Pentheus, Pwyll and Pan Twardowski: Fairly Faustian

(Marguerite’s garden in Gounod’s “Faust,” set design by Édouard Desplechin. (1859))

Christopher Marlowe based his “Dr. Faustus” on Germany’s Faust legend, which was in turn inspired by Johann Georg Faust’s reputation.

And on J. G. Faust’s abrupt death in 1520, give or take a few decades.

Someone or something wrung Faust’s neck. Or he didn’t survive an alchemical laboratory explosion. Stories agree that he died abruptly, but vary on details.

J. G. Faust had been a Renaissance con man of sorts, presenting himself as an alchemist, astrologer and magician. His reputation grew after his unpleasant death, inspiring a slew of chapbooks, plays, operas, ballets and video games.

Gounod’s “Faust” was an early Faustian opera, and I’m wandering off-topic.1

Or maybe not so much.

Faust’s Literary (?) Debut

Spies, a printer in Frankfurt, published “Historia von D. Johann Fausten…” in 1587.

Its Brobdingnagian title, translated into English, runs to 70 words and tells the whole ‘Faust’ story.

We don’t write stuff quite like that any more, which may explain why academics haven’t agreed on whether the chapbook is literature, trash or something else.

As far as we know, “Historia von” and so forth put “Johann Fausten” on the literary map. It’s a tale of “…the renowned sorcerer and black magician…” who sold his soul to the devil. And therefore is “…a sincere warning to all the arrogant, curious and ungodly.”2

“Black magician?”

Maybe that needs explaining.

Bear in mind that “Historia” etc. was written in 16th century German.

J. G. Faust, the Renaissance con man whose life inspired the Faust legend, was almost certainly German. Or northwestern European, at any rate.

Back in Germany, in 1587, calling someone a [redacted] magician didn’t have the meaning my culture’s self-appointed guardians might assume.

Let’s see if I can fix this affront to contemporary mores.

A more politically-correct translation might be “misunderstood magician,” or maybe even “fascist” or “oppressed” magician, depending on whether Faust is in or out of favor at the moment.

AKA Faust?

From the 'Faust' collection, central library, German Classic, National Research and Memorial Sites, Weimar.
(From Jürgen Ludwig, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Would you buy an elixir from this man? J. G. Faust, as imagined in 1726.)

Speaking of names, I’m not convinced that “Faust” was the alleged alchemist, astrologer and magician’s original name.

My Latin’s rusty, at best, but seems to me that “faustus” means “good luck” or “lucky” in Latin. Maybe Herr Faust had a surname ironically suited to his profession and legend.

Or maybe it’s a name he used to make his job easier. “Faust” is also German for “fist,” but never mind that.

Faustian Origins

(From Ken Eckert, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(The Huntington Library’s “Faustus” manuscript: Ken Eckert’s photo.)

I’ve heard that there are three, 20, 36 and seven basic stories: archetypes expressed in everything from “Hamlet” to “Watership Down.” Or maybe just one.

I’m not sure which or whose story archetype model has academia’s current approval. Or whether any are generally accepted.

A fair number of well-known stories fit Christopher Booker’s seven archetypes:3

  • Overcoming the Monster
    • “Dracula,” Bram Stoker
  • Rags to Riches
    • “David Copperfield,” Charles Dickens
  • The Quest
    • “The Lord Of The Rings,” J. R. R. Tolkien
  • Voyage and Return
    • Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland,” Lewis Carroll
  • Comedy
    • “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” William Shakespeare
  • Tragedy
    • “The Picture of Dorian Gray,” Oscar Wilde
  • Rebirth
    • “A Christmas Carol,” Charles Dickens

Scott Adam's 'Dilbert' strip: Dogbert's Good News Show. ('We'll all die!')Booker’s ‘archetypes’ book came out in 2007. I’m not sure why he left an eighth archetype out: “Everything’s Hopeless and We’ll All Die.”

Maybe fashionable melancholy is going out of vogue. If so, it’s about time. And another topic. (October 22, 2017)

In Booker’s seven-point breakdown, Marlowe’s “Dr. Faustus” would be a tragedy: the story of a hero with a serious glitch.

Anyway, England’s Christopher Marlowe didn’t make up the “Faust” story. It was maybe a century old by the time his “Dr. Faustus” first hit the boards.

‘Pact with a devil’ tales are older. And, maybe, have very deep roots.

Pan Twardowski: Faust Legend Knockoff, or Maybe Inspiration

Michał Elwiro Andriolli's Pan Twardowski and the devil. (1895)I haven’t confirmed it, but I’m guessing that German “Faust” folklore and chapbooks thrived because J. G. Faust was a close match to none-too-discrete folks in even older tales.

I’m also pretty sure that Germans weren’t the only folks with Faustian folktales.

Pan Twardowski, for example, looks like an adaptation of the Faust story.

Pan Twardowski’s basic plot is pretty much the same as the Germanic Faust’s.

P.T. makes a deal with the devil, enjoys fame and fortune, and comes to a bad end.

Since the Pan Twardowski tales we have say he’s a 16th century Polish noble, they look like Faust legend knockoffs.4 But my language, English, is a Germanic language: so maybe my sources don’t go deep enough into Polish tradition.

I’ll get back to ‘pact with a devil’ stories, after looking at two other chaps who really should have known better.

Pwyll, Rhiannon’s Hasty Husband

Then there’s Pwyll, Pendefig Dyfed; often translated Pwyll, Prince of Dyfed. Maybe it’d be more accurate to say Pwyll, Noble of Dyfed. Then again, maybe not.

At any rate, Pwyll was a VIP in Dyfed and Rhiannon’s husband. Maybe “consort” would be more accurate.

This is a Welsh tale, set in a culture with its own rules.

Briefly, Rhiannon is smart, Pwyll is generous, and they’re both at a feast when Gwawl — I’m not sure who he is — asks Pwyll for a favor. Pwyll’s response boils down to ‘sure, anything I can do.’

Gwawl says ‘I want Rhiannon,’ and the conversation goes downhill from there.

Rhiannon being from Annwn didn’t help.

Annwn, Tír na nÓg, Mag Mell and Emain Ablach — are cans of worms I’ll leave for another day. The same goes for Tech Duinn.

The point I’m groping for is that Pwyll was deeply involved with someone from an otherworld, and not exercising sufficient prudence.

Pwyll’s story, the versions we have of it, may have been influenced by post-Christian contact scribes. Or garbled. Ongoing academic arguments over what the ‘real’ Mabinogion was like may never be settled.

Then there are post-Enlightenment efforts to reanimate Druidism, and I’m skidding off-topic again.5

I’m pretty sure that most cultures have stories about someone who lacked street smarts when it came to otherworldly powers.

Dionysus, Pentheus and All That

Walls of Troy, millennia after the Trojan War.I’m guessing that the Faust legend’s roots go back at least to Mycenaean Greece.

That’s the Aegean civilization that came just before Plato and company.

Think of them as the Ancient Greece for Ancient Greeks.

We don’t know much about them, thanks partly to the Late Bronze Age collapse. We lost a great many records in that incident, whatever it was.

I was going somewhere with this. Marlowe. Faustian opera. The Mabinogion. Right.

Dionysus is mainly known as the Greek god of wine, intoxication and insanity.

His story probably goes back to Zagreus and pre-Mycenaean cultures.

The little we know about pre-Mycenaean cultures is not even close to being internally consistent. No surprises there, since some of the fragmented narratives we have may predate Sargon by several millennia.

Pentheus, king of Thebes, reminds me of Marlowe’s Dr. Faustus. Sort of. They’re both a trifle clueless when it comes to dealing with otherworld persons.

Dionysus wasn’t, back in the day, just the god of wine and lethal benders. Among other things, the stories have him taking long excursions, disguised as a human.

Sometimes he’d help folks out, teaching them how make wine.6

Other times: well, there was that Pentheus incident.

Seemed Like a Good Idea at the Time??

Antonio Tempesta's 'The Death of Pentheus.' (ca. 1606)Pentheus, king of Thebes — don’t bother trying to remember these names — thought that destroying Dionysian temples and killing the worshipers was a good idea.

Why, I don’t know.

Meanwhile, a stranger had arrived in Thebes.

Figuring the stranger was a Dionysian, Pentheus put him in prison.

Tried to put him, that is. Chains wouldn’t stay chained and doors wouldn’t close properly.

Then the stranger suggested that Pentheus dress as a woman and go see what Theban gals were up to when they went out in the woods.

Pentheus — I mentioned he was clueless, right? — thought this was a good idea.

Long story short, the stranger and Pentheus arrive during Dionysian rites.

The stranger wasn’t a Dionysian follower.

He was Dionysus. Obviously, I figure, to everyone but Pentheus.

And Dionysus was not pleased with the Theban king’s anti-Dionysian policy.

Dionysian rites being what they were, the gals were unhinged.

They spotted Pentheus, misidentifying him as a wild animal.

Pentheus was promptly deboned.

We know the Pentheus story mainly because Euripides wrote “The Bacchae,” a play that’s currently in favor among academics.7

A tip of the hat to number-one daughter, for pointing out the Faust-Pwyll-Pentheus connection. Which may or may not eventually get traction in academia.

Demons, Deals and European Folklore

Louis-Léopold Boilly's 'Tartini's Dream.' (1824)
(From Louis-Léopold Boilly, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Louis-Léopold Boilly’s “Tartini’s Dream.” (1824))

Tales about Satan and devils in general abound in my culture: from Robert Johnson’s legendary deal and Tartini’s inspiration, back to stories about St. Theophilus of Adana and St. Cyprian of Antioch.

Sts Theophilus the Penitent and Cyprian of Antioch: Faust Prototypes?

'Legend of the monk Theophilus.' (before 1528)Theophilus was an archdeacon who turned down an offer to be bishop.

Then the regrettable piece of work who became bishop fired him.

Theophilus, the story goes, asked Satan for help, and got it.

Along with the Bishop’s job. In exchange, as usual, for his soul.

Then, smitten by buyer’s remorse, Theophilus changed his mind. He prayed for and got forgiveness: after a lengthy process. Some 14½ centuries later, we recognize Theophilus of Adana as a real historical figure, and a Saint.

“Buyer’s remorse?” Maybe that should be “seller’s remorse.” Moving on.

I see his ‘Satanic interval’ legend as European folklore. Mainly because the legend started with Eutychianus: who is known mainly for cashing in on T. of Adana’s fame by writing an unauthorized biography. Or maybe he really thought he’d been a witness.

Theophilus of Adana’s legendary Satanic deal may be an inspiration of “Faust” legends.

Or maybe St. Cyprian of Antioch’s life was where the Faust legend began.

Or maybe it wasn’t. Either way, Cyprian of Antioch was an alleged magician, repented and is now recognized as a Saint.

He and Justina lived about 17 centuries back, when Christianity was illegal in the Roman Empire. They were killed during Diocletian’s effort to protect his realm.

Ill-advised effort, I think: but I’m a Christian, so I would see it that way.

Maybe Diocletian didn’t realize that, aside from their refusal to recognize Caesars as gods, the Christian obligation to love their neighbors made them good citizens. And that’s yet another topic.

That’s also a lot of “maybes.” I figure that Marlowe’s “Dr Faustus” is based on a German chapbook, which told the story of a con man whose life fit pre-existing folklore. Probably.8

And that vaguely-Faustian cautionary tales were ancient in Homer’s day.

Taking Satan Seriously: But Not Too Seriously

Gustave Doré illustration for Canto XXXIV of Divine Comedy, Inferno, by Dante Alighieri; via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.
(From Gustave Doré, via Wikimedia Commons, used w/o permission.)
(Gustave Doré’s 1860s illustration for Dante’s “Divine Comedy,” “Inferno.” (ca. 1320))

Before I wrap up this installment in my Marlowe’s Faustus series, a few words about humans, angels and demons.

I’m a human. When I die, I won’t become an angel. I can’t.

We’re very different sorts of creatures.

Humans are creatures with intelligence and will, made of spirit and with physical bodies. (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 355373, 1730)

Angels aren’t.

Angels are people, persons, in the sense that they have intelligence and will. They’re also spirits with no physical bodies. (Catechism, 328330)

Demons are angels who made a really bad decision. Satan, or the devil, is our name for the angel who decided that saying “no” to God made sense. (Catechism, 391395)

Like I said, a really bad decision.

I’ll be talking quite a bit about demons, Satan and Marlowe’s Mephistophilis. Necessarily, since the play is about Dr. Faustus’ demonic deal and its consequences.

But I also think C. S. Lewis made a good point:

“…There are two equal and opposite errors into which our race can fall about the devils. One is to disbelieve in their existence. The other is to believe, and to feel an excessive and unhealthy interest in them. They themselves are equally pleased by both errors and hail a materialist or a magician with the same delight….”
(“The Screwtape Letters,” Preface, C. S. Lewis (1942))

Posts that aren’t entirely unrelated to this one:

1 J. G. Faust and stuff inspired by his legend:

2 First post-Faust Faustian ‘Faust’ story:

3 Categorizing stories:

4 Meanwhile, in Poland:

5 European heritage:

6 Ancient civilizations, even more ancient tales:

7 Pentheus, king of Thebes, and a perilous stranger:

8 Comparatively recent folklore and people:

How interesting or useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

I am sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let me learn why!

How could I have made this more nearly worth your time?

About Brian H. Gill

I was born in 1951. I'm a husband, father and grandfather. One of the kids graduated from college in December, 2008, and is helping her husband run businesses and raise my granddaughter; another is a cartoonist and artist; #3 daughter is a writer; my son is developing a digital game with #3 and #1 daughters. I'm also a writer and artist.
This entry was posted in Marlowe's Faustus, Series and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Pentheus, Pwyll and Pan Twardowski: Fairly Faustian

  1. irishbrigid says:

    You’re welcome!

    Also, that picture of Satan from Dante’s Inferno looks less “tortured” and more “miffed.”

    • I’m finally getting caught up – sort of. Almost.
      And – yeah. I see what you mean. Miffed. Vexed. Peeved. Maybe the result of changing artistic conventions – – – – although the MVP interpretation is not all that far from Dante’s text.

Thanks for taking time to comment!