sufficiently powerful authority at the international level, governments cannot be denied the right to legitimate defense once every means of peaceful settlement has been exhausted….”
(“Gaudium et Spes,” Pope Bl. Paul VI (December 7, 1965))

“…The answer to the fear which darkens human existence at the end of the twentieth century is the common effort to build the civilization of love, founded on the universal values of peace, solidarity, justice, and liberty….”
(“To the United Nations Organization,”5 Pope St. John Paul II (October 5, 1995))

Part of my job is contributing “…to the good of society in a spirit of truth, justice, solidarity, and freedom….” (Catechism, 1928–1942, 2239)

I think that includes suggesting that learning to sort out conflicts without war is a good idea. (Catechism, 2307–2317)

I don’t think the United Nations will become Tennyson’s “Federation of the world.”

But I think it is a good start. It’s already lasted longer than the Second Continental Congress’ Articles of Confederation. (February 5, 2017)

If we keep working with all people of good will, I think we can develop a close approximation of Tennyson’s “Parliament of man … Federation of the world.” Eventually.

It won’t be easy. There’s an enormous backlog of unresolved issues. But I think we can succeed. I am certain that we must try:

Posted in Being a Citizen, Being Catholic | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment